Abstract
Quine and Davidson employ proxy functions to demonstrate that the use of language (behaviouristically conceived) is compatible with indefinitely many radically different reference relations. They also believe that the use of language (behaviouristically conceived) is all that determines reference. From this they infer that reference is indeterminate, i.e. that there are no facts of the matter as to what singular terms designate and what predicates apply to. Yet referential indeterminacy yields rather dire consequences. One thus does wonder whether one can hold on to a Quine--Davidson stance in semantics-cum-metaphysics and still avoid embracing referential indeterminacy. I argue that one can. Anyone adhering to the behaviouristic account pivotal to the Quine--Davidson stance is bound to acknowledge certain facts about verbal behaviour -- that some utterances are tied to situations, that some utterances are tied to segments in situations, that some predicates have non-contextualised conditions of application, and that use involves causal dependencies. The restrictions from these facts ensure that only reference relations generated by means of rather exceptional proxy functions are compatible with verbal behaviour. I conclude that this allows one to rebuff the Quine--Davidson argument for the indeterminacy of reference, as it were, from within. I moreover tentatively conclude that the line of thought laid out provides good reason for just about anyone to hold that there are facts about reference after all.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
R. B. Barrett R. F. Gibson (Eds) (1990) Perspectives on Quine Blackwell Oxford
J. Barwise J. Perry (1983) Situations and Attitudes MIT Press Cambridge, MA
S. Blackburn (1994) ‘Enchanting Views’ P Clark B Hale (Eds) Reading Putnam Blackwell Oxford 12–30
E. Brown (1988) ArticleTitle‘Internal Realism–Transcendental Idealism?’ Midwest Studies in Philosophy 12 145–155
W. Child (1994) Causality Interpretation and the Mind Oxford University Press Oxford
P. Clark B. Hale (Eds) (1994) Reading Putnam Blackwell Oxford
M. J. Cresswell (1991) ‘Basic Concepts of Semantics’ A Stechow D Wunderlich (Eds) Semantics. An International Hand book of Contemporary Research de Gruyter Berlin, New York 24–31
D. Davidson (1963) ‘Action, Reasons, and Causes’ D. Davidson (Eds) Essays on Action and Events Clarendon Press Oxford 3–20
D. Davidson (1967a) ‘Truth and Meaning’ D. Davidson (Eds) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Clarendon Press Oxford 17–36
D. Davidson (1967b) ‘Causal Relations’ D. Davidson (Eds) Essays on Action and Events Clarendon Press Oxford 149–162
D. Davidson (1973a) ‘Radical Interpretation’ D. Davidson (Eds) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Clarendon Press Oxford 125–140
D. Davidson (1973b) ‘In Defence of Convention T’ D. Davidson (Eds) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Clarendon Press Oxford 65–76
D. Davidson (1974a) ‘Belief and the Basis of Meaning’ D. Davidson (Eds) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Clarendon Press Oxford 141–154
D. Davidson (1974b) ‘On the Very Idea of a Conceptual Scheme’ D. Davidson (Eds) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Clarendon Press Oxford 183–198
D. Davidson (1976) ‘Reply to Foster’ D. Davidson (Eds) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Clarendon Press Oxford 171–181
D. Davidson (1977) ‘Reality without Reference’ D. Davidson (Eds) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Clarendon Press Oxford 215–226
D. Davidson (1979) ‘The Inscrutability of Reference’ D. Davidson (Eds) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Clarendon Press Oxford 227–242
D. Davidson (1980) Essays on Action and Events Clarendon Press Oxford
D. Davidson (1982) ‘Rational Animals’ E Lepore B McLaughlin (Eds) Actions and Events: Perspectives on the Philosophy of Donald Davidson Blackwell Oxford 473–480
D. Davidson (1983) ‘A Coherence Theory of Truth and Knowledge’ E. Lepore (Eds) Truth and Interpretation Blackwell Oxford 307–319
D. Davidson (1984) Inquiries into Truth and Interpretation Clarendon Press Oxford
D. Davidson (1990a) ArticleTitle‘The Structure and Content of Truth’ Journal of Philosophy 87 279–328
D. Davidson (1990b) ‘Representation and Interpretation’ M. Said (Eds) Modelling the Mind Clarendon Press Oxford 13–26
D. Davidson (1990c) ‘Meaning Truth and Evidence’ RB Barrett RF Gibson (Eds) Perspectives on Quine Blackwell Oxford 68–79
D. Davidson (1990d) ‘Turing’s Test’ M. Said (Eds) Modelling the Mind Clarendon Press Oxford 1–11
D. Davidson (1991a) ‘Three Varieties of Knowledge’ P. Griffith (Eds) A.J. Ayer Memorial Essays Cambridge University Press Cambridge 153–166
D. Davidson (1991b) ArticleTitle‘Epistemology Externalized’ Dialectica 45 191–202
D. Davidson (1992) ArticleTitle‘The Second Person’ Midwest Studies in Philosophy 17 255–267
D. Davidson (1994) ‘The Social Aspect of Language’ B. McGuiness (Eds) The Philosophy of Michael Dummett Kluwer Dordrecht 1–16
D. Davidson (1995) ArticleTitle‘Laws and Cause’ Dialectica 49 263–278 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1746-8361.1995.tb00165.x
D. Davidson (1996a) ArticleTitle‘The Folly of Trying to Define Truth’ Journal of Philosophy 93 263–278
D. Davidson (1996b) ‘Subjective Intersubjective Objective’ P Coates DD Hutto (Eds) Current Issues in Idealism Thoemmes Bristol 155–177
D. Davidson (1997a) ‘Indeterminism and Antirealism’ B. C. Kulp (Eds) Realism/Antirealism and Epistemology Lamman Maryland 1–15
D. Davidson (1997b) ‘Seeing Through Language’ J. Preston (Eds) Thought and Language Cambridge University Press Cambridge 15–27
D. Davidson (1999a) ‘Reply to Quine’ L. E. Hahn (Eds) The Philosophy of Donald Davidson Open Court La Salle, IL 81–86
D. Davidson (1999b) ‘Reply to Føllesdal’ L. E. Hahn (Eds) The Philosophy of Donald Davidson Open Court La Salle, IL 729–732
D. Davidson (1999c) ArticleTitle‘The Emergence of Thought’ Erkenntnis 51 1–10
M. Devitt (1984) Realism and Truth Blackwell Oxford
F. Dretske (1977) ArticleTitle‘Referring to Events’ Midwest Studies in Philosophy 2 369–378
G. Evans (1975) ‘Identity and Predication’ G. Evans (Eds) Collected Papers Clarendon Press Oxford 25–48
H. Field (1973) ArticleTitle‘Theory Change and the Indetermincay of Reference’ Journal of Philosophy 70 462–481
J. Fodor (1994) The Elm and the Expert. Mentalese and Its Semantics The 1993 Jean Nicod Lectures MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
D. Føllesdal (1999) ‘Triangulation’ L. E. Hahn (Eds) The Philosophy of Donald Davidson Open Court La Salle, IL 719–728
H. -J. Glock (1996) ‘On Safari with Wittgenstein Quine and Davidson’ RL Arrington HJ Glock (Eds) Wittgenstein and Quine Routledge London, New York 144–172
H. -J. Glock (2003) Quine and Davidson on Language Thought and Reality Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
C. Glymour (1982) ArticleTitle‘Conceptual Scheming, or, Confessions of a Metaphysical Realist’ Synthèse 51 169–180
L. E. Hahn (Eds) (1999) The Philosophy of Donald Davidson Open Court La Salle, IL
B. Hale C. Wright (1997) ‘Putnam’s Model-Theoretic Argument against Metaphysical Realism’ B Hale C Wright (Eds) A Companion to the Philosophy of Language Blackwell Companions to Philosophy Blackwell Oxford 427–457
M. Hallett (1994) ‘Putnam and the Skolem Paradox’ P Clark B Hale (Eds) Reading Putnam Blackwell Oxford 66–97
G. Harman (1982) ArticleTitle‘Metaphysical Realism and Moral Relativism: Reflections on Hilary Putnam’s Reason, Truth and History’ Journal of Philosophy 79 568–575
P. Horwich (1998) Meaning Clarendon Press Oxford
R. Kirk (1986) Translation Determined Clarendon Press Oxford
S. Kripke (1977) ArticleTitle‘Speaker’s Reference and Semantic Reference’ Midwest Journal of Philosophy 2 255–276 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1475-4975.1977.tb00045.x
S. Leeds (1973) ArticleTitle‘How to Think about Reference’ Journal of Philosophy 70 485–503
S. Leeds (1978) ArticleTitle‘Theories of Reference and Truth’ Erkenntnis 13 111–129
E. Lepore (Eds) (1987) Truth and Interpretation Blackwell Oxford
E. Lepore B. McLaughlin (Eds) (1985) Actions and Events: Perspectives on the Philosophy of Donald Davidson Blackwell Oxford
W. Lycan (1987) ‘Semantic Competence and Truth-Conditions’ E. Lepore (Eds) Truth and Interpretation Blackwell Oxford 143–155
D. H. Mellor (1995) The Facts of Causation Routledge London, New York
H. Putnam (1976) ‘Realism and Reason’ H. Putnam (Eds) Meaning and the Moral Sciences Routledge & Kegan Paul London 123–140
H. Putnam (1981a) Reason Truth and History Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
H. Putnam (1981b) ‘Why There Isn’t a Ready-made World’ H. Putnam (Eds) Realism and Reason. Philosophical Papers Cambridge University Press Cambridge 205–228
H. Putnam (1986) ‘Information and the Mental’ E Lepore (Eds) Truth and Interpretation Blackwell Oxford 262–271
H. Putnam (1989) ‘Model Theory and the ‘Factuality’ of Semantics’ A. George (Eds) Reflections on Chomsky Blackwell Oxford 212–232
W. V. O. Quine (1960) Word and Object MIT Press Cambridge, MA
W. V. O. Quine (1968) ‘Ontological Relativity’ W. V. O. Quine (Eds) Ontological Relativity and Other Essays Columbia New York 26–68
W. V. O. Quine (1969) Ontological Relativity and Other Essays Columbia New York
W. V. O. Quine (1972) ‘Methodological Reflections on Current Linguistic Theory’ D Davidson G Harman (Eds) Semantics of Natural Language Reidel Dordrecht 442–454
W. V. O. Quine (1973) The Roots of Reference Open Court La Salle
W. V. O. Quine (1975) ‘Mind and Verbal Disposition’ S. Guttenplan (Eds) Mind and Language Clarendon Press Oxford 83–95
W. V. O. Quine (1979a) ArticleTitle‘Cognitive Meaning’ Mind 62 129–142
W. V. O. Quine (1979b) ‘Fact of the Matter’ R Shahan C Swoyer (Eds) Essays in the Philosophy of W.V. Quine Harvester Oklahoma 155–169
W. V. O. Quine (1981a) Theories and Things Cambridge MA
W. V. O. Quine (1981b) ‘Things and Their Place in Theories’ W. V. O. Quine (Eds) Theories and Things Cambridge MA 1–23
W. V. O. Quine (1985) ‘Events and Reification’ E Lepore B McLaughlin (Eds) Actions and Events: Perspectives on the Philosophy of Donald Davidson Blackwell Oxford 162–171
W. V. O. Quine (1987) ArticleTitle‘Indeterminacy of Translation Again’ Journal of Philosophy 84 5–10
W. V. O. Quine (1990) ‘Three Indeterminies’ RB Barrett RF Gibson (Eds) Perspectives on Quine Blackwell Oxford 1–16
W. V. O. Quine (1992a) Pursuit of Truth revised edition Cambridge, MA
W. V. O. Quine (1992b) ArticleTitle‘Structure and Nature’ Journal of Philosophy 89 5–9
W. V. O. Quine (1993) ArticleTitle‘In Praise of Observation Sentences’ Journal of Philosophy 90 107–116
W. V. O. Quine (1994) ArticleTitle‘Assuming Objects’ Theoria 60 171–183 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1755-2567.1994.tb00935.x
W. V. O. Quine (1995) From Stimulus to Science Harvard University Press Cambridge, MA
G. Rey (1997) ArticleTitle‘Fodor and the Inscrutability Problem’ Mind and Language 12 475–489
S. L. Reynolds (1995) ArticleTitle‘Proxy Functions and the Indeterminacy of Reference’ Analysis 54 228–235
J. Rosner (1996) ArticleTitle‘Quine’s Global Structuralism’ Dialectica 50 235–241 Occurrence Handle10.1111/j.1746-8361.1996.tb00010.x
M. Said (Eds) (1990) Modelling the Mind Clarendon Press Oxford
S. R. Schiffer (1987) Remnants of Meaning MIT Press Cambridge, MA
B. Stroud (1995) ‘Quine on Exile and Acquiescense’ P Leonardi M Santambrogio (Eds) On Quine. New Essays Cambridge University Press Cambridge 37–52
C. J. L. Talmage (1997) ArticleTitle‘Meaning and Triangulation’ Linguistics and Philosophy 20 139–145
J. Cleve Particlevan (1992) ArticleTitle‘Semantic Supervenience and Referential Indeterminacy’ Journal of Philosopy 89 344–361
J. Wallace (1977) ArticleTitle‘Only in the Context of a Sentence Do Words Have Meaning’ Midwest Studies in Philosophy 2 144–163
R. Wilburn (1992) ArticleTitle‘Semantic Indeterminacy and the Realist Stance’ Erkenntnis 37 281–308
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Nimtz, C. Reassessing Referential Indeterminacy. Erkenntnis 62, 1–28 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10670-004-8975-1
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10670-004-8975-1