Abstract
This paper offers a narrative approach to understanding the process of clinical reasoning in complex cases involving medical uncertainty, moral ambiguity, and futility. We describe a clinical encounter in which the pediatric health care team experienced a great deal of conflict and distrust as a result of an ineffective process of interpretation and communication. We propose a systematic method for analyzing the technical, ethical, behavioral, and existential dimensions of the clinical reasoning process, and introduce the Clinical Reasoning Discussion Tool—a dialogical and interpretive device aimed at improving communication, understanding, empathy, and moral deliberation in the clinical setting.
Article PDF
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
American Academy of Pediatrics. (1996). Committee on bioethics, policy statement, ethics and the care of critically ill infants and children. Pediatrics, 98, 149–152.
Attig, T. (1996). Beyond pain: The existential suffering of children. Journal of Palliative Care, 12, 20–23.
Barnard, D. (1988). Love and death: Existential dimensions of physicians' difficulties with moral problems. The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 13, 393–409.
Blackhall, L. J. (1987). Must we always use CPR? New England Journal of Medicine, 317, 1281–1285.
Boisaubin, E., & Carter, M. A. (1999). Optimizing ethics services and education in a teaching hospital: Rounds versus consultation. The Journal of Clinical Ethics, 10, 294–299.
Brody, H. (1987). Stories of sickness. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Brody,H. (1994).‘My story is broken, can you help me fix It?’ Medical ethics and the joint construction of narrative. Literature and Medicine, 13, 79–92.
Caplan, A. L., Engelhardt, H. T., & McCartney, J. J. (1981). Concepts of health and disease: Interdisciplinary perspectives. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company.
Caplan, A. L. (1996). Odds and ends: Trust and the debate over medical futility. Annals of Internal Medicine, 125, 688–689.
Cassell, E. J. (1985). Talking with patients: The theory of doctor-patient communications. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Chambers, T. S. (1994). The bioethicist as author: The medical ethics case as rhetorical device. Literature and Medicine, 13, 66–78.
Chambers, T. S. (1996). From the ethicist's point of view: The literary nature of ethical inquiry. Hastings Center Report, 26, 25–32.
Cohler, B. J. (1982). Personal narrative and life course. In P. B. Bates & O. G. Brim (Eds.), Life-span development and behavior(pp. 205–241). New York: Academic Press.
Coles, R. (1989). The call of stories: Teaching and the moral imagination. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.
Dickinson, G. E., & Tournier, R. E. (1994). A decade beyond medical school: A longitudinal study of physicians' attitudes toward death and terminally-ill patients. Social Science & Medicine, 38, 1397–1400.
Fleischman, A. R., Nolan, K., Dubler, N., Epstein, M., Gerber, M., Jellinek, M. S., Litt, I., Miles, M., Oppenheimer, S., Shaw, A., Van Eyes, J., & Vaughan, V. (1994). Caring for gravely ill children. Pediatrics, 94, 433–439.
Frank, A.W. (1995). The wounded storyteller: Body, illness, and ethics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Hunter, K. M. (1988). Making a case. Literature and Medicine, 7, 66–79.
Hunter, K. M. (1991). Doctors' stories: The narrative structure of medical knowledge. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Jameton, A. L. (1984). Nursing practice: The ethical issues. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Jellinek, M. S., Catlin, E. A., Todres, I. D., & Cassem, E. H. (1992). Facing tragic choices with parents in the neonatal intensive care unit: Clinical perspectives Pediatrics, 89, 119–122.
Jones, A. H. (1994). Reading patients-cautions and concerns. Literature and Medicine, 13, 190–200.
Jonsen, A., & Toulmin, S. (1998). The abuse of casuistry. Berkeley, CA: The University of California Press.
Jonsen, A., Siegler, M., & Winslade, W. (1992). Clinical ethics: A practical approach to ethical decisions in clinical medicine. New York: McGraw-Hill.
King James Version, The Bible. (2000). Isaiah 11:6.
King, N. (1992). Transparency in the neonatal intensive care. Hastings Center Report, 22, 18–25.
King, N. M. P., & Stanford, A. F. (1992). Patient stories, doctor stories, and true stories: A cautionary reading. Literature and Medicine, 11, 185–199.
Kleinman, A. (1980). Patients and healers in the context of culture. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Kleinman, A. (1988). The illness narratives: Suffering, healing, and the human condition. New York: Basic Books.
Kleinman, A. (1993). Medicine's symbolic reality: On a central problem in the philosophy of medicine. Inquiry, 16, 206–213.
Kopelman, L. M. (1997). The best-interests standard as threshold, ideal, and standard of reasonableness. Medical Philosophy, 22, 271–289.
Lantos, J. D. (1997). Do we still need doctors? New York: Routledge.
Levin, J. S., Larson, D. B., & Puchalski, C. M. (1997). Religion and spirituality in medicine: Research and education. Journal of the American Medical Association, 278, 792–793.
Lo, B., & Jonsen, A. (1980). Clinical decisions to limit treatment. Annals of Internal Medicine, 18, 1435–1439.
Marshall, P. A. (1995). Special supplement: The support study: Who's talking. Hastings Center Report, S10.
Mayeroff, B. (1992). Remembered lives: The work of ritual, storytelling, and growing older. Ann Arbor, MI: The University of Michigan Press.
Miles, S. H. (1991). Informed demand for‘non-beneficial’ medical treatment. New England Journal of Medicine, 325, 512–515.
Nelson, A. R. (1989). Humanism and the art of medicine. Journal of the American Medical Association, 262, 1228–1230.
Pellegrino, E. D. (1987).The anatomy of clinical-ethical judgments in perinatology and neonatology: A substantive and procedural framework. Seminars in Perinatology, 11, 202–209.
Penticuff, J. H. (1998). Defining futility in neonatal intensive care. Nursing Clinics of North America, 33, 339–352.
Poirier, S., & Brauner, D. J. (1990). The voices of the medical record. Theoretical Medicine, 11, 29–39.
President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research. (1983). Deciding to forego life-sustaining treatment: A report on the ethical, medical, and legal issues in treatment decisions. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
Puchalski, C. M., & Larson, D. B. (1998). Developing curricula in spirituality and medicine. Academic Medicine, 73, 970–974.
Rogers W. R.,& Barnard, D. (1979). Nourishing the humanistic in medicine. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Rushton, C. H., & Hogue, E. E. (1993). When parents demand‘everything.’ Pediatric Nursing, 19, 180–183.
Schneiderman, N. S., Jecker, N. S., & Jonsen, A. R. (1990). Medical futility: Its meanings and ethical implications. Annals of Internal Medicine, 112, 949–954.
Schon, D. (1987). Educating the reflective practitioner. San Francisco: Joseey Bass.
Smith, C. (1998). The meaning of birds: Birds of America-stories by Lorrie Moore. New York: Alfred A. Knoff.
Soloman, M. Z. (1993). How physicians talk about futility. The Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics, 2, 231–235.
Taylor, C. (1989). Sources of the self: The making of the modern identity. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Todorov, T. (1984). Mikhail Bakhtin: The dialogical principle trans. Wlad Godzich. In Anonymous, Theory And History of Literature. Minneapolis and London: The University of Minnesota Press.
Troug, R., Brett, A., & Frader, J. (1992). The problem with futility. New England Journal of Medicine, 326, 1560–1564.
Whiltshire, J. (1994). Beyond the ouija board: Dialogue and heteroglossia in the medical narrative. Literature and Medicine, 13, 211–228.
Youngner, S. J. (1999). The definition of death: Contemporary controversies. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
Youngner, S. J., Landefeld, C. S., Coulton, C. J., Juknialis, B.W., & Leary,M. (1989). Brain death and organ retrieval: A cross-sectional survey of knowledge and concepts among health professionals. Journal of the American Medical Association, 261, 2205–2210.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Carter, M.A., Robinson, S.S. A Narrative Approach to the Clinical Reasoning Process in Pediatric Intensive Care: The Story of Matthew. Journal of Medical Humanities 22, 173–194 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016653500071
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1016653500071