Abstract
On the basis of what Aristotle says in the Posterior Analytics about how sciences are differentiated and about the impermissibility (save in some exceptional cases) of ‘kind-crossing’, many commentators suppose that when it comes to his scientific practice, Aristotle treats the boundaries of the sciences as impermeable, so that if subject-matter X is the business of one science, it simply cannot (save for the exceptional cases) be the business of another. I call this the impermeable boundary theory of the sciences: knowledge is divided into watertight compartments, determined by their distinct genera, and what goes on in one compartment cannot turn up in another. I argue that, even if this is a correct account of Aristotle’s position in the Analytics, the view that he accepts the impermeable boundary theory when it comes to his scientific and philosophical work outside the Analytics is simply untenable.
- An. Post.
Posterior Analytics
- An. Pr.
Prior Analytics
- Cael.
De Caelo
- De An.
De Anima
- De Iuv.
De Iuventute et Senectute, De Vita et Morte, De Respiratione
- De Sensu
De Sensu et Sensibilibus
- MA
De Motu Animalium
- EE
Eudemian Ethics
- EN
Nicomachean Ethics
- GC
De Generatione et Corruptione
- Met.
Metaphysics
- Meteor.
Meteorologica
- PA
De Partibus Animalium
- Phys.
Physics
Achtenberg, D. 2002 Cognition of Value in Aristotle’s Ethics: Promise of Enrichment, Threat of Destruction. Albany.Search in Google Scholar
Adams, M. P. 2015. “Demarcating Aristotelian Rhetoric: Rhetoric, the Subalternate Sciences, and Boundary Crossing”. Apeiron 48, 99–122.10.1515/apeiron-2014-0017Search in Google Scholar
Barnes, J. 1994. Aristotle’s Posterior Analytics: Translated with a Commentary, 2nd edition. Oxford.Search in Google Scholar
Bolton, R. 1991. “Aristotle’s Method in Natural Science: Physics I”. In Aristotle’s Physics: A Collection of Essays. Ed. L. Judson. Oxford, 1–29.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2010. “Biology and Metaphysics in Aristotle”. In Being, Nature, and Life in Aristotle. Eds J. G. Lennox/R. Bolton. Cambridge/New York, 30–55.10.1017/CBO9780511919275.005Search in Google Scholar
Bostock, D. 1994. Aristotle’s Metaphysics Books Ζ and Θ: Translated with a Commentary. Oxford.10.1093/oseo/instance.00262329Search in Google Scholar
Burnyeat, M. 2001. A Map of Metaphysics Zeta. Pittsburgh.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2004. “Introduction: Aristotle on the Foundations of Sublunary Physics”. In Aristotle’s On Generation and Corruption I. Eds F. de Haas/J. Mansfeld. Oxford, 7–24.Search in Google Scholar
Charles, D. 2000. “Metaphysics Λ 2: Matter and Change”. In Aristotle’s Metaphysics Lambda: Symposium Aristotelicum. Eds M. Frede/D. Charles. Oxford, 81–110.Search in Google Scholar
Clarke, T. 2017. “Physics I.2”. In Aristotle’s Physics I: The Principles of Natural Things. Ed. D. Quarantotto. Cambridge.10.1017/9781108181853.004Search in Google Scholar
Distelzweig, P. M. 2013. “The Intersection of the Mathematical and Natural Sciences: The Subordinate Sciences in Aristotle”. Apeiron 46, 85–105.10.1515/apeiron-2011-0008Search in Google Scholar
Falcon, A. 2005. Aristotle and the Science of Nature: Unity without Uniformity. Cambridge/New York.10.1017/CBO9780511482519Search in Google Scholar
Frede, M. 2000. “Metaphysics Λ 1”. In Aristotle’s Metaphysics Lambda: Symposium Aristotelicum. Eds M. Frede/D. Charles. Oxford, 53–80.Search in Google Scholar
Hankinson, R. J. 2005. “Aristotle on Kind-Crossing”. In Philosophy and the Sciences in Antiquity. Ed. R.W. Sharples. Aldershot, 23–54.10.4324/9781351151726-3Search in Google Scholar
Irwin, T. 1981. “Aristotle’s Method of Ethics”. In Studies in Aristotle. Ed. D. J. O’Meara. Washington, DC, 193–223.10.2307/j.ctv1765z.12Search in Google Scholar
–. 1988. Aristotle’s First Principles. Oxford.10.1093/0198242905.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Jaeger, W. 1948. Aristotle: Fundamentals of the History of his Development, trans. by R. Robinson, 2nd edition. Oxford.Search in Google Scholar
Johnson, M. R. 2009. “The Aristotelian Explanation of the Halo”. Apeiron 42, 325–58.10.1515/APEIRON.2009.42.4.325Search in Google Scholar
Judson, L. 1997. “Aristotle on Fair Exchange”. Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 15, 147–75.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2015. “Aristotle’s Astrophysics”. Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy, 49, 151–92.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198749516.003.0005Search in Google Scholar
–. 2017. “Physics I.5”. In Aristotle’s Physics I: The Principles of Natural Things. Ed. D. Quarantotto. Cambridge.10.1017/9781108181853.007Search in Google Scholar
–. 2019. Aristotle, Metaphysics Λ: Translated with an Introduction and Commentary. Oxford.Search in Google Scholar
Kung, J. 1982. “Aristotle’s ‘De Motu Animalium’ and the Separability of the Sciences”. Journal of the History of Philosophy 20, 65–76.10.1353/hph.1982.0011Search in Google Scholar
Lennox, J. G. 1986. “Aristotle, Galileo, and ‘Mixed Sciences’”. In Reinterpreting Galileo. Ed. W. A. Wallace. Washington, D. C., 29–51.10.2307/j.ctv175zv.5Search in Google Scholar
–. 2005. “The Place of Zoology in Aristotle’s Natural Philosophy”. In Philosophy and the Sciences in Antiquity. Ed. R.W. Sharples. Aldershot, 55–71.10.4324/9781351151726-4Search in Google Scholar
–. 2008. “‘As if we were Investigating Snubness’: Aristotle on the Prospects for a Single Science of Nature”. Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 35, 149–86.Search in Google Scholar
–. 2010. “Aristotle’s Natural Science: the Many and the One”. Apeiron 43, 1–24.10.1515/APEIRON.2010.43.2-3.1Search in Google Scholar
Leunissen, M. 2010. Explanation and Teleology in Aristotle’s Science of Nature. Cambridge.10.1017/CBO9780511762499Search in Google Scholar
McKirahan, R. D. 1978. “Aristotle’s Subordinate Sciences”. The British Journal for the History of Science 11, 197–220.10.1017/S0007087400043776Search in Google Scholar
–. 1992. Principles and Proofs: Aristotle’s Theory of Demonstrative Science. Princeton.10.1515/9781400887163Search in Google Scholar
Mueller, I. 2006. “Physics and Astronomy: Aristotle’s Physics II.2.193b22–194a12a”. Arabic Sciences and Philosophy 16, 175–206.10.1017/S0957423906000300Search in Google Scholar
Nussbaum, M. C. 1978. Aristotle’s De Motu Animalium. Princeton.10.1515/9780691219486Search in Google Scholar
Owen G. E. L. 1966/1986. “The Platonism of Aristotle”. Proceedings of the British Academy 51, 125–50; reprinted in Owen, Logic, Science and Dialectic: Collected Papers in Greek Philosophy. Ed. M. Nussbaum. London, 200–220.Search in Google Scholar
Peramatzis, M. 2011. Priority in Aristotle’s Metaphysics. Oxford.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199588350.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Rapp, C. 2016. “The Principles of Sensible Substance in Metaphysics Λ 2–5”. In Aristotle’s Metaphysics Lambda – New Essays. Ed. C. Horn. Boston and Berlin, 87–117.10.1515/9781501503443-006Search in Google Scholar
Roche, T. D. 1988. “On the Alleged Metaphysical Foundation of Aristotle’s Ethics”. Ancient Philosophy 8, 49–62.10.5840/ancientphil19888120Search in Google Scholar
Ross, W. D. 1936. Aristotle’s Physics: A Revised Text with Introduction andCommentary. Oxford.10.1093/actrade/9780198141099.book.1Search in Google Scholar
Scott, D. 2015. Levels of Argument: A Comparative Study of Plato’s Republic and Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics. Oxford.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199249640.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Steinkrüger, P. 2018. “Aristotle on Kind-Crossing”. Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 54, 107–58.10.1093/oso/9780198825128.003.0004Search in Google Scholar
© 2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
