Abstract
Evans developed a classical unified field theory of gravitation and electromagnetism on the background of a spacetime obeying a Riemann-Cartan geometry. This geometry can be characterized by an orthonormal coframe ϑ α and a (metric compatible) Lorentz connection Γ αβ. These two potentials yield the field strengths torsion T α and curvature R αβ. Evans tried to infuse electromagnetic properties into this geometrical framework by putting the coframe ϑ α to be proportional to four extended electromagnetic potentials \(\mathcal{A}^{\alpha }\) ; these are assumed to encompass the conventional Maxwellian potential A in a suitable limit. The viable Einstein-Cartan (-Sciama-Kibble) theory of gravity was adopted by Evans to describe the gravitational sector of his theory. Including also the results of an accompanying paper by Obukhov and the author, we show that Evans’ ansatz for electromagnetism is untenable beyond repair both from a geometrical as well as from a physical point of view. As a consequence, his unified theory is obsolete.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bishop, R.L., Crittenden, R.J.: Geometry of Manifolds. Academic Press, New York (1964)
Blagojević, M.: Gravitation and Gauge Symmetries. Institute of Physics, Bristol (2002)
Bruhn, G.W.: No energy to be extracted from the vacuum. Phys. Scr. 74, 535–536 (2006)
Bruhn, G.W.: No Lorentz property of M.W. Evans’ O(3)-symmetry law. Phys. Scr. 74, 537–538 (2006)
Bruhn, G.W.: On the non-Lorentz invariance of M.W. Evans’ O(3)-symmetry law. arXiv.org/ physics/0607186
Bruhn, G.W.: The central error of M.W. Evans’ ECE theory—a type mismatch. arXiv.org/ physics/0607190
Bruhn, G.W.: Refutation of Myron W. Evans B (3) field hypothesis. http://www.mathematik.tu-darmstadt.de/~bruhn/B3-refutation.htm
Bruhn, G.W.: Comments on M.W. Evans’ preprint chapter 2: duality and the antisymmetric metric, pp. 21–30. http://www.mathematik.tu-darmstadt.de/~bruhn/Comment-Chap2.htm
Bruhn, G.W.: Remarks on Evans’ 2nd Bianchi identity. http://www.mathematik.tu-darmstadt.de/~bruhn/EvansBianchi.html
Bruhn, G.W.: Comments on Evans’ duality. http://www.mathematik.tu-darmstadt.de/~bruhn/EvansDuality.html
Bruhn, G.W.: ECE Theory and Cartan geometry. http://www.mathematik.tu-darmstadt.de/~bruhn/ECE-CartanGeometry.html
Bruhn, G.W., Lakhtakia, A.: Commentary on Myron W. Evans’ paper “The electromagnetic sector ...”. http://www.mathematik.tu-darmstadt.de/~bruhn/EvansChap13.html
Cartan, É.: Sur une généralisation de la notion de corbure de Riemann et les espaces à torsion. C. R. Acad. Sci. (Paris) 174, 593–595 (1922)
Cartan, É.: On a generalization of the notion of Riemann curvature and spaces with torsion. In: Bergmann, P.G., De Sabbata, V. (eds.), Cosmology and Gravitation, pp. 489–491. Plenum, New York (1980) (Translation of [13] from the French by G.D. Kerlick). See also the remarks of A. Trautman, ibid. pp. 493–496
Cartan, É.: On Manifolds with an Affine Connection and the Theory of General Relativity. Bibliopolis, Napoli (1986) (English translation of the French original)
Cartan, E.: Riemannian Geometry in an Orthogonal Frame. World Scientific, Hackensack (2001), Sect. 87 (Translation from Russian by V.V. Goldberg)
Corson, E.M.: Introduction to Tensors, Spinors, and Relativistic Wave-Equations. Blackie, London (1953)
Debever, R. (ed.): Elie Cartan—Albert Einstein, Lettres sur le Parallélisme Absolu 1929–1932, original letters with translations in English. Palais des Académies/Princeton University Press, Bruxelles/Princeton (1979)
de Carvalho, A.L.T., Rodrigues, W.A. Jr.: The non sequitur mathematics and physics of the ‘new electrodynamics’ of the AIAS group. Random Oper. Stoch. Equ. 9, 161–206 (2001). arXiv.org/physics/0302016
Eckardt, H.: Slides from the first workshop on ECE theory. http://aias.us → publications → Results of first workshop
Evans, M.W.: Solutions of the ECE field equations, paper 50 of Evans’ theory. http://www.aias.us/documents/uft/a50thpaper.pdf
Evans, M.W.: Wave mechanics and ECE theory, paper 54 of Evans’ theory. http://www.aias.us/documents/uft/a54thpaper.pdf
Evans, M.W.: Generally covariant dynamics, paper 55 of Evans’ theory. http://www.aias.us/documents/uft/a55thpaper.pdf
Evans, M.W.: A generally covariant field equation for gravitation and electromagnetism. Found. Phys. Lett. 16, 369–377 (2003)
Evans, M.W.: The spinning and curving of spacetime: the electromagnetic and gravitational fields in the Evans field theory. Found. Phys. Lett. 18, 431–454 (2005)
Evans, M.W.: Generally Covariant Unified Field Theory, the Geometrization of Physics, vol. I. Arima, Suffolk (2005)
Evans, M.W.: Generally Covariant Unified Field Theory, the Geometrization of Physics, vol. II. Abramis Academic, publisher@abramin.co.uk (2006)
Evans, M.W.: Generally Covariant Unified Field Theory, the Geometrization of Physics, vol. III. Amazon.com (2006)
Evans, M.W., Eckardt, H.: The resonant Coulomb law of Einstein Cartan Evans theory, paper 63 of Evans’ theory. http://aias.us/documents/uft/a63rdpaper.pdf
Eyraud, H.: La théorie affine asymétrique du champs électromagnétique et gravifique et le rayonnement atomique. C. R. Acad. Sci. (Paris) 180, 1245–1248 (1925)
Garcia, A.A., Hehl, F.W., Heinicke, C., Macias, A.: Exact vacuum solution of a (1+2)-dimensional Poincaré gauge theory: BTZ solution with torsion. Phys. Rev. D 67, 124016 (2003). arXiv:gr-qc/0302097
Goenner, H.F.M.: On the history of unified field theories. Living Rev. Relat. 7 (2004). http://www.livingreviews.org/lrr-2004-2H.Goenner (cited on 01 Dec 2006)
Gronwald, F.: Metric-affine gauge theory of gravity, I: fundamental structure and field equations. Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 6, 263–304 (1997). arXiv.org/gr-qc/9702034
Gronwald, F., Hehl, F.W.: On the gauge aspects of gravity. In: Bergmann, P.G. et al. (eds.) Proceeding of the International School of Cosmology and Gravitation. 14th Course: Quantum Gravity, Erice, Italy, pp. 148–198. World Scientific, Singapore (1996). arXiv.org/gr-qc/9602013
Hehl, F.W.: On the kinematics of the torsion of space–time. Found. Phys. 15, 451–471 (1985)
Hehl, F.W., von der Heyde, P., Kerlick, G.D., Nester, J.M.: General relativity with spin and torsion: foundations and prospects. Rev. Mod. Phys. 48, 393–416 (1976)
Hehl, F.W., McCrea, J.D.: Bianchi identities and the automatic conservation of energy–momentum and angular momentum in general-relativistic field theories. Found. Phys. 16, 267–293 (1986)
Hehl, F.W., McCrea, J.D., Mielke, E.W., Ne’eman, Y.: Metric-affine gauge theory of gravity: field equations, Noether identities, world spinors, and breaking of dilation invariance. Phys. Rep. 258, 1–171 (1995)
Hehl, F.W., Obukhov, Yu.N.: Foundations of Classical Electrodynamics: Charge, Flux, and Metric. Birkhäuser, Boston (2003)
Hehl, F.W., Obukhov, Y.N.: Electric/magnetic reciprocity in premetric electrodynamics with and without magnetic charge, and the complex electromagnetic field. Phys. Lett. A 323, 169–175 (2004). arXiv.org/physics/0401083
Hehl, F.W., Obukhov, Yu.N.: Dimensions and units in electrodynamics. Gen. Relativ. Gravit. 37, 733–749 (2005). arXiv.org/physics/0407022
Hehl, F.W., Obukhov, Yu.N.: An assessment of Evans’ unified field theory II. Found. Phys. (2007). doi:10.1007/s10701-007-0188-70. arXiv.org/physics/0703117
Heinicke, C.: Exact solutions in Einstein’s theory and beyond. PhD thesis, University of Cologne (2005)
Heinicke, C., Baekler, P., Hehl, F.W.: Einstein-aether theory, violation of Lorentz invariance, and metric-affine gravity. Phys. Rev. D 72, 025012 (2005). arXiv.org/gr-qc/0504005
Horie, K.: Geometric interpretation of electromagnetism in a gravitational theory with torsion and spinorial matter, PhD thesis, University of Mainz (1995). arXiv.org/hep-th/9601066
Infeld, L.: Zur Feldtheorie von Elektrizität und Gravitation. Phys. Z. 29, 145–147 (1928)
Itin, Y., Kaniel, S.: On a class of invariant coframe operators with application to gravity. J. Math. Phys. 41, 6318–6340 (2000). arXiv.org/gr-qc/9907023
Itin, Y.: Energy-momentum current for coframe gravity. Class. Quantum Gravity 19, 173–189 (2002). arXiv.org/gr-qc/0111036
Jadczyk, A.: Vanishing vierbein in gauge theories of gravitation. arXiv.org/gr-qc/9909060
Kaiser, G.: Energy-momentum conservation in pre-metric electrodynamics with magnetic charges. J. Phys. A 37, 7163–7168 (2004). arXiv.org/math-ph/0401028
Kibble, T.W.B.: Lorentz invariance and the gravitational field. J. Math. Phys. 2, 212–221 (1961)
Kuhfuss, R., Nitsch, J.: Propagating modes in gauge field theories of gravity. Gen. Relativ. Gravit. 18, 1207–1227 (1986)
Lakhtakia, A.: Is Evans’ longitudinal ghost field B (3) unknowable? Found. Phys. Lett. 8, 183–186 (1995)
Lämmerzahl, C., Macias, A., Mueller, H.: Lorentz invariance violation and charge (non-)conservation: a general theoretical frame for extensions of the Maxwell equations. Phys. Rev. D 71, 025007 (2005). arXiv.org/gr-qc/0501048
McCrea, J.D., Hehl, F.W., Mielke, E.W.: Mapping Noether identities into Bianchi identities in general relativistic field theories of gravity and in the field theory of static lattice defects. Int. J. Theor. Phys. 29, 1185–1206 (1990)
Obukhov, Y.N.: Poincaré gauge gravity: selected topics. Int. J. Geom. Methods Mod. Phys. 3, 95–138 (2006). arXiv.org/gr-qc/0601090
Obukhov, Y.N., Rubilar, G.F.: Invariant conserved currents in gravity theories with local Lorentz and diffeomorphism symmetry. Phys. Rev. D 74, 064002 (2006). arXiv.org/gr-qc/0608064
Particle Data Group: Review of particle physics. J. Phys. G 33, 1–1231 (2006)
Pilch, K.: Geometrical meaning of the Poincaré group gauge theory. Lett. Math. Phys. 4, 49–51 (1980)
Post, E.J.: Formal Structure of Electromagnetics—General Covariance and Electromagnetics. North-Holland/Dover, Amsterdam/Mineola (1962/1997)
Rodrigues, W.A. Jr., Gomes de Souza, Q.A.: An ambiguous statement called ‘tetrad postulate’ and the correct field equations satisfied by the tetrad fields. Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 14, 2095–2150 (2005). arXiv.org/math-ph/0411085
Ruggiero, M.L., Tartaglia, A.: Einstein–Cartan theory as a theory of defects in space–time. Am. J. Phys. 71, 1303–1313 (2003)
Ryder, L.H.: Quantum Field Theory. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1996)
Schouten, J.A.: Ricci Calculus, 2nd edn. Springer, Berlin (1954)
Schouten, J.A.: Tensor Analysis for Physicists, 2nd edn. reprinted. Dover, New York (1989)
Sciama, D.W.: On the analogy between charge and spin in general relativity. In: Recent Developments of General Relativity, pp. 415–439. Pergamon, London (1962)
Sciama, D.W.: The physical structure of general relativity. Rev. Mod. Phys. 36, 463–469 (1964); 1103(E)
Sezgin, E., van Nieuwenhuizen, P.: New ghost free gravity Lagrangians with propagating torsion. Phys. Rev. D 21, 3269–3280 (1980)
Sharpe, R.W.: Differential Geometry: Cartan’s Generalization of Klein’s Erlangen Program. Springer, New York (1997)
Tonnelat, M.A.: La théorie du champ unifié d’Einstein et quelques-uns de ses développements. Gauthier-Villars, Paris (1955)
Trautman, A.: On the structure of the Einstein–Cartan equations. Symp. Math. 12, 139–162 (1973)
Trautman, A.: Einstein–Cartan theory. In: Francoise, J.-P. et al. (eds.) Encyclopedia of Mathematical Physics, pp. 189–195. Elsevier, Oxford (2006). arXiv.org/gr-qc/0606062
Tresguerres, R., Mielke, E.W.: Gravitational Goldstone fields from affine gauge theory. Phys. Rev. D 62, 044004 (2000)
Wielandt, E.: The superposition principle of waves not fulfilled under M.W. Evans’ O(3) hypothesis. Phys. Sc. 74, 539–540 (2006). arXiv. org/physics/0607262
Wise, D.K.: MacDowell–Mansouri gravity and Cartan geometry. arXiv.org/gr-qc/0611154
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Hehl, F.W. An Assessment of Evans’ Unified Field Theory I. Found Phys 38, 7–37 (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-007-9190-0
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-007-9190-0