There are (STILL) no coercive offers

Journal of Medical Ethics 40 (9):592-593 (2014)
  Copy   BIBTEX


John McMillan's article raises numerous important points about the ethics of surgical castration of sex offenders.1 In this commentary, we focus solely on and argue against the claim that the offer of release from detention conditional upon surgical castration is a coercive offer that compromises the validity of the offender's consent. We take no view on the question as to whether castration for sex offenders is ethically permissible. But, we reject the claim that it is ethically permissible only if competing ethical considerations outweigh worries about coercion. For in the situation described, the proposal is not coercive at all.McMillan states that if offenders agree to castration because they fear long-term detention, then ‘it seems, intuitively, as if agreeing to be castrated under these conditions makes the decision coerced in some way.’1 He adds that if castration is ‘the only way that they will be released back into the community, the status of this decision as a genuine expression of their autonomy is questionable.’1 In defence of his claim, he uses two analogies that he borrows from Joel Feinberg. First, if a governor offers to commute a death sentence if the prisoner agrees to participate in a medical experiment, then ‘it's clear that the governor is coercing the prisoner.’1 Second, if a millionaire offers to give a woman $1 000 000 …



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 92,168

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

The Last Word on Coercive Offers …(?).Daniel Lyons - 1982 - Philosophy Research Archives 8:393-414.
Payment for research participation: a coercive offer?A. Wertheimer & F. G. Miller - 2008 - Journal of Medical Ethics 34 (5):389-392.
Welcome Threats and Coercive Offers.Daniel Lyons - 1975 - Philosophy 50 (194):425 - 436.
Coercive wage offers.David Zimmerman - 1981 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 10 (2):121-145.
Zimmerman on coercive wage offers.Lawrence A. Alexander - 1983 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 12 (2):160-164.
Coercive offers.Robert Stevens - 1988 - Australasian Journal of Philosophy 66 (1):83 – 95.
More on coercive wage offers: A reply to Alexander.David Zimmerman - 1983 - Philosophy and Public Affairs 12 (2):165-171.
“Undue Inducement' as Coercive Offers.Joan McGregor - 2005 - American Journal of Bioethics 5 (5):24 – 25.
Law and Coercion.Robert C. Hughes - 2013 - Philosophy Compass 8 (3):231-240.


Added to PP

83 (#203,483)

6 months
13 (#198,663)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?