Abstract
Jewish Nietzscheans have traditionally shied away from any detailed examination of Nietzsche’s comments on contemporary Jewry or the Jewish religion. Scholars who have examined Jewish Nietzscheans have therefore sought to connect Nietzsche with some dimension of Jewish thought through similarities in views between Nietzsche and the Jewish intellectuals who were purportedly influenced by him. The two books under consideration in this essay strain to find solid connections between Nietzsche’s philosophy and the writings of eminent Jewish writers. Daniel Rynhold and Michael Harris examine how selected Nietzschean concepts can also be found in the work of the noted Jewish thinker Rabbi Joseph Soloveitchik. David Ohana, by contrast, examines a variety of Jewish writers who at some point exhibited an enthusiasm for Nietzsche, ranging from Hebrew scholars and translators to German-Jewish intellectuals. Both books suffer from many of the shortcomings of general Nietzschean influence studies: there is often no sound philological evidence of influence, or the “connection” is so general that it is difficult to see Nietzsche as the source of influence, or the alleged influence was of short duration, and it is difficult to understand what remains Nietzschean in the individual influenced.
Bibliography
Golomb, Jacob: Nietzsche and Zion, Ithaca, NY 200410.7591/9781501727214Search in Google Scholar
Holub, Robert C.: “Nietzsche: Socialist, Anarchist, Feminist”, in Lynne Tatlock / Matt Erlin (eds.), German Culture in Nineteenth-Century America: Reception, Adaptation, Transformation, Rochester, NY 2005, 129–49Search in Google Scholar
Overbeck, Franz: Erinnerungen an Friedrich Nietzsche, Berlin 2011Search in Google Scholar
Poliakov, Léon: The Aryan Myth: A History of Racist and Nationalistic Ideas in Europe, New York 1996Search in Google Scholar
Ratner-Rosenhagen, Jennifer: American Nietzsche: A History of an Icon and His Ideas, Chicago 201110.7208/chicago/9780226705842.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Soloveitchik, Joseph B.: Halakhic Man, Philadelphia, PA 1983Search in Google Scholar
Soloveitchik, Joseph B.: The Lonely Man of Faith, New York 1965Search in Google Scholar
Stegmaier, Werner / Krochmalnik, Daniel (eds.): Jüdischer Nietzscheanismus, Berlin 200010.1515/9783110809770Search in Google Scholar
Volkov, Shulamith: Antisemitismus als kultureller Code, Munich 1990Search in Google Scholar
© 2021 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
