The War That Must Not Occur

Jean-Pierre Dupuy

Published by Stanford University Press 2023

The War That Must Not Occur

Jean-Pierre Dupuy
Translated by: Malcolm DeBevoise

https://doi.org/10.1515/9781503636651

Overview
Contents

About this book

The possibility of a nuclear war that could destroy civilization has influenced the course of international affairs since 1945, suspended like a sword of Damocles above the heads of the world's leaders. The fact that we have escaped a third world war involving strategic nuclear weapons—indeed, that no atomic weapon of limited power has yet been used under battlefield conditions—seems nothing short of a miracle.

Revisiting debates on the effectiveness and ethics of nuclear deterrence, Jean-Pierre Dupuy is led to reformulate some of the most difficult questions in philosophy. He develops a counterintuitive but powerful theory of apocalyptic prophecy: once a major catastrophe appears to be possible, one must assume that it will in fact occur. Dupuy shows that the contradictions and paradoxes riddling discussions of deterrence arise from the tension between two opposite conceptions of time: one in which the future depends on decisions and strategy, and another in which every occurring event is one that could not have failed to occur.

Considering the immense destructive power of nuclear warheads and the almost unimaginable ruin they are bound to cause, Dupuy reaches a provocative conclusion: whether they bring about good or evil does not depend on the present or future intentions of those who are in a position to use them. The mere possession of nuclear weapons is a moral abomination.

Author / Editor information

Jean-Pierre Dupuy is Professor Emeritus of Social and Political Philosophy at the École Polytechnique in Paris and Professor in the Program in Science, Technology, and Society at Stanford University. He is a member of the French Academy of Technology and formerly Chair of the Ethics Committee of the French High Authority on Nuclear Safety and Security. His many books, translated into thirteen languages, include How to Think About Catastrophe: Toward a Theory of Enlightened Doomsaying (2022) and The Mark of the Sacred (Stanford, 2013). Malcolm DeBevoise has translated some fifty works from French and Italian in every branch of scholarship. He is a three-time winner of the French-American Foundation translation prize for nonfiction.

Reviews

"This brilliant analysis is as frightening as it is illuminating. Dupuy assesses policy, words of candidates and politicians, and real-time war events (including Russia and Ukraine), giving nuance to them with theological and moral arguments....Essential."—R. Ward, CHOICE

"Most of us navigate our private joys and woes without thinking about collective nuclear annihilation. This is not because the threat has vanished. It is because it is unthinkable. In this compelling work of rational doomsaying, Dupuy models how to think the unthinkable. The result is a challenging and urgent book."—Alison McQueen, author of Political Realism in Apocalyptic Times

"Dupuy, one of the most incisive thinkers of our times, allows us to rethink history while it is in the making. This book is mandatory reading for anyone who seeks to understand our present."—Frank Ruda, coauthor of Reading Hegel

"Dupuy provides an extremely important service by bringing much-needed attention to the existential risk that society largely ignored prior to the war in Ukraine and, even now, does not take seriously enough. Highly recommended."—Martin E. Hellman, winner of the Turing Award

"This is a provocative exploration of the paradoxes of nuclear deterrence. If we are to postpone nuclear catastrophe indefinitely, Dupuy argues, we must understand that nuclear war is not merely possible but bound to occur."—David Holloway, author of Stalin and the Bomb

"We all live under the shadow of a forthcoming catastrophe: pandemic, ecological disaster, nuclear war. Our reactions to such threats are often irrational, and Dupuy provides a superbly readable rational analysis of all these irrationalities: why the logic of nuclear MAD (mutually assured destruction) is really mad, why nuclear threats are never just rhetoric but can trigger an actual catastrophe, why sometimes to be taken seriously one has to act as if one is mad, why the only rational strategy is to accept that things can at any moment go wrong. Dupuy is our best theorist of catastrophes and his new book is a book for all of us—in a well-organized state, it would be massively printed and freely distributed to all families. So it is vulgar and trivial to say that this is an excellent book—it is rather a book that we all need like ordinary daily bread."—Slavoj Žižek, author of Surplus-Enjoyment

"A stimulating read, essential for understanding the remaining options afforded to our civilization, now that we live with the irreversibility of the nuclear bomb."—Diane Delaurens, Nonfiction

Topics

Frontmatter Publicly Available Download PDF	i
Contents Publicly Available Download PDF	ix
Introduction Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	1
ONE. Ninety Seconds from Apocalypse and Why (Almost) No One Gives a Damn Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	15
TWO. MAD: The Birth of a Structure Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	33
THREE. The Pure Theory of MAD Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	59
FOUR. Metaphysical MAD Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	101
Appendix Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	139
Acknowledgments Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	155
Notes Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	157

Language: English
Publisher: Stanford University Press
Audience: Professional and scholarly;
Pages
- Main content: 192
Illustrations
- Illustrations: 4
Keywords: Nuclear War; Deterrence; Preemption; Rationality; Ethics; Metaphysics; Apocalypse; Nuclear Deterrence; Preemptive War

eBook

Published: September 19, 2023
ISBN: 9781503636651