Abstract
Since the validity of Bell's inequalities implies the existence of joint probabilities for non-commuting observables, there is no universal consensus as to what the violation of these inequalities signifies. While the majority view is that the violation teaches us an important lesson about the possibility of explanations, if not about metaphysical issues, there is also a minimalist position claiming that the violation is to be expected from simple facts about probability theory. This minimalist position is backed by theorems due to A. Fine and I. Pitowsky.Our paper shows that the minimalist position cannot be sustained. To this end,we give a formally rigorous interpretation of joint probabilities in thecombined modal and spatiotemporal framework of `stochastic outcomes inbranching space-time' (SOBST) (Kowalski and Placek, 1999; Placek, 2000). We show in this framework that the claim that there can be no joint probabilities fornon-commuting observables is incorrect. The lesson from Fine's theorem is notthat Bell's inequalities will be violated anyhow, but that an adequate modelfor the Bell/Aspect experiment must not define global joint probabilities. Thus we investigate the class of stochastic hidden variable models, whichprima facie do not define such joint probabilities. The reasonwhy these models fail supports the majority view: Bell's inequalities are notjust a mathematical artifact.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
REFERENCES
Aspect, A., Dalibard, J., and Roger, G.: 1982, 'Experimental Test of Bell's Inequalities Using Time-Varying Analyzers', Physical Review Letters 49, 1804–1807.
Belnap, N.: 1992, 'Branching Space—Time', Synthese 92, 385–434.
Bugajski, S.: 1976, 'Joint Probabilities in Quantum Mechanics', Unpublished typescript, Katowice.
Bugajski, S.: 1978, 'A Remark on Joint Probability Distributions for Quantum Observables', Zeitschrift für Naturforschung 33a, 1383–1385.
De Beare, W., Mann, A., and Revzen: M.: 1999, 'Locality and Bell's Theorem', Foundations of Physics 29, 67–77.
Fine, A.: 1982a, 'Hidden Variables, Joint Probability, and the Bell Inequalities', Physical Review Letters 48, 291–295.
Fine, A.: 1982b, 'Joint Distributions, Quantum Correlations, and Commuting Observables', Journal of Mathematical Physics 23, 1306–1310.
Hofer-Szabó, G., Rédei, M., and Szabó, L. E.: 1999, 'On Reichenbach's Common Cause Principle and Reichenbach's Notion of Common Cause', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 50, 377–399.
Huelga, S., Ferrero, M., and Santos, E.: 1995, 'Loophole-free Test of the Bell Inequality', Physical Review A 51, 5008–5011.
Kowalski, T. and Placek, T.: 1999, 'Outcomes in Branching Space—Time', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 50, 349–375.
Landau, L. J.: 1987, 'On the Violation of Bell's Inequality in Quantum Theory', Physics Letters A120, 54–56.
Nelson, E.: 1967, Dynamical Theories of Brownian Motion, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Pitowsky, I.: 1989, Quantum Probability — Quantum Logic, Springer, Berlin.
Placek, T.: 2000, 'Stochastic Outcomes in Branching Space—Time: Analysis of Bell's Theorem', British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 51(3), 445–475.
Reichenbach, H.: 1956, The Direction of Time, University of California Press, Berkeley.
Suppes, P. and Zanotti, M.: 1976, 'On the Determinism of Hidden Variable Theories with Strict Correlation and Conditional Statistical Independence of Observables', in P. Suppes (ed.), Logic and Probability in Quantum Mechanics, D. Reidel, Dordrecht, pp. 445–455.
Svetlichny, G., Redhead, M., Brown, H., and Butterfield, J.: 1988, 'Do the Bell Inequalities Require the Existence of Joint Probability Distributions?', Philosophy of Science 55, 387–401.
Szabó, L. E.: forthcoming 2000, 'Critical Reflections on Quantum Probability Theory', in M. Rédei and M. Stoelzner (eds), John von Neumann and the Foundations of Physics, Kluwer, Dordrecht.
Weihs, G., Jennewein, T., Simon, C., Weinfurter, H., and Zeilinger, A.: 1998, 'Violation of Bell's Inequality under strict Einstein Locality Conditions', Physical Review Letters 81, 5039–5043.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Müller, T., Placek, T. Against a Minimalist Reading of Bell's Theorem: Lessons from Fine. Synthese 128, 343–379 (2001). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011971808127
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1011971808127