Abstract
The rationality of scientific concept formation in theory transitions, challenged by the thesis of semantic incommensurability, can be restored by theChains of Meaning approach to concept formation. According to this approach, concepts of different, succeeding theories may be identified with respect to referential meaning, in spite of grave diversity of the mathematical structures characterizing them in their respective theories. The criterion of referential identity for concepts is that they meet a relation ofsemantic embedding, i.e. that the embedding concept can be substituted by the embedded one in “classical limit” situations. Three case studies from contemporary physics theories will be used to show that the Chains of Meaning approach not only yields meaning comparisons for already established concepts (as for Newtonian and Schwarzschild mass) but is also well suited to characterize actual scientific strategies of concept formation in yet open cases such as black hole entropy or relativistic thermodynamics.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Achinstein, P.: 1964, ‘On the Meaning of Scientific Terms’,The Journal of Philosophy 61, 497–509.
Achinstein, P.: 1968,Concepts of Science, Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore.
Anderson, J. L.: 1964, ‘Relativity Principles and the Role of Coordinates in Physics’, in: H.-Y. Chiu and W. F. Hoffmann (eds.),Gravitation and Relativity, W. A. Benjamin, New York, pp. 175–94.
Bekenstein, J.: 1973, ‘Black Holes and Entropy’,Physical Review D 7, 2333–6.
Bekenstein, J.: 1975, ‘Statistical Black-hole Thermodynamics’,Physical Review D 12, 3077–85.
Bekenstein, J.: 1980, ‘Black-hole Thermodynamics’,Physics Today 33, 24–31.
Bridge, J.: 1977,Beginning Model Theory, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Chuang Liu: 1991,Relativistic Thermodynamics: Its History and Foundations, Diss. University of Pittsburgh.
Denbigh, K. G. and J. S. Denbigh: 1985,Entropy in Relation to Incomplete Knowledge, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Eimerl, D.: 1975, ‘On Relativistic Thermodynamics’,Annals of Physics 91, 481–98.
Gerlach, U. H.: 1976, ‘The Mechanism of Blackbody Radiation from an Incipient Black Hole’,Physical Review D 14, 1479–508.
Grad, H.: 1961, ‘The Many Faces of Entropy’,Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics 14, 323–54.
Hawking, S. W.: 1976, ‘Black Holes and Thermodynamics’,Physical Review D 13, 191–7.
Van Kampen, N. G.: 1968, ‘Relativistic Thermodynamics of Moving Systems’,The Physical Review 173, 295–301.
Kellerman, P. L.: 1980, ‘Heat Flow in Relativistic Equilibrium Thermodynamics’,Foundations of Physics 10, 163–73.
Kuhn, T. S.: 1982, ‘Commensurability, Comparability, Communicability’, in P. D. Asquith and T. Nickles (eds.),PSA 1982, Vol. 2, Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, pp. 669–88.
Landsberg, P. T.: 1967, ‘Does a Moving Body Appear Cool?’,Nature 214, 903–4.
Landsberg, P. T.: 1970, ‘Special Relativistic Thermodynamics. A Review’, in E. B. Stuart, A. J. Brainard and B. Gal-Or (eds.),A Critical Review of Thermodynamics, Mono Book Corp., Baltimore, pp. 253–72.
Landsberg, P. T.: 1980, ‘Thought Experiment to Determine the Special Relativistic Temperature Transformation’,Physical Review Letters 45, 149–50.
Landsberg, P. T.: 1981, ‘Einstein and Statistical Thermodynamics I: Relativistic Thermodynamics’,European Journal of Physics 2, 203–7.
Muschik, W., W. H. Müller, and P. Carelos: 1979, ‘Nonuniqueness of Special Relativistic Transformation Law for Non-Equilibrium Temperature’, unpublished manuscript.
Nersessian, N.: 1984,Faraday to Einstein: Constructing Meaning in Scientific Theories, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Nersessian, N.: 1988, ‘Reasoning from Imagery and Analogy in Scientific Concept Formation’, in A. Fine and J. Leplin (eds.),PSA 1988, Vol. 1, Philosophy of Science Association, East Lansing, pp. 41–7.
Neugebauer, G.: 1980,Relativistische Thermodynamik, Vieweg, Berlin.
Newburgh, R. G.: 1979, ‘Relativistic Thermodynamics: Temperature Transformations, Invariance and Measurement,Il Nuovo Cimento 52B, 219–28.
Ott, H.: 1963, ‘Lorentz-Transformation der Wärme und der Temperatur’,Zeitschrift für Physik 175, 70–104.
Penrose, R.: 1989,The Emperor's New Mind, Oxford Unlversity Press, Oxford.
Planck, M.: 1908, ‘Zur Dynamik bewegter Systeme’,Annalen der Physik 26, 1–34.
Reif, F.: 1983,Fundamentals of Statistical and Thermal Physics, McGraw-Hill, Tokyo.
Schwarzschild, K.: 1916a, ‘Über das Gravitationsfeld eines Massenpunktes nach der Einsteinschen Theorie’,Berliner Berichte, January, 189–96.
Schwarzschild, K.: 1916b, ‘Über das Gravitationsfeld einer Kugel aus inkompressibler Flüssigkeit nach der Einsteinschen Theorie’,Sitzungsberichte der Deutschen Akademie der Wissenschaften, Kl. Math, Phys. Tech., 424–34.
Treder, H.-J.: 1977, ‘Die Strahlungstemperatur bewegter Körper’,Annalen der Physik 34, 23–9.
Treder, H.-J.: 1978, ‘Zur Strahlungstemperatur bewegter Körper’,Annalen der Physik 35, 77–8.
Wald, R. M.: 1984,General Relativity, Chicago University Press, Chicago.
Zurek, W. H. and K. S. Thorne: 1985, ‘Statistical Mechanical Origin of the Entropy of a Rotating Charged Black Hole’,Physical Review Letters 54, 2171–5.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bartels, A. Chains of meaning: A model for concept formation in contemporary physics theories. Synthese 105, 347–379 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01063563
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01063563