Abstract
Trotsky’s contribution to historical materialism has been subject to two broadly defined critical assessments. Detractors have tended to dismiss his interpretation of Marxism as a form of productive force determinism, while admirers have tended to defend his Marxism as a voluntarist negation of the same. In this essay I argue that both of these opinions share an equally caricatured interpretation of Second International Marxism against which Trotsky is compared. By contrast, I argue that Trotsky’s Marxism can best be understood as a powerful application and deepening of the strongest elements of Second International methodology to a novel set of problems. Thus, against Trotsky’s admirers, I locate his Marxism as both emerging out of, in addition to breaking with, Second International Marxism; while, against his critics, I argue that it was precisely the strengths of this earlier interpretation of Marxism that informed Trotsky’s powerful contributions to historical materialism: his concept of combined and uneven development and his discussion of the role of individual agents within the Marxist interpretation of history.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
P Anderson (1980) Arguments with English Marxism Verso London
P Beilharz (1985) ArticleTitle“Trotsky as Historian” History Workshop Journal 20 IssueIDAutumn 36–55
Beilharz, P. Trotsky, Trotskyism and the Transition to Socialism, Beckenham, Croom Helm, 1987
Blackledge, P. “Karl Kautsky’s Contribution to Historical Materialism,” Science and Society 70, (2006).
T Brotherstone P. Dukes (Eds) (1992) The Trotsky Reappraisal University Press Edinburgh
Cliff, T. Trotsky (Vols. I–IV), London, Bookmarks, 1989–1993
Deutscher I. Trotsky: The Prophet Armed, Oxford University Press, 1954.
Deutscher I. Trotsky: The Prophet Outcast, Oxford University Press, 1963.
Donald M. Marxism and Revolution, Yale University Press, 1993.
Eley G. “Marxist Historiography,” in S. Berger et al. (ed.), Writing History: Theory and Practice, Arnold, London, 2003.
J Elster (1986) “The Theory of Combined and Uneven Development: A Critique” J. Roemer (Eds) Analytical Marxism Cambridge University Press Cambridge
F Engels (1956) The Peasant War in Germany Progress Publishers Moscow
A Gramsci (1977) Selections from Political Writings 1921–1926 Lawrence and Wishart London
N Harding (1983) Lenin’s Political Thought Macmillan London
C.L.R James (1994) “Trotsky’s Place in History” C. McLemee P. LeBlanc (Eds) C.L.R. James and Revolutionary Marxism: Selected Writings of C.L.R. James 1939–1949 Humanities Press New Jersey
K. Kautsky (2004) ArticleTitle“The American Worker,” Historical Materialism 11 IssueID4 15–77 Occurrence Handle10.1163/156920603322889231
K Kautsky (1983) “The Driving Force of the Russian Revolution and its Prospects” N. Harding (Eds) Marxism in Russia: Key Documents 1879–1906 Cambridge University Press Cambridge
B Knei-Paz (1978) The Social and Political thought of Leon Trotsky Oxford University Press Oxford
N Krasso (1967) ArticleTitle“Trotsky’s Marxism,” New Left Review 44 64–86
Labriola, A. Essays on the Materialist Conception of History, 1896 at http://www.marxists.org/archive/labriola/index.htm
Labriola, A. Socialism and Philosophy, 1897 at http://www.marxists.org/archive/labriola/index.htm
V Lenin (1964) The Development of Capitalism in Russia Progress Publishers Moscow
M Lowy (1981) The Politics of Combined and Uneven Development Verso London
A MacIntyre (1971) “Trotsky in Exile” A. MacIntyre (Eds) Against the Self-Images of the Age Duckworth London
E. Mandel (1968) ArticleTitle“Trotsky’s Marxism: An Anti-Critique,” New Left Review 47 32–51
E Mandel (1995) Trotsky as Alternative Verso London
K Marx (1973) “Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte” K. Marx (Eds) Surveys from Exile Penguin London
K Marx (1976) Capital (vol. I) Penguin London
J Molyneux (1981) Leon Trotsky’s Theory of Revolution Harvester Brighton
M Perry (2002) Marxism and History Palgrave London
Plekhanov, G. Socialism and the Political Struggle, 1883 at http://www.marxists.org/archive/plekhanov/1883/struggle/index.htm
G Plekhanov (1940) The Role of the Individual in History Progress Publishers Moscow
G Plekhanov (1946) The Materialist Conception of History Progress Publishers Moscow
G Plekhanov (1962) Fundamental Problems of Marxism Progress Publishers Moscow
P. Pomper (Eds) (1986) Trotsky’s Notebooks, 1933–1935 Columbia University Press New York
J Rees (1998) The Algebra of Revolution Routledge London
Rigby S. Marxism and History, Manchester University Press, 1998.
A.L Rowse (1947) “An Epic of Revolution: Reflections on Trotsky’s History” A.L. Rowse (Eds) The End of an Epoch Macmillan London
R Segal (1979) The Tragedy of Leon Trotsky Peregrine London
H. Ticktin M. Cox (Eds) (1995) The Ideas of Leon Trotsky Porcupine Press London
I Thatcher (2003) Trotsky Routledge London
W Thompson (2004) Postmodernism and History Palgrave London
Trotsky, L. “Results and Prospects,” in L. Trotsky (ed.), The Permanent Revolution & Results and Prospects, Pathfinder, New York, 1969 [1906]
Trotsky, L. 1905, Penguin, London, 1973 [1907]
Trotsky, L. Terrorism and Communism, New Park, London, 1975 [1920]
Trotsky, L. The Lessons of October, Bookmarks, London, 1987 [1924]
Trotsky, L. My Life, Penguin, London, 1970 [1930]
Trotsky, L. “The Permanent Revolution,” in L. Trotsky (ed.), The Permanent Revolution & Results and Prospects, Pathfinder, New York, 1969 [1931]
Trotsky, L. The History of the Russian Revolution, Pluto, London, 1977 [1931–3]
Trotsky, L. “What is Historical Objectivity?,” in L. Trotsky (ed.), Writings of Leon Trotsky, Pathfinder, New York, 1972 [1933]
Trotsky, L. Diary in Exile, 1935, Faber, London, 1958 [1935]
Trotsky, L. The Revolution Betrayed, Pathfinder, New York, 1972 [1936]
Trotsky, L. Stalin, Hollis and Carter, London, 1947 [1940a]
Trotsky, L. “The Class, the Party and the Leadership,” in L. Trotsky (ed.), The Spanish Revolution, Pathfinder, New York, 1973 [1940b]
Williams R. Marxism and Literature, Oxford University Press, 1977.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Blackledge, P. Leon Trotsky’s Contribution to the Marxist Theory of History. Stud East Eur Thought 58, 1–31 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11212-005-3677-z
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11212-005-3677-z