Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter July 16, 2016

Ab alio movetur: Aristotle and Causal Determinism

  • Jason Jordan EMAIL logo
From the journal Apeiron

Abstract

This paper addresses the contentious issue of Aristotle’s commitment to causal determinism, particularly as concerns the efficient cause. After distinguishing between determinism, fatalism, and necessitarianism, several common arguments in favor of indeterminist interpretations of Aristotle are examined and rebutted. Afterwards, several positive arguments in favor of a determinist interpretation are advanced. The paper then turns to Aristotle’s seminal theory of chance and his resistance to systemic/metaphysical conceptions of determinism. Finally the paper asks whether Aristotle’s theory of chance succeeds in vanquishing determinism, or even necessitarianism.

Bibliography

Al-Farabi. 1981. Commentary and Short Treatise on Aristotle’s De Interpretatione. Translated by F. W. Zimmermann. London: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Al-Farabi. 2001. The Philosophy of Plato and Aristotle. Translated by Muhsin Mahdi. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Al-Ghazali. 1963. Tahafut Al-Falasifah. Translated by Sabih Ahmad Kamali. Lahore, Pakistan: Pakistan Philosophical Congress.Search in Google Scholar

Ammonius. 1998. On Aristotle’s on Interpretation 9. Translated by David Blank and Norman Kretzmann. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Anscombe, G. E. M. 1956. “Aristotle and the Sea Battle.” Mind 65:1–15.10.1007/978-1-349-15267-4_2Search in Google Scholar

Anscombe, G. E. M. 1971. Causality and Determination. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Aphrodisias, Alexander of. 1983. On Fate. Translated by R.W. Sharples. London: Gerald Duckworth & Co.Search in Google Scholar

Aphrodisias, Alexander of. 1992. Quaestiones 1.1–2.15. Translated by R.W. Sharples. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Aphrodisias, Alexander of. 1994. Quaestiones 2.16–3.15. Translated by R.W. Sharples. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Aphrodisias, Alexander of. 1999. On Aristotle Prior Analytics 1.14–22. Translated by Josiah Gould. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Aquinas, T. 1923. Summa Contra Gentiles. Translated by The English Dominican Fathers. London: Burns Oates & Washbourne Ltd.Search in Google Scholar

Aquinas, T. 1952. On the Power of God (Quaestiones Disputatae De Potentia Dei). Translated by The English Dominican Fathers. Westminster, MD: Newman Press.Search in Google Scholar

Aquinas, T. 1964. Summa Thelogiae. Translated by The English Dominican Fathers. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company.Search in Google Scholar

Aristotle. 1984. Complete Works. Edited by Jonathan Barnes. Princeton. NJ: Princeton Univeristy Press.Search in Google Scholar

Aspasius. 2007. On Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics 1–4, 7-8. Translated by David Konstan. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Aurelius, Marcus Antoninus. 1916. Marcus Aurelius. Translated by C. R. Haines. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Averroes. 1969. The Incoherence of the Incoherence. Translated by Simon van Den Bergh. 2 vol. London: Messrs Luzac & Company Ltd.Search in Google Scholar

Balme, D. 1939. “Greek Science and Mechanism I. Aristotle on Nature and Chance.” The Classical Quarterly 33:129–38.10.1017/S0009838800022308Search in Google Scholar

Balme, D. 1972. Aristotle’s De Partibus Animalium I and De Generatione Animalium I. Oxford: Clarendon Press.10.1093/oseo/instance.00262095Search in Google Scholar

Balme, D. 1980. “Teleology and Necessity.” In Philosophical Issues in Aristotle’s Biology, Edited by A. Gotthelf and J. G. Lennox, 275–86. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511552564.015Search in Google Scholar

Barnes, J. 1975. Aristotle’s Posterior Analytics. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Search in Google Scholar

Barnes, J. 1979. The Presocratic Philosophers, 2 vol. London: Routledge.Search in Google Scholar

Bayle, P. 1991. Historical and Critical Dictionary: Selections. Translated by Richard H. Popkin. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Company.Search in Google Scholar

Bobzien, S. 1998. Determinism and Freedom in Stoic Philosophy. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Search in Google Scholar

Boeri, M. D. 1995. “Chance and Teleology in Aristotle’s Physics.” International Philosophical Quarterly 35:87–96.10.5840/ipq199535161Search in Google Scholar

Boethius, A. M. S. 1918. Consolation of Philosophy. Translated by S. J. Tester. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Boethius, A. M. S. 1998. On Aristotle’s on Interpretation 9. Translated by David Blank and Norman Kretzmann. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Botros, S. 1985. “Freedom, Causality, Fatalism and Early Stoic Philosophy.” Phronesis 30:274–304.10.1163/156852885X00101Search in Google Scholar

Bradie, M., and F. D. Miller Jr. 1984. “Teleology and Natural Necessity in Aristotle.” History of Philosophy Quarterly 1:133–46.Search in Google Scholar

Broadie, S. 2001. “From Necessity to Fate: A Fallacy?.” Journal of Ethics 5:21–37.10.1023/A:1011466914535Search in Google Scholar

Byrne, C. 2002. “Aristotle on Physical Necessity and the Limits of Teleological Explanation.” Apeiron 35:20–46.10.1515/APEIRON.2002.35.1.19Search in Google Scholar

Christidis, T. 2001. “Chance, Necessity and the Role of Time in Aristotle’s Physics.” In Aristotle and Contemporary Science, edited byD. Sphendonē-Mentzu. New York: Peter Lang.Search in Google Scholar

Cicero, M. T. 1914. De Finibus Bonorum Et Malorum. Translated by H. Rackham. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.10.4159/DLCL.marcus_tullius_cicero-de_finibus_bonorum_et_malorum.1914Search in Google Scholar

Cicero, M. T. 1933. De Natura Deorum. Academica. Translated by H. Rackham. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.10.4159/DLCL.marcus_tullius_cicero-de_natura_deorum.1933Search in Google Scholar

Cicero, M. T. 1942. De Fato. Paradoxia Stoicorum. Translated by H. Rackham. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.10.4159/DLCL.marcus_tullius_cicero-de_fato.1942Search in Google Scholar

Cooper, J. M. 1987. “Hypothetical Necessity and Natural Teleology.” In Philosophical Issues in Aristotle’s Biology, Edited by A. Gotthelf and J. G.. Lennox, 243–74. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511552564.014Search in Google Scholar

DeLacy, P. H. 1939. “The Problem of Causation in Plato’s Philosophy.” Classical Philology 34:97–115.10.1086/362224Search in Google Scholar

Dudley, J. 2005. “Necessity and Chance: Aristotle’s Criticism of the Presocratics.” In Hasard Et Nécessité Dans La Philosophie Grecque, Edited by E. Moutsopoulos. Athina: Académie d‘Athènes.Search in Google Scholar

Dudley, J. 2012. Aristotle’s Conception of Chance. Albany: State University of New York Press.Search in Google Scholar

Edmunds, L. 1972. “Necessity, Chance, and Freedom in the Early Atomists.” Phoenix 26:342–57.10.2307/1087594Search in Google Scholar

Empiricus, S. 1933. Outlines of Pyrrhonism. Translated by R. G. Bury. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Empiricus, S. 1935. Against Logicians. Translated by R. G. Bury. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Empiricus, S. 1936. Against Physicists. Against Ethicists. Translated by R. G. Bury. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Empiricus, S. 1949. Against Professors. Translated by R. G. Bury. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Epictetus. 1925. Discourses, Encheiridion and Fragments. Translated by W. A. Oldfather. Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press.10.4159/DLCL.epictetus-discourses.1925Search in Google Scholar

Fine, G. 1981. “Aristotle on Determinism: A Review of Richard Sorabji’s ‘Necessity, Cause, and Blame..’” The Philosophical Review 90:561–79.10.2307/2184607Search in Google Scholar

Fine, G. 1984. “Truth and Necessity in De Interpretatione 9.” History of Philosophy Quarterly 1:23–48.Search in Google Scholar

Frede, D. 1985. “Aristotle on the Limits of Determinism: Accidental Causes in Metaphysics E.3.” In Aristotle on Nature and Living Things, Edited by A. Gotthelf, 207–25. Pittsburgh: Mathesis Pub.Search in Google Scholar

Funkenstein, A. 1986. Theology and the Scientific Imagination From the Middle Ages to the Seventeenth Century. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Furley, D. 1986. “The Rainfall Example in Physics II.8.” In Aristotle on Nature and Living Things, edited by A. Gotthelf, 177–82. Pittsburch: Mathesis.Search in Google Scholar

Galen. 1968. On the Usefulness of the Parts of the Body. Translated by Margaret Tallmadge May. 2 vol. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Gaskin, R. 1995. The Sea Battle and the Master Argument. New York: De Gruyter.10.1515/9783110866346Search in Google Scholar

Gellius, A. 1927. Attic Nights. 3 vol. Translated by J. C. Rolfe. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.10.4159/DLCL.gellius-attic_nights.1927Search in Google Scholar

Gomperz, T. 1912. Greek Thinkers. Translated by Laurie Magnus. London: John Murray.Search in Google Scholar

Graham, D. W. 2010. The Texts of Early Greek Philosophy, 2 vol. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Gregory, A. 2007. Ancient Greek Cosmology. London: Bloomsbury.Search in Google Scholar

Grgić, F. 1998. “Aristotle Against the Determinist: Metaphysics 6.3.” International Philosophy Quarterly 38:127–36.10.5840/ipq19983821Search in Google Scholar

Guthrie, W. C. K. 1962. A History of Greek Philosophy, 6 vol. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Hankinson, R. J. 1995. “Philosophy of Science.” In The Cambridge Companion to Aristotle, edited by J. Barnes, 109–39. Cambridge: Cambridge UP.Search in Google Scholar

Hankinson, R. J. 1998. Cause and Explanation in Ancient Greek Thought. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Search in Google Scholar

Heath, D. D. 1879. “Some Further Observations on Ancient Theories of Causation.” Journal of Philology 8:172–7.10.1017/CBO9781139523615.020Search in Google Scholar

Hintikka, J., et al. 1973. Time and Necessity: Studies in Aristotle’s Theory of Modality. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Search in Google Scholar

Hintikka, J., et al. 1977. Aristotle on Modality and Determinism. Amsterdam: North Holland Pub. Co.Search in Google Scholar

Hourani, G. F. 1972. “Ibn Sina on Necessary and Possible Existence.” Philosophical Forum 4:74–86.Search in Google Scholar

Hume, D. 1955. A Treatise of Human Nature. Edited by L.A. Selby-Bigge. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Ide, H. 1993. “Aristotle Metaphysics VI 2–3 and Coincidences.” Ancient Philosophy 13:341–54.10.5840/ancientphil19931326Search in Google Scholar

Inwood, B. and L. P. Gerson, Eds. 2008. The Stoics Reader: Selected Writings and Testimonia. Translated by Brad Inwood and Lloyd P. Gerson. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Company.Search in Google Scholar

Isidore of Seville. 2010. Etymologies. Translated by Stephen A. Barney et al. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Judson, L. 1988. “La Bataille Navale d‘Aujourd’hui: De Interpretatione 9.” Revue De Philosophie Ancienne 6:5–37.Search in Google Scholar

Kirk, G. S., and J. E. Raven. 1962. The Presocratic Philosophers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Kirwan, C. 1993. Aristotle’s Metaphysics Books Γ, Δ, E. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/oseo/instance.00262329Search in Google Scholar

Kogan, B. S. 1985. Averroes and the Metaphysics of Causation. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.Search in Google Scholar

Kullmann, W. 1974. Wissenschaft Und Methode. Berlin: De Gryuter.10.1515/9783110834994Search in Google Scholar

Laertius, D. 1925. Lives of the Eminent Philosophers, 2 vol. Translated by R. D. Hicks. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Leibniz, G. W. 1951. Theodicy. Translated by E. M. Huggard. New Haven: Yale University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Leunissen, M. 2010. Explanation and Teleology in Aristotle’s Science of Nature. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511762499Search in Google Scholar

Loening, R. 1903. Die Zurechningslehre Des Aristoteles. Jena: Hildesheim.Search in Google Scholar

Long, A. A., and D. N. Sedley. 1970. “Stoic Determinism and Alexander of Aphrodisias’ De Fato (i-xiv).” Archiv Für Geschichte Der Philosophie 52:247–68.10.1515/agph.1970.52.3.247Search in Google Scholar

Long, A. A., and D. N. Sedley. 1987. The Hellenistic Philosophers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9781139165907Search in Google Scholar

Lucretius, Carus Titus. 1975. De Rerum Natura. Translated by W.H.D. Rouse. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Madigan, A. 1984. “Metaphysics E. 3: A Modest Proposal.” Phronesis 29:123–36.10.1163/156852884X00111Search in Google Scholar

Maison, A. 1946. Introduction À La Physique Aristotélicienne. Louvain: Institut supérieur de philosophie.Search in Google Scholar

Meehan, F. X. 1940. Efficient Causality in Aristotle and St. Thomas. Washington D.C: Catholic University of America Press.Search in Google Scholar

Mill, J. S. 1843. A System of Logic. London: John W. Parker.Search in Google Scholar

Nemesius. 2008. On the Nature of Man. Translated by R. W. Sharples and P. J. van der Eijk. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press.Search in Google Scholar

O’Keefe, T. Why there Are No Fresh Starts in Metaphysics Epsilon or Nicomachean Ethics III 5 Unpublished Dissertation.Search in Google Scholar

Panayides, C. Y. 2002. Aristotle on Modality and Determinism. Cyprus: Intercollege Press.Search in Google Scholar

Panayides, C. Y. 2009. “Aristotle on Causal Determinism and Fatalism.” Ancient Philosophy 29:107–22.10.5840/ancientphil20092916Search in Google Scholar

Philoponus, J. 1999. On Aristotle’s Physics 2. Translated by A. R. Lacy. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Philoponus, J. 2005. On Aristotle’s on the Soul 1.1-2. Translated by Richard Soraji. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Plato. 1997. Complete Works. Edited by John M. Cooper. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Company.Search in Google Scholar

Plotinus. 1984. Enneads. 7 vol. Translated by A. H. Armstrong. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Plutarch. 1927. Moralia. 16 vol. Translated by Frank Cole Babbitt et al. 16 vol. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Popper, K. R. 1956. The Open Universe: An Argument for Indeterminism. Totowa, NJ: Rowman & Littlefield.Search in Google Scholar

Proclus. 2007. On Providence. Translated by Carlos Steel. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Rivaud, A. 1906. Le Problem Du Devenir. Paris: Alcan.Search in Google Scholar

Roberts, A., et al (eds.). 1994. The Early Church Fathers, 38 vol. Peabody: Hendrickson Publishers.Search in Google Scholar

Ross, W. D. 1923. Aristotle. London: Methuen & Co. Ltd.Search in Google Scholar

Ross, W. D. 1936. Aristotle’s Physics. Oxford: Clarendon.10.1093/actrade/9780198141099.book.1Search in Google Scholar

Ross, W. D. 1958. Aristotle’s Metaphysics. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Search in Google Scholar

Sambursky, S. 1956. “On the Possible and the Probable in Ancient Greece.” Osiris 12:35–48.10.1086/368595Search in Google Scholar

Sambursky, S. 1959. Physics of the Stoics. London: Routledge.Search in Google Scholar

Schopenhauer, A. 1974. The Fourfold Root of the Principle of Sufficient Reason. Translated by E. F. J. Payne. Le Salle: Open Court.Search in Google Scholar

Seneca, L. A. 1935. Moral Essays. 3 vol. Translated by John W. Basore. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Seneca, L. A. 1971. Natural Questions, 2 vol. Translated by Thomas H. Corcoran. Cambrdge: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Sharples, R. W. 1979. “‘If What Is Earlier, Then of Necessity What Is Later’? Some Ancient Discussion of Aristotle.” De Generatione Et Corruptione 2.11.” Bulletin of the Institute of Classical Studies 26:27–44.10.1111/j.2041-5370.1979.tb00493.xSearch in Google Scholar

Sharples, R. W. 1986. “Soft Determinism and Freedom in Early Stoicism.” Phronesis 31:266–79.10.1163/156852886X00164Search in Google Scholar

Sharples, R. W. 2010. Peripatetic Philosophy 200BC to AD 200: An Introduction and Collection of Sources in Translation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511781506Search in Google Scholar

Simplicius. 1997. On Aristotle’s Physics 2. Translated by Barrie Fleet. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Simplicius. 2002. On Aristotle’s Categories 7–8. Translated by Barrie Fleet. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Simplicius. 2004. On Aristotle’s on the Heavens 1.5–9. Translated by R. J. Hankinson. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Simplicius. 2006. On Aristotle’s on the Heavens 1.10–12. Translated by R. J. Hankinson. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Sorabji, R. 1980. “Causation, Laws, and Necessity.” In Doubt and Dogmatism, Edited by M. Schofield, M. Burnyeat, and J. Barnes, 250–82. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Search in Google Scholar

Sorabji, R. 1980. Necessity, Cause, and Blame: Perspectives on Aristotle’s Theory. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Sorabji, R. (ed.) 2005. The Philosophy of the Commentators: 200–600 AD. 3 vol. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Stephanus. 2000. On Aristotle’s ‘on the Soul 3.9–13,’ with on Aristotle’s ‘on Interpretation’. Translated by William Charlton. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Strang, C. 1960. “Aristotle and the Sea Battle.” Mind 69:447–65.10.1093/mind/LXIX.276.447Search in Google Scholar

Suárez, F. 1994. On Efficient Causality: Metaphysical Disputations 17, 18, and 19. Translated by Alfred J. Freddoso. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Taylor, R. 1957. “The Problem of Future Contingencies.” The Philosophical Review 66:1–28.10.2307/2182851Search in Google Scholar

Upton, T. V. 1987. “The Principle of Excluded Middle and Causality: Aristotle’s More Complete Reply to the Determinist.” History of Philosophy Quarterly 4:359–67.Search in Google Scholar

Waterlow, S. 1982. Nature, Change, and Agency in Aristotle’s Physics. Oxford: Clarendon Press.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198246534.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

White, M. J. 1980. “Necessity and Unactualized Possibilities in Aristotle.” Philosophical Studies 38:287–98.10.1007/BF00375662Search in Google Scholar

White, M. J. 1981. “Fatalism and Causal Determinism.” Philosophical Quarterly 31:231–41.10.2307/2219112Search in Google Scholar

Williams, D. 1951. “The Sea Fight Tomorrow,” in Structure, Method and Meaning. New York: Liberal Arts Press.Search in Google Scholar

Williams, C. J. F. 1986. “Some Comments on Metaphysics E. 2, 3.” Illinois Classical Studies 11:181–92.Search in Google Scholar

Xenophon. 1959. Memorabilia. Translated by E.C. Marchant. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

von Armin, H. 1903–5. Stoicorum Veterum Fragmenta, 3 vol. Stuttgart: Teubner.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2016-7-16
Published in Print: 2016-10-1

©2016 by De Gruyter

Downloaded on 4.5.2024 from https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/apeiron-2015-0045/html
Scroll to top button