Abstract
The theoretical system Lyell presented in 1830 was composed of three requirements or principles: 1) the Uniformity Principle which states that past geological events must be explained by the same causes now in operation; 2) the Uniformity of Rate Principle which states that geological laws operate with the same force as at present; 3) the Steady-state Principle which states that the earth does not undergo any directional change. The three principles form a single thesis called “uniformitarianism” which has been repeatedly questioned and which has been reputed to be unable to face the competing “directional synthesis” based on the theory of the earth's cooling down. As a result, the significance of Lyell's system has been reduced to a simple “actualism” which admits the validity of the only Uniformity Principle. I believe that the only way to understand Lyell's role in the history of science is to maintain the unity of his synthesis. To show the Newtonian roots of this synthesis I will compare Lyell's principles and Newton's Rules of Reasoning. I will conclude with an analysis of the methodological function of principles in Lyell's scientific endeavour.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bartholomew, M.: 1973, ‘Lyell and Evolution: An Account of Lyell's Response to the Prospect of Evolutionary Ancestry for Man’, British Journal for the History of Science 6, 261-303.
Bartholomew, M.: 1976, ‘The Non-Progress of Non-progression: Two Responses to Lyell's Doctrine’, British Journal for the History of Science 9, 166-174.
Blake, R.M., Ducasse, C.J. and Madden, E.H.: 1960, Theories of Scientific Method. The Renaissance through the Nineteenth Century, University of Washington Press, Seattle and London.
Bohr N.: 1961, Atomic Theory and the Description of Nature, 2nd ed., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Brown, G.C.: 1982, ‘The Energy Budget of the Earth’, in Smith, D.G. (ed.), The Cambridge Encyclopedia of the Earth Sciences, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 140-163.
Cannon, W.F.: 1960, ‘The Uniformitarian-Catastrophist Debate’, Isis 51, 38-55.
Cannon, W.F.: 1961, ‘The Impact of Uniformitarianism’, Proceedings of the American Philosphical Society CV, 301-314.
Cannon, W.F.: 1976, ‘Charles Lyell, Radical Actualism and Theory’, The British Journal for the History of the Science 9, 104-120.
Cartwright, N.: 1983, How the Laws of Physics Lie, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Cohen, I.B.: 1956, Franklin and Newton, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Cohen, I.B.: 1990, ‘Newton's Method and Newton's Style’, in Durham, F. and Purrington, R. (eds.), Some Truer Methods. Reflections on the Heritage of Newton, Columbia University Press, New York.
Darwin, F.: 1897, Life and Letters of Charles Darwin, 2 Vols., Murray, London.
Davie, G.E.: 1964, The Democratic Intellect. Scotland and Her Universities in the Nineteenth Century, 2nd ed., Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.
Élie de Beaumont, L.: 1831, ‘Research on Some Revolutions on the Surface of the Earth’, engl. transl. Philosophical Magazine 10, 241-264.
Geikie, A.: 1897, The Founders of Geology, repr. 1962, Dover Publications, New York.
Gillispie, C.C.: 1951, Genesis and Geology, Harvard University Press, Cambridge Mass.
Gohau, G.: 1990, A History of Geology, translated by A. and M. Carozzi, Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick.
Gould, S.J.: 1965, ‘Is Uniformitarianism necessary?’, American Journal of Science 263, 223-228.
Gould, S.J.: 1980, Ever since Darwin, Norton & Co., New York.
Gould, S.J.: 1987, Time's Arrow, Time's Cycle, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Grave, S.A.: 1960, The Scottish Philosophy of Common Sense, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Hall, T.S.: 1968, ‘On Biological Analogs of Newtonian Paradigms’, Philosophy of Science 35, 6-27.
Hamilton, E.I.: 1965, Applied Geochronology, Academic Press, London.
Herschel, J.: 1830/1987, A Preliminary Discourse on the Study of Natural Philosophy, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Hodge, M.J.S.: 1991, ‘The History of the Earth, Life and Man: Whewell and Palaetiological Sciences’, in Fish, M. and Schaffer, S. (eds.), William Whewell. A Composite Portrait, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Hooykaas, R.: 1963, Natural Law and Divine Miracle. The Principle of Uniformity in Geology Biology and Theology, Brill, Leiden.
Hooykaas, R.: 1970, Catastrophism in Geology, North Holland, Amsterdam.
Hugget, R.: 1990, Catastrophism, Arnold, London, New York.
Hull, D.L.: 1974, Philosophy of Biological Science, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
Hull, D.L.: 1975, ‘Central Subjects and Historical Narratives’, History and Theory 14; quoted from reprint in Hull, D.L.: 1989, The Metaphysics of Evolution, State University of New York Press, Albany, NY.
Hull, D.L.: 1988a, Science as a Process, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Hull, D.L.: 1988b, ‘Progress in Ideas of Progress’, in Nitecki, M.H. (ed.), Evolutionary Progress?, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Laudan, L.: 1981, ‘Thomas Reid and the Turn of British Methodological Thought’, in Science and Hypothesis, Reidel, Dordrecht.
Laudan, R.: 1987, From Mineralogy to Geology, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Lawrence, P.: 1977, ‘Heaven and Earth: The Relation of Nebular Hypothesis to Geology’, in Yourgrau, W. and Breck, D. (eds.), Cosmology, History and Theology, Plenum, New York.
Lawrence, P.: 1978, ‘Charles Lyell versus the Theory of Central Heat’, Journal of The History of the Biology 11, 101-128.
Lyell, C.: 1830–1833, Principles of Geology, 3 vols., Murray, London. Reprinted 1990, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Lyell, C.: 1863, The Antiquity of Man, 2nd ed., Murray, London.
Lyell, C.: 1872, Principles of Geology, 11th edition in 2 Vols., Appleton & Co., New York.
Lyell, C.: 1970, The Scientific Journals on the Species Question, ed. by Leonard Wilson, Yale University Press, New Haven.
Lyell, K. (ed.): 1881, Life, Letters, Journals of Sir Charles Lyell, 2 Vols., Murray, London.
Mamiani, M.: 1976, Isaac Newton Filosofo della Natura, La Nuova Italia, Firenze.
McGuire, J.E.: 1995, Tradition and Innovation. Newton's Metaphysics of Nature, Kluwer A. P., Dordrecht.
McMullin, E.: 1978, Newton on Matter and Activity, Univ. of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame.
Mill, J.S.: 1973, ‘A System of Logic: Ratiocinative and Inductive (1843)’, in Robson, J.M. (ed.), Collected Works, vol. VII, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.
Newton, I.: 1952, Opticks, based on the 4th ed., London, 1730; Dover Publications, New York.
Newton, I.: 1968, The Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy (1729), transl. by A. Motte, repr. 2 vols., Dawson, London.
Olson R.: 1975, Scottish Philosophy and British Physics, 1750–1880, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Ospovat, D.: 1977, ‘Lyell's Theory of the Climate’, Journal of the History of Biology 10, 317-339.
Popper, K.: 1972, Objective Knowledge, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Popper, K.: 1976, Conjectures and Refutations, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.
Porter, R.: 1977, The Making of Geology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Quine, W.v.O.: 1964, From a Logical Point of View, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Reid, T.: 1983, Works, McLachlan & Stewart, Edinburgh, 1872; repr. Holmes, Hildesheim.
Richards, R.: 1991, The Meaning of Evolution, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Rudwick, M.: 1967, ‘A Critique of Uniformitarian Geology’, in Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society CXI, 272-287.
Rudwick, M.: 1969, ‘Lyell on Etna and the Antiquity of Earth’, in Schneer, C.J. (ed.), Toward a History of Geology, M.I.T. Press, Cambridge MA.
Rudwick, M.: 1970, ‘The Strategy of Lyell's Principles of Geology’, Isis 61, 4-33; revised and re-published as an Introduction to the 1990 reprint of the Principles of Geology.
Rudwick, M.: 1971, ‘Uniformity and Progression: Reflections on the Structure of Geological Theory in the Age of Lyell’, in Roller, D.H.D. (ed.), Perspectives in the History of Science and Technology, Norman, Oklahoma University Press, pp. 209-227.
Rudwick, M.: 1976, The Meaning of Fossils, Science and History Publications, New York; repr. 1985, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Ruse, M.: 1979, The Darwinian Revolution, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Ruse, M.: 1991, ‘William Whewell: Omniscientist’, in Fish, M. and Schaffer, S. (eds.), William Whewell. A Composite Portrait, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Ruse, M.: 1996, Monad to Man. The Concept of Progress in Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
Sedgwick, A.: 1831, ‘Presidential Address to Geological Society’, The Philosophical Magazine IX, 281-317.
Sober, E.: 1998, Two Outbreaks of Lawlessness in Recent Philosophy of Biology, forthcoming in Darden L. (ed.), PSA 1996, II, Philosophy of Science Ass.
Stewart, D.: 1854, Collected Works, Constable & Co., Edinburgh.
Suppe, F.: 1989, The Semantic Conception of Scientific Theories and Scientific Realism, University of Illinois Press, Urbana.
Tarski, A.: 1944, ‘The Semantic Conception of Truth and the Foundations of Semantics’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research IV, 341-376.
Watson, R.A.: 1969, ‘Explanation and Prediction in Geology’, Journal of Geology 77, 488-494.
Whewell, W.: 1832, ‘Principles of Geology by Charles Lyell. Vol. II’, Quarterly Review 47, 103-132.
Whewell, W.: 18472, Philosophy of Inductive Sciences, 2 vols., Parker, London; Reprint 1967, Johnson Repr., New York.
Whewell, W.: 18633, History of the Inductive Sciences, 2 vols., Appleton & Co., New York.
Wilson, L.: 1969, ‘The Intellectual Background to Lyell, Principles of Geology’, in Schneer, C.J. (ed.), Toward a History of Geology, M.I.T. Press, Cambridge MA.
Wilson, L.: 1972, Charles Lyell. The Years to 1841, Yale University Press, New Haven.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Camardi, G. Charles Lyell and the Uniformity Principle. Biology & Philosophy 14, 537–560 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006504910017
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1006504910017