Abstract
There is a tendency by scholars arguing for a more just and sustainable future to position the “ecological crisis” as a fundamental reason for major educational reforms. Relying on crisis-talk to fuel social and environmental justice and environmentalism reinforces the thinking of the past, which inadvertently perpetuates the acceptance of present cultural attitudes which frame our relationships with others and the natural world. To evaluate previous cultural thinking and associated traditions of Euro-West society, Chet Bowers asserts that we ought to analyze how assumptions are carried forward as metaphors, which are associated with attitudes towards science, technology, and nature. This pedagogy is called ecojustice education and serves to conserve and sustain cultural diversity and the biodiversity of Earth’s ecosystems, which are threatened and vulnerable. But, also carried forward in the language of ecojustice philosophy (and other ecological works) is a presumption that feeds into scientifically proving that a crisis exists, which is associated with organizing schools around an implicit shock doctrine of fear and urgency. This paper explores these assumptions and others associated with a supposition of ecological crisis. The ecological crisis has the potential to marginalize many diverse people who are needed during these times of increasing ecological awareness and uncertainties. Situating education (and the world) in the frenzy associated with crisis, versus the assertion that schools should increase awareness around the belief that a more sustainable lifestyle is beneficial for the individual, the community and the environment is a worthwhile debate and is rich with respect to research opportunities in education.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abram D (1996) The spell of the sensuous: perception and language in a more-than-human world. Vintage Books, New York
Aslaksen J, Myhr A (2007) “The worth of a wildflower”: precautionary perspectives on the environmental risk of GMOs. Ecol Econ 60(3):489–497
Berliner D, Biddle B (1995) The manufactured crisis: myths, fraud and the attack on America’s public schools. Perseus Books, New York
Bowers C (1993) Education, cultural myths, and the ecological crisis: toward deep changes. State University of New York Press, Albany
Bowers C (1996) The cultural dimensions of ecological literacy. J Environ Educ 27(2):5–10
Bowers C (2001) Educating for eco-justice and community. University of Georgia Press, Athens
Bowers C (2003) The environmental ethic implicit in three theories of evolution. Trumpeter 19(3):67–86
Bowers C (2004) Revitalizing the commons or an individualized approach to planetary citizenship: the choice before us. Educ Stud 36(1):45–58
Bowers C (2006) Transforming environmental education: making renewal of the cultural and environmental commons the focus of educational reform. Ecojustice Press, Eugene. http://cabowers.net/pdf/TransformingEE.pdf. Retrieved 24 Dec 2006
Bowler P (1992) The Norton history of the environmental sciences. W.W. Norton & Company, New York
Brewer C, Gross L (2003) Training ecologists to think with uncertainty in mind. Ecology 84(6):1412–1414
Burgman M, Lindenmayer D, Elith J (2005) Managing landscapes for conservation under uncertainty. Ecology 86(8):2007–2017
Callicott J (1999) Beyond the land ethic: more essays in environmental philosophy. State University of New York Press, Albany
Carson R (1962/1994) Silent spring. Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston
Chalmers A (1976/1982/1999) What is this thing called science? Hackett Publishing, Indianapolis
Christensen M, Graham M, Vinebrooke R, Finlay D, Paterson M, Turner M (2006) Multiple anthropogenic stressors cause ecological surprises in boreal lakes. Glob Change Biol 12:2316–2322
Clark J (2003a) Uncertainty in ecological inference and forecasting. Ecology 84(6):1349–1350
Clark J (2003b) Uncertainty and variability in demography and population growth: a hierarchical approach. Ecology 84(6):1370–1381
Code L (2006) Ecological thinking: the politics of epistemic location. Oxford University Press, Oxford and New York
Corcoran P (2004) What if? The educational possibilities of the earth charter. Educ Stud 36(1):108–117
Coyle K (2005) Environmental literacy in America: what ten years of NEETF/Roper research and related studies say about environmental literacy in the US. The National Environmental Education & Training Foundation, Washington, DC
de Melo-Martin I, Intemann K (2007) Can ethical reasoning contribute to better epidemiology? A case study in research on racial disparities. Eur J Epidemiol 22(4):215–221
Diamond J (2005) Collapse: how societies choose to fail or succeed. Penguin Books, New York
Ellner S, Fieberg J (2003) Using PVA for management despite uncertainty: effects of habitat, hatcheries, and harvest on Salmon. Ecology 84(6):1359–1369
Fuller M, Gross L, Duke-Sylvester S, Palmer M (2008) Testing the robustness of management decisions to uncertainty: everglades restoration scenarios. Ecol Appl 18(3):711–723
Furman G, Gruenewald D (2004) Expanding the landscape of social justice: a critical ecological analysis. Educ Adm Q 40(1):47–76
Gore A (2006) An inconvenient truth. Rodale, New York
Grimm K (2006) Katrina, Wilma and Me: learning to live with climate surprises? Geosci Can 33(2):76–80
Gruenewald D (2003) The best of both worlds: a critical pedagogy of place. Educ Res 32(4):3–12
Hill RJ (2003) Environmental justice: environmental adult education at the confluence of oppressions. In: Hill L, Clover D (eds) Environmental adult education: ecological learning theory, and practice for socioenvironmental change. New directions for adult and continuing education, no. 99. Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, pp 23–38
International Panel on Climate Change (2001) Climate change 2001: the scientific basis. Contribution of working group I to the third assessment report of the international panel on climate change. Cambridge University Press, UK
Jickling B, Wals A (2008) Globalization and environmental education: looking beyond sustainable development. J Curric Stud 40(1):1–21
Jucker R (2004) Have the cake and eat it: ecojustice versus development? Is it possible to reconcile social and economic equity, ecological sustainability, and human development? Some implications for ecojustice education. Educ Stud 36(1):10–26
Kuhn T (1962/1970/1996) The structure of scientific revolutions. The University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Leopold A (1949/1968) A sand County Almanac. Oxford University Press, London
Longino H (1990) Science as social knowledge: values and objectivity in scientific inquiry. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Louv R (2005) Last child in the woods: saving our children from nature-deficit disorder. Algonquin Books, Chapel Hill
Martin J (1985) Reclaiming a conversation: the ideal of the educated woman. Yale University Press, New Haven
Martusewicz R (2005) Eros in the commons: educating for eco-ethical consciousness in a poetics of place. Ethics Place Environ 8(3):331–348
Martusewicz R, Edmundson J (2005) Social foundations as pedagogies of responsibility and eco-ethical commitment. In: Butin D (ed) Teaching social foundations of education: contexts, theories, and issues. Lawrence Elrbaum Publishers, Mahwah, pp 71–91
Merchant C (2001) The death of nature. In: Zimmerman M, Callicott J, Sessions G, Warren K, Clark J (eds) Environmental philosophy: from animal rights to radical ecology. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, pp 322–342
Morrison R (1999) The spirit in the gene: humanity’s proud illusion and the laws of nature. Cornell University Press, Ithaca
Mueller M (2007) A philosophical analysis of Chet Bowers’. Ethical theory of ecojustice: shifting towards uncertainty thinking in science education. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Mueller M (2008) Ecojustice as ecological literacy is much more than being “green!” A philosophical review of Chet Bowers’ transforming environmental education: making the cultural and environmental commons the focus of educational reform—implications for commons education. Educ Stud 44(2):155–166
Mueller M, Bentley M (2007) Beyond the “decorated landscapes” of educational reform: toward landscapes of pluralism in science education. Sci Educ 91(2):321–338
Mueller M, Bentley M (in press) Environmental and science education in “developing nations”: a Ghanaian approach to renewing and revitalizing the local community and ecosystems. Journal of Environmental Education
National Research Council (2001) Climate change science: an analysis of some key questions. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
National Research Council (2002) Abrupt climate change: inevitable surprises. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
National Research Council (2003) Integrating research and education: biocomplexity investigators explore the possibilities. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
National Research Council (2007) Status of pollinators in North America. National Academy Press, Washington, DC
National Science Foundation (2003) Intellectual imperatives in ethnobiology. NSF biocomplexity workshop report. Missouri Botanical Garden, St. Louis
Noddings N (2003) Happiness and education. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Noddings N (2006) Critical lessons: what our schools should teach. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Orr D (1994) Earth in mind: on education, environment, and the human prospect. Island Press, Washington, DC
Pennisi E (2007) Variable evolution. Science 316:686–687
Pollack H (2003/2005) Uncertain science … uncertain world. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Regan H, Ben-Haim Y, Langford B, Wilson W, Lundberg P, Andelman S, Burgman M (2005) Robust decision-making under severe uncertainty for conservation management. Ecol Appl 15(4):1471–1477
Rolston HIII (2001) Challenges in environmental ethics. In: Zimmerman M, Callicott J, Sessions G, Warren K, Clark J (eds) Environmental philosophy: from animal rights to radical ecology. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, pp 126–146
Schwartz M, Iverson L, Prasad A, Matthews S, O’Connor R (2006) Predicting extinctions as a result of climate change. Ecology 87(7):1611–1615
Shiva V (1997) Biopiracy: the plunder of knowledge and nature. South End Press, Boston
Shiva V (2001) The impoverishment of the environment: women and children last. In: Zimmerman M, Callicott J, Sessions G, Warren K, Clark J (eds) Environmental philosophy: from animal rights to radical ecology. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, pp 287–303
Shiva V (2005) Earth democracy: justice, sustainability, and peace. South End Press, Cambridge
Smith G (2004) Cultivating care and connection: preparing the soil for a just and sustainable society. Educ Stud 36(1):73–92
Smith G, Williams D (eds) (1999) Ecological education in action: on weaving education, culture, and the environment. State University of New York Press, Albany
Sobel D (1996) Beyond ecophobia: reclaiming the heart in nature education. The Orion Society and the Myrin Institute, Great Barrington
Sobel D (2005) Place-based education: connecting classrooms & communities. The Orion Society, Great Barrington
Sterba J (2001) Three challenges to ethics: environmentalism, feminism, and multiculturalism. Oxford University Press, New York
Stewart A (2005) Bushido: the virtues of Rei and Makoto. Celtic Cat Publishing, Knoxville
Takacs D (2003) How does your positionality bias your epistemology? Thought Action 19(1):27–38
Taylor P (1986) Respect for nature: a theory of environmental ethics. Princeton University Press, Princeton
Thayer-Bacon B (2000) Transforming critical thinking: thinking constructively. Teachers College Press, New York
Thayer-Bacon B (2003) Relational (e)pistemologies. Peter Lang, New York
Thayer-Bacon B (2008) Beyond liberal democracy in schools: the power of pluralism. Teachers College Press, New York
Van Dover C, German C, Speer K, Parson L, Vrijenhoek R (2002) Evolution and biogeography of deep-sea vent and seep invertebrates. Science 295(5558):1253–1257
Warren K (2001) The power and the promise of ecological feminism. In: Zimmerman M, Callicott J, Sessions G, Warren K, Clark J (eds) Environmental philosophy: from animal rights to radical ecology. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, pp 322–342
Wayne K, Gruenewald D (2004) Introduction: special issue: ecojustice and education. Educ Stud 36(1):6–9
West C (2004) Democracy matters: winning the fight against imperialism. Penguin Books, New York
White L (1967) Our historical roots of the ecological crisis. Science 155:1203–1207
White C (2007) The idols of environmentalism. Orion 26(2):18–23
Williams T (2004) The open space of democracy. The Orion Society, Great Barrington
Willis K, Birks H (2006) What is natural? The need for a long-term perspective in biodiversity conservation. Science 314:1261–1265
Wilson E (2002) The future of life. Vintage Books, New York
Wilson E (2006) The creation: an appeal to save life on earth. W.W. Norton & Company, New York
Wolf M, DeAngelis D (2003) Uncertainty in spatially explicit animal dispersal models. Ecol Appl 13(3):794–805
Zimmerman M, Callicott J, Sessions G, Warren K, Clark J (eds) (2001) Environmental philosophy: from animal rights to radical ecology. Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs
Acknowledgments
The author thanks Barbara Thayer-Bacon, Arthur Stewart, Michael Bentley, John Peters, Amadou Sall, J. Steve Oliver, Christy Moroye, the editor and reviewers, for their thoughtful comments on previous drafts of this manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Mueller, M.P. Educational Reflections on the “Ecological Crisis”: EcoJustice, Environmentalism, and Sustainability. Sci & Educ 18, 1031–1056 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-008-9179-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11191-008-9179-x