Abstract
The healing and preventive powers of people's health resources and self-assessed knowledge have so far been grossly underestimated in medicine. In this article, we call attention to ethical and epistemological dilemmas related to knowledge, values, communication, and autonomy embedded in the prevailing risk-oriented epidemiology, and suggest a patient-centred salutogenetic approach to promote a better balance between resources and risks in medicine. Identification and intervention upon risk factors can provide hypotheses about origins of disease and predict and sometimes prevent disease at a group level. However, there are several pitfalls related to this perspective concerning causal factors, group level based possibilities, adequate end points for intervention, informed consent, and medicalization, especially in the individualized context of the clinical encounter. By introducing a salutogenic perspective, we urge to shift the attention toward resources, agency and strength, which may counteract risk of disease and empower the patient. Talk can mediate oppression as well as empowerment. A communicative key question approach, and self-assessed health resources identified through this strategy, are briefly presented as examples of empowerment through dialogue.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Antonovsky, A.: 1979, Health, Stress, and Coping. New Perspective on Mental and Physical Well-Being. Washington: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
Backer, P., P.L. Kragh, C.E. Mabeck, K.B. Rasmussen and J. Gaugin (eds.): 1977, Lærebog i almen medicin 2, basisbog 1. København: FADLs Forlag.
Giere, R.N.: 1991, Understanding Scientific Reasoning. Fort Worth: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc.
Hetlevik, I. and J. Holmen: 1994, ‘Hvilket forhold har leger til risiko? (How Do GP's Relate to Risk?)’, Tidsskrift for Den norske lægeforening 114, 1709–1710.
Hollnagel, H.: 1985, 40-åriges helbred (The Health of the 40-Year Old) (dissertation). København: Københavns Universitet.
Hollnagel, H.: 1999, ‘Explaining Risk Factors to Patients During a General Practice Consultation. Conveying Group-Based Epidemiological Knowledge to Individual Patients’, Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care 17(1), 3–5.
Hollnagel, H. and K. Malterud: 1995, ‘Shifting Attention From Objective Risk Factors to Patients' Self-Assessed Health Resources. A Clinical Model for General Practice’, Practicus 12, 423–429.
Idler, E.L.: 1992, ‘Self-Assessed Health and Mortality: A Review of Studies’, Int Rev Health Psychol 1, 33–54.
Idler, E.L.: 1999, ‘Self-Assessments of Health: The Next Stage of Studies’, Research on Aging 21, 287–392.
Idler, E.L. and V.K. Stanislav: 1995, ‘Self-Ratings of Health: Do They Also Predict Change in Functional Ability?’, J Gerontology Soc Sciences 6, 344–353.
Kvale, S.: 1996, InterViews. An Introduction to Qualitative Research Interviewing. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications.
Malterud, K.: 1994, ‘Key Questions-a Strategy for Modifying Clinical Communication. Transforming Tacit Skills into a Clinical Method’, Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care 12, 121–125.
Malterud, K. and H. Hollnagel: 1997, ‘Women's Self-Assessed Personal Health Resources’, Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care 15, 163–168.
Malterud, K. and H. Hollnagel: 1998, ‘Talking with Women About Personal Health Resources in General Practice. Key Questions About Salutogenesis’, Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care 16, 66–71.
Malterud, K. and H. Hollnagel: 1999, ‘Encouraging the Strengths of Women Patients. A Case Study from General Practice on Empowering Dialogues’, Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care 17, 254–259.
Marta, J.: 1996, ‘A Linguistic Model of Informed Consent’, J Med Philos 21, 41–60.
McCormick, J.: 1994, ‘Health Promotion: The Ethical Dimension’, Lancet 344, 390–391.
Møller, L., T.S. Kristensen and H. Hollnagel: 1996, ‘Self Rated Health as a Predictor of Coronary Heart Disease in Copenhagen, Denmark’, J Epidemiol Community Health 50, 423–428.
Nessa, J. and K. Malterud: 1998, ‘Tell Me What's Wrong with Me: A Discourse Analysis Approach to the Concept of Patient Autonomy’, Journal of Medical Ethics 24, 394–400.
O'Neill, O.: 1984, ‘Paternalism and Partial Autonomy’, Journal of Medical Ethics 10, 172–178.
Skolbekken, J.A.: 1995, ‘The Risk Epidemic in Medical Journals’, Social Science and Medicine 40, 291–305.
Skolbekken, J. A.: 1998, ‘Communicating the Risk Reduction Achieved by Cholesterol Reducing Drugs’, British Medical Journal 316, 1956–1958.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hollnagel, H., Malterud, K. From risk factors to health resources in medical practice. Med Health Care Philos 3, 255–262 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026597306628
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1026597306628