Journal of Philosophical Logic 43 (5):979-997 (2014)
AbstractThe debate over Hypothetical Syllogism is locked in stalemate. Although putative natural language counterexamples to Hypothetical Syllogism abound, many philosophers defend Hypothetical Syllogism, arguing that the alleged counterexamples involve an illicit shift in context. The proper lesson to draw from the putative counterexamples, they argue, is that natural language conditionals are context-sensitive conditionals which obey Hypothetical Syllogism. In order to make progress on the issue, I consider and improve upon Morreau’s proof of the invalidity of Hypothetical Syllogism. The improved proof relies upon the semantic claim that conditionals with antecedents irrelevant to the obtaining of an already true consequent are themselves true. Moreover, this semantic insight allows us to provide compelling counterexamples to Hypothetical Syllogism that are resistant to the usual contextualist response
Similar books and articles
Why Hypothetical Syllogism is Invalid for Indicative Conditionals.Moti Mizrahi - 2013 - Thought: A Journal of Philosophy 2 (1):40-43.
The Destructive Hypothetical Syllogism in Greek Logic and in Attic Oratory.Stanley Wilcox - 1939 - [New Haven.
Logic, History Of: Ancient Logic.Susanne Bobzien - 2006 - In Donald M. Borchert (ed.), Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Thomson Gale.
Denying Conditionals: Abaelard and the Failure of Boethius' Account of the Hypothetical Syllogism.Christopher Martin - 2007 - Vivarium 45 (s 2-3):153-168.
The Pure Hypothetical Syllogism and Entailment.D. L. C. Maclachlan - 1970 - Philosophical Quarterly 20 (78):26-40.
Reconstructing Aristotle: The Practical Syllogism.John R. Welch - 1991 - Philosophia 21 (1-2):69-88.
Stanley Wilcox: The Destructive Hypothetical Syllogism in Greek Logic and in Attic Oratory. Pp. 143. (Yale Dissertation, Photo-Copy of Typescript) 1938. Paper. [REVIEW]J. Tate - 1940 - The Classical Review 54 (02):113-114.
The Stoics on Hypotheses and Hypothetical Arguments.Susanne Bobzien - 1997 - Phronesis 42 (3):299-312.
Aristotle’s Theory of the Syllogism: A Logico-Philological Study of Book A of the Prior Analytics.Günther Patzig - 1968 - Dordrecht: D. Reidel.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
Possible World Semantics and True-True Counterfactuals.Lee Walters - 2016 - Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 97 (3):322-346.
A Contextualist Defence of the Material Account of Indicative Conditionals.Matheus Silva - manuscript
References found in this work
A Theory of Conditionals.Robert C. Stalnaker - 1968 - In Nicholas Rescher (ed.), Studies in Logical Theory (American Philosophical Quarterly Monographs 2). Oxford: Blackwell. pp. 98-112.