Summary:
This paper examines Josephus' account of a judicial incident that occurred in around 62 C.E., which involved both Judaean elites and the Roman imperial powers. While traditional readings of the passage have focussed on mining it for information about the nature of the Judaean council that is often referred to as the „sanhedrin“, it is here argued that this report sheds light on several other key issues related to the operation of law within the region: indigenous perspectives on loci of authority within a judicial context, the importance of judicial power within broader societal conflicts, and the role of Judaean-Roman interactions in maintaining and redefining jurisdictional boundaries. It thus constitutes a valuable testimony for understanding the operation of law in this particular part of the Roman Empire.
Acknowledgements:
I am extremely grateful to Dr. Benedikt Eckhardt for his extensive comments on an early draft of this paper. All remaining errors are of course my own.
Bibliography
Appelbaum (1974): A. Appelbaum, The Legal Status of the Jewish Communities in the Diaspora, in: S. Safrai – M. Stern (eds.), The Jewish People in the First Century I., Philadelphia 1974, 420–463.Search in Google Scholar
Appelbaum (2013): A. Appelbaum, The Dynasty of the Jewish Patriarchs (Texte und Studien zum antiken Judentum 156), Tübingen 2013.10.1628/978-3-16-152969-6Search in Google Scholar
Bauckham (1999): R. Bauckham, For What Offence Was James Put To Death?, in: B. Chilton – C. Evans (eds.), James the Just and Christian Origins (Supplements to Novum Testamentum 98), Leiden 1999, 199–232.Search in Google Scholar
Ben Zeev (1998): M. P. Ben Zeev, Jewish Rights in the Roman World. The Greek and Roman Documents Quoted by Josephus Flavius, Tübingen 1998.Search in Google Scholar
Berman (2009): P. S. Berman, The New Legal Pluralism, Annual Review of Law and Social Science 5, 2009, 225–242.10.1146/annurev.lawsocsci.093008.131539Search in Google Scholar
Bernheim (1997): P.-A. Bernheim, James, Brother of Jesus, London 1997.Search in Google Scholar
Bruinsma – Nelken (2007): F. Bruinsma – D. Nelken (eds.), Explorations in Legal Cultures, Gravenhage 2007.Search in Google Scholar
Brunt (1975): P. A. Brunt, The Administrators of Roman Egypt, JRS 65, 1975, 124–147.10.2307/370067Search in Google Scholar
Bryen (2013): A. Bryen, Violence in Roman Egypt. A Study in Legal Interpretation, Philadelphia 2013.10.9783/9780812208214Search in Google Scholar
Bryen (2014): A. Bryen, Law in Many Pieces, CPh 109, 2014, 346–365.10.1086/677860Search in Google Scholar
Büchler (1902): A. Büchler, Das Synhedrion in Jerusalem und das grosse Beth-Din in der Quaderkammer des jerusalemischen Tempels, Wien 1902.Search in Google Scholar
Burkhill (1956): T. A. Burkhill, The Competence of the Sanhedrin, VChr. 10, 1956, 80–96.Search in Google Scholar
Clark Kee (1999): H. Clark Kee, Central Authority in Second-Temple Judaism and Subsequently. From Synedrion to Sanhedrin, Review of Rabbinic Judaism 2.1, 1999, 51–63.Search in Google Scholar
Cotton (1993): H. M. Cotton, The Guardianship of Jesus Son of Babatha. Roman and Local Law in the Province of Arabia, JRS 83, 1993, 94–108.10.2307/300980Search in Google Scholar
Cotton (1999): H. M. Cotton, Some Aspects of the Roman Administration of Judaea/Syria-Palaestina, in: W. Eck (ed.), Lokale Autonomie und römische Ordnungsmacht in den kaiserzeitlichen Provinzen vom 1. bis 3. Jahrhundert, Munich 1999, 75–91.10.1524/9783486596014-007Search in Google Scholar
Czajkowski (2016): K. Czajkowski, Justice in Client Kingdoms. The Many Trials of Herod's Sons, Historia 65, 2016, 473–496.10.25162/historia-2016-0024Search in Google Scholar
De Lange (1976): N.R.M. De Lange, Origen and the Jews: Studies in Jewish-Christian Relations in Third-Century Palestine (University of Cambridge Oriental Publications 25), Cambridge 1976.Search in Google Scholar
Eck (2007): W. Eck, Judaea wird römisch. Der Weg zur eigenständigen Provinz, in: W. Eck, Rom und Judaea. Fünf Vorträge zur römischen Herrschaft in Palaestina, Tübingen 2007, 1–51.Search in Google Scholar
Feldman (1984): L. Feldman, Josephus and Modern Scholarship (1937–1980), Berlin 1984.10.1515/9783110841589Search in Google Scholar
Feldman (1987): L. Feldman, Introduction, in: L. Feldman – G. Hata (eds.), Josephus, Judaism and Christianity, Detroit 1987, 23–67.Search in Google Scholar
Friedman (1969): L. Friedman, Legal Culture and Social Development, Law and Society Review 4, 1969, 29–44.10.2307/3052760Search in Google Scholar
Friedman (1994): L. Friedman, Is There a Modern Legal Culture?, Ratio Juris 7.2, 1994, 117–131.Search in Google Scholar
Galanter (1981): M. Galanter, Justice in Many Rooms. Courts, Private Ordering, and Indigenous Law, Journal of Legal Pluralism 19, 1981, 1–47.Search in Google Scholar
Goodblatt (1994): D. Goodblatt, The Monarchic Principle. Studies in Jewish Self-Government in Antiquity (Texte und Studien zum antiken Judentum 38), Tübingen 1994.Search in Google Scholar
Goodman (1992): M. Goodman, The Roman State and the Jewish Patriarch in the Third Century, in: L. I. Levine (ed.), The Galilee in Late Antiquity, New York – Jerusalem 1992, 127–139.Search in Google Scholar
Gordon – Horwitz (2014): R. W. Gordon – M. J. Horwitz (eds.), Law, Society, and History. Themes in the Legal Sociology and Legal History of Lawrence M. Friedman (Cambridge Studies in Law and Society), Cambridge 2014.Search in Google Scholar
Grabbe (2008): L. Grabbe, Sanhedrin, Sanhedriyyot, or Mere Invention?, JSJ 39, 2008, 1–19.Search in Google Scholar
Habas-Rubin (1991): E. Habas-Rubin, The Patriarch in the Roman-Byzantine Era. The Making of a Dynasty (In Hebrew), Two Volumes, (PhD Thesis) Tel-Aviv University 1991.Search in Google Scholar
Humfress (Unpublished): C. Humfress, Lex and the City. Roman Law, Local Law and the Case of Dionysia (P. Oxy. II.237 c.186 CE), 1–26.Search in Google Scholar
Humfress (2011): C. Humfress, Law and Custom under Rome, in: A. Rio (ed.), Law, Custom, and Justice in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages. Proceedings of the 2008 Byzantine Colloquium, London 2011, 23–47.Search in Google Scholar
Humfress (2013): C. Humfress, Thinking through Legal Pluralism. ‚Forum shopping‘ in the Later Roman Empire, in: J. Duindam – J. Harries – C. Humfress – N. Hurvitz (eds.), Law and Empire. Ideas, Practices, Actors (Rulers & Elites 3), Leiden 2013, 225–250.Search in Google Scholar
Jacobs (1995): M. Jacobs, Die Institution des jüdischen Patriarchen. Eine quellen- und traditionskritische Studie zur Geschichte des Juden in der Spätantike (Texte und Studien zum antiken Judentum 52), Tübingen 1995.Search in Google Scholar
Juster (1914): J. Juster, Les Juifs Dans L'empire Romain Leur Condition Juridique, Economique Et Sociale, Volume II, Paris 1914.Search in Google Scholar
Kantor (2009): G. Kantor, Knowledge of Law in Roman Asia Minor, in: R. Haensch (ed.), Selbstdarstellung und Kommunikation. Die Veröffentlichung staatlicher Urkunden auf Stein und Bronze in der römischen Welt. Internationales Kolloquium an der Kommission für Alte Geschichte und Epigraphik in München (1. bis 3. Juli 2006) (Vestigia 61), München 2009, 249–265.Search in Google Scholar
Kelly (2011): B. Kelly, Petitions, Litigation, and Social Control in Roman Egypt (Oxford Studies in Ancient Documents), Oxford 2011.Search in Google Scholar
Kokkinos (1998): N. Kokkinos, The Herodian Dynasty. Origins, Role in Society and Eclipse (Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha Supplement Series 30), Sheffield 1998.Search in Google Scholar
Mantel (1961): H. Mantel, Studies in the History of the Sanhedrin, Cambridge 1961.Search in Google Scholar
Martin (1988): R. P. Martin, James (Word Biblical Commentary 48), Waco 1988.Search in Google Scholar
Mason (1992): S. Mason, Josephus and the New Testament, Peabody [MA]1992.Search in Google Scholar
Nelken (2012): D. Nelken (ed.), Using Legal Culture, London 2012.Search in Google Scholar
Oppenheimer (1998): A. Oppenheimer, Jewish Penal Authority in Roman Judaea, in: M. Goodman (ed.), Jews in a Graeco-Roman World, Oxford 1998, 181–191.Search in Google Scholar
Rajak (1984): T. Rajak, Was there a Roman Charter for the Jews?, JRS 74, 1984, 107–123.10.1163/9789047400196_023Search in Google Scholar
Rajak (1985): T. Rajak, Jewish Rights in the Greek Cities under Roman Rule. A New Approach, in: W. S. Green (ed.), Approaches to Ancient Judaism. Theory and Practice. Volume 5: Studies in Judaism and Its Greco-Roman Context (Brown Judaic Studies 32), Atlanta 1985, 19–35.Search in Google Scholar
Rajak (2003): T. Rajak, Josephus. The Historian and His Society, London 22003.Search in Google Scholar
Rivkin (1975): E. Rivkin, Beth Din, Boulé, Sanhedrin. A Tragedy of Errors, HebrUCA 46, 1975, 181–99.Search in Google Scholar
Sanders (1992): E. P. Sanders, Judaism. Practice and Belief. 63 B. C. E.–66 C. E., London 1992.Search in Google Scholar
Schürer – Vermes – Millar (1973–1987): E. Schürer – G. Vermes – F. Millar (eds.), The History of the Jewish People in the Age of Jesus Christ (175 B. C.–A. D. 135). Three Volumes, Edinburgh 1973–1987.10.5040/9780567691149Search in Google Scholar
Schwartz (2011): D. R. Schwartz, Josephus on Albinus. The Eve of Catastrophe in Changing Retrospect, in: M. Popović (ed.), The Jewish Revolt against Rome: Interdisciplinary Perspectives, Leiden 2011, 291–309.Search in Google Scholar
Shahar (2008): I. Shahar, State, Society and the Relations Between Them. Implications for the Study of Legal Pluralism, Theoretical Inquiries in Law 9.2, 2008, 417–441.Search in Google Scholar
Sherwin-White (1963): A. N. Sherwin-White, Roman Society and Roman Law in the New Testament. The Sarum Lectures 1960–1961, Oxford 1963.Search in Google Scholar
Twining (2010): W. Twining, Normative and Legal Pluralism. A Global Perspective, Duke Journal of Comparative & International Law 20, 2010, 473–517.Search in Google Scholar
Wilker (2007): J. Wilker, Für Rom und Jerusalem. Die herodianische Dynastie im 1. Jahrhundert n. Chr. (Studien zur Alten Geschichte 5), Frankfurt 2007.Search in Google Scholar
Winter (1964): P. Winter, The Trial of Jesus and the Competence of the Sanhedrin, NTS 10.4, 1964, 494–499.Search in Google Scholar
Zeitlin (1945): S. Zeitlin, The Political Synedrion and the Religious Sanhédrin, Jewish Quarterly Review 36, 1945, 109–140.10.2307/1452495Search in Google Scholar
© 2018 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
