Abstract
Images of Native Americans and of aspects of Native American culture are common in advertisements in the United States. Three such images can be distinguished — the Noble Savage, the Civilizable Savage and the Bloodthirsty Savage images. The aim of this paper is to argue that the use of such images is not morally acceptable because these images depend upon an underlying conception of Native Americans that denies that they are human beings. By so doing, it also denies to them any moral standing and thus any claim to moral consideration and treatment. I begin by arguing that the traits which are distinctively human are fostered only within a cultural framework consisting of the accumulated knowledge and activities of a group of human beings. I then argue that savages are conceptualized as natural and cultureless beings. Furthermore, within the traditional Western conceptualization of the world mere natural objects have no moral standing. Thus, it follows that Native Americans insofar as they are also merely natural objects would have no standing or status as moral beings. The conception of Native Americans as savages undercuts the very conditions for the possibility of moral respect. I then turn to an application of these principles to some current commercial uses of images of Native Americans and other indigenous peoples.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Aeschylus: 1965,Prometheus Unbound, translated by R. W. Corrigan (Dell Publishing Co., Inc., New York).
Axtell, J.: 1981,The European and the Indian Essays in the Ethnohistory of Colonial North America (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
Bataille, G. M. and C. L. P. Silet: 1980,The Pretend Indians Images of Native Americans in the Movies (The Iowa State University Press, Ames).
Benedict, R.: 1959,Patterns of Culture (Houghton Mifflin, Cambridge, Massachusetts).
Childe, V. G.: 1965, ‘Early Forms of Society’, in C. Singer, E. J. Holmyard, and A. R. Hall (eds.),A History of Technology (Clarendon Press, Oxford), Vol, I, pp. 38–58.
Churchill, W.: 1988, ‘Sam Gill'sMother Earth: Colonialism, Genocide and the Expropriation of Indigenous Spiritual Tradition in Contemporary Academia’,American Indian Culture and Research Journal 12(3), pp. 48–67.
Cooper, J. F.: 1963,The Deerslayer (New American Library, Inc., New York).
Dickason, O. P.: 1984,The Myth of the Savage and the Beginnings of French Colonialism in the Americas (The University of Alberta Press, Edmonton, Alberta).
Feest, C. F.: 1990 (May/June), ‘Europe's Indians’,Society, pp. 46–51.
Friar, R. E. and N. A. Friar: 1972,The Only Good Indian ... The Hollywood Gospel (Drama Book Specialists, New York).
Giago, T.: 1992 (January), ‘I Hope the Redskins Lose’,Newsweek 27, p. 8.
Hall, D. L. and R. T. Ames: 1987,Thinking Through Confucius (State University of New York Press, Albany).
Hanson, J. R. and L. P. Rouse: 1987, ‘Dimensions of Native American Stereotyping’,American Indian Culture and Research Journal 11(4), pp. 33–58.
Hetgel, G. W. F.: 1977,Phenomenology of Spirit, translated by A. V. Miller (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
Indian Historian, The: 1972, ‘Stanford Removes Indian Symbol’,5(1), pp. 21–22.
Jenning, F.: 1976,The Invasion of America Indians, Colonialism, and the Cant of Conquest (The University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hill).
Joseph, C.: 1972, ‘An Indian's View of Indian Affairs’, in W. C. Vanderwerth (ed.),Indian Oratory Famous Speeches by Noted Indian Chieftains (University of Oklahoma Press, Norman).
Keiser, A.: 1970,The Indian in American Literature (Octagon Books, New York).
Lane, H. L.: 1976,The Wild Boy of Aveyron (Harvard University Press, Cambridge).
Langer, S. K.: 1951,Philosophy in a New Key (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts).
Levi-Strauss, C.: 1969,The Raw and the Cooked, translated by John and D. Weightman (Harper & Row, Publishers, New York).
Lurie, Y.: 1991, ‘Wittgenstein on Culture and Civilization’,Inquiry 32, pp. 375–397.
Matijasic, T. D.: 1987, ‘Reflected Values: Sixteenth-Century Europeans View the Indians of North America’,American Indian Culture and Research Journal 11(2), pp. 31–50.
Mead, G. H.: 1934,Mind, Self and Society, Charles Morris (ed.) (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).
Monaghan, P.: 1992 (Jan. 8), ‘New Debates Rage over Symbols that Offend Many American Indians’,The Chronicle of Higher Education, pp. 39–40.
Mutiso, G. C. M.: 1976, ‘African Perceptions of the Ideas of Freedom and Revolution’,Thought and Practice V, pp. 163–173.
New York Times, The: 1992 (Monday, Jan. 27), ‘2,000 at Metrodome For Mascot Protest’, C4.
O'Neill, G. P.: 1987 (May), ‘The North American Indian in Contemporary History and Social Studies Textbooks’,Journal of American Indian Education, pp. 22–28.
Pearce, R. H.: 1965,The Savages of America: A Study in the Indian and the Idea of Civilization (John Hopkins Press, Baltimore).
Shakespeare, W.,The Tempest.
Shutte, A.: 1990 (Fall), ‘Nmuntu Ngumuntu Ngabantu: An African Conception of Humanity’,Philosophy & Theology 5(1), pp. 39–54.
Singh, the Reverend J. A. L. and R. M. Zingg: 1966,Wolf-Children and Feral Man (Harpers & Row, Inc., New York).
Smith, J. R.: 1981, ‘Native American Images and the Broadcast Media’,American Indian Culture and Research Journal 5(1), pp. 81–92.
Smits, D. D.: 1987, ‘We Are Not to Grow Wild: Seventeenth-Century New England's Repudiation of Anglo-Indian Intermarriage’,American Indian Culture and Research Journal 11(4), pp. 1–32.
Thorne, A. G. and M. H. Wolpoff: 1992 (April), ‘The Multiregional Evolution of Humans’,Scientific American 266(4), pp. 76–83.
Tsosie, R.: 1988, ‘Changing Women: The Cross-Currents of American Indian Feminine Identity’,American Indian Culture and Research Journal 12(1), pp. 1–37.
van Eercke, W.: 1975, ‘The Look, the Body and the Other’, in D. Inde (ed.),Dialogues in Phenomenology (Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague), pp. 224–246.
Wilson, A. C. and R. L. Cann: 1992 (April), ‘The Recent African Genesis of Humans’,Scientific American 266(4), pp. 68–73.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Dr. Michael K. Green, Ph.D. in Philosophy, has published inPolitical Theory, The New Scholasticism, The Journal of Business Ethics, andSocial Theory and Practice, as well as various other journals. He was president of MKG Enterprises, Inc., for six years and is a fellow at the Hartwick Humanities in Management Leadership Institute.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Green, M.K. Images of Native Americans in advertising: Some moral issues. J Bus Ethics 12, 323–330 (1993). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01666536
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01666536