Abstract
Student cheating and reporting of that cheating represents one form of organizational wrong-doing and subsequent whistle-blowing, in the context of an academic organization. Previous research has been hampered by a lack of information concerning the validity of survey responses estimating the incidence of organizational wrongdoing and whistle-blowing. An innovative method, the Randomized Response Technique (RRT), was used here to assess the validity of reported incidences of wrongdoing and whistle-blowing. Surprisingly, our findings show that estimates of these incidences did not vary significantly when RRT questionnaire results were compared to those obtained from standard surveys. In fact, a large number of business undergraduates admitted cheating while only a small percentage reported peers' cheating when they observed it. These results should be sobering for managers and their implications are considered in some detail.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abernathy, J. R., B. G. Greenberg and D. G. Horvitz: 1970, ‘Estimates of Induced Abortion in Urban North Carolina’,Demography 7(1), 19–29.
Abul-Ela, A. A., B. G. Greenberg and D. G. Horvitz: 1967, ‘A Multi-Proportions Randomized Response Model’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 62, 990–1008.
Barnett, D. C. and J. C. Dalton: 1981, ‘Why College Students Cheat’,Journal of College Student Personnel, Nov., 545–551.
Baucus, M. S. and J. P. Near: 1991, ‘Can Illegal Corporate Behavior be Predicted?’,Social Psychology 40, 290–302.
Berry, L. E., G. B. Harwood and J. L. Katz: 1987, ‘Performance of Auditing Procedures by Governmental Auditors: Some Preliminary Evidence’,The Accounting Review 63(1), 14–28.
Blackburn, M. S.: 1988,Employee Dissent: The Choice of Voice Versus Silence (unpublished doctoral dissertation, The University of Tennessee, Knoxville).
Bourke, P. D.: 1982, ‘Randomized Response Multivariate Designs for Categorical Data’,Communications in Statistics-Theory Methods 11, 2889–2901.
Brunning, J. L. and B. L. Kintz: 1977,Computational Handbook of Statistics 2nd ed. (Foresman and Company, Glenview, IL).
Buchman, T. A. and J. A. Tracy: 1982, ‘Obtaining Responses to Sensitive Questions: Conventional Questionnaire versus Randomized Response Technique’,Journal of Accounting Research 20, 263–271.
Buchman, T. A.: 1983, ‘The Reliability of Internal Auditors' Working Papers’,Auditing 3(1), 92–103.
Carr, J. W., L. A. Marascuilo and P. Busk: 1982, ‘Optimal Randomized Response Models and Methods for Hypothesis Testing’,Journal of Educational Statistics 7(4), 295–310.
Columbus Dispatch, April, 8, 1987. Therapists' Sexual Misconduct Covered Up, 2B.
Corcoran, K. J. and J. B. Rotter, 1987, ‘Morality-Conscience Guilt Scale as a Predictor of Ethical Behavior in a Cheating Situation’,Journal of General Psychology 114, 117–123.
Covey, M. K., Saladin, S. and P. J. Killen: 1989, ‘Self-Monitoring, Surveillance, and Incentive Effects on Cheating’,Journal of Social Psychology 129(5), 673–679.
Cressey, D. R: 1976, ‘Restraint of Trade, Recidivism, and Delinquent Neighborhoods’. In J. F. Short (ed.)Delinquency, Crime and Society (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
Crowne, D. P. and D. Marlowe: 1960, ‘A New Scale of Social Desirability Independent of Psychopathology’,Journal of Consulting Psychology 24, 349–354.
Dalton, D. R. and M. B. Metzger: 1992, ‘Towards Candor, Cooperation, and Privacy in Applied Business Ethics Research: The Randomized Response Technique’,Business Ethics Quarterly 2, 207–221.
Duffy, J. C. and J. J. Waterton: 1984, ‘Randomized Response Models for Estimating the Distribution Function of a Quantitative Character’,International Statistical Review 52(2), 165–171.
Durham, A. M. I. and M. J. Lichtenstein: 1983, ‘Response Bias in Self-Report Surveys: Evaluating Randomized Response’. In G. P. Waldo (ed.)Measurement Issues in Criminal Justice (Sage, Beverly Hills, Cal.).
Edgell, S. E., S. Himmelfarb and K. L. Duchan: 1982, ‘Validity of Forced Responses in a Randomized Response Model’,Sociological Methods and Research 11, 89–100.
Edgell, S. E., S. Himmelfarb and D. J. Cira: 1986, ‘Statistical Efficiency of Using Two Quantitative Randomized Response Techniques to Estimate Correlation’,Psychological Bulletin 100(2), 251–256.
Eichhorn, B. H. and L. S. Hayre: 1983, ‘Scrambled Randomized Response Methods for Obtaining Sensitive Quantitative Data’,Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference 7, 307–316.
Folsom, R. E., B. G. Greenberg, D. G. Horvitz and J. R. Abernathy: 1973, ‘The Two Alternate Questions Randomized Response Model for Human Surveys’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 68, 525–530.
Geurts, M. D., R. R. Andrus and J. Reinmuth: 1976, ‘Researching Shoplifting and Other Deviant Customer Behavior, Using the Randomized Response Research Design’,Journal of Retailing 51(4), 43–48.
Glazer, M. P. and P. M. Glazer: 1987, ‘Pathways to Resistance: An Ethical Odyssey in Government and Industry’, in M. Lewis and J. L. Miller (eds.)Research in Social Problems and Public Policy 4 (JAI Press, Greenwich), pp. 193–219.
Glazer, M. P. and P. M. Glazer: 1989,The Whistle-Blowers: Exposing Corruption in Government and Industry (Basic Books, New York).
Goodstadt, M. S. & V. Gruson: 1975, ‘The Randomized Response Technique: A Test on Drug Use.Journal of the American Statistical Association 70, 814–818.
Goodstadt, M. S., G. Cook and V. Gruson: 1978, ‘The Validity of Reported Drug Use: The Randomized Response Technique’,International Journal of the Addictions 13, 359–367.
Greenberg, B. G., A. A. Abul-Ela, W. R. Simmons and D. G. Horvitz: 1969, ‘The Unrelated Question Randomized Response Model: Theoretical Framework’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 64, 520–539.
Greenberg, B. G., R. R. Kuebler, Jr., J. R. Abernathy and D. G. Horvitz: 1971, ‘Application of the Randomized Response Technique in Obtaining Quantitative Data’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 66, 243–250.
Haines, V. J., G. M. Diekhoff, E. E. LaBeff and R. E. Clark: 1986, ‘College Cheating: Immaturity, Lack of Commitment, and the Neutralizing Attitude’,Research in Higher Education 25(4), 342–354.
Horvitz, D. G., B. G. Greenberg and J. R. Abernathy: 1976, ‘Randomized Response: A Data Gathering Device for Sensitive Questions’,International Statistical Review 44(2), 181–196.
Horvitz, D. G., B. G. Greenberg and J. R. Abernathy: 1990, ‘Recent Developments in Randomized Response Design’, In J. N. Srivastava (ed.),A Survey of Statistical Design and Linear Models (Elsevier Publishing, New York), pp. 271–285.
I-cheng, C., L. P. Chow and R. V. Rider: 1972, ‘The Randomized Response Technique as Used in the Taiwan Pregnancy Study’,Studies in Family Planning 2, 265–269.
Keenan, J. P.: 1988a, ‘Communication Climate, Whistle-blowing, and the First-Level Manager: A Preliminary Study’,Academy of Management Best Paper Proceedings 40, 247–251.
Keenan, J. P.: 1988b, ‘Communication Climate, Whistle-blowing, and the First-Level Manager: A Preliminary Study’ (Working paper, School of Business-Management Institute, University of Wisconsin, Madison).
Keenan, J. P.: 1990, ‘First-Level Managers and Whistleblowing: An Exploratory Study of Individual and Organizational Influences’ (Working paper, School of Business-Management Institute, University of Wisconsin, Madison).
Kibler, W. L.: 1992, ‘Cheating: Institutions Need a Comprehensive Plan for Promoting Academic Integrity’,Chronicle of Higher Education, Nov. 11, B1–B2.
Martin, G. L. and I. M. Newman: 1982, ‘Randomized Response: A Technique For Improving the Validity of Self-Reported Health Behaviors’,Journal of School Health April, 222–226.
Mathews, M. C.: 1987, ‘Codes of Ethics: Organizational Behavior and Mishebavior’, in W. C. Frederick (ed.),Research in Corporate and Social Performance and Policy 9 (JAI Press, Greenwich, CT) pp. 107–130.
Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB): 1981, ‘Whistle-Blowing and the Federal Employee’ (U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC).
Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB): 1984, ‘Blowing the Whistle in the Federal Government: A Comparative Analysis of 1980 and 1983 Survey Findings’ (U.S. Government Printing Office Washington, DC).
Miceli, M. P., J. B. Dozier and J. P. Near: 1991, ‘Blowing the Whistle on Data-Fudging: A Controlled Field Experiment’,Journal of Applied Social Psychology 21, 301–325.
Miceli, M. P. and J. P. Near: 1988, Individual and situational correlates of whistle-blowing’,Personnel Psychology 41, 267–281.
Miceli, M. P. and J. P. Near: 1989, ‘The incidence of wrongdoing, whistle-blowing, and retaliation: Results of a natural occurring field experiment’,Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal 2, 91–108.
Miceli, M. P. and J. P. Near: 1992,Blowing the Whistle: The Organizational & Legal Implications for Companies and Employees (Lexington Books, New York).
Miceli, M. P., Near, J. P., and C. R. Schwenk: 1992, ‘Who blows the whistle and why: Perceptions of victims, perpetrators, and role related variables’,Industrial Labor Relations Review 45, 113–130.
Michaels, J. W. and T. D. Miethe: 1989, ‘Applying Theories of Deviance to Academic Cheating’,Social Science Quarterly 70, 870–885.
Moorman, R. H. and P. M. Podsakoff: 1992, ‘A Meta-Analytic Review and Empirical Test of the Potential Confounding Effects of Social Desirability Response Sets in Organizational Behaviour Research’,Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 65, 131–149.
Moors, J. J. A.: 1971, ‘Optimization of the Unrelated Question Randomized Response Model’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 66, 627–629.
Near, J. P., M. S. Baucus and M. P. Miceli: 1993, ‘The Relationship Between Values and Practice: Organizational Climates for Wrongdoing’,Administration and Society 25, 204–226.
Near, J. P., T. M. Dworkin and M. P. Miceli: 1993, ‘Explaining the Whistle-blowing Process: Suggestions from Power Theory and Justice Theory’,Organization Science 4, 411.
Near, J. P. and M. P. Miceli: 1985, ‘Organizational Dissidence: The Case of Whistle-blowing’,Journal of Business Ethics 4, 1–16.
Near, J. P. and M. P. Miceli: 1987, ‘Whistle-Blowers in Organizations: Dissidents or Reformers?’, in B. M. Staw and L. L. Cummings (eds.),Research in Organizational Behavior 9 (JAI Press, Greenwich, CT) pp. 321–368.
Near, J. P. and M. P. Miceli: 1988,The Internal Auditor's Ultimate Responsibility: The Reporting of Sensitive Issues (The Institute of Internal Auditors Research Foundation, Altamonte Springs, FL).
Nederhof, A. J.: 1984, ‘Methods of Coping with Social Desirability Bias: A Review’,European Journal of Social Psychology 15, 263–280.
Nelson, T. and N. Schaefer: 1986, ‘Cheating among College Students Estimated with the Randomized-Response Technique’,College Student Journal 20, 321–325.
Newhouse, R. C.: 1982, ‘Alienation and Cheating Behavior in the School Environment’,Psychology in the Schools 19, 234–237.
Nuss, E. M.: 1984, ‘Academic Integrity: Comparing Faculty and Student Attitudes’,Improving College and University Teaching 32(3), 140–144.
Orwin, R. G. and R. F. Boruch: 1982, ‘RRT Meets RDD: Statistical Strategies for Assuring Response in Telephone Surveys’,Public Opinion Quarterly 46, 560–571.
Pollock, H. H. and Y. Bek: 1976, ‘A Comparison of Three Randomized Response Models for Quantitative Data’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 71, 884–886.
Poole, W. K.: 1974, ‘Estimation of the Distribution Function of a Continuous Type Random Variable Through Randomized Response’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 69, 1002–1005.
Scheers, N. J. and C. M. Dayton: 1987, ‘Improved Estimation of Academic Cheating Behavior Using the Randomized Response Technique’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 26(1), 61–69.
Shimizu, I. M. and G. S. Bonham: 1978, ‘Randomized Response Technique in a National Survey’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 73, 35–39.
Sierles, F. S., B. D. Kushner and P. B. Krause: 1988, ‘A Controlled Experiment With a Medical Student Honor System’,Journal of Medical Education 63, 705–712.
Soeken, K. L.: 1987, ‘Randomized Response Methodology in Health Research’,Evaluation and Health Professions 10(1), 58–66.
Soeken, K. L. and S. P. Damrosch: 1986, ‘Randomized Response Technique: Applications to Research on Rape’,Psychology of Women Quarterly 10, 119–126.
Soeken, K. L. and G. B. Macready: 1986, ‘Application of Setwise Randomized Response Procedures for Surveying Multiple Sensitive Attributes’,Psychological Bulletin 99(2): 289–295.
Soeken, K. L. and D. R. Soeken: 1987, ‘A survey of whistleblowers: Their stressors and coping strategies’,Proceedings of the hearing on H.R. 25 (U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC), pp. 156–166.
Tamhane, A. C.: 1981, ‘Randomized Response Techniques for Multiple Sensitive Attributes’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 76, 916–923.
Tangney, J. P.: 1987, ‘Fraud Will Out — or Will It?’,New Scientist 115, 62–63.
Tom, G and N. Borin: 1988, ‘Cheating in Academe’,Journal of Education for Business, Jan., 153–157.
Tracy, R. E. and J. A. Fox: 1981, ‘The Validity of Randomized Response for Sensitive Measurement’,American Sociological Review 46 (April): 187–200.
Warner, S. L.: 1965, ‘Randomized Response: A Survey Technique for Eliminating Evasive Answer Bias’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 60, 63–69.
Warner, S. L.: 1971, ‘The Linear Randomized Response Model’,Journal of the American Statistical Association 66, 884–888.
Zdep, S. M. and I. N. Rhodes: 1976, ‘Making the Randomized Response Technique Work’,Public Opinion Quarterly 40, 531–537.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Brian K. Burton is a doctoral student in strategic management as well as managing editor ofBusiness Horizons, the interdisciplinary business journal published by Indiana University. His research interests include business ethics, stakeholder analysis, corporate political activity, and nontraditional approaches to management.
Janet P. Near is Professor and Chairperson, Management Dept., and Adjunct Professor, Sociology Dept., Indiana University. Her research interests include: (a) whistle-blowing in organizations and (b) the relationship between work and non-work domains of life, focusing especially on the correlation between job satisfaction and life satisfaction. She has published several articles on these topics and, with Marcia Miceli, a book on whistle-blowing.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Burton, B.K., Near, J.P. Estimating the incidence of wrongdoing and whistle-blowing: Results of a study using randomized response technique. J Bus Ethics 14, 17–30 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00873732
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00873732