Abstract
During the cold war, Frank Fenner (protégé of Macfarlane Burnet and René Dubos) and Francis Ratcliffe (associate of A. J. Nicholson and student of Charles Elton) studied mathematically the coevolution of host resistance and parasite virulence when myxomatosis was unleashed on Australia’s rabbit population. Later, Robert May called Fenner the “real hero” of disease ecology for his mathematical modeling of the epidemic. While Ratcliffe came from a tradition of animal ecology, Fenner developed an ecological orientation in World War II through his work on malaria control (with Ratcliffe and Ian Mackerras, among others)—that is, through studies of tropical medicine. This makes Fenner at least a partial exception to other senior disease ecologists in the region, most of whom learned their ecology from examining responses to agricultural challenges and animal husbandry problems in settler colonial society. Here I consider the local ecologies of knowledge in southeastern Australia during this period, and describe the particular cold-war intellectual niche that Fenner and Ratcliffe inhabited.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
Burnet to Fenner, 2 July 1945, folder 143/6/1, box 3, F. J. Fenner papers, MS 143, Basser Library, Australian Academy of Science, Canberra, Australia (Fenner papers).
Greenwood was professor of epidemiology and vital statistics at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine.
Myxoma is a poxvirus, like ectromelia and smallpox, which causes skin tumors, blindness, fatigue and fever in European rabbits, usually resulting in death within twelve days. The virus was discovered in Uruguay in the late-nineteenth century.
Ratcliffe to People [Family], 4 June 1929, box 8, Francis N. Ratcliffe papers, MS 2493, National Library of Australia, Canberra (Ratcliffe papers). A friend of Roy Campbell, the poet and fascist sympathiser, Ratcliffe’s father Samuel was a conservative journalist and freethinker who dedicated his life to explaining England to Americans. See Powell (2001) and Mulligan and Hill (2001).
Ratcliffe to Mother, 4 October 1929, box 8, Ratcliffe papers.
Keogh to Ted Ford, 29 October [1943], Edward Ford papers, Royal Australasian College of Physicians, Sydney (Ford papers). A graduate in medicine and zoology from Sydney, and an expert in veterinary entomology and parasitology, Mackerras was appointed after the war as the first director of the Queensland Institute of Medical Research. As a Melbourne medical researcher before the war, Keogh was a rival of Burnet, and later he dedicated himself—through the army, philanthropic foundations, and the Anti-Cancer Council of Victoria—to promoting the research careers of the promising young men he befriended. Another Melbourne medical graduate, Ford became director of the School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, dean of the Faculty of Medicine, and acting vice-chancellor of the University of Sydney.
Keogh to Ted Ford, I October 1942, Ford papers.
For documentation of these early attempts, see folder 143/9/3, box 5, Fenner papers. On Breinl and the Institute of Tropical Medicine, see Anderson (2006). A conservative nationalist, Aragão became director of the Oswaldo Cruz Institute in the 1940s.
Before becoming chief of the CSIR's division of animal nutrition in Adelaide (1930–33), Martin had taught physiology at the University of Melbourne and was director of the Lister Institute of Preventive Medicine, London (1903-30), where Burnet obtained his Ph.D. Burnet and Dora Lush at the Hall Institute had also begun to experiment with myxoma virus before the war: see Lush (1937). Bull also obtained a virulent strain of the virus from Shope’s laboratory.
Bull to Fenner, 13 December 1961, folder 143/9/1, box 5, Fenner papers. The Commonwealth director-general of health, J.H.L. Cumpston, who had reluctantly approved the importation of the virus, constrained the choice of experimental site.
Bull to Fenner, 3 August 1955, folder 143/9/1, box 5, Fenner papers. See Bull & Mules (1944).
Melbourne Herald (11 May 1949). Macnamara had worked in the 1920s and 1930s with Burnet, differentiating strains of poliomyelitis virus and studying psittacosis. See Zwar (1984).
Ratcliffe to Douglas Stewart, 28 February 1968, folder 143/9/1, I 1-3, box 4, Fenner papers. Stewart published Rolls (1969), which was full of praise for Macnamara and criticism of Bull and Ratcliffe.
Ratcliffe to Frederick White, 28 February 1968, folder 143/9/1, I 1-3, box 4, Fenner papers.
Extracts from Burnet diary, 9 February 1951, folder 143/9/1B, box 4, Fenner papers. As a veterinary scientist with the CSIR in Sydney, Clunies Ross studied host-parasite relations, especially sheep and hydatids, before the war.
Fenner to Dubos, 1 March 1951, folder 143/7, box 3, Fenner papers.
Dubos to Fenner, 29 March 1951, folder 143/7, box 3, Fenner papers.
Dubos to Fenner, 18 September 1951, folder 143/7/2A, box 3, Fenner papers.
The Lamarckian anatomist and anthropologist Frederic Wood Jones was a strong influence. Wood Jones introduced Fenner to his friend Ford. Fenner’s family was loosely associated with the Jindyworobaks and the Australia First movement, though active in neither.
Fenner to Everyone, 29 May 1941, folder 3C, box 4, Fenner papers.
Keogh found Fenner frustrating at times: I “am worried about him [Noffie],” he wrote to Ford, “He is a pigheaded little bugger, fond and all as I am of him” (Keogh to Ford, February 1943, Ford papers). On connections between malaria research and disease ecology in this period, see Way (2015).
Myers to Fenner, 8 May 1998, folder 143/9/9, box 7, Fenner papers.
Ratcliffe’s team included biochemists John H. Calaby and M. Lazarus; agricultural scientist Bernard V. Fennessy; veterinary scientist Roman Mykytowycz; and zoologists Myers and R. Brereton. Myers was later professor of zoology at the University of Guelph, Canada, but returned after ten years there to work again at the CSIRO.
Fenner to Myers, 14 March 1951, folder 143/9/1, box 5, Fenner papers.
Myers to Fenner, 9 November 1951, folder 143/9/1, box 5, Fenner papers.
Myers to Fenner, 6 December 1951, folder 143/9/1, box 5, Fenner papers.
Myers to Fenner, 6 December 1951, folder 143/9/1, box 5, Fenner papers.
Sobey to Fenner, 26 March 1998, folder 143/9/9, box 7, Fenner papers. A South African, Sobey completed his Ph.D. at Edinburgh before joining the CSIRO in 1953.
Myers to Fenner, 6 December 1951, folder 143/9/1, box 5, Fenner papers.
Kohler (2002) ambiguously describes the adjacency of laboratory and field in terms of both frontier (or boundary) and borderland (or contact zone), leaning toward the latter.
Max Day interviewed by Max Blythe (1993), Australian Academy of Science, http://www.sciencearchive.org.au/scientists/interviews/d/day.html, accessed 7 March 2016. As a child, Day was a keen butterfly collector, encouraged by the lepidopterist G. A. Waterhouse. Later, he became the first chief of the division of forest research at the CSIRO.
Max Day interviewed by Max Blythe (1993). Among other activities, Burnet was advising the US department of defense on preparedness for biological warfare.
Day to Fenner, 15 December 1955, folder 143/9/1D, box 4, Fenner papers. See Fenner et al. (1956).
A few years later, case mortality was 25%.
On 16 August 1953, Ratcliffe wrote to Burnet: “I was most interested in your blueprint of how you thought strains of reduced virulence emerged in nature” (folder 143/9/1, I 1-3, box 4, Fenner papers). He continued, in reference to Lake Urana: “field studies of rabbit resistance are very laborious.”
Fenner to Dubos, 28 September 1954, folder 143/7, box 3, Fenner papers.
Francis N. Ratcliffe, Myxomatosis—Dame Jean Macnamara and the CSIRO, 1969 [typescript], p. 2, box 8, Ratcliffe papers.
Ratcliffe, Myxomatosis, p. 2.
Ratcliffe, Myxomatosis, p. 3.
Ratcliffe, Myxomatosis, p. 6.
Smallpox eradication focused on “surveillance and containment,” whereas for myxomatosis it was all about inoculation, or spread, and surveillance.
Fenner may have heard of Langmuir through mutual interests in wartime malaria research; certainly he knew his postwar advocacy of surveillance; and Fenner’s collaborator D. A. Henderson (a student of Langmuir) later introduced them. See the correspondence in folders 29 and 48, box 6, Langmuir papers, Alan Mason Chesney Medical Archives, Johns Hopkins Medical School, Baltimore, MD. See also Langmuir (1965, 1971); Susser (1985); Declich and Carter (1994); Dando (1999); Brown and Fee (2001); and Fearnley (2010). To this should be added the “medical snooping” of Joseph E. Smadel (friend of Burnet and Fenner) and his acolytes in the early 1950s at the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research: see Anderson (2008): chapter 2.
Fenner went on to write The Biology of Animal Viruses (1968). Later, he founded the Centre for Resources and Environmental Studies at the ANU and became an outspoken advocate of human population control. Ratcliffe was a founder of the Australian Conservation Foundation.
References
Agamben, G. (1998). Homo sacer: Sovereign power and bare life (Daniel Heller-Roazen, Trans.). Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Amsterdamska, O. (2005). Demarcating epidemiology. Science, Technology and Human Values, 30, 17–51.
Anderson, W. (2004). Natural histories of infectious disease: ecological vision in twentieth-century biomedical science. Osiris, 19, 39–61.
Anderson, W. (2006). The cultivation of whiteness: Science, health, and racial destiny in Australia. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Anderson, W. (2008). The collectors of lost souls: Turning Kuru scientists into whitemen. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Anderson, W. (2013). The military spur to Australian medical research. Health and History, 15(1), 80–103.
Anderson, W. (2015). Edge effects in science and medicine. Western Humanities Review, 69, 373–384.
Anderson, W. (2016). Postcolonial ecologies of parasite and host: making parasitism cosmopolitan. Journal of the History of Biology, 49, 241–259.
Anker, P. (2001). Imperial ecology: Environmental order in the British Empire, 1895–1945. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Bartrip, P. W. J. (2008). Myxomatosis: A history of pest control and the rabbit. London: Tauris Academic Studies.
Brown, T. M., & Fee, E. (2001). Preemptive biopreparedness: Can we learn anything from history? American Journal of Public Health, 91, 721–726.
Bull, L. B., & Mules, M. W. (1944). An investigation of Myxomatosis cuniculi, with special reference to the use of the disease to control rabbit populations in Australia. Journal of the CSIR Australia, 17, 79–93.
Burnet, F. M. (1940). Biological aspects of infectious disease. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Collier, S. J., & Lakoff, A. (2007). The vulnerability of vital systems: how “critical infrastructure” became a security problem”. In M. A. Dunn & K. S. Kristensen (Eds.), Securing “The Homeland”: critical infrastructure, risk and (In)Security (pp. 17–39). New York: Routledge.
Collier, S. J., & Lakoff, A. (2008). Distributed preparedness notes on the genealogy of homeland security. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 26, 7–28.
Condon-Rall, M. E. (2000). Malaria in the Southwest Pacific in World War II. In R. M. MacLeod (Ed.), Science and the Pacific War: Science and Survival in the Pacific, 1939–1945 (pp. 51–70). Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic.
Crosby, A. W. (1972). The Columbian exchange: The biological and cultural consequences of 1492. New York: Greenwood Press.
Dando, M. (1999). The impact of the development of modern biology and medicine on the evolution of offensive biological warfare programs in the twentieth century. Defense Analysis, 15, 43–62.
Declich, S., & Carter, A. O. (1994). Public health surveillance: historical origins, methods, and evaluation. Bulletin of the WHO, 72, 285–304.
Deveson, E. (2016). Parasites, politics and public science: the promotion of biological control in Western Australia, 1900–1910. British Journal of the History of Science, 49, 231–258.
Dolman, C. E., & Wolfe, R. J. (2003). Suppressing the diseases of animals and man: Theobald Smith, microbiologist. Boston: Boston Medical Library and Harvard University Press.
Dubos, R. (1958). The evolution of infectious diseases in the course of history. Canadian Medical Association Journal, 79, 447–448.
Erickson, P. & Mitman, G. (2007). When Rabbits became Human (and Humans, Rabbits): Stability, Order, and History in the Study of Populations, Working Papers on the Nature of Evidence No. 19. London: Department of Economic History, London School of Economics.
Farley, J. (1992). Parasites and the germ theory of disease. In C. E. Rosenberg & J. Golden (Eds.), Framing disease: Studies in cultural history (pp. 34–49). New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Fearnley, L. (2010). Epidemic intelligence: Langmuir and the birth of disease surveillance. Behemoth: A Journal on Civilisation, 3, 36–56.
Fenner, F. (1948). The pathogenesis of acute exanthems: an interpretation based on experimental investigations with mousepox (infectious extromelia of mice). Lancet, 2, 915.
Fenner, F. (1952). Myxomatosis: The virus and the disease it causes. Australian Journal of Science, 15, 81–85.
Fenner, F. (1953). Changes in the mortality rate due to myxomatosis in the Australian wild rabbit. Nature, 172, 228–230.
Fenner, F. (1957). Myxomatosis in European rabbits: evolutionary changes in an infectious disease. Australian Journal of Science, 19, 117–122.
Fenner, F. (1968). The biology of animal viruses (Vol. 2). New York: Academic Press.
Fenner, F. (1983). Biological control, as exemplified by smallpox eradication and myxomatosis. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B, 218, 259–285.
Fenner, F. (1999). Nature, nurture, and my experience with smallpox eradication: A career influenced by chance events. Medical Journal of Australia, 171, 638–641.
Fenner, F. (2006). Nature, nurture and chance: The lives of Frank and Charles Fenner. Canberra: ANU ePress.
Fenner, F., Day, M. F., & Woodroofe, G. M. (1956). Epidemiological consequences of the mechanical transmission of myxomatosis by mosquitoes. Journal of Hygiene, 54, 284–303.
Fenner, F., & Fantini, B. (1999). biological control of vertebrate pests: The history of myxomatosis, an experiment in evolution. New York: CABI Publishing.
Fenner, F., Henderson, D. A., Arita, I., Jezek, Z., & Ladnyi, I. D. (1988). Smallpox and its eradication. Geneva: World Health Organization.
Fenner, F., Poole, W. E., Marshall, I. D., & Dyce, A. L. (1957). Studies in the epidemiology of infectious myxomatosis of rabbits. IV: The experimental introduction of the European strain of myxoma virus into Australian wild rabbit populations. Journal of Hygiene, 55, 192–206.
Fenner, F., & Ratcliffe, F. N. (1965). Myxomatosis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Frawley, J., & McCalman, I. (Eds.). (2014). Rethinking invasion ecologies for the environmental humanities. London: Routledge.
Greenwood, M., Bradford Hill, A., Topley, W. W. C. & Wilson, J. (1936). Experimental Epidemiology. Medical Research Council Special Report No. 209. London: HMSO.
Griffiths, T., & Robin, L. (Eds.). (1997). Ecology and empire: Environmental history of settler societies. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
Grove, R. H. (1995). Green imperialism: Colonial expansion, tropical island Edens, and the origins of environmentalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hackett, L. W. (1937). Malaria in Europe: An ecological study. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hardy, A., & Magnello, M. E. (2002). Statistical methods in epidemiology: Karl Pearson, Ronald Ross, Major Greenwood and Austin Bradford Hill, 1900–1945. Sozial- und Präventivmedizin, 47, 80–89.
Honigsbaum, M. (2016). “Tipping the balance”: Karl Friedrich Meyer, latent infection, and the birth of modern ideas of disease ecology. Journal of the History of Biology, 49, 261–309.
King, N. B. (2004). The scale politics of emerging diseases. Osiris, 19, 62–76.
Kingsland, S. E. (1996). Evolutionary theory and the foundations of population ecology: the work of A. J. Nicholson (1895–1969). In R. B. Floyd, A. W. Sheppard, & P. J. de Barro (Eds.), Frontiers of population ecology (pp. 13–25). Canberra: CSIRO Publishing.
Kohler, R. E. (2002). Landscapes and labscapes: Exploring the lab-field border in biology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Langmuir, A. D. (1965). Newer surveillance methods in the control of communicable disease: developing concepts of surveillance. Millbank Memorial Fund Quarterly, 43, 369–372.
Langmuir, A. D. (1971). Communicable disease surveillance: the evolution of the concept of surveillance in the United States. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 64, 681–684.
Latour, B., & Woolgar, S. (1979). Laboratory life: The construction of scientific facts. Beverley Hills: Sage.
Lush, D. (1937). The virus of infectious myxomatosis of rabbits on the chorioallantoic membrane of the developing egg. Australian Journal of Experimental Biology and Medical Science, 15, 131.
Martin, C. J. (1936). Observations on Myxomatosis cuniculi (Sanarelli) Made with a View to the Use of the Virus in the Control of Rabbit Plagues. Bulletin of the CSIR Australia, Bulletin no. 96.
May, R. M. (1993). Ecology and evolution of host-virus interactions. In S. S. Morse (Ed.), Emerging viruses (pp. 58–68). New York: Oxford University Press.
May, R. M., & Anderson, R. M. (1982). Coevolution of hosts and parasites. Parasitology, 85, 411–426.
McNeill, W. H. (1976). Plagues and peoples. New York: Doubleday.
Mendelsohn, J. A. (1998). From eradication to equilibrium: how epidemics became complex after World War I. In C. Lawrence & G. Weisz (Eds.), Greater than the parts: Holism in biomedicine, 1920–1950 (pp. 303–331). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Mulligan, M., & Hill, S. (2001). Ecological pioneers: A social history of australian ecological thought and action. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
Myers, K. (1954). Studies in the epidemiology of infectious myxomatosis of rabbits. II: Field experiments, August–November 1950, and the first epizootic of myxomatosis in the Riverine plain of south-eastern Australia. Journal of Hygiene, 52, 47–59.
Myers, K., Marshall, I. D., & Fenner, F. (1954). Studies in the epidemiology of infectious myxomatosis of rabbits. III: Observations on two succeeding epizootics in Australian wild rabbits on the Riverine plain of south-eastern Australia. Journal of Hygiene, 52, 337–360.
Mykytowycz, R. (1953). An attenuated strain of the myxomatosis virus recovered from the field. Nature, 172, 448–449.
Nicholson, A. J. (1933). The balance of animal populations. Journal of Animal Ecology, 2, 131–178.
Powell, S. (2001). “Why misguided humans have attempted to make their homes it is more than I can comprehend”: Francis Ratcliffe”s first impressions of Australia. Eras Journal, 1, http://www.arts.monash.edu.au/eras/edition_1/powell.htm. Accessed Nov 6, 2001.
Ratcliffe, F. (1938). Flying fox and drifting sand: The adventures of a biologist in Australia. London: Chatto and Windus.
Ratcliffe, F. N., Myers, K., Fennessy, B. V., & Calaby, J. H. (1952). Myxomatosis in Australia: A step toward the biological control of the rabbit. Nature, 170, 7–19.
Rheinberger, H.-J. (1997). Toward a history of epistemic things: Synthesizing proteins in the test-tube. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Rolls, E. C. (1969). They all ran wild: The story of pests on the land in Australia. Sydney: Angus and Robertson.
Rosenberg, C. E. (1979). Toward an ecology of knowledge: on discipline, context and history. In A. Oleson & J. Voss (Eds.), The organization of knowledge in modern America, 1860–1920 (pp. 440–455). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Rosenberg, C. E. (1992). Explaining epidemics. In Explaining epidemics and other studies in the history of medicine (pp. 293–304). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schedvin, C. B. (1984). Environment, economy and Australian biology, 1890–1939. Australian Historical Studies, 21, 11–28.
Schedvin, C. B. (1987). Shaping science and industry: A history of Australia”s council for scientific and industrial research, 1926–49. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
Spencer, M. (1994). Malaria and the Land Headquarters Medical Research Unit, 1943–1946. Medical Journal of Australia, 161, 78–82.
Susser, M. (1985). Epidemiology in the United States after World War II: The evolution of technique. Epidemiological Reviews, 7, 147–177.
Sweeney, T. (2003). Malaria frontline: Australian Army Research during World War II. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
Tilley, H. (2011). Africa as a living laboratory: Empire, development, and the problem of scientific knowledge, 1870–1950. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Walker, A. S. (1952). Clinical problems of war. Canberra: Australian War Memorial.
Way, A. G. (2015). The invisible and indeterminable value of ecology: From malaria control to ecological research in the American south. Isis, 106, 310–336.
Worboys, M. (1988). Manson, Ross and colonial medical policy: tropical medicine in London and Liverpool, 1899–1914. In R. MacLeod & M. Lewis (Eds.), Disease, medicine, and empire: perspectives on western medicine and the experience of European expansion (pp. 21–38). New York: Routledge.
Zwar, D. (1984). The Dame: the life and times of Dame Jean Macnamara, medical pioneer. Melbourne: Macmillan.
Acknowledgements
I am grateful to Mark Honigsbaum and Pierre-Olivier Méthot for prompting me to write this essay. Frank Fenner clarified aspects of his involvement in an interview with me in Canberra, 20 July 2002. My analysis benefited from discussions with Lyle Fearnley, Emma Kowal, Robert Peckham, Joanna Radin, and Charles Rosenberg; and Mark Veitch provided some epidemiological intelligence. James Dunk gave valuable research assistance. Thanks to the officers and staff of the Australian Academy of Science and its Basser Library I was able to consult the Fenner papers. Also helpful were archivists from the National Library of Australia, the Royal Australasian College of Physicians, the University of Melbourne, and the Alan Mason Chesney Archives of the Johns Hopkins University. My research was supported by a Grant from the Australian Research Council (FL110100243).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Anderson, W. Nowhere to run, rabbit: the cold-war calculus of disease ecology. HPLS 39, 13 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40656-017-0140-7
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s40656-017-0140-7