Abstract
Two different concepts of distinguishability are often mixed up in attempts to derive in quantum mechanics the (anti)symmetry of the wave function from indistinguishability of identical particles. Some of these attempts are analyzed and shown to be defective. It is argued that, although identical particles should be considered as observationally indistinguishable in (anti)symmetric states, they may be considered to be conceptually distinguishable. These two notions of (in)distinguishability have quite different physical origins, the former one being related to observations while the latter has to do with the preparation of the system.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Blokhintsev, D. I.: 1964, Quantum Mechanics, D. Reidel, Dordrecht.
Dirac, P. A. M.: 1958, The Principles of Quantum Mechanics, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Gibbs, J. W.: 1902, Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics, Yale University Press, New Haven.
Goldberger, M. L. and K. M. Watson: 1964, Collision Theory, John Wiley, New York.
Green, H. S.: 1963, ‘A Generalized Method of Field Quantization’, Physical Review 90, 270–73.
Greenberg, N. I. and S. Raboy: 1982, ‘One-Body and Two-Body Operators on Systems of Identical Particles’, American Journal of Physics 50, 148–55.
Hestenes, D.: 1970, ‘Entropy and Indistinguishability’, American Journal of Physics 38, 840–45.
Jauch, J. M.: 1966, Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Reading, Mass., Chap. 15.
Kaplan, I. G.: 1976, ‘The Exclusion Principle and Indistinguishability of Identical Particles in Quantum Mechanics’, Soviet Physics Uspekhi 18, 988–94.
Landau, L. D. and E. M. Lifshitz: 1959, Quantum Mechanics, Pergamon Press, London.
Lyuboshitz, V. L. and M. I. Podgoretskii: 1969, ‘Interference of Nonidentical Particles’, Soviet Physics JETP 28, 469–75.
Lyuboshitz, V. L. and M. I. Podgoretskii: 1971, ‘The Question of the Identity of Elementary Particles’, Soviet Physics JETP 33, 5–10.
Margenau, H.: 1944, ‘The Exclusion Principle and its Philosophical Importance’, Philosophy of Science 11, 187–208.
Mathews, W. N. Jr. and M. A. Esrick: 1980, ‘Locality of the Field Operators of Many-Body Theory’, American Journal of Physics 48, 782–83.
Messiah, A.: 1958, Quantum Mechanics, North-Holland, Amsterdam.
Messiah, A. M. L. and O. W. Greenberg: 1964, ‘Symmetrisation Postulate and its Experimental Foundation’, Physical Review B136, 248–67.
Mirman, R.: 1973, ‘Experimental Meaning of the Concept of Identical Particles’, Nuovo Cimento 18B, 110–22.
de Muynck, W. M.: 1975, ‘Distinguishable- and Indistinguishable-Particle Descriptions of Systems of Identical Particles’, International Journal of Theoretical Physics 14, 327–46.
Robertson, B.: 1973, ‘Introduction to Field Operators in Quantum Mechanics’, American Journal of Physics 41, 678–90.
Sarry, M. F.: 1979, ‘Permutation Symmetry of Wave Functions of a System of Identical Particles’, Soviet Physics JETP 50, 678–80.
Schiff, L. I.: 1955, Quantum Mechanics, McGraw-Hill, New York.
Shadmi, Y.: 1978, ‘Teaching the Exclusion Principle With Philosophical Flavor’, American Journal of Physics 46, 844–48.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
de Muynck, W.M., van Liempd, G.P. On the relation between indistinguishability of identical particles and (anti)symmetry of the wave function in quantum mechanics. Synthese 67, 477–496 (1986). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00485944
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00485944