Skip to main content

Advertisement

SpringerLink
Log in

Leadership and Integrity: Crisis and Challenge for the Global Economy

  • Published:
Philosophy of Management Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

This paper formulates a vision for leadership based on integrity in business, banking, government and politics. It proposes a tripartite response to the current grave difficulties affecting international finance and markets: a renewal of values and virtues, acceptance of the centrality of the human person, and appropriate recourse to key principles of Catholic social teaching, as articulated in Pope Benedict XVI’s encyclical, Caritas in Veritate. By considering Ireland’s “Celtic Tiger” period, particularly the actions of the Anglo Irish Bank, we show how failures in leadership and integrity at all levels of Irish society, including business, politics, government, public sector and church, have eroded trust and damaged the reputation of key institutions. The paper presents plain suggestions for civic leaders on how putting people first can help restore trust, reputation, integrity and professionalism at local and global levels.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  1. Our thanks to Professor Patricia H Werhane, Professor Edwin M Hartman, Dr Con Power and Dr Ethna Regan for useful suggestions on an earlier draft of this paper. Anonymous referees also offered helpful advice.

  2. Paul Krugman ‘How Did Economists Get It So Wrong?’ The New York Times 2 September 2009. Available at < http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/06/magazine/06Economic-t.html> (accessed 19 August 2010).

  3. See John Finnis ‘The Basic Values’, in: P Singer (ed) Ethics Oxford, Oxford University Press 1994 pp. 229-35.

  4. For an introduction to virtue ethics, see R.J. Devettere, Introduction to Virtue Ethics: Insights of the Ancient Greeks Washington DC, Georgetown University Press 2002. See further J.G. Murphy, ‘Virtue Ethics and Christian Moral Reflection’ Milltown Studies 55 (2005) pp. 82-112; D. Birsch Ethical Insights: A Brief Introduction, 2nd edn Boston, McGraw-Hill 2002 pp. 135-53; D. Koehn, A Role for Virtue Ethics in the Analysis of Business Practice’ Business Ethics Quarterly 5 (1995) pp. 533-9; R.C. Solomon ‘Business With Virtue: Maybe Next Year’ Business Ethics Quarterly 10 (2000) pp. 339-41; T. Libby and L. Thorne ‘The Identification and Categorization of Auditors’ Virtues’, Business Ethics Quarterly 14 (2004) pp. 479-98; G. Moore ‘Corporate Character: Modern Virtue Ethics and the Virtuous Corporation’ Business Ethics Quarterly 15 (2005) pp. 659-85; M.J. Naughton and J.R. Cornwall ‘The Virtue of Courage in Entrepreneurship: Engaging the Catholic Social Tradition and the Life-Cycle of the Business’ Business Ethics Quarterly 16 (2006) pp. 69-93; D.J. Moberg ‘Role Models and Moral Exemplars: How do Employees Acquire Virtues by Observing Others?’ Business Ethics Quarterly 10 (2000) pp. 675-96; S.M. Mintz ‘Aristotelian Virtue and Business Ethics Education’, Journal of Business Ethics 15 (1996) pp. 827-38. See further D.N. McCloskey, The Bourgeois Virtues: Ethics for an Age of Commerce Chicago, The University of Chicago Press, 2006. McCloskey presents a new interpretation of ‘virtue ethics’ as ‘better than Kantianism.’

  5. See for example B. McKenna D. Rooney and K.B. Boal ‘Wisdom principles as a meta-theoretical basis for evaluating leadership’ The Leadership Quarterly 20 (2009) pp. 177-90; M. Benefiel The Soul of a Leader: Finding Your Path to Success and Fulfillment New York, Crossroad Publishing 2008.

  6. Benedict XVI Encyclical Letter: Caritas in Veritate. Available at < http://www.vatican.va/holy%20father/benedictxvi/encyclicals/documents/hf%20ben-xvi%20enc%2020090629%20caritas-in-veritate%20en.html>(accessed 27 April 2010).

  7. See Doris Kearns Goodwin Teams of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln London, Penguin 2005.

  8. D. Rooney, B. McKenna and P. Liesch Wisdom and Management in the Knowledge Economy London, Routledge 2010; see also G.J. Hughes Routledge Philosophy Guidebook to Aristotle on Ethics London, Routledge 2001 Chapter 5; A. Maclntyre A Short History of Ethics: A history of moral philosophy from the Homeric Age to the twentieth century 2nd edn London, Routledge 1998 Chapter 7.

  9. D. Knowles The Evolution of Medieval Thought London, Longman 1962 pp. 202-5. Also B. Davies The Thought of Thomas Aquinas 2nd edn Oxford, Clarendon Press 1993 Oxford p. 26; F. C. Copleston Aquinas, 2nd edn London, Penguin 1991 p. 63; John Paul II: 1998, Encyclical Letter Fides et Ratio on the Relationship Between Faith and Reason Vatican City, Libreria Editrice Vaticana § 43.

  10. J. Porter ‘Virtue Ethics’ in: R Gill (ed) The Cambridge Companion to Christian Ethics pp. 96-111 at 103 Cambridge, Cambridge University Press 2001.

  11. F. Kerr After Aquinas: Versions of Thomism Oxford, Blackwell 2002 p. 120.

  12. M. D Jordan Rewritten Theology: Aquinas after his Readers Oxford, Blackwell 2006 pp. 85-8.

  13. Kerr, p. 10.

  14. Copleston, Aquinas pp. 66-7.

  15. J. Maritain St. Thomas Aquinas London, Sheed& Ward 1942 pp. 14-16.

  16. C. Fisher& A. Lovell Business Ethics and Values London, Financial Times 2003 pp. 113-14. Fisher and Lovell’s illustration of values acting as heuristics is particularly helpful when applied to business. ‘People … use values as filters to reduce the amount of information they take into account when making a decision. […] Just as a mechanic manages to choose the right tool to repair a car so people choose the best heuristic to hand to help them make their mind up or take a decision.’

  17. A. Gini ‘Moral Leadership and Business Ethics’ in: J.B. Ciulla (ed) Ethics, the Heart of Leadership, 2nd edn Westport Connecticut, Praeger 2004 pp. 25-43 at 34, 36.

  18. L.W. Fry and M.P. Cohen ‘Spiritual Leadership as a Paradigm for Organizational Transformation and Recovery from Extended Work Hours Cultures’ Journal of Business Ethics 84 (2009) pp. 265-78 at 266.

  19. See B. Leavy ‘Inspirational Leadership in Business and Other Domains’ in G. Flynn (ed) Leadership and Business Ethics, Issues in Business Ethics 25 New York, Springer 2008 pp. 103-16.

  20. Fry and Cohen, p. 266.

  21. Fry and Cohen, p. 276.

  22. Fry and Cohen, p. 268.

  23. G. Flynn ‘The Virtuous Manager: A Vision for Leadership in Business’ Journal of Business Ethics 78 (2008) pp. 359-72 at 361-4.

  24. A. Bertland, ‘Virtue Ethics in Business and the Capabilities Approach’ Journal of Business Ethics 84 pp. 25-32 at

  25. Bertland, p. 25.

  26. A.K. Sen On Ethics and Economics Oxford, Blackwell 1987.

  27. See A. Sen Development as Freedom Oxford, Oxford University Press 1999.

  28. D.K. Goodwin ‘Leadership Lessons from Abraham Lincoln’ Harvard Business Review 87 (2009) pp. 43-7 at 44.

  29. Goodwin, pp. 45-7.

  30. R. Heifetz, A. Grashow and M. Linsky ‘Leadership in a (Permanent) Crisis’ Harvard Business Review 87 (2009) pp. 62-9 at 69.

  31. See M. Bene fiel ‘Using Discernment to Make Better Business Decisions’ in: Flynn (ed) Leadership and Business Ethics pp. 31-8; D. Dorr ‘Alternative Business Ethics: A Challenge for Leadership’ in: Flynn (ed) Leadership and Business Ethics pp. 211-27; also, D. Dorr ‘Framework for Change’, available at <http://donaldorr.com/> (accessed 27 April 2010); J. Verstraeten ‘Responsible Leadership beyond Managerial Rationality: The Necessity of Reconnecting Ethics and Spirituality’ in: Flynn (ed) Leadership and Business Ethics, pp. 131-47, also J. Verstraeten ‘Beyond Business Ethics: Leadership, Spirituality, and the Quest for Meaning’ Logos: A Journal of Catholic Thought and Culture 5 (2002) 17-39.

  32. For a detailed treatment of the Celtic Tiger period, see C. Power Metamorphosis: Lessons from the Formative Years of the Celtic Tiger, 1979–1993 Cork, Oak Tree Press 2009.

  33. A. Bergin et al Recovery Scenarios for Ireland, ESRI Research Series 007 Dublin, Economic and Social Research Institute 2009 p. ix. This report positively assesses the Irish economy’s capacity to recover from the present recession: ‘if the world economy recovers significant momentum by 2011, the Irish economy, as long as it regains competitiveness, can be expected to grow quite rapidly in the 2011–2015 period, recovering some of the lost ground of the current recession. Available at <http://www.esri.ie/UserFiles/publications/20090513115638/RS007.pdf> (Accessed 20 August 2010). Also National Economic& Social Council ‘The Euro: An Irish Perspective’ no. 121 Dublin, July 2010 p. x. Available at <http://www.nesc.ie/dynamic/docs/NESC 121 Euro.pdf> (Accessed 21 August 2010). The Report shows that if Ireland had not joined the Euro, it would likely have fared worse in the crisis of 2008–10. ‘The future stability of the euro area depends on more effective surveillance and co-ordination of member states’ fiscal positions and structural policies, stronger EU-level financial regulation and a successful outcome of the ongoing reform process.’

  34. See K. Regling and M. Watson ‘A Preliminary Report on the Sources of Ireland’s Banking Crisis’ Dublin, Government Publications 2010. Available at <http://www.bankinginquiry.gov.ie/Preliminary%20Report%20into%20Ireland’s%20Banking%20Crisis%20 31%20May%202010.pdf> (Accessed 20 August 2010).

  35. P. Honohan et al. ‘The Irish Banking Crisis Regulatory and Financial Stability Policy 2003–2008: A Report to the Minister for Finance by the Governor of the Central Bank’ Dublin, Government Publications 2010. Available at <http://www.bankinginquiry.gov.ie/The%20Irish%20Banking%20Crisis%20Regulatory%20and%20Financial%20Stability%20Policy%202003–2008.pdf–(Accessed 22 June 2010).

  36. Regling and Watson, p. 6.

  37. See J. M. Clarke ‘Ethical Hypotheticals’ Accountancy Ireland 30 (June 1998) p. 16.

  38. Transparency International An Alternative to Silence: Whistleblower Protection in Ireland’ (January 2010) pp. 1-30 at 5. Available at < http://www.transparency.ie/Files/2010 Alternative to Silence Ireland vl.pdf> (Accessed 20 August 2010).

  39. G. Connor, T. Flavin and B. O’Kelly ‘The U.S. and Irish Credit Crises: Their Distinctive Differences and Common Features’ pp. 1-25 at 2 (italics in original). Available at <http://www.irisheconomy.ie/Notes/IrishEconomyNote10.pdf> (Accessed 18 August 2010).

  40. Paul Krugman ‘What Ireland tells us about the financial crisis’ The New York Times 8 March 2010.

  41. See Regling and Watson; Power, Metamorphosis; A.L. Spollen Corporate Fraud: The Danger from Within Dublin, Oak Tree Press 1997. See further R.C Solomon and F. Flores Building Trust in Business, Politics, Relationships, and Life Oxford, Oxford University Press 2001 p. 3.

  42. Editor ‘Watch That Next Step — It’s a Big One’ Harvard Business Review 87 (2009) p. 14.

  43. See J.M. Clarke ‘Truth, Reputation, Integrity and Professionalism: Reflections on Business Relationships’ Accountancy Ireland 39 (February 2007) pp. 54-8.

  44. R.M. Gula Reason Informed by Faith: Foundations of Catholic Morality New York, Paulist Press 1989.

  45. Solomon and Flores Building Trust, p. 151.

  46. P.H. Werhane ‘Corporate Social Responsibility, Corporate Moral Responsibility, and Systems Thinking: Is There a Difference and the Difference it Makes’ in: Flynn (ed) Leadership and Business Ethics pp. 269-89.

  47. C.S. Lewis The Four Loves, 22nd edn Glasgow, Collins 1981 p. 7.

  48. Vatican II, Pastoral Constitution on the Church in the Modern world: Gaudium et Spes <http://www.vatican.va/archive/histcouncils/iiVatican council/documents/vat-iicons19651207gaudium-et-spesen.html> § 46 (accessed 3 October 2010).

  49. Benedict XVI Caritas in Veritate § 45.

  50. Ibid, § 47-8.

  51. Ibid § 40 (italics in original).

  52. R.A. Sirico ‘The Pope on “Love in Truth”’ The Wall Street Journal Europe edn 13 July 2009.

  53. B. Laurent ‘Caritas In Veritate as a Social Encyclical: A Modest Challenge to Economic, Social, and Political Institutions’ Theological Studies 71 (2010) pp. 515-44 at 544.

  54. Benedict XVI Caritas § 36.

  55. Laurent, p. 542.

  56. Benedict XVI Caritas § 76 (italics in original).

  57. K. Jayabalan ‘Letter from the Director’ Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Liberty 29 March 2010. Available at <http://www.acton.org/global/article/letter-director-march-2010> (accessed 11 September 2010).

  58. See Anglo Irish Bank, 2007, ‘Interim Report 2007: Six Months ended 31 March 2007’. Available at <http://www.angloirishbank-interim-results.com/notesinterim.asp> (accessed 20 August 2010). See further S. Carswell ‘Profits at Anglo Irish Bank break billion euro barrier’ The Irish Times 11 November 2007. Available at <http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/finance/2007/1129/1196263130156.html> (accessed 30 April 2010).

  59. Available at < http://www.independent.ie/business/irish/the-share-price-collapse-at-anglo-irish-bank-appears->to-mark-end-of-the-road-1573685.html> (accessed 30 April 2010).

  60. Available at ∼ http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/anglo-irish-bank-chiefs-quit-amid-loans->scandal-1205117.html> (accessed 30 April 2010).

  61. See C. O’Brien ‘Anglo Irish Bank reports €12.7 billion pretax loss’ The Irish Times 31 March 2010. Available at <http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/breaking/2010/0331/breaking54.html> http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/breaking/2010/0331/breaking54.html>(accessed 20 August 2010).

  62. T. Lyons ‘Named: four of Anglo’s “golden circle”’ The Sunday Times 22 February 2009. Available at <http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/ireland/article5781014.ece>> (accessed 20 August 2010).

  63. PriceWaterhouseCoopers: 2009, ‘Project Atlas — Anglo Irish Bank Corporation plc: Summary Report Extracts’. Available at <http://www.finance.gov.ie/documents/publications/other/2009/Anglopwc.pdf>> (accessed 19 August 2010).

  64. See RTÉ News, available at <http://www.rte.ie/news/2010/0712/anglo.html> http://www.rte.ie/news/2010/0712/anglo.html>(accessed 21 August 2010).

  65. B. Lenihan,‘Minister’s StatementonBanking 2010’ http://www.rte.ie/news/2010/0712/anglo.html>. Available at< http://www.rte.ie/news/2010/0712/anglo.html>http://www.finance.gov.ie/viewdoc.asp?DocID=6515>> http://www.rte.ie/news/2010/0712/anglo.html>(accessed 4 October 2010).

  66. Ireland RepTrak™ http://www.rte.ie/news/2010/0712/anglo.html>2122http://www.rte.ie/news/2010/0712/anglo.html>Niamh Boyle (Managing Director) ‘2010 Reputation study of the largest and most visible firms in Ireland’. Available at <http://www.corporatereputations.ie/tools/Ireland RepTrak 2010 Corporate Reputations.pdf http://www.corporatereputations.ie/tools/Ireland%20RepTrak%202010%20Corporate%20Reputations.pdf>< (accessed 3 October 2010).

  67. P. Newenham ‘Google “most reputable” firm in Ireland’, The Irish Times 28 April 2010. Available at <http://www.irishtimes.com/newspaper/breaking/2010/0428/breakingl5.html>> (accessed 20 August 2010).

  68. J. Collins and J.I. Porras Built to Last: Successful Habits of Visionary Companies New York, Harper Business 1994 pp. xiv-xv.

  69. Collins and Porras, p. 87.

  70. D.N. McCloskey The Bourgeois Virtues: Ethics for an Age of Commerce Chicago, University of Chicago Press 2006 p. 3.

  71. A. Bertland, ‘Virtue Ethics in Business and the Capabilities Approach’ p. 31.

  72. D.K. Goodwin ‘Leadership Lessons’, p. 44.

Download references

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Mater Dei Institute, a College of Dublin City University, Dublin, Ireland

    Gabriel Flynn (Academic Leader for Research)

Authors
  1. Gabriel Flynn
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

  2. Julian Clarke
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Flynn, G., Clarke, J. Leadership and Integrity: Crisis and Challenge for the Global Economy. Philos. of Manag. 10, 9–28 (2011). https://doi.org/10.5840/pom20111018

Download citation

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.5840/pom20111018

Keywords

Search

Navigation