Abstract
History of science provides access to a reservoir of meaningful experiments that can be studied and reproduced in classrooms. This is the case of Joule’s paddle-wheel experiment which displays the potentiality to help students improve their understanding of the concept of energy. This experiment has been mentioned in many physics textbooks during the twentieth century. Recently, it has received renewed attention by several researchers in science education. However, the accounts of Joule’s experiment proposed by these researchers are at variance with each other: either in terms of equivalences, in terms of energy change, or in terms of energy transformation and Rankine’s definition. This raises several questions: What is their respective contribution to the understanding of the historical emergence of the energy concept, and to the understanding of the very meaning of this concept? Are these accounts concurrent? Eventually, how can they help for the teaching energy? To investigate these questions, historical details concerning this experiment are first considered. It is stressed that Joule did not made use of the concept of energy, and instead described his experiment in terms of conversion of living force into heat. The three accounts of Joule’s experiment are then presented and their respective contribution discussed. By emphasizing different aspects of this experiment, they are shown to suggest different strategies for teaching energy. For all that, they are not contradictory and, considered together, they bring to light the great potential of Joule’s experiment to foster students understanding of this concept.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
source Joule 1850)
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
The pagination used for all Joule’s quotations is the one of The Scientific Papers of James Prescott Joule, Vol. 1, 1884, Taylor & Francis.
References
Bächtold, M. (2018). How should energy be defined throughout schooling? Research in Science Education, 48(2), 345–367.
Bächtold, M., & Guedj, M. (2014). Teaching energy informed by the history and epistemology of the concept with implications for teacher education. In M. Matthews (Ed.), International handbook of research in history, philosophy and science teaching (pp. 211–243). Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer.
Bächtold, M., & Munier, V. (2019). Teaching energy at high school by making use of history and philosophy of science: a sequence based on Joule’s experiment and Rankine’s definition. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 56(6), 765–796.
Bécu-Robinault, K., & Tiberghien, A. (1998). Integrating experiments into the teaching of energy. International Journal of Science Education, 20(1), 99–114.
Beynon, J. (1990). Some myths surrounding energy. Physics Education, 25(6), 314–316.
Brewe, E. (2011). Energy as a substance like quantity that flows: Theoretical considerations and pedagogical consequences. Physical Review Special Topics - Physics Education Research, 7(020106), 1–14.
Cardwell, D. (1989). James Joule: A biography. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Cassirer, E. (1929 [1972]). La philosophie des formes symboliques 3: la phénoménologie de la connaissance (fr. tr.). Paris: Les éditions de Minuit.
Chang, H. (2011). How historical experiments can improve scientific knowledge and science education: The cases of boiling water and electrochemistry. Science & Education, 20(3–4), 317–341.
Clausius, R (1850). Über die bewegende Kraft der Wärme und die Gesetze, welche sich daraus für die Wärmelehr selbst ableiten lassen. Annalen der Physik und Chemie, 155(3), 368–397 [English translation in E. Mendoza (ed.) (1960). Reflections on the motive power of fire by Sadi Carnot, and other papers on the second law of thermodynamics, by E. Clapeyron and R. Clausius (pp. 73–74, 109–152). New York: Dover Publications].
Clausius, R. (1867). The mechanical theory of heat: with its application to the steam engine and to the physical properties of bodies (ed. by T.A. Hirst). London: John van Voorst.
Coelho, R. (2009). On the concept of energy: How understanding its history can improve physics teaching. Science & Education, 18, 961–983.
Coelho, R. (2014). On the concept of energy: Eclecticism and rationality. Science & Education, 23, 1361–1380.
De Berg, K. (1997). The development of the concept of work: A case study where history can inform pedagogy. Science & Education, 6(5), 511–527.
De Hosson, C., (2011). L’histoire des sciences: un laboratoire pour la recherche en didactique et l’enseignement de la physique. University Paris-Diderot. Retrieved from https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-00655594/.
Doménech, J.-L., Gil-Pérez, D., Gras-Marti, A., Guisasola, J., Martínez-Torregrosa, J., Salinas, J., et al. (2007). Teaching of energy issues: A debate proposal for a global reorientation. Science & Education, 16, 43–64.
Duit, R. (1987). Should energy be introduced as something quasi-material? International Journal of Science Education, 9, 139–145.
Elkana, Y. (1974). The discovery of the conservation of energy. London: Hutchinson Educational.
Falk, G., Hermann, F., & Schmid, G. (1983). Energy forms or energy carriers? American Journal of Physics, 51(12), 1074–1077.
Forrester, J. (1975). Chemistry and the conservation of energy: The work of James Prescott Joule. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, Part A, 6(4), 273–313.
Galison, P. (1987). How experiments end. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Gauld, C. (1991). History of science, individual development and science teaching. Research in Science Education, 21(1), 133–140.
Hacking, I. (1983). Interpreting and intervening: Introductory topics in philosophy of natural science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Harman, P. (1982). Energy, force and matter: The conceptual development of nineteenth century physics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hiebert, E. (1981). Historical roots of the principle of conservation of energy. New York: Arno Press.
Joule, J. (1845). On the existence of an equivalent relation between heat and the ordinary forms of mechanical power. Philosophical Magazine, series 3, 27, 205–207. Reprinted in The Scientific Papers of James Prescott Joule, Vol. 1, 1884 (pp. 202–205). Taylor & Francis.
Joule, J. (1847a). On matter, living force, and heat. Published in the Manchester Courier newspaper, May 5 and 12. Reprinted in The Scientific Papers of James Prescott Joule, Vol. 1, 1884 (pp. 265–276). Taylor & Francis.
Joule, J. (1847b). On the mechanical equivalent of heat, as determined by the heat evolved by the friction of fluids. Philosophical Magazine, series 3, 31, 173–176. Reprinted in The Scientific Papers of James Prescott Joule, Vol. 1, 1884 (pp. 277–283). Taylor & Francis.
Joule, J. (1847c). Expériences sur l’identité entre le calorique et la force mécanique: détermination de l’aquivalent par la chaleur dégagée pendant la friction du mercure. Comptes Rendus, 23 août. Reprinted in The Scientific Papers of James Prescott Joule, Vol. 1, 1884 (pp. 283–286). Taylor & Francis.
Joule, J. (1850). On the mechanical equivalent of heat. Philosophical Transactions, part I. Reprinted in The Scientific Papers of James Prescott Joule, Vol. 1, 1884 (pp. 298–328). Taylor & Francis.
Kuhn, T. (1959). Energy conservation as an example of simultaneous discovery. In M. Clagett (ed.), Critical Problems in the History of Science (pp. 321–56). Madison (Wis.): The University of Wisconsin Press. Reprinted in T. Kuhn (1978), The essential tension: selected studies in scientific tradition and change (pp. 66–104). Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Lehavi, Y., & Eylon, B.-S. (2018). Integrating science education research and history and philosophy of science in developing an energy curriculum. In M. Matthews (Ed.), History, philosophy and science teaching: New perspectives (pp. 235–260). Cham: Springer.
Lehavi, Y., Yosovich, A., & Barak, S. (2016). Bringing Joule back to school. School Science Review, 97(361), 9–14.
Nordine, J., Krajcik, J. & Fortus, D. (2011). Transforming energy instruction in middle school to support intergrated understanding and future learning. Science Education, 95(4), 670–699.*
Papadouris, N., & Constantinou, C. (2016). Investigating middle school students’ ability to develop energy as a framework for analyzing simple physical phenomena. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 53(1), 119–145.
Pickering, A. (1995). The mangle of practice: Time, agency, and science. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Rankine, W. (1853). On the general law of the transformation of energy. Philosophical magazine, 1853(5), 106–117.
Rankine, W. (1855). Outlines of the science of energetics. The Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal, II(3), 121–141.
Sibum, H. (1995). Reworking the mechanical value of heat: instruments of precision and gestures of accuracy in early Victorian England. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 26(1), 73–106.
Smith, C. (2003). Force, energy, and thermodynamics. In M. J. Nye (Ed.), The Cambridge history of science: The modern physical and mathematical sciences (pp. 289–310). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Thomson, W. (1849). An account of Carnot’s theory of the motive power of heat; with numerical results deduced from Regnault's experiments on steam. Earth and Environmental Science Transactions of The Royal Society of Edinburgh, XVI, 5, 541–574.
Thomson, W. (1851). On the dynamical theory of heat: With a numerical result deduced from Mr Joule’s equivalent of a thermal unit, and M. Regnault’s observations on steam. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, 3, 48–52.
Thomson, W. (1852). On a universal tendency in nature to the dissipation of mechanical energy. In Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh for April 19, 1852.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Ethics declarations
Conflict of interest
The author declares that he has no conflict of interest.
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bächtold, M. Introducing Joule’s Paddle Wheel Experiment in the Teaching of Energy: Why and How?. Found Sci 26, 791–805 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10699-020-09664-2
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10699-020-09664-2