Abstract
The paper offers a critical examination of Jennifer Hornsby's view that actions are internal to the body. It focuses on three of Hornsby's central claims: (P) many actions are bodily movements (in a special sense of the word “movement”) (Q) all actions are tryings; and (R) all actions occur inside the body. It is argued, contra Hornsby, that we may accept (P) and (Q) without accepting also the implausible (R). Two arguments are first offered in favour of the thesis (Contrary-R): that no actions occur inside the body. Three of Hornsby's arguments in favour of R are then examined. It is argued that we need to make a distinction between the causes and the causings of bodily movements (in the ordinary sense of the word “movement”) and that actions ought to be identified with the latter rather than the former. This distinction is then used to show how Hornsby's arguments for (R) may be resisted.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bennett, J. (1988)Events and Their Names (Oxford, Oxford University Press).
Boyd, R. (1980) Materialism Without Reductionism: What Physicalism Does not Entail, in N. Block (Ed.),Readings in Philosophy of Psychology, Vol. 1 (London, Methuen).
Cleveland, T. (1997)Trying Without Willing: An Essay in the Philosophy of Mind (Brookfield, VT, Ashgate).
Chisholm, R. (1966) Freedom and Action, in K. Lehrer (Ed.),Freedom and Determinism (New York, Random House).
Chisholm, R. (1976) The Agent as Cause, in M. Brand & D. Walton (Eds.)Action Theory (Dordrecht, Reidel).
Dretske, F. (1988)Explaining Behavior: Reasons in a World of Causes (Cambridge, MA, MIT Press).
Hornsby, J. (1980)Actions (London, Routledge and Kegan Paul).
Hornsby, J. (1993) Agency and Causal Explanation, in J. Heil & A. Mele (Eds.),Mental Causation (Oxford, Oxford University Press). Reprinted in Hornsby (1997).
Hornsby, J. (1997)Simple Mindedness (Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press).
McGinn, C. (1982)The Character of Mind (Oxford, OUP).
Taylor, R. (1966)Action and Purpose (Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice Hall).
Thomson, J.J. (1977)Acts and Other Events (Ithaca, NY, Cornell University Press).
Wiggins, D. (1968) On Béing in the Same Place at the Same Time,Philosophical Review, 77, pp. 90–95.
Wiggins, D. (1980)Sameness and Substance (Oxford, Blackwell).
Wilkins, J. (1668)An Essay Towards a Real Character and a Philosophical Language (London: Printed for Sa. Gallibrand).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Steward, H. Do actions occur inside the body?. Mind & Society 1, 107–125 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02512316
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02512316