Acta Biotheoretica 57 (1-2):269-294 (2009)
Despite the amount of work that has been produced on the subject over the years, the ‘transformation of cladistics’ is still a misunderstood episode in the history of comparative biology. Here, I analyze two outstanding, highly contrasting historiographic accounts on the matter, under the perspective of an influential dichotomy in the philosophy of science: the opposition between Scientific Realism and Empiricism. Placing special emphasis on the notion of ‘causal grounding’ of morphological characters in modern developmental biology’s theories, I arrive at the conclusion that a ‘new transformation of cladistics’ is philosophically plausible. This ‘reformed’ understanding of ‘pattern cladistics’ entails retaining the interpretation of cladograms as ‘schemes of synapomorphies’, but in association to construing cladogram nodes as ‘developmental-genetic taxic homologies’, instead of ‘standard Darwinian ancestors’. The reinterpretation of pattern cladistics presented here additionally proposes to take Bas Van Fraassen’s ‘constructive empiricism’ as a philosophical stance that could properly support such analysis of developmental-genetic data for systematic purposes. The latter suggestion is justified through a reappraisal of previous ideas developed by prominent pattern cladists , which concerned a scientifically efficient ‘observable/non-observable distinction’ linked to the conceptual pair ‘ontogeny and phylogeny’. Finally, I argue that a robust articulation of Antirealist alternatives in systematics may provide a rational basis for its disciplinary separation from evolutionary biology, as well as for a critical reconsideration of the proper role of certain Scientific Realist positions, currently popular in comparative biology
|Keywords||Philosophy Evolutionary Biology Philosophy of Biology|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
Homeostasis, Species, and Higher Taxa.Richard Boyd - 1999 - In R. A. Wilson (ed.), Species: New Interdisciplinary Essays. MIT Press. pp. 141-85.
On the Plurality of Species: Questioning the Party Line.David Hull - 1999 - In R. Wilson (ed.), Species: New Interdisciplinary Essays. MIT Press. pp. 23-48.
Intuitions and Truth.P. Greenough & M. Lynch - 2006 - In Patrick Greenough & Michael P. Lynch (eds.), Truth and Realism. Oxford University Press.
Phylogenetic Systematics and Species Revisited.Kevin de Queiroz & Michael J. Donoghue - 1990 - Cladistics 6 (1):83-90.
Citations of this work BETA
The Phylogeography Debate and the Epistemology of Model-Based Evolutionary Biology.Alfonso Arroyo-Santos, Mark E. Olson & Francisco Vergara-Silva - 2013 - Biology and Philosophy 29 (6):833-850.
Similar books and articles
Outline of an Explanatory Account of Cladistic Practice.Nico M. Franz - 2004 - Biology and Philosophy 20 (2-3):489-515.
Confusion in Philosophy: A Comment on Williams (1992).David M. Williams, Robert W. Scotland, Christopher J. Humphries & Darrell J. Siebert - 1996 - Synthese 108 (1):127 - 136.
'Total Evidence' in Phylogenetic Systematics.Olivier Rieppel - 2009 - Biology and Philosophy 24 (5):607-622.
Plants and the Conceptual Articulation of Evolutionary Developmental Biology.Francisco Vergara-Silva - 2003 - Biology and Philosophy 18 (2):249-284.
What, Exactly, is Cladistics?: Re-Writing the History of Systematics and Biogeography.D. M. Williams & M. C. Ebach - 2009 - Acta Biotheoretica 57 (1-2):249-268.
Cladistics, Sociology and Success: A Comment on Donoghue's Critique of David Hull.Gareth Nelson & Colin Patterson - 1993 - Biology and Philosophy 8 (4):441-443.
The Series, the Network, and the Tree: Changing Metaphors of Order in Nature.Olivier Rieppel - 2010 - Biology and Philosophy 25 (4):475-496.
A New Cladistics of Cladists.C. Ebach Malte, J. Morrone Juan & M. Williams David - 2008 - Biology and Philosophy 23 (1):153-156.
The Role of Fossils in Phylogeny Reconstruction: Why is It so Difficult to Integrate Paleobiological and Neontological Evolutionary Biology? [REVIEW]Todd Grantham - 2004 - Biology and Philosophy 19 (5):687-720.
Added to index2009-06-13
Total downloads61 ( #84,785 of 2,158,310 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #355,837 of 2,158,310 )
How can I increase my downloads?