Abilities, freedom, and inputs: a time traveller's tale
View/ Open
Date
05/06/2023Author
Coombes, Olivia
Metadata
Abstract
The philosophy of time travel is a sub-field of metaphysics – the study of what there is and what things are like – that considers questions about the possibility of time travel and what a world in which time travel is possible looks like. These questions range from whether time travel is actually possible, to how time travellers can act in the past or future.
This thesis delves into a particularly interesting, yet historically undertreated theme: the abilities of time travellers and relatedly their freedom as well.
The abilities and freedom of time travellers has been the source of a lot of recent discussion with some polarising views. The minority (which includes Lewis (1976), but also Ted Sider (2002)) argue for the affirmative – that time travellers are free and have the same (or perhaps more) abilities as non-time travellers. The majority (which includes Kadri Vihvelin (1996), Michael Rea (2005), Stephanie Rennick (2015), Alison Fernandes (2020), amongst others) argue for the negative, that time travellers do not have exactly the same freedoms and abilities as non-time travellers.
I think that it is a mistake to be so pessimistic about the abilities and freedom of time travellers. I treat concerns about the freedom of time travellers and concerns about the abilities of time travellers as two sides of the same coin. Therefore, in what follows, I argue for two related conclusions. First, I argue that time travellers have all sorts of abilities.
Second, I argue that time travellers are just as free as non-time travellers. In arguing for these conclusions, I first produce a novel analysis of ability which reveals important details about how abilities track inputs rather than outputs. Second, I use this new analysis of ability to present a new compatibilist account of free will.
If I am right in arguing positively for the abilities and freedoms of time travellers, then this has large implications for both the current time travel discourse and the general debate surrounding freedom. Significantly, I am arguing against some prominent views about time travel and in suggesting that these views are mistaken, I am presenting new ideas about ability and freedom: specifically, that time travellers have the ability and are free to do impossible things.
Collections
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Early English travellers in India: a study in the travel literature of the Elizabethan and Jacobean periods with particular reference to India
Prasad, Ram Chandra (The University of Edinburgh, 1959)The narratives of travel and exploration written by the English voyagers and merchant adventurers who visited India during 1579 -1630 are of great literary and historical value for many reasons. For the first time they ... -
Travel Guide (Travelling Fires)
Stern-Gottfried, Jamie; Rein, Guillermo; Torero, Jose L (Fire Risk Management, 2009-11)Close inspection of real fires in large, open compartments reveals that they do not burn simultaneously throughout the whole compartment. Instead, these fires tend to move as flames spread, partitions or false ceilings ... -
British travellers in Switzerland, with special reference to some women travellers between 1750-1850
Mains, Jean A (The University of Edinburgh, 1966)