Erkenntnis (S2):1-21 (2013)
The paper is a critique of the widespread conception of logic as a neutral arbiter between metaphysical theories, one that makes no `substantive’ claims of its own (David Kaplan and John Etchemendy are two recent examples). A familiar observation is that virtually every putatively fundamental principle of logic has been challenged over the last century on broadly metaphysical grounds (however mistaken), with a consequent proliferation of alternative logics. However, this apparent contentiousness of logic is often treated as though it were neutralized by the possibility of studying all these alternative logics within an agreed metalogical framework, typically that of first-order logic with set theory. In effect, metalogic is given the role of neutral arbiter. The paper will consider a variety of examples in which deep logical disputes re-emerge at the meta-level. One case is quantified modal logic, where some varieties of actualism require a modal meta-language (as opposed to the usual non-modal language of possible worlds model theory) in order not to make their denial of the Barcan formula self-defeating. Similarly, on some views the intended model theory for second-order logic can only be given in a second-order metalanguage—this may be needed to avoid versions of Russell’s paradox when the first-order quantifiers are read as absolutely unrestricted. It can be shown that the phenomenon of higher-order vagueness eventually forces fuzzy logical treatments of vagueness to use a fuzzy metalanguage, with consequent repercussions for what first-order principles are validated. The difficulty of proving the completeness of first-order intuitionistic logic on its intended interpretation by intuitionistically rather than just classically valid means is a more familiar example. These case studies will be discussed in some detail to reveal a variety of ways in which even metalogic is metaphysically contested, substantial and non-neutral
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
Citations of this work BETA
Response to Cohen, Comesaña, Goodman, Nagel, and Weatherson on Gettier Cases in Epistemic Logic.Timothy Williamson - 2013 - Inquiry : An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy 56 (1):77-96.
Inexact Knowledge Without Improbable Knowing.Jeremy Goodman - 2013 - Inquiry : An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy 56 (1):30-53.
Similar books and articles
Non-Classical Metatheory for Non-Classical Logics.Andrew Bacon - 2013 - Journal of Philosophical Logic 42 (2):335-355.
Toward Model-Theoretic Modal Logics.Minghui Ma - 2010 - Frontiers of Philosophy in China 5 (2):294-311.
Pure Second-Order Logic with Second-Order Identity.Alexander Paseau - 2010 - Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic 51 (3):351-360.
Modal Logic and Model Theory.Giangiacomo Gerla & Virginia Vaccaro - 1984 - Studia Logica 43 (3):203 - 216.
Modal Ontology and Generalized Quantifiers.Peter Fritz - 2013 - Journal of Philosophical Logic 42 (4):643-678.
Completeness and Categoricity. Part I: Nineteenth-Century Axiomatics to Twentieth-Century Metalogic.Steve Awodey & Erich H. Reck - 2002 - History and Philosophy of Logic 23 (1):1-30.
Completeness and Categoricity, Part II: Twentieth-Century Metalogic to Twenty-First-Century Semantics.Steve Awodey & Erich H. Reck - 2002 - History and Philosophy of Logic 23 (2):77-94.
Representability in Second-Order Propositional Poly-Modal Logic.G. Aldo Antonelli & Richmond H. Thomason - 2002 - Journal of Symbolic Logic 67 (3):1039-1054.
Modal Logic as Metalogic.Kosta Došen - 1992 - Journal of Logic, Language and Information 1 (3):173-201.
Undecidability of First-Order Intuitionistic and Modal Logics with Two Variables.Roman Kontchakov, Agi Kurucz & Michael Zakharyaschev - 2005 - Bulletin of Symbolic Logic 11 (3):428-438.
Completeness and Categoricity, Part I: 19th Century Axiomatics to 20th Century Metalogic.Steve Awodey & Erich H. Reck - unknown
Completeness and Categoricty, Part II: 20th Century Metalogic to 21st Century Semantics.Steve Awodey & Erich H. Reck - unknown
Added to index2010-12-22
Total downloads241 ( #14,764 of 2,169,105 )
Recent downloads (6 months)18 ( #18,096 of 2,169,105 )
How can I increase my downloads?