Abstract
The balance of nature concept is an old idea that manifests itself in anumber of forms in population and community ecology. This paper focuseson population ecology, where controversy surrounding the balance ofnature takes the form of perennial debates over the significance ofdensity dependence, population regulation, and species interactions suchas competition. One of the most striking features of these debates, overthe course of the previous century in ecology, is the tendency to arguethe case on largely conceptual grounds. This paper explores twoquestions. Why this tendency to settle on conceptual grounds what is soobviously an empirical issue? Are there any good conceptual arguments tobe had in this area?
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Andrewartha, H.G.: 1957, ‘The Use of Conceptual Models in Population Ecology', Cold Spring Harbor Symposium on Quantitative Biology 22, 219-232.
Andrewartha, H.G. andBirch, L.C.: 1954, The Distribution and Abundance of Animals, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Andrewartha, H.G. andBirch, L.C.: 1984, The Ecological Web, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Anonymous: 1944, ‘British Ecological Society Symposium on “The Ecology of Closely Allied Species”’, Journal of Animal Ecology 13, 176-178.
Beatty, J.: 1995, ‘The Evolutionary Contingency Thesis', in G. Wolters andJ.G. Lennox (eds), Concepts, Theories, and Rationality in the Biological Sciences, University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, pp. 45-81.
Berryman, A.A.: 1987, ‘Equilibrium or Nonequilibrium: Is That the Question?', Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America 68, 500-502.
Berryman, A.A.: 1991, ‘Stabilization or Regulation:What it All Means!’, Oecologia 86, 140-143.
Botkin, D.B.: 1990, Discordant Harmonies: A New Ecology for the Twenty-First Century, Oxford University Press, New York.
Brandon, R. andRausher, M.D.: 1996, ‘Testing Adaptationism: A Comment on Orzack and Sober', American Naturalist 148, 189-201.
Brown, J.H.: 1995, Macroecology, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Cappuccino, N.: 1995, ‘Novel Approaches to the Study of Population Dynamics', in N. Cappuccino andP.W. Price (eds), Population Dynamics: New Approaches and Synthesis, Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 3-18.
Cappuccino, N. andPrice, P.W. (eds): 1995, Population Dynamics: New Approaches and Synthesis, Academic Press, San Diego.
Caswell, H.: 1978, ‘Predator-mediated Coexistence: A Nonequilibrium Model', American Naturalist 112, 127-154.
Caswell, H.: 1988, ‘Theory and Models in Ecology: A Different Perspective', Bulletin of the Ecological Society of America 69, 102-109.
Chesson, P.L.: 1981, ‘Models for Spatially Distributed Populations: The Effect of Withinpatch Variability', Theoretical Population Biology 19, 288-325.
Chesson, P.L.: 1982, ‘The Stabilizing Effect of a Random Environment', Journal of Mathematical Biology 15, 1-36.
Chesson, P.L. andCase, T.J.: 1986, ‘Overview: Nonequilibrium Community Theories: Chance, Variability, History, and Coexistence', in J. Diamond andT. Case (eds), pp. 229-239.
Chitty, D.: 1996, Do Lemmings Commit Suicide? Beautiful Hypotheses and Ugly Facts, Oxford University Press, New York.
Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology: 1957, Population Studies: Animal Ecology and Demography, No. 22, The Biological Laboratory, Cold Spring Harbor, NY.
Colwell, R.K.: 1984, ‘What& New? Community Ecology Discovers Biology', in P.W. Price,C.N. Slobodchikoff andW.S. Gaud (eds), A New Ecology: Novel Approaches to Interactive Systems, John Wiley & Sons, New York, pp. 387-396.
Connell, J.H.: 1990, “Apparent Versus “Real” Competition in Plants', in J.B. Grace andD. Tilman (eds), Perspectives on Plant Competition, Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 9-26.
Connell, J.H. andSousa, W.P.: 1983, ‘On the Evidence Needed to Judge Ecological Stability or Persistence', The American Naturalist 121, 789-824.
Connor, E.F. andSimberloff, D.: 1986, ‘Competition, Scientific Method, and Null Models in Ecology', American Scientist 74, 155-162.
Cooper, G.: 1990, ‘The Explanatory Tools of Theoretical Population Biology', in A. Fine,M. Forbes andL. Wessels (eds), PSA 1990, Vol. 1, pp. 165-178.
Cooper, G.: 1993, ‘The Competition Controversy in Community Ecology', Biology and Philosophy 8, 359-384.
Cooper, G.: 1997, ‘Theoretical Modeling and Biological Laws', in L. Darden (ed.), PSA 1996, Supplement to Philosophy of Science, 63: 28-35.
Cooper, G.: 1998, ‘Generalizations in Ecology: A Philosophical Taxonomy', Biology and Philosophy 13, 555-586.
Cooper, G.: forthcoming, The Science of the Struggle for Existence: On the Foundations of Ecology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Costanza, R. andMaxwell, T.: 1994, ‘Resolution and Predictability: An Approach to the Scaling Problem', Landscape Ecology 9, 47-57.
DeAngelis, D. L. andWaterhouse, J.C.: 1987, ‘Equilibrium and Nonequilibrium Concepts in Ecological Models', Ecological Monographs 57, 1-21.
den Boer, P.J.: 1968, ‘Spreading the Risk and Stabilization of Animal Numbers’, Acta Biotheoretica 18, 165-194.
den Boer, P.J.: 1986, ‘The Present Status of the Competitive Exclusion Principle', Trends in Evolutionary Ecology 1, 25-28.
den Boer, P.J. andReddingius, J.: 1996, Regulation and Stabilitzation Paradigms in Population Ecology, Chapman and Hall, London.
Dennis, B. andTaper, B.: 1994, ‘Density Dependence in Time Series Observation of Natural Populations: Estimation and Testing', Ecological Monographs 64, 205-224.
Diamond, J. andCase, T. (eds): 1986, Community Ecology, Harper and Row, New York.
Dobzhansky, T.: 1957, ‘Discussion', from H.G. Andrewartha, ‘The Use of Conceptual Models in Population Ecology', Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology, p. 235.
Egerton, F.N.: 1973, ‘Changing Concepts of the Balance of Nature', The Quarterly Review of Biology 48, 322-350.
Elton, C.: 1933, The Ecology of Animals, Methuen, London.
Gilbert, F.S.: 1980, ‘The Equilibrium Theory of Island Geography: Fact or Fiction', Journal of Biogeography 7, 209-235.
Hanski, I.: 1990, ‘Density Dependence, Regulation, and Variability in Animal Populations', in M.P. Hassell andR.M. May (eds), Population Regulation and Dynamics, The Royal Society, London, pp. 141-150.
Hanski, I.: 1991a, ‘Single-species Metapopulation Dynamics: Concepts, Models and Observations’, in M. Gilpin andI. Hanski (eds), Metapopulation Dynamics: Empirical and Theoretical Investigations, Academic Press, London, pp. 17-38.
Hanski, I.: 1991b, ‘Metapopulation Dynamics: Brief History and Conceptual Domain', Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 42, 3-16.
Hanski, I.: 1996, ‘Metapopulation Ecology', in O.E. Rhodes, Jr.,R.K. Chesser andM.H. Smith (eds), Population Dynamics in Ecological Space and Time, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 13-43.
Hanski, I., I. Woiwod andJ. Perry: 1993, ‘Density Dependence, Population Persistence, and Largely Futile Arguments', Oecologia 95, 595-598.
Hanski, I. andGilpin, M.E.: 1997, Metapopulation Biology: Ecology, Genetics, and Evolution, Academic Press, San Diego.
Harrison, S.: 1991, ‘Local Extinction in a Metapopulation Context: An Empirical Evaluation', Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 42, 73-88.
Holyoak, M. andLawton, J.H.: 1993, ‘Comments Arising from a Paper by Wolda and Dennis: Using and Interpreting the Results of Tests for Density Dependence', Oecologia 95, 592-594.
Howard, L.O. andFiske, W.F.: 1911, The Importation into the United States of the Parasites of the Gipsy Moth and the Brown-Tail Moth. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Bureau of Entomology, Bulletin No. 91. Reprinted: 1977), Arno Press, New York.
Hunter, M.D. andPrice, P.W.: 1998, ‘Cycles in Insect Populations: Delayed Density Dependence or Exogenous Driving Variables?’ Ecological Entomology 23, 216-222.
Hutchinson, G.E.: 1948, ‘Circular Causal Systems in Ecology', Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 50, 221-246.
Kingsland, S.: 1985, Modeling Nature. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Kingsland, S.: 1995, Modeling Nature, 2nd edn. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Kuhn, T.: 1962, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Lack, D.L.: 1954, The Natural Regulation of Animal Numbers, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
Lakatos, I.: 1970, ‘Falsification and the Methodology of Scientific Research Programmes', in I. Lakatos andA. Musgrave (eds), Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge, Cambridge University Press, London, pp. 91-197.
May, R.M.: 1973, Stability and Complexity in Model Ecosystems, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
May, R.M.: 1986, ‘The Search for Patterns in the Balance of Nature: Advances and Retreats', Ecology 67, 1115-1126.
McIntosh, R.P.: 1987, ‘Pluralism in Ecology', Annual Review of Ecological Systems 18, 321-341.
Menge, B.A.: 1992, ‘Community Regulation: UnderWhat Conditions Are Bottom-Up Factors Important on Rocky Shores?’ Ecology 73, 755-765.
Murdoch, W.W.: 1994, ‘Population Regulation in Theory and Practice', Ecology 75, 271-287.
Murray, B.G.: 1982, ‘On the Meaning of Density Dependence', Oecologia 53, 370-373.
Murray, B.G.: 1987, ‘The Calculation of the Rate of Increase, R, of Populations with Heterogeneous Life Histories', Oikos 50, 262-266.
Murray, B.G.: 1998, ‘Can the Population Regulation Controversy Be Buried and Forgotten?’ Oikos 84, 148-152.
Nicholson, A.J.: 1933, ‘The Balance of Animal Populations', Journal of Animal Ecology 2, 132-178.
Nicholson, A.J.: 1954, ‘An Outline of the Dynamics of Animal Populations', Australian Journal of Zoology 2, 9-65.
Nicholson, A.J.: 1957, ‘Discussion', from L.C. Birch, ‘The Role of Weather in Determining the Distribution and Abundance of Animals', Cold Spring Harbor Symposia on Quantitative Biology 22, 216.
Nicholson, A.J.: 1960, ‘The Role of Population Dynamics in Natural Selection', in S. Tax (ed.), Evolution After Darwin, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
Nicholson, A.J. andBailey, V.A.: 1935, The Balance of Animal Populations, Zoological Society of London, London.
Orians, G.H.: 1962, ‘Natural Selection and Ecological Theory', The American Naturalist 46, 257-263.
Orzack, S.H. andSober, E.: 1994, ‘Optimality Models and the Test of Adaptationism', American Naturalist 143, 361-380.
Pickett, S.T.A.,Kolasa, J. andJones, C.G.: 1994, Ecological Understanding, Academic Press, New York.
Price, P.W.: 1984, ‘Alternative Paradigms in Community Ecology', in P.W. Price,C.N. Slobodchikoff andW.S. Gaud (eds), pp. 354-383.
Price, P.W.,Slobodchikoff, C.N. andGaud, W.S.: 1984, A New Ecology: Novel Approaches to Interactive Systems, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
Price, P.W. andHunter, M.D.: 1995, ‘Novelty and Synthesis in the Development of Population Dynamics', in N. Cappuccino andP.W. Price (eds), pp. 389-413.
Reddingius, J.: 1971, ‘Gambling for Existence: A Discussion of Some Theoretical Problems in Animal Populations Ecology', Acta Biotheoretica 20 (suppl.), 1-208.
Reeve, J. D.,Ayres, M.P. andLorio, P.L. Jr.: 1995, ‘Host Sustainability, Predation, and Bark Beetle Population Dynamics', in N. Cappuccino andP.W. Price (eds), pp. 339-358.
Resetarits, W.J., Jr andBernardo, J.: 1998, Experimental Ecology: Issues and Perspectives, Oxford University Press, New York.
Richardson, J.L.: 1980, ‘The Organismic Community: Resilience of an Embattled Ecological Concept', BioScience 30, 465-471.
Ricklefs, R.E.: 2000, ‘Density Dependence, Evolutionary Optimization, and the Diversification of Avian Life Histories', The Condor 102, 9-22.
Roughgarden, J.S.D.,May, R.M. andLevin, S.A. (eds): 1989, Perspectives in Ecological Theory, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Royama, T.: 1992, Analytical Population Dynamics, Chapman & Hall, London.
Shipley, B. andKeddy, P.A.: 1987, ‘The Individualistic and Community-Unit Concepts as Falsifiable Hypotheses', Vegetatio 69, 47-55.
Shipley, B. andPeters, R.H.: 1991, ‘The Seduction by Mechanism: A Reply to Tilman', The American Naturalist 138, 1276-1282.
Shrader-Frechette, K.S.: 1989, ‘Idealized Laws, Antirealism, and Applied Science: A Case in Hydrogeology', Synthese 81, 329-352.
Shrader-Frechette, K.S. andMcCoy, E.D.: 1993, Method in Ecology, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Strong, D.R.: 1984a, ‘Density-Vague Ecology and Liberal Population Regulation in Insects', in P.W. Price,C.N. Slobodchikoff and W.S. Gaud (eds), A New Ecology: Novel Approaches to Interactive Systems, John Wiley & Sons, New York, pp. 313-327.
Strong, D.R.: 1984b, ‘Natural Variability and the Manifold Mechanisms of Ecological Communities', in G.W. Salt (ed.), Ecology and Evolutionary Biology: A Round Table on Research, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, pp. 56-80.
Strong, D.R.: 1986, ‘Density Vagueness: Abiding the Variance in the Demography of Real Populations', in J. Diamond andT. Case (eds), Community Ecology, Harper and Row, New York, pp. 257-268.
Thompson, W.R.: 1939, ‘Biological Control and the Theories of the Interaction of Populations', Parasitology 31, 299-388.
Tilman, D.: 1989, ‘Discussion: Population Dynamics and Species Interactions', in J.S.D. Roughgarden,R.M. May andS.A. Levin (eds), Perspectives in Ecological Theory, Princeton University Press, Princeton, pp. 89-100.
Tilman, D.: 1991, ‘The Schism between Theory and Ardent Empiricism: A Reply to Shipley and Peters', The American Naturalist 138, 1283-1286.
Tilman, D.: 1993, ‘Community Diversity and Succession: The Roles of Competition, Dispersal, and Habitat Modification', in E.D. Schulze andH.A. Mooney (eds), Biodiversity and Ecosystem Function, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 328-344.
Tilman, D. andKareiva, P.: 1997, Spatial Ecology: The Role of Space in Population Dynamics and Interspecific Interactions, Monographs in Population Biology, No. 30, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
Turchin, P.: 1995, ‘Population Regulation: Old Arguments and a New Synthesis', in N. Cappuccino andP.W. Price (eds), Population Dynamics: New Approaches and Synthesis, Academic Press, San Diego, pp. 19-41.
Turchin, P.: 1999, ‘Population Regulation: A Synthetic View', Oikos 84, 153-159.
Turchin, P.,Getz, W.M.,Taneyhill, D.E. andGinzburg, L.: 1993, ‘The Logistic Equation Revisited: Final Installment,’ in ‘Letters to the Editor', Trends in Environmental Ecology 8, 68-70.
Turchin, P. andBerryman, A.A.: 2000, ‘Detecting Cycles and Delayed Density Dependence: A Comment on Hunter and Price (1998)', Ecological Entomology 25, 119-121.
Walter, G.H. andPatterson, H.E.H.: 1995, ‘Levels of Understanding in Ecology: Interspecific Competition and Community Ecology', Australian Journal of Ecology 20, 463-466.
White, T.C.R.: 1993, The Inadequate Environment: Nitrogen and the Abundance of Animals, Springer Verlag, Berlin.
Williams, G.C.: 1992, ‘“Gaia,” Nature Worship and Biocentric Fallacies', The Quarterly Review of Biology 67, 479-486.
Wilson, D.S.: 1989, ‘Reviving the Superorganism', Journal of Theoretical Biology 136, 337-356.
Wilson, J.: 1999, 'To Be Continued ...', Biology and Philosophy 14, 615-619.
Wimsatt, W.C.: 1980, ‘Randomness and Perceived-Randomness in Evolutionary Theory', in E. Saarinen (ed.), Conceptual Issues in Ecology, D. Reidel Publishing Company, Dordrecht, The Netherlands, pp. 279-322.
Wolda, H.: 1989, ‘The Equilibrium Concept and Density Dependence Tests:What Does It All Mean?’ Oecologia 81, 430-432.
Wolda, H.: 1991, ‘The Usefulness of the Equilibrium Concept in Population Dynamics', Oecologia 86, 144-145.
Wolda, H.,Dennis, B. andTaper, M.L.: 1994, Density Dependent Tests, and Largely Futile Comments: Answers to Holyoak and Lawton (1993) and Hanski, Woiwod and Perry (1993)', Oecologia 98, 229-234.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Cooper, G. Must There Be a Balance of Nature?. Biology & Philosophy 16, 481–506 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011935220219
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011935220219