Abstract
In his Disrupted Dialogue: Medical Ethics and the Collapse of Physician-Humanist Communication (1770–1980) Robert Veatch presents a scholarly tour de force of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Anglophone medical ethics to demonstrate how the easy communication between physicians and humanists in the Scottish Enlightenment progressively dissipated as medicine became detached from humanistic disciplines. In this paper I offer two comments—that the discourse of medical ethics in the Scottish Enlightenment was a discourse of Baconian moral science and that nineteenth-century medical ethics in the United States became detached from that discourse. The result was that a principal resource for physicians at the birth of bioethics, the American Medical Association’s Principles of Medicine Ethics of 1957, did not equip physicians with the conceptual tools they needed to formulate and address the ethical challenges that became the agenda of bioethics. The paper opens with a brief portrait of Robert Veatch, the author’s connections to him, and his little-known role as an impresario of the classical music of the Blue Ridge and Appalachia.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Foundations of Ethics and its Relationship to Sciences. NEH grant details: Research Program on the Foundations of Ethics and Its Relationship to Sciences. National Endowment for the Humanities. https://securegrants.neh.gov/publicquery/main.aspx?f=1&gn=RH-10030-75.
Blomquist, Clarence, and Laurence B. McCullough. 1976. The psychiatrist’s role in moral dilemmas: Is a crisis of conscience a medical problem? Hastings Center Report 6 (3): 27–28.
Barns, Jim. 2017. After nearly 45 years, it’s lights out for the Lucketts Fair. The Washington Post, August 28, 2017. https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/after-nearly-45-years-its-lights-out-for-the-lucketts-fair/2017/08/25/b6b9ca96-8998-11e7-961d-2f373b3977ee_story.html.
Stained Glass Bluegrass. Stained Glass Bluegrass—Bluegrass Country. https://bluegrasscountry.org/shows/stained-glass-bluegrass/.
Jonsen, Albert AR.. 1998. The birth of bioethics. New York: Oxford University Press.
Veatch, Robert M. 2012. Hippocratic, religious, and secular medical ethics: The points of conflict. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
Whitehead, Alfred North. 1978. Process and reality: essays in cosmology. Gifford Lectures delivered in the University of Edinburgh during the session 1927–1928. Corrected Edition. Griffin DR. Cherburne DW (eds.). New York: The Free Press.
Veatch, Robert M. 2005. Disrupted dialogue: Medical ethics and the collapse of physician-humanist communication (1770–1980). New York: Oxford University Press.
Snow, C.P. 1998. The two cultures, with an introduction by Stefan Collini. New York: Cambridge University Press.
McCullough, Laurence B. 1998. John Gregory and the invention of professional medical ethics and the profession of medicine. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers (now Springer).
Hume, David. [1739–1740]. 2000. A treatise of human nature, ed. David Fate Norton and Mary J. Norton. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Boerhaave, Hermann. 1747. Institutiones medicae. Parisiis apud Guillelum Cavalier, Patrem, via Jacobeâ, sub Signo Lilii Aurei.
Gregory, John. [1772] 1998. Lectures on the Duties and Qualifications of a Physician. London: W. Strahan and T. Cadell. In John Gregory’s Writings on Medical Ethics and Philosophy of Medicine, ed. Laurence B. McCullough, 161–245. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers (now Springer).
Meyers, Sylvia Harcstark. 1990. The Bluestocking Circle: Women, friendship, and the life of the mind in eighteenth-century England. Oxford: The Clarendon Press.
McCullough, Laurence B. 2022. Thomas Percival’s Medical Ethics and the invention of medical professionalism: With three key Percival texts, two concordances, and a chronology. New York: Springer.
Percival, Thomas. 1765. Dissertatio medica inauguralis de frigore. Submitto Thomas Percival. Lugduni Batavorum, Apud Theodorum Haak.
Percival, Thomas. 1807. The works, literary, moral, and medical of Thomas Percival, Volumes 1-IV, ed. Edward Percival. Printed by Richard Cruttwell, St. James-Street, Bath; for J. Johnson, St. Paul’s Church-Yard, London.
Percival, Thomas. 1803. Medical Ethics or, a Code of Institutes and Precepts Adapted to the Professional Conduct of Physicians and Surgeons, Section I-IV. Manchester: Printed by S. Russell, for J. Johnson, St, Paul’s Church Yard, and R. Bickerstaff, Strand, London.
Percival, Thomas. [1803] 2022. Medical Ethics or, a Code of Institutes and Precepts Adapted to the Professional Conduct of Physicians and Surgeons, Section I-IV. Manchester: Printed by S. Russell, for J. Johnson, St, Paul’s Church Yard, and R. Bickerstaff, Strand, London. In McCullough, Laurence B. 2022. Thomas Percival’s Medical Ethics and the invention of medical professionalism: with three key Percival texts, two concordances, and a chronology: NNN-NNN. New York: Springer.
Ambrose, Charles T. 2005. The secret Kappa Lambda Society of Hippocrates (and the origin of the American Medical Association’s Principles of Medical Ethics). Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine 78: 45–56.
Baker, Robert B. 2013. Before bioethics: A history of American medical ethics from the colonial period to the bioethics revolution. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kappa Lambda Society. 1823. Extracts from the Medical Ethics of Dr. Percival. Philadelphia: Published privately for the Kappa Lambda Secret Society of Hippocrates by Clark & Fraser, Printers, 33 Carter’s Alley.
Percival, Thomas. [1823] 2022. Extracts from the Medical Ethics of Dr. Percival. Philadelphia [Clark & Raser, printers]. In McCullough, Laurence B. 2022. Thomas Percival’s Medical Ethics and the invention of medical professionalism: with three key Percival texts, two concordances, and a chronology: NNN-NNN. New York: Springer.
American Medical Association. Code of Ethics. [1847] 1999. In The American medical ethics revolution: How the AMA’s Code of Ethics has transformed physicians’ relationships to patients, professionals, and society, (eds.). Baker, Robert B, Arthur L. Caplan, Linda L. Emanuel, and Stephen R. Latham, 324–334. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
American Medical Association. [1957] 1999. Principles of medical ethics. In The American medical ethics revolution: How the AMA’s Code of Ethics has transformed physicians’ relationships to patients, professionals, and society, (eds.). Baker, Robert B, Arthur L. Caplan, Linda L. Emanuel, and Stephen R. Latham, 355–357. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
MacIntyre, Alasdair. 1981. After virtue. South Bend, Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Publisher's Note
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
McCullough, L.B. Robert Veatch’s Disrupted Dialogue and its implications for bioethics. Theor Med Bioeth 43, 221–233 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-022-09576-1
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11017-022-09576-1