Abstract
In the superannuation/pension industry, ordinary investors entrust their retirement savings to the trustees of the superannuation plan. Investors rely on the trustees to ensure that ethical business and risk management practices are implemented to protect their retirement savings. Governance practices ensure the monitoring of ethical risk management (Drennan, L. T.: 2004, Journal of Business Ethics 52, 257–266). The Australian superannuation industry presents a unique scenario. Legislation requires employers to contribute a minimum of 9% of the employees wage to retirement savings. However, there are no legislated governance standards, although there are standards of recommended governance practices. In this article, we examine the level of voluntary adoption of governance practices by the trustees of Australian public sector and industry superannuation funds. We also assess whether superannuation governance practices are associated with performance and volatility/riskiness of returns. Survey results show that the majority of superannuation plans adopt recommended governance practices supporting the concept of ethical management of the member’s retirement savings. The examination of governance principles that impact returns and risk shows that board size and regular review of conflicts are positively associated with return. Superannuation plans with higher volatility in returns meet more frequently.
Abbreviations
- APRA:
-
Australian Prudential Reg- ulation Authority
- ASFA:
-
Association of Superannuation Funds of Australia
- ACSI:
-
Australian Council of Super Investors
- AIST:
-
Australian Institute of Superannuation Trustees
- ASX:
-
Australian Securities Exchange
- ICAA:
-
The Institute of Chartered Accountants Australia
- CEOs:
-
Chief Executive Officers
- CIOs:
-
Chief Investment Officers
- PDS:
-
Product Disclosure Statement
- CRIF:
-
Centre for Research in Finance
References
Albrecht W. G. and V. L. Hingorani: 2004, ‘Effects of Governance Practices and Investment Strategies on State and Local Government Pension Fund Financial Performance’, International Journal of Public Administration, 27(8), 673–700.
Albrecht W.G., H. Shamsub, and N.A. Giannatasio: 2007, ‘Public Pension Governance Practices and Financial Performance’, Journal of Public Budgeting: Accounting and Financial Management, 19(2), 245–267.
Ambachtsheer, K., R. Capelle and H. Lum: 2007, The State of Global Pension Fund Governance Today: Board Competency Still a Problem, Working Paper, Rotman International Center for Pension Management, University of Toronto, Toronto.
Association of Superannuation Funds Australia: 2004, ASFA Best Practice Series Superannuation; Superannuation Fund Governance: Understanding the Framework, Addressing the Issue, ASFA Best Practice Paper No. 7 (Revised), Australia.
Australian Council of Super Investors: 2005, ‘ASCI Corporate Governance Guidelines: A Guide for Superannuation Trustees to Monitor Listed Australian Companies’, Australia.
Australian Government: 1993, ‘Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act. 1993’, http://www.comlaw.gov.au/comlaw/Legislation/ActCompilation1.nsf/0/D1ECBBEBDB3C341ECA25748200025ECA?OpenDocument.
Australian Government: 2008, ‘Guide to Social Security Law’, http://www.fahcsia.gov.au/guides_acts/ssg/ssguide-4/ssguide-4.8/ssguide-4.8.1/ssguide-4.8.1.10.html.
Australian Government Attorney-General’s Department: 2005, ‘Superannuation Choice Act No. 82’, C2005 A00082, Australia.
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority: 2001, ‘Review of the Methodology behind APRA Superannuation Statistics’, Australia.
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority: 2005, ‘Statistics Classification of Superannuation Entities’, Australia.
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority: 2007, ‘APRA Insight: Celebrating 10 Years of Superannuation Data Collection 1999–2006’, Issue 2, Special Edition, Australia. http://www.apra.gov.au/Insight/APRA-Insight-Issue-2-2007.cfm
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority: 2008, ‘APRA Insight: Superannuation Fund Governance: Trustee Policies and Practices’, Issue 1, Australia, pp. 2–17. http://www.apra.gov.au/Insight/upload/Superannuation-fund-governance.pdf.
Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) Corporate Governance Council: 2007, Corporate Governance Principles and Recommendations, 2nd Edition (ASX Corporate Governance Council, Australia).
Beasley, J., V. Carcello, D. R. Hermanson and P. D. Lapides: 2000, ‘Fraudulent Financial Reporting: Considerations of Industry Traits and Corporate Governance Mechanisms’, Accounting Horizons 14(4), 441–454.
Bédard, J., S. M. Chtourou, and L. Courteau: 2004, ‘The Effect of Audit Committee Expertise, Independence, and Activity on Aggressive Earnings Management’, Auditing: A Journal of Practice and Theory, 23 (2), 13-35.
Berk, J. B., and R. C. Green: 2004, ‘Mutual Fund Flows and Performance in Rational Markets’, Journal of Political Economy, 112(6), 1269-1295.
Bilson, C., A. Frino, and R. Heaney: 2005, ‘Australian Retail Fund Performance Persistence’, Accounting and Finance, 45(1), 25-42.
Chen, F., L. W. Chen and J. C. Ling: 2005, Monitoring Mechanisms and Management Turnover in Mutual Fund Industry, Working Paper, Louisiana State University, National Chi-Nan University.
Chen, J., H., Hong, M. Huang and J. D. Kubik: 2004, ‘Does Fund Size Erode Mutual Fund Performance? The Role of Liquidity and Organization’, American Economic Review, 94(5), 1276-1302.
Cheng, S: 2008, ‘Board Size and the Variability of Corporate Performance’, Journal of Financial Economics 87(1), 157–176.
Clark, G.L. and A.H.B. Monk: 2008, ‘Conceptualizing the Defined Benefit Pension Promise: Implications from a Surevey of Expert Opinion’, Benefits Quarterly, 24, 7-18.
Clark, G.L. and R. Urwin: 2008, ‘Best-Practice Pension Fund Governance’, Journal of Asset Management, 9, 2–21.
Clark, G.L. and R. Urwin: 2009, Innovative Models of Pension fFund Governance in the Context of the Global Financial Crisis, Pensions , 15(1): 62–77.
Coleman, A.D.F., N. Esho and M. Wong: 2006, ‘The Impact of Agency Costs on the Investment Performance of Australian Pension Funds’, Journal of Pension, Economics and Finance, 5(3), 299-324.
Core, J. E., R. W. Holthausen and D. F. Larcker: 1999, ‘Corporate Governance, Chief Executive Officer Compensation, and Firm Performance’, Journal of Financial Economics, 51(3), 371-406.
CPA Australia: 2006, ‘Super Funds Should be ‘Super’ Investors Say Australian Public: CPA Australia Survey’, November, www.cpaaustralia.com.au/links?cicr.
Ding, B. and R. Wermers: 2005, Mutual Fund Performance and Governance Structure: The Role of Portfolio Managers and Board of Directors, Working Paper, The State of University New York, University of Maryland.
Drennan, L.T: 2004, ‘Ethics, Governance and Risk Management: Lessons From Mirror Group Newspapers and Barings Bank’, Journal of Business Ethics, 52, 257–266.
Drew, M. E. and J. D. Stanford: 2003, ‘Principal and Agent Problems in Superannuation Funds’, Australian Economic Review, 36(1), 98-107.
Erickson, J., Y.W. Park, J. Reising and H. H. Shin: 2005, ‘Board Composition and Firm Value under Concentrated Ownership: The Canadian Evidence’, Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, 13, 387-410.
Evans, J. and C. Weir: 1995, ‘Decision Processes, Monitoring, Incentives and Large Firms’, Management Decision, 33(6), 32–38.
Frino, A., R. Heaney and D. Service: 2005, ‘Do Past Performance and Past Cash Flows Explain Current Cash Flows into Retail Superannuation Funds in Australia’? Australian Journal of Management, 30(2), 229–244.
Gompers, P. A., J.L. Ishii and A. Metrick: 2003, ‘Corporate Governance and Equity Prices’, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(1), 107–155.
Goodstein, J., K., Gautam and W. Boeker: 1994, ‘The Effects of Board Size and Diversity on Strategic Change’. Strategic Management Journal, 15, 241-250.
Hallahan, T., R. W. Faff. and K. L. Benson: 2008, `Favours the Bold? Exploring Tournament Behaviour Among Australian Superannuation Funds', Journal of Financial Services Research 33(3), 205–220.
Harper, J. T.: 2008, Board of Trustee Composition and Investment Performance of US Public Pension Plans, Working Paper, Rotman International Centre for Pension Management, University of Toronto.
Hutchinson, M. and F. A. Gul: 2004, ‘Investment Opportunity Set, Corporate Governance Practices and Firm Performance’, Journal of Corporate Finance, 10(4), 595-614.
Indro, D. C., C. X. Jiang, M. V., Hu and W. Y. Lee: 1999, ‘Mutual Fund Performance: Does Fund Size Matter’? Financial Analysts Journal, 55(3), 74-87.
Institute of Chartered Accountants Australia and Deloitte: 2008, ‘The Governance of Superannuation Funds – The Industry Three Years on from Trustee Licensing’, http://www.deloitte.com/assets/DcomAustralia/Local%20Assets/Documents/Deloitte_ICAA_Governance_Survey_online(1).pdf.
Institute of Chartered Accountants Australia and Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu: 2002, ‘Governance of Superannuation Funds’, Research Report, Australia. http://www.charteredaccountants.com.au/files/documents/governance_of_super_funds_2008.pdf.
Jensen, M. C. and W. H. Meckling: 1976, ‘Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behaviour Agency Costs and Ownership Structure’, Journal of Financial Economics, 3(4), 305-360.
Klein, P., D. Shapiro and J. Young: 2005, ‘Corporate Governance, Family Ownership and Firm Value: The Canadian evidence’, Corporate Governance: An International Review 13(6), 769–784.
McMullen, D. A. and K. Raghundan: 1996, ‘Enhancing Audit Committee Effectiveness’, Journal of Accountancy, 183, 79-81.
Peasnell, K. V., P. F. Pope and S. Young: 2005, ‘Board Monitoring and Earnings Management: Do Outside Directors Influence Abnormal Accruals?’, Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 32(7/8), 1311-1346.
Picou A. and Michael J. Rubach: 2006, ‘Does Good Governance Matter to Institutional investors? Evidence from the Enactment of Corporate Governance Guidelines’, Journal of Business Ethics, 65, 55-67.
Ryan, L.V. and B. Dennis: 2003, ‘The Ethical Undercurrents of Pension Fund Management: Establishing a Research Agenda’. Business Ethics Quarterly 13(3), 315-335.
Schneider S. and F. Damanpour: 2002a, ‘The Role of Fund Value Maximization and Public Choice Theory’, Public Management Review, 4(1), 551–573.
Schneider S. and F. Damanpour: 2002b, ‘Public Choice Economics and Public Pension Plan Funding: An Empirical Test’, Administration & Society, 34(1), 57-86.
Tufano, P., and M. Sevick: 1997, ‘Board Structure and Fee-setting in the U.S. Mutual Fund Industry’, Journal of Financial Economics, 46(3), 321-355.
University of Melbourne Centre for Corporate Law and Securities Regulation: 2000, ‘Corporate Governance: The Role of Superannuation Trustees’, Institutional Analysis, Melbourne, Australia.
Useem, M. and O.S. Mitchell: 2000, ‘Holders of the Purse Strings: Governance and Performance of Public Retirement Systems’, Social Science Quarterly, 81(2), 489-506.
Vafeas, N.: 1999, ‘Board Meeting Frequency and Firm Performance’, Journal of Financial Economics, 53(1), 113-142.
Wellman, J. and J. Zhou: 2005, Corporate Governance and Mutual Fund Performance: A First Look at the Morningstar Stewardship Grades, Working Paper, The State University of New York.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Benson, K.L., Hutchinson, M. & Sriram, A. Governance in the Australian Superannuation Industry. J Bus Ethics 99, 183–200 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-010-0648-1
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-010-0648-1