Abstract
This paper explores how embryos have been representedin law. It argues that two main models haveunderpinned legal discourse concerning the embryo. Onediscourse, which has become increasingly prevalent,views embryos as legal subjects or persons. Suchrepresentations are facilitated by technologicaldevelopments such as ultrasound imaging. In additionto influencing Parliamentary debate prior to thepassage of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act1990, images of embryos as persons featureprominently in popular culture, including advertisingand films, and this discourse came to the fore in the`orphaned embryo' debate in 1996. The main opposingdiscourse dismisses embryos as commodifiable objects,which fits with a trend towards legal recognition thatreproductive materials such as sperm may be classifiedas property which may be donated or sold. In thecase of cryo-preserved embryos these competingperspectives have resulted in litigation over thestatus of frozen embryos. In this paper I argue thatit might be productive to shift the debate from thispolarised dispute over whether embryos matter or not,whether they are pre-persons or commodities. Instead,I suggest that we should attempt to locate them in abiotechnological milieu, where cyborg metaphors may beutilised, and questions of how we should treat embryoswould be contextualised alongside our response toother cyborgs.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Balsamo, A. (1999) Reading Cyborgs, Writing Feminism. In J. Wolmark (Ed.), Cybersexualities: A Reader on Feminist Theory, Cyborgs and Cyberspace. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Bateman Novaes, S. and Salem, T. (1998) Embedding the Embryo. In J. Harris and S. Holm (Eds), the Future of Human Reproduction. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Brazier, M. (1999a) Can You Buy Children? Child and Family Law Quarterly 11, 345–354.
Brazier, M. (1999b) Regulating the Reproduction Business? Medical Law Review 7, 166–193.
Canadian Royal Commission on New Reproductive Technologies, 1993.
Campbell, R. and Porter, S. (1997) Feminist Theory and the Sociology of Childboirth: A Response to Ellen Annadale and Judith Clark. Sociology of Health and Illness 19, 238–258.
Cavalieri, P. and Singer, P. (1993), The Great Ape Project: Equality Beyond Humanity. London: Fourth Estate.
Condit, D.M. (1995) Fetal Personhood: Political Identity Under Construction. In P. Boling (Ed.), Expecting Trouble: Surrogacy, Fetal Abuse & New Reproductive Technologies (pp. 25–54). Boulder: Westview Press.
Corea, G. (1984) Egg Snatchers. In R. Arditti et al. (Eds), Test-Tube Women: What Future for Motherhood? (pp. 37–51). London: Pandora Press.
Davis-Floyd, R. and Dumit, J. (1998) Cyborg Babies: Children of the Third Millenium. In R. Davis Floyd and J. Dumit (Eds), Cyborg Babies: From Techno-Sex to Techno-Tots (pp. 67–89). New York: Routledge.
Davis, T. (1990) Protecting the Cryopreserved Human Embryo Tennessee Law Review 57, 507–537 at 519.
Dickerson, D. (1997) Property, Women and Politics. London: Polity Press.
Doane, M. (unpub) Technology, Representation and the Feminine: Science Fictions (cited in Balsamo, 1999: 148).
Dyson, A. and Harris, J. (Eds) (1990) Experiments on Embryos. London: Routledge.
Fovargue, S. (1998) Case-Note. Journal of Family and Social Welfare Law 20 427–437.
Fovargue, S. and Miola, J. (1998) Policing Pregnancy: Implications of the Attorney-General's Reference (No 3 of 1994). Medical Law Review 6, 265–296.
Fox, M. and McHale, J. (forthcoming 2000) Framing the Clinical Body: The Legal Regulation of Body Parts and Products. Oxford: Hart.
Francione, G. (1995) Animals, Property, and the Law. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Franklin, S. (1993) Making Representations: The Parliamentary Debate on the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act. In J. Edwards et al. (Eds), Technologies of Procreation: Kinship in the Age of Assisted Conception. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Fuss, D. (1996) Introduction. In Human, All Too Human. New York: Routledge, p. 1.
Hables Gray, C. (Ed.) (1995) The Cyborg Handbook. New York: Routledge.
Harris, J. (1998) Clones, Genes and Immortality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Haraway, D. (1985) A Manifesto for Cyborgs: Science, Technology, and Socialist Feminism in the 1980s, Reprinted. In L.J. Nicolson (Ed.), Feminism/Postmodernism (pp. 190–233). New York: Routledge.
Haraway, D. (1997) Modest-Witness@Second_Millenium. FemaleMan_Meets_OncoMouse. New York: Routledge.
Hartouni, V. (1997) Cultural Conceptions: On Reproductive Technologies and the Remaking of Life. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, p. 59.
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority and Human Genetics Advisory Commission (1998) Cloning Issues in Reproduction, Science and Medicine. BMA Discussion Paper, October 1999.
Hyde A. (1997) Bodies of Law. Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press.
Kennedy, I. (1987) The Moral Status of the Embryo. In Treat Me Right. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Latham, M. (1998) Regulating the New Reproductive Technologies: A Cross-Channel Comparison. Medical Law International 3, 89–115.
Latham, M. (1998) The French Parliamentary Guidelines of May 1997: Clarification or Fudge? Medical Law International 3, 135–141.
Lee, S. (1986) Law and Morals. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lim, H. (1999) Caesareans and Cyborgs. Feminist Legal Studies, 233–249.
Litman, M.M. and Robertson, G.B. (1993) Reproductive Technology: Is a Property Law Regime Appropriate? In Research Volumes prepared for the Canadian Royal Commission on New Reproductive Technologies.
Mentor, S. (1998) Witches, Nurses, Midwives and Cyborgs. In R. Davis Floyd and J. Dumit (Eds), Cyborg Babies: From Techno-Sex to Techno-Tots (pp. 67–89). London: Routledge.
Mitchell, L. and Georges, E. (1998) Baby's First Picture: The Cyborg Fetus of Ultrasound Imaging. In Davis Floyd, R. and Dumit, J. (Eds), Cyborg Babies: From Techno-Sex to Techno-Tots. Routledge: New York.
Morgan D. and Lee, R. (1991) Blackstone's Guide to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act. London: Blackstone Press.
Mulkay, M. (1997) The Embryo Research Debate: Science and the Politics of Reproduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Murphy, T. (1997) Feminism on Flesh. Law and Critique 8, 37–59.
Nedelsky, J. (1993) Property in Potential Life: A Relational Approach to Choosing Legal Categories. Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence 6, 343–365.
Nixon, N. (1999) Cyberpunk: Preparing the Ground for Revolution or Keeping the Boys Satisifed? In J. Wolmark (Ed.), Cybersexualities: A Reader on Feminist Theory, Cyborgs and Cyberspace (pp. 191–207). Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Overall, C. (1995) Frozen Embryos and ‘Fathers’ Rights: Parenthood and Decision-Making in the Cryopreservation of Embryos. In J. Callaghan (Ed.), Reproduction, Ethics and the Law (pp. 178–198) Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Rapp, R. (1991) Real-Time Fetus: The Role of the Sonogram in the Age of Monitored Reproduction. In C. Penley and A. Ross (Eds), Technoculture. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Robertson, J. (1990) In the Beginning: The Legal Status of Early Embryos. Virginia Law Review 76 437–481.
Rothman, B.K. (1984) The Meanings of Choice in Reproductive Technology. In R. Arditti et al. (Eds), Test-Tube Women. London: Pandora.
Sheldon, S. (1993) Who is the Mother to Make the Judgment? The Constructions of Women in English Abortion Law. Feminist Legal Studies 1, 3.
Sheldon, S. (1997) Out of Control: Medical Power and Abortion Law. London: Pluto Press.
Singer, P. et al. (Eds) (1990) Embryo Experimentation: Ethcial, Legal and Social Issues. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Spallone, P. (1989) Beyond Conception: The New Politics of Reproduction. London: Routledge, pp. 36–40.
Stabile, C. (19994) Shooting the Mother: Fetal Photography and the Politics of Disappearance. In Feminism and the Technological Fix. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Steinberg, D.L. (1991) Adversarial Politics: The Legal Construction of Abortion. In S. Franklin et al. (Eds), Off Centre: Feminism and Cultural Studies (pp 175–189). London: Harper Collins.
Steinberg, D.L. (1997) Bodies in Glass: Genetics, Eugenics, Embryo Ethics. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Steinbock, B. (1987) Life Before Birth: The Moral and Legal Status of Embryos and Fetuses. New York: Oxford University Press.
Steinbock, B. (1998) Sperm as Property. In J. Harris and S. Holm (Eds), The Future of Human Reproduction. (pp. 150–161) Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Strathern, M. (1992) Reproducing the Future: Essays on anthropology, Kinship and the New Reproductive Technologies. Manchester: Manchester University Press, p. 4.
Stern, K. (1994) Strict Liability and the Supply of Donated Gametes. Medical Law Review 2, 261–277.
Taylor, J. (1992) The Public Fetus and the Family Car: From Abortion Politics to a Volvo Advertisement. Public Culture 4, 67–80.
Thomson, M. (1998) Reproducing Narrative. Aldershot: Ashgate.
Ward, K. (1990) An Irresolvable Dipsute? In A. Dyson and J. Harris (Eds), Experiments on Embryos (pp. 106–119). London: Routledge.
Warnock, M. (1984) Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Human Fertilisation and Embryology, Cmnd. 9314.
Watt, H. (1996) Potential and the Early Human. Journal of Medical Ethics 22, 222–226.
Weir, L. (1998) Pregnancy Ultrasound in Maternal Discourse. In M. Shildrick and J. Proce (Eds), Vital Signs: Feminist Reconfigurations of the Bio/logical Body (pp. 78–99) Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Wolmark, J. (1999) Introduction: Cybersubjects: Cyborgs and Cyberpunks. In Wolmark (Ed.), Cybersexualities: A Reader on Feminist Theory, Cyborgs and Cyberspace. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.