Abstract
This article (Part III) deals with the early applications of wave mechanics to atomic problems—including the demonstration of the formal mathematical equivalence of wave mechanics with the quantum mechanics of Born, Heisenberg, and Jordan, and that of Dirac—by Schrödinger himself and others. The new theory was immediately accepted by the scientific community.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Letter from E. Schrödinger to A. Sommerfeld, January 23, 1926.
R. Courant and D. Hilbert,Methoden der mathematischen Physik, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1924).
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 515.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 518, footnote 1; English translation, p. 33, footnote 1.
R. Courant and D. Hilbert, Ref. 313..
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 516; English translation, p. 31.
Actually, what have been called the Hermitian orthogonal functions are not exp(−x 2/2)H n (x), but the normalized functions (2n n!)−1/2·exp(−x 2/2)H n (x). [See Ref. 313, p. 77, Eq. (66).]
E. Schrödinger, Der stetige Übergang von der Mikro- zur Makromechanik,Naturwissenschaften 14, 664–666 (1926), English translation: The Continuous Transition from Micro- to Macromechanics, Ref. 256, pp. 41–44.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 320, p. 665; English translation, p. 42.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 519; English translation, p. 34.
P. Ehrenfest, Bemerkung betreffs der spezifischen Wärme zweiatomiger Gase,Verh. Dtsch. Phys. Ges. 15, 451–457 (1913); reprinted in Collected Scientific Papers, pp. 333–339.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 520; English translation, pp. 34–35.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 521; English translation, p. 35.
For details, see Ref. 245, Chapter IV, pp. 596–599.
P. S. Epstein, Zur Theorie des Starkeffekts,Phys. Z. 17, 148–150 (1916);Ann. Phys. 50, 489–521 (1916).
H. A. Kramers, Intensities of spectral lines: On the Application of the Quantum Theory to the Problem of the Relative Intensities of the Components of the Fine Structure and of the Stark Effect of These Lines of the Hydrogen Spectra,Kgl. Danske Vid. Selsk. Skrifter, 8. Raekke III.3; reprinted inCollected Scientific Papers, 5–108 (1956).
E. Schrödinger, Quantisierung als Eigenwertproblem (Dritte Mitteilung: Störungstheorie, mit Anwendung auf den Starkeffekt der Balmerlinien),Ann. Phys. 80, 437–490 (1926); English translation in Collected Papers on Wave Mechanics, 1928, pp. 62–101; p. 463, English translation, p. 81.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 330, p. 463; English translation, p. 81.
Letter from W. Wien to E. Schrödinger, March 21, 1926.
Letter from E. Schrödinger to W. Wien, June 18, 1926.
See A. Sommerfeld,Three Lectures on Atomic Physics (based on lectures given in March at the University of London), Methuen, London (1926).
Letter from E. Schrödinger to M. Planck, February 26, 1926.
Letter from M. Planck to E. Schrödinger, April 2, 1926.
Letter from A. Einstein to E. Schrödinger, April 16, 1926.
Letter from E. Schrödinger to A. Einstein, April 23, 1926.
Letter from A. Einstein to E. Schrödinger, April 26, 1926.
Letter from A. Einstein to P. Ehrenfest, February 12, 1926.
See, especially, letter from H. A. Lorentz to E. Schrödinger, May 27, 1926 in Ref. 339.
Letter from M. Planck to E. Schrödinger, May 24, 1926.
Letter from M. Planck to E. Schrödinger, June 4, 1926.
Letter from E. Schrödinger to M. Planck, June 11, 1926.
Letter from E. Schrödinger to W. Wien, March 19, 1926.
Letter from W. Wien to E. Schrödinger, March 21, 1926.
M. Born, W. Heisenberg, and P. Jordan, Zur Quantenmechanik II,Z. Phys. 36, 557–615 (1926).
E. Schrödinger, Über das Verhältnis der Heisenberg-Born-Jordanschen Quantenmechanik zu der meinen,Ann. Phys. 79, 734–756 (1926); “On the Relation between the Quantum Mechanics of Heisenberg, Born, and Jordan, and That of Schrödinger,” inCollected Papers on Wave Mechanics, (Blackie and Son, Ltd., London and Glasgow, 1927), p. 45.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 735; English translation, pp. 45–46.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, pp. 735–736, English translation, p. 46.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 726; English translation, p. 46.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 726; English translation, pp. 46–47.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 737; slightly revised English translation, p. 47.
W. Heisenberg, Über quantenmechanische Umdeutung kinematischer und mechanischer Beziehungen,Z. Phys. 33, 879–893 (1925), Eq. (16).
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 244, p. 362, Eq. (5).
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, pp. 737–738; English translation, p. 47.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 739; English translation, pp. 48–49.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, pp. 745–746; English translation, p. 54.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 749, English translation, p. 56.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 750; English translation, p. 57.
Letter from W. Pauli to G. Wentzel, May 8, 1926.
Letter from W. Pauli to P. Jordan, April 12, 1926.
C. Eckart, The Solution of the Problem of the Simple Oscillator by a Combination of the Schrödinger and the Lanczos Theories,Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 12, 473–476 (1926), p. 473.
C. Eckart, Operator Calculus and the Solution of the Equations of Quantum Dynamics,Phys. Rev. 28, 711–726 (1926).
C. Eckart, Ref. 365, p. 711.
L. Flamm, Die Grundlagen der Wellenmechanik,Phys. Z. 27, 600–617 (1926).
L. de Broglie, “Remarques sur la nouvelle Mécanique ondulatoire,”Compt. Rend. (Paris)183, 272–274 (1926), p. 272.
P. A. M. Dirac, On the Theory of Quantum Mechanics,Proc. R. Soc. London A 112, 661–677 (1926).
C. G. Darwin, The Electron as a Vector Wave,Nature (London) 119, 282–284 (1927).
E. Fues, Das Eigenschwingungsspektrum zweiatomiger Moleküle in der Undulationsmechanik,Ann. Phys. 80, 367–396 (1926).
K. Schwarzschild, Zur Quantenhypothese,Sitz. Preuss. Akad. Wiss. (Berlin), 548–568 (1916).
T. Heurlinger,Untersuchungen über die Struktur der Bandenspektren, Doctoral Dissertation, University of Lund, 1918;Zur Theorie der Bandenspektren, Phys. Z. 20, 188–190 (1919); Über Atomschwingungen und Molekülspektra,Z. Phys. 1, 82–91 (1920).
W. Lenz, Zur Theorie der Bandenspektren,Verh. Dtsch. Phys. Ges. 21, 632–643 (1919).
A. Kratzer, Die ultraroten Rotationsbanden der Halogenwasserstoffe,Z. Phys. 3, 289–307 (1920); Die spektropische Bestätigung der Isotope des Chlors,Z. Phys. 3, 460–465 (1920); Störungen und Kombinationsprinzip im System der violetten Cyanbanden,Sitz. Gayer. Akad. Wiss. (München), 107–118 (1922).
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 522 ff.
See A. Sommerfeld,Atombau und Spektrallinien, 4th edn., (Fried. Vieweg & Sohn, Braunschweig, 1924), p. 833 ff.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 526; English translation, p. 39.
E. Schrödinger, Quantisierung als Eigenwertproblem. (Dritte Mitteilung: Störungstheorie, mit Anwendung auf den Starkeffekt der Balmerlinien),Ann. Phys. 80, 437–490 (1927);Collected Papers on Wave Mechanics, pp. 62–101.
L. Mensing, Die Rotations-Schwingungsbanden nach der Quantenmechanik,Z. Phys. 36, 814–823 (1926).
W. Heisenberg, Ref. 355, pp. 89–893.
M. Born and P. Jordan, Zur Quantenmechanik,Z. Phys. 34, 858–888 (1925), p. 860.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, pp. 513–514; English translation, p. 30.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 753; English translation, p. 59.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 379, p. 470–471, 474; English translation, pp. 88, 90.
W. Pauli, Über das Wasserstoffspektrum vom Standpunkt der neuen Quantenmechanik,Z. Phys. 36, 336–363 (1926).
Letter from W. Pauli to G. Wentzel, May 8, 1926.
Letter from W. Pauli to A. Landé, June 2, 1926.
Letter from W. Pauli to G. Wentzel, July 5, 1926.
G. Wentzel, Über die Intensitäten in der Röntgenspektren,Naturwissenschaften 14, 621–622 (1926).
G. Wentzel, Ref. 390, p. 621.
G. Wentzel, Ref. 390, pp. 621–622.
A. Jönsson, Intensitätsmessungen von Röntgenstrahlen mit Hilfe der Geigerschen Spitzkammer,Z. Phys. 36, 426–456, 1926.
H. Hönl, Die Intensitäten der Zeemankomponenten,Z. Phys. 31, 340–354 (1925); Zum Intensitätsproblem der Spektrallinien,Ann. Phys. 79, 273–323 (1926).
R. H. Fowler, Applications of the Correspondence Principle to the Theory of Line Intensities in Band Spectra,Philos. Mag. 49, 1272–1288, 1925.
See E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, Section 3.3.
E. Fues, Zur Intensität der Bandenlinien und des Affinitätsspektrums zweiatomiger Moleküle,Ann. Phys. 81, 281–313 (1926).
E. Schrödinger, Quantisierung als Eigenwertproblem. (Vierte Mitteilung),Ann. Phys. 81, 109–139 (1926); inCollected Papers on Wave Mechanics, pp. 102–123.
See E. Fues, Ref. 397, Eq. (26), where Fues used a slightly different energy parameter.
E. Fues, Ref. 397, p. 313.
I. Waller, Der Starkeffekt zweiter Ordnung bei Wasserstoff und die Rydbergkorrektion der Spektra von He und Li+,Z. Phys. 38, 635–646 (1926).
I. Waller, Ref. 401, pp. 640–641.
G. Wentzel, Eine Verallgemeinerung der Quantenbedingungen für die Zwecke der Wellenmechanik,Z. Phys. 38, 518–529 (1926).
C. Eckart, The Hydrogen Spectrum in the New Quantum Theory,Phys. Rev. 28, 927–935 (1926).
See, e.g., Ref. 389.
C. Eckart, Ref. 404, p. 935.
P. S. Epstein, The Stark Effect from the Point of View of Schrödinger's Quantum Theory,Phys. Rev. 28, 695–710 (1926).
See P. S. Epstein, Ref. 407, p. 708, Eq. (61).
M. Born, Zur Quantenmechanik der Stoßvorgänge. (Voläufige Mitteilung),Z. Phys. 37, 863–867 (1926).
M. Born, Ref. 409, p. 863.
M. Born and N. Wiener, A New Formulation of the Laws of Quantization of Periodic and Aperiodic Phenomena,J. Math. Phys. M.I.T. 5, 84–98 (1926).
M. Born, Ref. 409, p. 864.
M. Born, Quantenmechanik der Stoßvorgänge,Z. Phys. 38, 803–827 (1926).
M. Born, Ref. 409, p. 864.
M. Born, Ref. 413, p. 803.
M. Born, Ref. 413, p. 804.
For details of Born's treatment of atomic collision processes, see J. Mehra and H. Rechenberg,The Historical Development of Quantum Theory, (Springer-Verlag, New York, 1987), Part 2, Chapter IV, Section 4, pp. 723–735.
M. Born, Ref. 413, p. 826.
Letter from W. Heisenberg to W. Pauli, May 5, 1926.
Letter from W. Heisenberg to M. Born, May 26, 1926.
W. Heisenberg, Mehrkörperproblem und Resonanz in der Quantenmechanik,Z. Phys. 38, 411–426 (1926).
Letter from H. Heisenberg to W. Pauli, June 8, 1926.
W. Heisenberg, Über die Spektra von Atomsystemen mit zwei Elektronen,Z. Phys. 39, 499–518 (1926).
W. Heisenberg, Ref. 423, p. 518.
Letter from W. Heisenberg to W. Pauli, July 28, 1926.
W. Heisenberg, in conversation with J. Mehra, April 1960 and June 1968.
P. A. M. Dirac, The Fundamental Equations of Quantum Mechanics,Proc. R. Soc. London A 109, 642–653 (1925); Quantum Mechanics and a Preliminary Investigation of the Hydrogen Atom,Proc. R. Soc. London A 110, 561–579 (1926); Relativity Quantum Mechanics with an Application to Compton Scattering,Proc. R. Soc. London A 111, 405–423 (1926); On Quantum Algebra,Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 23, 412–418 (1926).
P. A. M. Dirac, On the Theory of Quantum Mechanics,Proc. R. Soc. London A 112, 661–677 (1926).
P. A. M. Dirac, The Elimination of Nodes in Quantum Mechanics,Proc. R. Soc. London A 111, 281–305 (1926).
P. A. M. Dirac, Relativity Quantum Mechanics with an Application to Compton Scattering,Proc. R. Soc. London A 111, 405–423 (1926). Dirac noted in this paper that some difficulties arise between the “quantum energy”E and the quantum mechanical Hamiltonian, because the new variableE ought to commute with, say, the position variable, whereas the Hamiltonian does not do so.
E. Fermi presented a short note, Sulla quantizzazione del gas perfetto monoatomico,Rend. R. Accad. Lincei 3, 145–149 (1926), on February 7, 1926, and an extended version, Zur Quantelung des idealen einatomigen Gases,Z. Phys. 36, 902–912 (1926), was received on March 26, 1926. Fermi wrote to Dirac on September 1926, drawing his attention to his own earlier work.
P. A. M. Dirac, in Conversations with J. Mehra, June 1968 at Trieste, Italy; also AHQP Interview with Dirac.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 244, p. 372; English translation, p. 9.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, pp. 489–514.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 506; English translation, p. 25.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 256, p. 508; English translation, p. 26.
Letter from W. Wien to E. Schrödinger, May 13, 1926.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 735, footnote 2; English translation, p. 46, footnote 1.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 751.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 752.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 349, p. 753 English translation, p. 59. Schrödinger's claim with respect to the possibility of treating collision processes in wave mechanics was substantiated a few months later by the work of Max Born, as we have reported earlier.
Letter from E. Schrödinger to W. Wien, June 18, 1926.
Letter from E. Wigner to J. Mehra, November 20, 1985.
E. Schrödinger, Quantisierung als Eigenwertproblem. (Vierte Mitteilung),Ann. Phys. 81, 109–139 (1926), p 109; inCollected Papers on Wave Mechanics, pp. 102–123, p. 102.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 446, p. 110; English translation, p. 103.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 446, p. 110; English translation, p. 103.
R. Courant and D. Hilbert, Ref. 313, Chapter V, Section 8.
P. A. M. Dirac, Ref. 428, pp. 674–676.
P. A. M. Dirac, The Quantum Theory of Emission and Absorption of Radiation,Proc. R. Soc. London A 114, 243–265 (1927); The Quantum Theory of Dispersion,Proc. R. Soc. London A 114, 610–624 (1927).
Letter from W. Wien to E. Schrödinger, June 23, 1926.
See the announcement inVerh. Dtsch. Phys. Ges. 7, 36 (1926). Walther Nernst chaired the meeting.
The meeting was chaired by the astrophysicist Robert Emden. [SeeVerh. Dtsch. Phys. Ges. 7, 38 (1926).]
E. Schrödinger, An Undulatory Theory of the Mechanics of Atoms and Molecules,Phys. Rev. 28, 1049–1070 (1926).
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 456, p. 1049.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 456, p. 1050.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 456, p. 1070.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 446, p. 139; English translation, p. 123.
Letter from A. Einstein to A. Sommerfeld, August 21, 1926.
W. Heisenberg,Gesammelte Werke/Collected Works, Series C/Volume IV:Biographisches und Kernphysik, (R. Piper Verlag, Munich, Zurich, 0000), pp. 26–27.
Letter from A. Sommerfeld to W. Pauli, July 26, 1926.
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 446, pp. 133–134; English translation, p. 119.
Letter from W. Pauli to P. Jordan, Ref. 363, Eq. (3).
O. Klein, Quantentheorie und fünfdimensionale Relativitätstheorie,Z. Phys. 37, 895 (1926).
T. Kaluza, Zum Unitätsproblem de Physik,Sitzber. Preuss. Akad. Wiss. (Berlin), 966–972 (1921).
O. Klein, Ref. 466, p. 895.
V. Fock, Zur Schrödingerschen Wellenmechanik,Z. Phys. 38, 242–250 (1926).
V. Fock, Über die invariante Form der Wellen- und der Bawegungsgleichungen für einen geladenen Massenpunkt,Z. Phys. 39, 226–232 (1926).
Th. De Donder and F. H. van den Dungen, La quantification déduite de la Gravifique einsteinienne,Compt. Rend. (Paris) 183, 22–24 (1926).
Th. De Donder, Application de la quantification de la Gravifique einsteinienne,Compt. Rend. (Paris) 183, 594–595 (1926).
L. de Broglie, Remarques sur la nouvelle Mécanique ondulatoire,Compt. Rend. (Paris) 183, 272–274 (1926). De Broglie's method of deriving Eq. (205) was basically the one originally pursued by Schrödinger and independently given by Pauli.
J. Kudar, Zur vierdimensionalen Formulierung der undulatorischen Mechanik,Ann. Phys. 81, 632–636 (1926); Schrödingersche Wellengleichung und vierdimensionale Relativitätsmechanik,Phys. Z. 27, 724 (1926).
W. Gordon, Der Comptoneffekt nach der Schrödingerschen Theorie,Z. Phys. 40, 117–133 (1926).
Pauli called Eq. (205) “the equation with many fathers”: “I do not believe that the relativistic equation of second order with many fathers corresponds to reality” (Letter from W. Pauli to E. Schrödinger, November 22, 1926); also see H. Kragh, Equation with Many Fathers: The Klein-Gordon Equation in 1926,Am. J. Phys. 52, 1024–1033 (1984), and J. Mehra and H. Rechenberg,The Historical Development of Quantum Theory, Volume 5, Part 2, (Springer-Verlag, New York, 1987), Chapter IV, Section 5.
Letter from W. Heisenberg to W. Pauli, June 8, 1926.
Letter from W. Heisenberg to W. Pauli, July 28, 1926.
Letter from N. Bohr to E. Schrödinger, September 11, 1926.
For an account of Schrödinger's visit to Copenhagen, see J. Mehra and H. Rechenberg,The Historical Development of Quantum Theory (Springer-Verlag, New York, 1987), Volume 5, Part 2, Chapter IV, Section 5, and K. Stolzenburg, Die Entwicklung des Bohrschen Komplementaritätsgedankens in der Jahren 1924 bis 1929, Doctoral Dissertation, University of Stuttgart, 1975.
Letter from E. Schrödinger to N. Bohr, September 21, 1926.
Telegram from E. Schrödinger to N. Bohr, September 27, 1926.
See W. Heisenberg,Physics and Beyond (Harper and Row, New York, Evanston, and London, 1971), pp. 73–75.
See J. Mehra and H. Rechenberg, Ref. 481, p. 823, and footnote 295.
Letter from E. Schrödinger to W. Wien, October 21, 1926.
Letter from N. Bohr to R. H. Fowler, October 26, 1926.
G. Breit, A Correspondence Principle in the Compton Effect,Phys. Rev. 27, 362–372 (1926).
E. Schrödinger, Über den Comptoneffekt,Ann. Phys. 82, 257–264 (1927).
E. Schrödinger, Über das thermische Gleichgewicht zwischen Licht-und Schallstrahlen,Phys. Z. 25, 89–94 (1924).
G. Wentzel, Zur Theorie des Photoelektrischen Effekts,Z. Phys. 40, 574–589 (1926).
G. Wentzel, Über die Richtungsverteilung der Photoelektronen,Z. Phys. 41, 828–832 (1927).
J. Robert Oppenheimer, Quantentheorie des kontinuierlichen Absorptionsspektrums,Naturwissenschaften 14, 1282 (1926).
J. Robert Oppenheimer, On the Quantum Theory of the Problem of Two Bodies,Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 23, 422–431 (1926); Quantum Theory and Intensity Distribution of Continuous Spectra,Nature (London) 18, 771 (1926).
J. Robert Oppenheimer, Zur Quantenmechanik kontinuierlichen Spektren,Z. Phys. 41, 268–293 (1927).
C. Manneback, Die Dielektrizitätskonstante der zweiatomigen Dipolgase nach der Wellenmechanik,Phys. Z. 27, 563–569 (1926).
L. Mensing and W. Pauli, Über die Dielektrizitätskonstante von Dipolgasen nach der Quantenmechanik,Phys. Z. 27, 509–512 (1926).
C. Manneback, Ref. 496,.
F. Reiche, Die Quantelung des symmetrischen Kreisels nach Schrödingers Undulationsmechanik,Z. Phys. 39, 444–464 (1926).
E. Schrödinger, Ref. 345, pp. 747–748.
H. Rademacher and F. Reiche, Die Quantelung des symmetrischen Kreisels nach Schrödingers Undulationsmechanik. II,Z. Phys. 41, 453–493 (1927).
D. M. Dennison, The Rotation of Molecules,Phys. Rev. 28, 318–333 (1926).
R. K. Kronig and I. I. Rabi, The Symmetrical Top in the Undulatory Mechanics,Phys. Rev. 29, 262–269 (1927).
C. Manneback, Dielektrizitätskonstante und Starkeffekt polyatomiger Dipolgase mit symmetrischen Molekülen nach der Wellenmechanik,Phys. Z. 28, 72–84 (1927).
W. Pauli, Über das Wasserstoffmolekülions,Ann. Phys. 68, 177–240 (1922).
K. F. Niessen,Zur Quantentheorie des Wasserstoffmolekülions, Doctoral Dissertation, University of Utrecht, Utrecht: I. van Druten.
Letter from W. Heisenberg to W. Pauli, November 23, 1926.
Øyvind Burrau, Berechnung des Energiewertes des Wasserstoffmolekül-Ions (H +2 ) im Normalizustand,Kgl. Dansk. Vid. Selsk. Math.-Fys. Medd. 7, No. 14 (1927).
E. Schrödinger, Reisetagebuch. See K. von Meyenn, Die Rezeption der Wellenmechanik und Schrödingers Reise nach Amerika im Winter 1926/27,Gesnerus 39, 261–277 (1982).
Letter from E. Schrödinger to W. Wien, September 3, 1927.
A. Schrödinger, AHQP Interview, April 5, 1963, p. 8.
C. L. Davisson and L. H. Germer, The Scattering of Electrons by a Single Crystal of Nickel,Nature (London) 119, 558–560 (1927).
G. P. Thomson and A. Reid, Diffraction of Cathode Rays by a Thin Film,Nature (London) 119, 890 (1927).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Additional information
This article (in three parts) is an expanded version of the Schrödinger Centenary Lecture delivered by me at CERN (Organisation Européenne pour la Recherche Nucléaire), 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland, on July 30, 1987.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mehra, J. Erwin Schrödinger and the rise of wave mechanics. III. Early response and applications. Found Phys 18, 107–184 (1988). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01882930
Received:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01882930