Abstract
Considerable controversy has surrounded the use of computerized performance monitoring (CPM) by employers. Critics of this technology contend that CPM usage raises serious ethical concerns. Beliefs that the use of computerized performance monitors results in unfair performance evaluation, stress and health problems underlie much of the current concern over this technology. A field study was undertaken to provide empirical evidence that could be used to guide the design and use of computerized performance monitors to minimize these problems. One hundred forty three members of the Communication Workers of America participated in a cross sectional field study. The study examined the relationship between various monitoring system characteristics and employees' health problems, stress and satisfaction with the performance evaluation process. The ethical implications of the results are discussed.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson, R. E., D. G. Johnson, D. Gotterbar, and J. Perrolle: 1993, ‘Using the New ACM Code of Ethics in Decision Making’,Communications of the ACM 36, 98–107.
Beauchamp, T. L. and N. E. Bowie: 1993,Ethical Theory and Business — Fourth Edition (Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, NJ).
Chalykoff, J. and T. A. Kochan: 1989, ‘Computer-Aided Monitoring: Its Influence on Employee Job Satisfaction and Turnover’,Personnel Psychology 42, 808–834.
Cohen, J. and P. Cohen: 1975,Applied Multiple Regression/Correlational Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ).
Cook, M. F.: 1988, ‘What's Ahead in Human Resources?’,Management Review 77, 41–44.
Cooper, C. L. and J. Marshall: 1976, ‘Occupational Sources of Stress: A Review of the Literature Relating to Coronary Heart Disease and Mental Ill Health’,Journal of Occupational Psychology 49, 11–28.
Dipboye, R. L and R. Pontbriand: 1981, ‘Correlates of Employee Reactions to Performance Appraisals and Appraisal Systems’,Journal of Applied Psychology 66, 248–251.
Earley, P. C.: 1988, ‘Computer-Generated Performance Feedback in the Magazine-Subscription Industry’,Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 41, 50–64.
Folger, R. and M. A. Konovsky: 1989, ‘Effects of Procedural and Distributive Justice on Reactions to Pay Raise Decisions’,Academy of Management Journal 32, 115–130.
Fritz, N.: 1988, ‘Big Electronic Brother Is Watching’,Personnel 65, 4.
Gardner, E. P., S. R. Ruth, and B. Render: 1988, ‘Job Stress and the VDT Clerical Worker’,Human Systems Management 7, 359–365.
Grant, R., C. A. Higgins, and R. H. Irving: 1988, ‘Computerized Performance Monitors, Are They Costing You Customers?’,Sloan Management Review, 39–45.
Grant, R. and C. A. Higgins: 1991, ‘The Impact of Computerized Performance Monitoring on Service Work: Testing a Causal Model’,Information Systems Research 2, 116–142.
Greenberg, J.: 1986, ‘Determinants of Perceived Fairness of Performance Evaluations’,Journal of Applied Psychology 71, 340–342.
Henriques, V. E.: 1987, ‘Positive Monitoring: How Employees Benefit from Computer Measurement’,Management World 16, 40.
Hershman, B., M. Rozen: 1984, ‘Corporate Big Brother Is Watching You’,Dun's Business Month 6, 36–39.
Hoerr, J., Hafner, G. DeGeorge, A. R. Field, and L. Zinn: 1988, ‘Privacy’,Business Week (March 28), 61–68.
Hoffman, P. J.: 1960, ‘The Paramorphic Representation of Clinical Judgement’,Psychological Bulletin 57, 116–131.
Howard, R.: 1985,Brave New Work-Place (Viking-Penguin Inc., New York).
Irving, R. H., C. A. Higgins, and F. R. Safayeri: 1986, ‘Computerized Performance Monitoring Systems: Use and Abuse’,Communications of the ACM 29, 794–801.
Landy, F. J., J. L. Barnes, and K. R. Murphy: 1978, ‘Correlates of Perceived Fairness and Accuracy of Performance Evaluation’,Journal of Applied Psychology 63, 751–754.
Lawler, E. E.: 1976, ‘Control systems in Organizations’, in M. D. Dunnette (ed.),Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology (Rand McNally College Publishing Co., New York), pp. 1247–1291.
Marx, G. T. and S. Sherizen: 1986, ‘Monitoring on the Job: How to Protect Privacy as Well as Property’,Technology Review 89, 62–72.
Nussbaum, K. and V. duRivage: 1986, ‘Computer Monitoring: Mismanagement by Remote Control’,Business and Society Review 56, 16–20.
Office of Technology Assessment (OTA): 1987,The Electronic Supervisor: New Technology, New Tensions (U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC).
Ottensmeyer, E. J. and M. A. Heroux: 1991, ‘Ethics, Public Policy, and Managing Advanced Technologies: The Case of Electronic Surveillance’,Journal of Business Ethics 10, 519–526.
Rule J. and P. Brantley: 1992, ‘Computerized Surveillance in the Workplace: Forms and Distributions’,Sociological Forum 7, 405–423.
Smith, M. J., B. G. Cohen, and L. W. Stammerjohn: 1981, ‘An Investigation of Health Complaints and Job Stress in Video Display Operations’,Human Factors 23, 387–400.
Stead, W. E.: 1990, ‘An Integrative Model for Understanding and Managing Ethical Behavior in Business Organizations’,Journal of Business Ethics 9, 233–242.
Susser, P. A.: 1988, ‘Electronic Monitoring in the Private Sector: How Closely Should Employers Supervise Their Workers?’,Employee Relations Law Journal 13, 575–598.
Westin, A. F.: 1986,Privacy and Quality of Worklife Issues in Employee Monitoring (Contractor Report for Office Technology Assessment).
Whithey, M., R. Draft, and W. Cooper: 1983, ‘Measures of Perrow's Work Unit Technology: An Empirical Assessment and a New Scale’,Academy of Management Journal 26, 45–63.
Zuboff, S.: 1982, ‘New Worlds of Computer-Mediated Work’,Harvard Business Review 60 (Sept.–Oct.), 142–152.
Zuboff, S.: 1988,In the Age of the Smart Machine: The Future of Work and Power (Basic Books, New York).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
Stephen R. Hawk is Associate Professor of Information Systems at the University of Wisconsin-Parkside's School of Business. His research interests include decision support systems, computerized performance monitoring and information system implementation. His articles have appeared inDecision Sciences, IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management, andInternational Journal of Man-Machine Studies.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hawk, S.R. The effects of computerized performance monitoring: An ethical perspective. J Bus Ethics 13, 949–957 (1994). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00881664
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00881664