Abstract
It is commonly believed thatgeriatric medicine generates a distinctive setof ethical problems. Implicated are such issuesas resource allocation, competence and consent,advance directives, medical futility anddeliberate death. It is also argued that itwould be unjust to allow the elderly to competewith younger populations for expensive andscarce health care resources because theelderly “have already lived,” and that treatingthem the same as these other populations woulddiminish the available resources unfairly,prolong a life of inevitably failing health andresult in increased health care expenditures.In fact, however, this perception of ethicaluniqueness is mistaken. Differences in medicalconditions, demographics and aetiology shouldnot be allowed to obscure the fact that ethicalissues in geriatric medicine are essentiallythe same as those faced in any other area ofhealth care, and that the solutions that areadopted in the geriatric context must beconsistent with the ethical principles that arefollowed elsewhere. The paper argues that theroot of the mistaken perception lies in theabandonment of the Hippocratic mandate ofmedicine and in an unreflective adherence tothe belief that medical advances are inevitablybeneficial. It is suggested that a return topatient-centred medicine and the use of ethicsimpact analyses before introducing medicaladvances may be ethically appropriate.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abrams, R.C. (1998) Physician-Assisted Suicide and Euthanasia's Impact on the Frail Elderly: Something to Think About. J Long Term Home Health Care 17, 19–27.
Anand, P. (1999) QALYS and the Integration of Claims in Health-Care. Health Care Analysis 7, 239–253.
Balaswamy, S. and Richardson, V.E. (2001) The Cumulative Effects of Life Event, Personal and Social Resources on Subjective Well-Being of Elderly Widowers. Int J Aging HumDev 53, 311–327.
Callahan, D. (1996) Controlling the Costs of Health Care for the Elderly - Fair Means and Foul. N Engl J Med 335, 744–746.
Charatan, F.B. (2000) The High Price of Aging. West J Med 172, 363–364.
Clarke, C.M. (2001) Rationing Scarce Life-Sustaining Resources on the Basis of Age. J Adv Nurs 35, 799–804.
Coppola, K.M., Danks, J.H., Ditto, P.H. et al. (1998) Perceived Benefits And Burdens of Life-Sustaining Treatments: Differences among Elderly Adults, Physicians, and Young Adults. J Ethics Law Aging 4, 3–13.
Coughlan, T. and O'Neill, D. (2001) General Hospital Resources Consumed by an Elderly Population Awaiting Long-Term Care. Ir Med J 94, 206–208.
Daniels, N. (1985) Just Health Care. Cambridge and London: Cambridge University Press.
Di Cicco-Bloom, B. (1998) Physician-assisted Suicide and Euthanasia's Impact on the Frail Elderly: The Perspective of a Hospice Nurse. J Long Term Home Health Care 17, 42–50.
Fisher, C. and Gill, D. (1996) Limiting Health Care for the Elderly. Plast Surg Nurs 16, 113–116.
Frezza, E.E., Squillario, D.M. and Smith, T.J. (1998) The Ethical Challenge and the Futile Treatment in the Older Population Admitted to the Intensive Care Unit. Am J Med Qual 13, 121–126.
Gillick, M.R. and Fried, T. (1995) The Limits of Proxy Decision Making: Undertreatment. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 4, 172–177.
Gordon, M. and Levitt, D. (1996) Physicians, Ethics, Advance Directives, and Long-Term Care. J Am Geriatr Soc 44, 471–472.
Grossberg, G.T. (1998) Advance Directives, Competency Evaluation, and Surrogate Management In Elderly Patients. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry 6(2 Suppl 1), S79-S84.
Haddad, A. (2001) Ethics in Action. A Competent, Elderly Chinese Woman Who Needs Immediate Treatment Says She Can't Give Consent Because She Must Wait for Her Family to Arrive to Give Approval. RN 64, 21–24.
Jones, D.G. (1997) Aging, Dementia and Care: Setting Limits on the Allocation of Health Care Resources to the Aged. N ZMed J vn 110, 466–468.
Kessel, A.S. and Meran, J. (1998) Advance Directives in the UK: Legal, Ethical, and Practical Considerations for Doctors. Br J Gen Pract 48, 1263–1236.
Kim, S.Y., Karlawish, J.H. and Caine, E.D. (2002) Current State of Research on Decision-Making Competence of Cognitively Impaired Elderly Persons. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry 10, 151–165.
Kluge, E-H. Biomedical Ethics in a Canadian Context. Scarborough, ON: Prentice Hall.
Kluge, E-H. Competition and Function: Health Care and the Canada-U.S. Free Trade Agreement. Business & Professional Ethics Journal 10, 24–41.
Koenig, H.G., Wildman-Hanlon, D. and Schmader, K. (1996) Attitudes of Elderly Patients and Their Families toward Physician-Assisted Suicide. Arch Intern Med 156, 2240–2248.
Koppelman, E.R. (2002) Dementia and Dignity: towards a New Method of Surrogate Decision Making. J Med Philos 27, 65–85.
Krause, N. and Shaw, B.A. (200) Giving Social Support to Others, Socioeconomic Status, and Changes in Self-Esteem in Late Life. J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci 55, S323–S323.
Kydd D. (1999) Euthanasia and the Elderly. Perspectives 23, 12–19.
Le, T.V. and Basta, L.L. (2002) Ethical Issues in theManagement of Geriatric Cardiac Patients. Am J Geriatr Cardiol 11, 56–57.
Matheis-Kraft, C. and Roberto, K.A. (1997) Influence of a Values Discussion on Congruence between Elderly Women and Their Families on Critical Health Care Decisions. J Women Aging 9, 5–22.
McCullough, L.B., Molinari, V. and Workman, R.H. (2001) Implications of Impaired Executive Control Functions for Patient Autonomy and Surrogate Decision Making. J Clin Ethics 12, 397–405.
Meerding, W.J., Polder, J., Bonneux, L. et al. (1998) Health-Care Costs of Ageing. Lancet 351, 140–141.
Merrill, J.M., Lorimor, R.J., Thornby, J.I. et al. (1996) Self-esteem and Caregivers' Attitudes toward Elderly Persons. Psychol Rep 79, 1349–1350.
Muller, M.T., Kimsma, G.K. and van der Wal, G. (1998) Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide: Facts, Figures and Fancies with Special Regard to Old Age. Drugs Aging 13, 185–191.
Pierce, J.R. (1995) Rationing Trauma Care to the Elderly: An Ethical Dilemma. Medsurg Nurs 4, 189–192, 215.
Post, S.G. (1995) Alzheimer Disease and the “then” Self. Kennedy Inst Ethics J 5, 307–321.
Rempusheski, V.F. and Hurley, A.C. (2000) Advance Directives and Dementia. J Gerontol Nurs 26, 27–34.
Sigmund, K. (1995) Games of Life: Explorations in Ecology, Evolution and Behavior. New York and London: Penguin.
Smith, G.P. (1996) Our Hearts Were Once Young and Gay: Health Care Rationing and the Elderly. Univ Fla J Law Public Policy 8, 1–23.
Stewart, K., Cumming, K. and Wagg, A. (1996) Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Elderly. J Med Ethics 22, 181–182.
Thomasma, D.C. (1995) The Ethical Challenge of Providing Healthcare for the Elderly. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 4, 148–162.
Tresch, D.D. and Thakur, R.K. (1998) Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation in the Elderly. Benefi-cial or an Exercise in Futility? Emerg Med Clin North Am 16, 649–63, ix.
Tsuchiya, A. (2000) QALYs and Ageism: Philosophical Theories and Age Weightin. Health Econ 9, 57–68.
Vollmann, J. (2001) Advance Directives in Patients with Alzheimer's Disease: Ethical and Clinical Considerations. Med Health Care Philos 4, 161–167.
Waddell, C., Clarnette, R.M., Smith M. et al. (1997) Advance Directives Affecting Medical Treatment Choices. J Palliat Care 13, 5–8.
Waun, J., Kilway, J.B. and Van Goor, K. (1998) Implementing Advance Directives. Mich Med 97, 18–19, 51.
Williams, A. (1997) Intergenerational Equity: An Exploration of the 'Fair Innings' Argument. Health Econ 6, 117–132.
Williams, A. (2001) The 'Fair Innings Argument' Deserves a Fairer Hearing! Health Econ 10, 583–585.
Williams, M. (1997) Rationing Health Care. Can a “Fair Innings” Ever be Fair? BMJ 314, 514.
World Medical Association (1981) Declaration of Lisbon: The Rights of the Patient.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Kluge, EH.W. Ethical Issues in Geriatric Medicine: A Unique Problematic?. Health Care Analysis 10, 379–390 (2002). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023479226847
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1023479226847