The Battle at the Cape of Italy
Abstract
Contrary to the widely held view that the Roman-Carthaginian naval encounter Polybios reports at 1.21.9-11 was separate from the one off Mylae (260 BC) told at length right afterwards (1.23), the battle at the ‘Cape of Italy’ is in fact - as suspected by some scholars long ago - identical with the one at Mylae. However, far from mistaking (as has been suggested) Philinos’ account of the latter for a separate engagement, Polybios knowingly and deliberately told the battle of Mylae twice: first in a brief summary, stripped of all detail, to illustrate how the Roman commander Cn. Scipio Asina (cos. 260) and his Punic counterpart, Hannibal, were both guilty of equally inappropriate acts of recklessness; then for a second time in detail and in its proper chronological place. Compositional considerations prompted this approach: to wait with the moralizing parallel until after his full account of Mylae (preceded in turn by the long technical disquisition on the Roman boarding bridges) would spoil the effect, and Polybios chose to place it immediately after Asina’s capture.
References
- 1. Arnaud, P. 2005.
Les routes de la navigation antique: Itinéraires en Méditerranée . Paris. - 2. Beck, H. 2005.
Karriere und Hierarchie: Die römische Aristokratie und die Anfänge des cursus honorum in der mittleren Republik . Berlin. - 3. Beloch, K. J. , Beloch
GG , 1912-27.Griechische Geschichte . 2nd ed., vols. 1-2, Strassburg. Vols. 3-4, Berlin/Leipzig. (1st ed.1893-1904, 3 vols., Strassburg.) - 4. Bleckmann, B. 2002.
Die römische Nobilität im Ersten Punischen Krieg: Untersuchungen zur aristokratischen Konkurrenz in der Republik . Berlin. - 5. Bung, P. 1950.
Q. Fabius Pictor, der erste römische Annalist: Untersuchungen über Aufbau, Stil und Inhalt seines Geschichtswerkes an Hand von Polybius I-II . Koln. - 6. Caven, B. 1980.
The Punic Wars . New York. - 7. De Sanctis SdR, De Sanctis, G.1907-23.
Storia dei Romani . 4 vols. Torino. - 8. De Souza, P. 2007. “Naval Battles and Sieges.” In
The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare. Vol. 1, Greece, the Hellenistic World and the Rise of Rome , 434-460. - 9. Eckstein, A. M. 1995.
Moral Vision in the Histories of Polybius . Berkeley/Los Angeles/London. - 10. FRHist, Cornell, T. J., Bispham, E. H., Rich, J. W., and C. J. Smith, edd. 2013.
The Fragments of the Roman Historians . 3 vols. Oxford. - 11. Gordon, A. E. 1983.
Illustrated Introduction to Latin Epigraphy . Berkeley/Los Angeles/London. - 12. Goldsworthy, A. 2000.
The Punic Wars . London. - 13. InscrItal, Degrassi, A., ed. 1937-63. Inscriptiones Italiae. Vol. 13, Fasti et Elogia. Roma.
- 14. Kondratieff, E. 2004. “The Column and Coinage of C. Duilius: Innovation in Iconography in Large and Small Media in the Middle Republic.”
SCI 23: 1-39. - 15. La Bua, V. 1966.
Filino-Polibio, Sileno-Diodoro: Il problema delle fonti dalla morte di Agatocle alla guerra mercenaria in Africa . Palermo. - 16. Lazenby, J. F. 1996.
The First Punic War: A Military History . Stanford. - 17. Morrison, J. S. 1996.
Greek and Roman Oared Warships . Oxford. - 18. Murray, W. M. 2012.
The Age of Titans: The Rise and Fall of the Great Hellenistic Navies . Oxford/ New York. - 19. Neumann, C. 1883.
Das Zeitalter der punischen Kriege . Breslau. - 20. Reuss, F. 1901. “Zur Geschichte des ersten punischen Krieges.”
Philologus 60: 102-148. - 21. Scullard, H. H. 1989. “Carthage and Rome.” In
The Cambridge Ancient History . 2nd ed., vol. 7.2,The Rise of Rome to 220 B. C. , 486-569. - 22. Tarn, W. W. 1907. “The Fleets of the First Punic War.”
JRS 27: 48-60. - 23. Thiel, J. H. 1954.
A History of Roman Sea-Power before the Second Punic War . Amsterdam. - 24. Tusa, S. and J. Royal. 2012. “The Landscape of the Naval Battle at the Egadi Islands (241 B. C.).”
JRA 25: 7-48. - 25. Walbank, F. 1945. “Polybius, Philinus, and the First Punic War.”
CQ 39: 1-18. - 26. Walbank HCP, id. 1957-79.
A Historical Commentary on Polybius . 3 vols. Oxford.