Abstract
The European Union welfare standardsfor intensively kept pigs have steadilyincreased over the past few years and areproposed to continue in the future. It isimportant that the cost implications of thesechanges in welfare standards are assessed. Theaim of this study was to determine theprofitability of rearing pigs in a range ofhousing systems with different standards forpig welfare. Models were constructed tocalculate the cost of pig rearing (6–95 kg) in afully-slatted system (fulfilling minimum EUspace requirements, Directive 91630/EEC); apartly-slatted system; a high-welfare,straw-based system (complying with the UK-basedRoyal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty toAnimals, Freedom Food standards) and afree-range system. The models were also used toassess the consequences of potential increasesin space allowance, and to estimate the cost ofrearing pigs under organic standards.
The cost of rearing pigs ranged from92.0 p/kg carcass weight (cw) and 94.6 p/kgcw forthe partly-slatted and fully-slatted systems,to 98.8 p/kgcw and 99.3 p/kgcw for the FreedomFood and free-range systems respectively. Whenspace allowance was increased by 60% to levelsin a recent proposal to revise pig welfareDirective (91/630/EEC), the rearing costs wereunchanged for the free-range system but rose by4.6 p/kgcw for the fully-slatted system. Rearingcosts under organic standards were 31% higherthan in the free-range system. These resultssuggest that improved pig welfare can beachieved with a modest increase in cost
At present, price premiums received for meatproduced under high welfare systems in the UKoffset the higher costs of production in thesesystems. To ensure profitability in the longterm, it is important that these premiums aremaintained.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Beattie, V. E., N. E. O'Connell, and B. W. Moss, “Influence of Environmental Enrichment on the Behaviour, Performance and Meat Quality of Domestic Pigs,” Livestock Production Science 65 (2000), 71–79.
Bennett, R. M., “People'sWillingness to Pay for Farm Animal Welfare,” Animal Welfare 5 (1996), 3–11.
Chadwick, L. (ed.), The Farm Management Handbook 2000/2001, 21st edn (Scottish Agricultural College, 2000).
den Ouden, M., Economic Modelling of Pork Production - Marketing Chains. PhDThesis, Wageningen Agricultural University, Wageningen, 1996.
Edwards, S. (1996). “Nutrition and Feeding Management in Outdoor Pig Production,” in Proceedings of 1st Symposium on Swine Raised Outdoors (Concordia, Brasil, 1996), pp. 117–126.
Edwards, S. A. and F. Casabianca, “Perception and Reality of Product Quality from Outdoor Production systems in Northern and Southern Europe,” in J. T. Sorensen (ed.), Livestock Farming Systems - More than Food Production, EAAP Publication No. 89 (Wageningen Pers, Wageningen, 1997), pp. 145–156.
Edwards, S. A., Outdoor Finishing Systems for Pigs (Proceedings of 2nd Symposium on Swine Raised Outdoors, (Concordia, Brasil, 1999).
Edwards, S. A., The Role of Animal Welfare in Quality Assurance Schemes for Livestock Products (Proceedings of the Ist PIC Espana Pork Chain Meeting, Barcelona, Spain, 2000).
Edwards, S. A., Personal Communication (School of Agriculture, Food and Rural Development, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, NE1 7RU, UK, 2001).
EU Scientific Veterinary Committee (Animal Welfare Section), The Welfare of Intensively Kept Pigs (1997). http://europa.eu.int/comm/food/fs/sc/oldcomm4/out17_en.pdf.
Fraser, D., P. A. Phillips, and T. Tennessen, “Effect of Straw on the Behaviour of Growing Pigs,” Applied Animal Behaviour Science 30 (1991), 307–318.
Gloag, D., Personal Communication (Signet, PO Box 603,Winterhill, Milton Keynes, UK, 2001).
Gourmelen, C., Y. Salaun, and P. Rousseau, “Economic Incidence of Possible Future Regulations Regarding the Welfare of Intensively Kept Pigs on Pig Meat Cost in France,” in 51st Annual Meeting of the European Association for Animal Production (The Hague, 2000a).
Gourmelen, C., Y. Salaun, and P. Rousseau, “Incidences economiques en production porcine de l'evolution des contraintes reglementaires relatives au bien-etre animal,” Insitut Technique Du Porc (Le Rheu Cedex, 2000b).
Grey, S., Personal Communication, A. M. Warkup, Aerodrome Works (Lisset Driffield, East Yorkshire, YO25 8PT, 1999).
Guy, J. H., P. Rowlinson, J. P. Chadwick, and M. Ellis, “Behaviour of Two Genotypes of Finishing Pig in Three Different Housing Systems,” Applied Animal Behaviour Science 75 (2002), 193–206.
Guy, J. H., P. Rowlinson, J. P. Chadwick, and M. Ellis, “Welfare of two Genotypes of Growing-Finishing Pig in Three Different Housing Systems,” Livestock Production Science 75 (2002), 233–243.
Kelly, H. R. C., J.M. Bruce, S. A. Edwards, P. R. English, and V. R. Fowler, “Limb Injuries, Immune Response and Growth Performance of Early-Weaned Pigs in Different Housing Systems,” Animal Science 70 (2000), 73–83.
Lampkin, N. and M. Measures (eds.), 2001 Organic Farm Management Handbook (University of Wales, Aberystwyth Organic Advisory Service (ERFC), 2001), p. 3 and 127- 129.
MAFF, Codes of Recommendations for the Welfare of Livestock: Pigs, Farm Animal Welfare Council. Booklet No.: PB 0075 (Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, London, 1999a).
MAFF, MAFF Pig Survey, 29 March 1999 (1999b) www.defra.gov.uk/esg/Work_htm/ Notices/pigsur.pdf
McEachern, M. and A. Tregear, “Farm Animal Welfare in the UK: A Comparison of Assurance Schemes,” Farm Management 10 (2000), 685–708.
Meunier-Salaun, M. C., M. N. Vantrimponte, A. Raab, and R. Dantzer, “Effect of Floor Area Restriction upon Performance, Behaviour and Physiology of Growing-Finishing Pigs,” Journal of Animal Science 64 (1987), 1371–1377.
Morgan, C. A., L. A. Deans, A. B. Lawrence, and B. L. Nielsen, “The Effects of Straw Bedding on the Feeding and Social Behaviour of Growing Pigs Fed by Means of Single-Space Feeders,” Applied Animal Behaviour Science 58 (1998), 23–33.
Mortensen, B., V. Ruby, B. K. Pedersen, J. Smidth, and V. A. Larsen, “Outdoor Pig Production in Denmark,” Pig News and Information 15 (1994), 117N–120N.
NAC (National Agricultural Centre), Pig Unit: The Outdoor Unit (Pig Demonstration Unit, NAC, Stonleigh Park, Warwickshire, 1992).
NAC (National Agricultural Centre), Pig Unit: A Review of Rearing Systems at the NAC Pig Unit (Pig Demonstration Unit, NAC, Stonleigh Park, Warwickshire, 1994a).
NAC (National Agricultural Centre), Pig Unit: Outdoor Unit - Up-Date (Pig Demonstration Unit, NAC, Stonleigh Park, Warwickshire, 1994b).
Nix, J., Farm Management Pocket Book (Imperial College at Wye, September 2001).
Pearce, C. A., Behaviour and other Indices of Welfare in Grower/Finisher Pigs Kept in Straw-Flow, Bare-Concrete, Full-Slats and Deep Straw. PhD Thesis, University of Aberdeen, 1993.
Peet, B., Personal Communication (Pig Industry Consultant, Harepit House, Fenny Compton, Leamington Spa, Warwickshire, CV33 OYG, 1999).
Petherick, J. C., “A Biological Basis for the Design of Space in Livestock Housing,” in S. H. Baxter, M. R. Baxter, and J. A. D. MacCormack (eds.), Farm Animal Housing and Welfare (Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1983).
PIC, PIC Management Yearbook 1997- 1998 (PIC UK, Fyfield Wick, Abingdon, UK, 1998), p. 70.
RSPCA, Profit with Principle, Animal Welfare and UK Pig Farming (2000).
Sheppard, A. (1996). “The Structure of Pig Production in England and Wales,” The Results of the National Survey of Pig Production Systems (Agricultural Economics Unit, University of Exeter, 1996).
Sheppard, A., Economic Efficiency in the Use of Inputs: Pigs (University of Exeter, 2001).
Signet, Pigfacts, April 2001 (Meat and Livestock Commission, Milton Keynes, Scottish Agricultural College, Edinburgh, 2001).
Soil Association, The Organic Food and Farming Report 2000 (2000).
Stolba, A. and D. G. M. Wood-Gush, “The Behaviour of Pigs in a Semi-Natural Environment,” Animal Production 48 (1989), 419–425.
Thompson G., Personal Communication (Pyramid Systems (Malton) Ltd. Showfield Lane, Malton, YO17 6BY, 1999).
Weng, R. C., S. A. Edwards, and P. R. English, Applied Animal Behaviour Science 59 (1998), 307–316.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bornett, H.L.I., Guy, J.H. & Cain, P. Impact of Animal Welfare on Costs and Viability of Pig Production in the UK. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 16, 163–186 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1022994131594
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1022994131594