Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 9 (2):167-174 (1999)
: The response of Barbara Pfeffer Billauer to my article "If I Am Only My Genes, What Am I? Genetic Essentialism and a Jewish Response" highlights the conflict between a sociological understanding of religion and the resistance to such analysis from within a faith tradition. Ms. Billauer makes three main points; the first strangely credits to me, and then attacks, an argument the article takes great pains to refute, but does so to emphasize the faith's prescient guidance in matters scientific. The second attempts to rebut my critical analysis of the tensions inherent in Jewish views of the body with an insistence that Judaism so perfectly balances the relation between the sacred and profane that there is not now, and never was, the slightest tension between corporeality and divinity in the Jewish corpus. The third uses my article as vehicle for her to expound on an interesting but tangential formulation of three Jewish terms. In all, the need to defend her interpretation of Judaism's solutions to the problems the article raises results in un-self-critical and ahistorical theorizing, making the utility of her arguments in a discussion of the sociology of religion unsatisfactory
|Keywords||No keywords specified (fix it)|
|Categories||categorize this paper)|
References found in this work BETA
No references found.
Citations of this work BETA
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Embracing Life & Facing Death: A Jewish Guide to Palliative Care.Daniel S. Brenner (ed.) - 2002 - Clal.
Emil L. Fackenheim: A Jewish Philosopher's Response to the Holocaust.David Patterson - 2008 - Syracuse University Press.
With Hearts Full of Faith: Insights Into Trust and Emunah: A Selection of Addresses.Yaakov Yosef Reinman - 2002 - Mesorah.
Tikkun Olam: Engaged Spirituality and Jewish Identity.Gerald Cromer - 2007 - Rappaport Center for Assimilation Research and Strengthening Jewish Vitality, Bar Ilan University, Faculty of Jewish Studies.
Judaism: The Religion of Reason: The Philosophy of Hermann Cohen and How It Shaped Modern Jewish Thought.Jehuda Melber - 1968 - Jonathan David Publishers.
Creating a Judaism Without Religion: A Postmodern Jewish Possibility.S. Daniel Breslauer - 2001 - University Press of America.
If I Am Only My Genes, What Am I? Genetic Essentialism and a Jewish Response.Paul Root Wolpe - 1997 - Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 7 (3):213-230.
On Judaism and Genes: A Response to Paul Root Wolpe.Barbara Pfeffer Billauer - 1999 - Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal 9 (2):159-165.
Added to index2009-01-28
Total downloads17 ( #285,300 of 2,172,903 )
Recent downloads (6 months)1 ( #324,815 of 2,172,903 )
How can I increase my downloads?