Abstract
The Value of Trees project, funded bythe International Development Research Council ofCanada (IDRC), supported the joint efforts of theUniversity of Alberta and the University of Zimbabweto investigate the economic costs and benefitsassociated with trees and forests in the small holderfarming sector in Zimbabwe. The Value of Trees project provided funding for graduate students andfaculty from the two participating universities tocarry out studies in the disciplines of forestry,agricultural economics, and sociology in order toprovide policy recommendations regarding the role ofwoodlands in sustainable small holder farming in acontext where agricultural production appears to putincreasing stress on woodlands. The numerous projectsincluded such topics as the following: the use offuelwood under conditions of scarcity, tree tenure andlocal institutions in woodland use and sustainability,gender and wealth as related to tree planting andconservation, time preferences in natural resourceconsumption, ownership and economic impact ofeucalyptus woodlots, cultural and economic valuesassociated with woodlands, and uses and conflictsrelating to woodlands across different land categoriessuch as resettlement land and state forests. Manyother studies were not funded by, but were associatedwith Value of Trees. The findings fall withintwo broad categories. The first set includes thosedirectly related to generating values for differentaspects of the woodlands, particularly from theperspectives of rural households. The main finding isthat despite being highly valued by local people forboth economic and social reasons, woodlands are rankedlower in importance by local farmers than agriculturalland. The second set of findings relates to thecomplexities of the social system of the woodlands.Local institutions, history, resource conflicts, andtenure issues emerge as key to understanding the waythat people interact with the woodlands. Finally,local people have valuable knowledge and strategies tooffer in the design of sustainable management. Thepolicy implications of these findings for Zimbabwe arethat economic incentives could be important in asustainable woodlands strategy, but that anysuccessful program must incorporate an understandingof the profoundly complex and at times contradictoryhuman dynamics of woodland use and values.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Adamowizc, W., M. Luckert, and M. Veeman (1997). “Issues in using valuation techniques cross-culturally: Three cases in Zimbabwe using contingent valuation, observed behaviour and derived demand techniques.” Commonwealth Forestry Review 76(3): 194–197.
Alexander, J. (1994). “State, peasantry and resettlement in Zimbabwe.” Review of African Political Economy 6: 325–345.
Bojo, J. (1993). “Economic valuation of indigenous woodlands,” in P. N. Bradley and K. McNamara (eds.), Living with Trees: Policies for Forestry Management in Zimbabwe. Washington, DC: World Bank Technical Paper 210.
Bradley, P. and P. Dewees (1993). “Indigenous woodlands, agricultural production and household economy in the communal areas,” in P. N. Bradley and K. McNamara (eds.), Living with Trees: Policies for Forestry Management in Zimbabwe. Washington, DC: World Bank Technical Paper 210.
Braedt, O. and Gunda, W. (in prep.). “Woodcraft industry in Zimbabwe: An overview.” Institute of Environmental Studies, University of Zimbabwe.
Brigham, T. E. (1994). Trees in the Rural Cash Economy: A Case Study from Zimbabwe's Communal Areas. MA Thesis. Department of Geography, Carleton University, Ottawa.
Brigham, T., A. Chihongo, and E. Chidumayo(1996). “Trade in woodland products from the miombo region,” in B.M. Campbell (ed.), The Miombo in Transition: Woodlands and Welfare in Africa (pp. 137–174). Bogor: Centre for International Research.
Campbell, B. M. and Bradley, P. N. 1994. “ Trees, wood and the small-scale farmer: Rethinking woodfuel development in Zimbabwe,” in J. Hesslberg (ed.), Environment and Development in a North/South Perspective: Environmental Issues. NADG Conference, University of Oslo, 1994.
Campbell, B. M., P. N. Bradley, and S. E. Carter (1997a). “Sustainability and peasant farming systems: Some observations from Zimbabwe.” Agriculture and Human Values 14(2): 159–168.
Campbell, B. M., M. Luckert, and I. Scoones (1997b). “Locallevel valuation of savanna: A case study from Zimbabwe.” Economic Botany 51(1): 59–77.
Campbell, B. M., B. B. Mukamuri, and G. S. Kowero (1998). “Exploring changing rural livelihoods, and woodland use and management.” IES Special Report 13. Institute of Environmental Studies, University of Zimbabwe.
Campbell, B. M. and C. Musvoto (1995). “Mango trees as components of agrogorestry systems in Mangwende, Zimbabwe.” Agroforestry Systems 32: 247–260.
Campbell, B. M. and R. F. du Toit (1994). “Vegetation patterns and the influence of small-scale farmers in a semi-arid savanna area in Zimbabwe.” Kirkia15: 10–32.
Campbell, B. M. and J. J. Mangono (1994). “Working towards a biomass energy strategy for Zimbabwe.” Harare: University of Zimbabwe.
Campbell, B. M., I. M. Grundy, and F. Matose (1993). “Trees and woodland resources the technical practices of small-scale farmers,” in P. N. Bradley and K. McNamara (eds.), Living with Trees: Policies for Forestry Management in Zimbabwe. Washington, DC: World Bank Technical Paper 210: 29–62.
Campbell, B. M., S. J. Vermeulen, and T. Lynam (1991). Value of Trees in the Small-Scale Farming Sector of Zimbabwe. IDRC-MR302e, Ottawa.
Cavendish, W. P. (1996). “Environmental resources and rural household welfare.”Mimeo, Centre for the Study of African Economies, University of Oxford.
Cheater, A. (1990). “The ideology of “communal” land tenure in Zimbabwe: Mythogenesis enacted?” Africa60(2): 188–206.
Clarke, J. M., W. Cavendish,and C. Coote (1996). “Rural household and miombo woodlands: Use, value and management,” in B. M. Campbell (ed.), The Miombo in Transition: Woodlands and Welfare in Africa (pp. 101–135). Bogor, Indonesia: Centre for International Research.
Frost, P. (1996). “The ecology of miombo woodlands,” in B. M. Campbell (ed.), The Miombo in Transition: Woodlands and Welfare in Africa (pp. 11–57). Bogor, Indonesia: Centre for International Forestry Research.
Funkhauser, S. L. (1995). “Masawu fruit from the mid-Zambezi Valley: From harvest to market. Summary of research for the non-wood forest products study.” Research project funded by IDRC Value of Trees Research Project.
Gambiza, J.,W. Bond, P. Frost, and S. Higgins (2000). “A simulation model of miombo woodland dynamic under different management regimes.” Ecological Economics (forthcoming).
Goebel, A. (1997). ‘No Spirits Control the Trees’: History, Culture and Gender in the Social Forest in a Zimbabwean Resettlement Area. Edmonton: Ph.D. Dissertation. Department of Sociology, University of Alberta.
Goebel, A. (1998). “Process, perception and power: Notes from ‘participatory’ research in a Zimbabwean resettlement area.” Development and Change 29(2): 277–305. An earlier version is published by the Centre for Applied Social Science (CASS), University of Zimbabwe, and the Department of Rural Economy, University of Alberta Working Paper Series (1996).
Goebel, A. (1999). “ ‘Then it's clear who owns the trees’: Common property and private control in the social forest in a Zimbabwean resettlement area.” Rural Sociology 64(4): 625–641. Also published as a Rural Economy Staff Paper Series, University of Alberta.
Graham, L.,W. Phillips, and K.Muir-Leresche (1997). “Empirical approaches to the valuation of small wildlife resources in communal areas in Zimbabwe.” Rural Economy Staff Paper 97–04, University of Alberta Value of Trees Working Paper #5, University of Alberta.
Grundy, I. (1995). Regeneration and Management of Brachystegia Spiciformis Benth. and Julbernardia Globiflora Benth. Troupin in Miombo Woodland, Zimbabwe. Ph.D. Thesis. Oxford University.
Grundy, I., J. Turpie, P. Jagger, E. Witkowski, I. Guambe, D. Semwayo, and A. Solomon (2000). “Implications of co-management for benefits from natural resources for rural households in north-western Zimbabwe.” Ecological Economics (forthcoming).
Grundy, I. M., B. M. Campbell, S. Balebereho, R. Cunliffe, C. Tafangenyasha, R. Fergusson, and D. Parry (1993). “Availability and use of trees in Mutanda resettlement area, Zimbabwe.” Forest Ecology and Management 56: 243–266.
GwaaiWorking Group (1997). “Local-level valuation of village 396 ALLISON GOEBEL ET AL. woodlands and state forests: Cases from Matebeleland South in Zimbabwe.” Institute of Environmental Studies Working Paper No 7, University of Zimbabwe.
Hatton-MacDonald, D., W. L. Adamowic, and M. Luckert (1998). “Valuing fuelwood resources using a site choice model of fuelwood collection.” Rural Economy Staff Paper 98–1, University of Alberta Value of TreesWorking Paper #8, University of Alberta.
Hot Springs Working Group (1995). “Local-Level Economic Valuation of Savanna Woodland Resources: Village Cases from Zimbabwe. Hidden Harvest Project Research Series 3” (86 pp.). London: International Institute for Environment and Development.
Kundhlande, G. K., W. L. Adamowicz, and I. Mapaure (2000). “Valuing ecological services in a savanna ecosystem: A case from Zimbabwe.” Ecological Economics (forthcoming).
Kwaramba, P. K. (1995). “Potential commercialisation of common property resource: The case of baobab (Adansonia digitata) bark around the Hot Springs area.” Institute of Environmental Studies Working Paper. University of Zimbabwe.
Lynam, T., B.M. Campbell, and S. Vermeulen (1994). “Contingent valuation of multipurpose trees resources in the smallholder farming sector, Zimbabwe.” Working paper Series 1994: 8, Department of Economics, Gothenburg University.
Mandondo, A. (in prep.). Local Practices and Ecology of Indigenous Wooodlands. PhD Dissertation. Institute of Environmental Studies, University of Zimbabwe.
Mandondo, A. (1997). “Trees and spaces as emotion and norm laden components of local ecosystems in Nyamaropa Communal lands, Zimbabwe.” Agriculture and Human Values 14(4): 353ff.
Mandondo, A. (1995). “Ownership and management of Eucalyptus camaldulensis in North-eastern Zimbabwe.” South African Forest Journal 174: 9–16.
Mandondo, A. and J. Jackson (1996). “Management and performance of Eucalyptus camaldulensis in Murewa and Mutoko Districts of Zimbabwe.” Institute of Environmental Studies Working Paper No 4. University of Zimbabwe.
Matose, F. (1994). Local People's Uses and Perceptions of Tree Resources: An Analysis of a State Property Regime in Zimbabwe. MSc. Thesis, Department of Rural Sociology, University of Alberta.
Matose, F., M. Mudhara, and P. Mushove (1997). “Woodcraft production along the Bulawayo-Victoria Falls Road.” Institute of Environmental Studies Working Paper 2. Harare: University of Zimbabwe.
Moyo, S., P. Robinson, Y. Katerere, S. Stevenson, and D. Gumbo (1991). Zimbabwe's Environmental Dilemma: Balancing Resource Inequities. Harare: ZERO.
Mukamuri, B. (1996a). “Marketing and use of medicinal plant and animal species in Zimbabwe's urban and rural areas.” Paper prepared for TRAFFIC (Eastern Africa).
Mukamuri, B. (1996b). “Values, uses and management of indigenous trees in Northeastern Zimbabwe: The case of Mutoko District-Charehwa Ward.” Presented at the International Conference on Sustainable Management of Indigenous Forests in the Dry Tropics. Kadoma, Zimbabwe. May 28-June 1 1996.
Mukamuri, B. (1995). “Local environmental conservation strategies: Kuranga religion, politics and environmental control.” Environment and History 1: 63–71.
Mukamuri, B. Campbell, B. M. and G. Kowero (in prep.). “Local institutions and forest management in Zimbabwe.” Institute of Environmental Studies, University of Zimbabwe.
Mukamuri, B. and B. Sithole (in prep.). “Dzimbahwe: The dynamics of a political and ecological cult in rural Zimbabwe.” Institute of Environmental Studies, University of Zimbabwe.
Parton, W. J., R. I. Sanford, P. A. Sanchez, and J. Stewart (1989). “Modeling soil OM dynamics in tropical soils,” in D. C. Coleman, J. M. Oades, and G. Uehara (eds.), Dynamics of Soil OM in Tropical Ecosystems (pp. 153–171). Paia, Hawaii: NifTAL Project.
Price, L. (1994). The Effect of Socio-Economic Factors on Household Tree Holding and Seedling Procurement Practices in Samatanda and Chigaba Village. Mutoko. Zimbabwe. MSc Thesis, University of Zimbabwe.
Rukuni, M. (1994). Report of the Commission of Inquiry into Appropriate Agricultural Land Tenure Systems. Volumes 1 and 2. Harare: Government Printers.
Scoones, I. (1990). Livestock Populations and the Household Economy: A Case Study from Southern Zimbabwe. PhD Dissertation. University of London.
Scoones, I. and F. Matose (1993). “Local woodland management: Constraints and opportunities for sustainable resource use,” in P. N. Bradley and K. McNamara (eds.), Living with Trees: Policies for Forestry Management in Zimbabwe. Washington, DC: World Bank Technical Paper 210.
Sithole, B. (1997). “The institutional framework for the management and use of natural resources in communal areas of Zimbabwe. Village cases of access to and use of dambos from Mutoko and Chiduku.” Monograph. Centre for Applied Social Sciences (CASS), University of Zimbabwe.
Vermeulen, S. (1996). “Cutting of trees by local residents in a communal area and an adjacent State Forest in Zimbabwe.” Forest Ecology and Management 81: 101–111.
Vermeulen, S. (1993). “Use of wood by rural households along the boundary of Mafungabusi State Forest.” MSc Thesis, University of Zimbabwe.
Vermeulen, S., B. M. Campbell, and G. Matzke (1996). “Consumption of wood by rural households in Gokwe communal area.” Human Ecology 24: 476–491.
Vermeulen, S., P. Woomer, B. M. Campbell, W. Kamukondiwa et al. (1993). “Use of the SCUAF model to simulate natural miombo woodland and maize monoculture systems in Zimbabwe.” Agroforestry Systems 22: 259–271.
Watson, L. (1994). Gender and Perceived Value of Trees on Homesites in Zimbabwe. MSc Thesis, Department of Rural Economy, University of Alberta.
Watson, L., E. C. Murray, and L. Just (1996). “Gender and the value of trees in Mutoko communal area, Zimbabwe.” Rural Economy Staff Paper 96–20, University of Alberta.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Goebel, A., Campbell, B., Mukamuri, B. et al. People, values, and woodlands: A field report ofemergent themes in interdisciplinary research in Zimbabwe. Agriculture and Human Values 17, 385–396 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026523629029
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026523629029