Abstract.
The ability to enforce the provisions of a code of conduct influences whether the code is effective in shaping behavior. Enforcement relies in part on the willingness of organization members to report violations of the code, but research from the business and educational environment suggests that fewer than half of those who observe code violations follow their organization’s procedures for reporting them. Based on a review of the literature in the business and educational environments, and a survey of 3605 students at a mid-sized comprehensive university, this paper attempts to make conceptual sense of the non-reporting phenomenon. We present a conceptual framework based on four distinct factors which we have labeled: (1) factual non-responsibility; (2) moral non-responsibility; (3) consequential exoneration; and, (4) functional exoneration. Each of these factors suggest a different remedial strategy as well as provide a theoretical foundation for future research. Testable propositions for future research are developed, and some implications for organization leaders are discussed.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
J. S. Adams A. Tashchian T. H. Shore (2001) ArticleTitle‘Codes of Ethics as Signals for Ethical Behaviour’ Journal of Business Ethics 29 199–211
J. R. Boatright J. (2003) Ethics and the Conduct of Business EditionNumber4 Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River
S. Bok (1983) ‘Whistle Blowing and Professional Responsibility,’ T. L. Beauchamp N. E. Bowie (Eds) Ethical theory and Business Prentice Hall Englewood Cliffs, NJ
Brenner J. S., and Molander E. A. (1971). ‘Is the Ethics of Business Changing?’ Harvard Business Review (January–February), 57–71.
Cole, S. and E. Kiss: 2000, ‘What Can We Do About Student Cheating?’ About Campus May–June, 5–12.
Christensen Hughes, J., B. Christian, J. Dayman, J. Kaufman, and N. Schmidt: 2001, ‘Fostering Academic Integrity’ Draft Report, University of Guelph Learning Commons, March 23, 2001.
J.C. Dalton (1998) ‘Creating a Campus Climate for Academic Integrity’ Dana D. Burnett Lynn Rudolph O. Karen Clifford (Eds) Academic Integrity Matters, National Association of Student Personnel Administrators (NASPA) Monograph 20 NASPA Washington, DC.
R. T. DeGeorge (1986) Business Ethics 2nd Edition Macmillan New York
A. Dupont J. Craig (1996) ArticleTitle‘Does Management Change the Experience of Retail Professionals: A Comparison of the Ethical Perceptions of Current Students with those of Recent Graduates?’ Journal of Business Ethics 15 IssueID8 815–826
Ethics Resource Centre (1994) Ethics in American Business: Policies, Programs and Perceptions. (Washington, DC).
Ethics Resource Centre (2003) National Business Ethics Survey: How Employees View Ethics in their Organizations (Washington, DC).
O. Ferrell L. Gresham (1995) ArticleTitle‘A Contingency Framework for Understanding Ethical Decision Making in Marketing,’ Journal of Marketing 49 87–96
R. Hardy (1982) ArticleTitle‘Preventing Academic Dishonesty: Some Important Tips for Political Science Professors’ Teaching Political Science 9 68–77
G. G. James (1980) ArticleTitle‘Whistle Blowing: Its Nature and Justification,’ Philosophy in Context 10 99–117
M. Jendrek (1989) ArticleTitle‘Faculty Reactions to Academic Dishonesty’ Journal of college Student Development 30 401–406
T. M. Jones (1991) ArticleTitle‘Ethical Decision Making by Individuals in Organizations: An Issue-contingent Model’ Academy of Management Review 16 IssueID2 366–395
L. A. Kidwell (2001) ArticleTitleStudent Honor Codes as a Tool for Teaching Professional Ethics Journal of Business Ethics 29 45–49
L. Kohlberg (1981) Essays on Moral Development Harper and Row San Francisco)
KPMG (2002) KPMG Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility Survey 2002
R. A. Larmer (1992) ArticleTitle‘Whistleblowing and Employee Loyalty’ Journal of Business Ethics 11 125–128
S. Lysonsky W. Gaidis (1991) ArticleTitleA Cross-cultural Comparison of the Ethics of Business Students Journal of Business Ethics 10 IssueID2 141–150
S. Maramark M. Maline (1993) ‘Academic Dishonesty among Students’ U.S. Department of Education, Office of Research Washington, DC
D. McCabe (1993) ArticleTitle‘Faculty Responses to Academic Dishonesty: The Influence of Student Honor Codes’ Research in Higher Education 34 IssueID4 647–657
McCabe D. and G. Pavela: 1998, ‘The Effect of Institutional Policies and Procedures on Academic Integrity,’ in Dana D. Burnett, Lynn Rudolph, and Karen O. Clifford (eds), Academic Integrity Matters, National Association of Student Personnel Administrators (NASPA) Monograph 20, (NASPA, Washington, DC) pp. 93–108.
D. McCabe L. Trevino K. Butterfield (1996) ArticleTitle‘The Influence of Collegiate and Corporate Codes of Conduct on Ethics-related Behaviour in the Workplace,’ Business Ethics Quarterly 6 461–476
D. McCabe L. Trevino K. Butterfield (1999) ArticleTitle‘Academic Integrity in Honor Code and Non-honor Code Environments’ The Journal of Higher Education 70 IssueID2 211–234
M. McNeil K. Pedigo (2000) ArticleTitle‘Western Australian Managers tell Their Stories: Ethical Challenges in International Business Operations’ Journal of Business Ethics 30 IssueID4 305–317
M. P. Miceli J. P. Near (1988) ArticleTitle‘Individual and Situational Correlates of Whistle-blowing’ Personnel Psychology 41 IssueID2 267–281
M. P. Miceli J. P. Near C. R. Schwenk (1991) ArticleTitle‘Who Blows the Whistle and Why?’ Industrial and Labor Relations Review 45 IssueID1 113–130
I. D. Montoya A. J. Richard (1994) ArticleTitle‘A Comparative Study of Codes of Ethics in Health Care Facilities and Energy Companies’ Journal of Business Ethics 13 713–718
Mullens, A.: 2000, ‘Cheating to win,’ University Affairs, December 2000: 22–28.
E. M. Nuss (1984) ArticleTitle‘Academic Integrity: Comparing Faculty and Student Attitudes’ Improving College and University Teaching 32 IssueID3 140–144
G. Pavela (1997) ArticleTitle‘Applying the Power of Association on Campus: A Model Code of Academic Integrity’ Journal of College and University Law 24 IssueID1 97–118
Z. R. Rezaee C. Elmore J. Z. Szendi (2001) ArticleTitle‘Ethical Behaviour in Higher Educational Institutions: The Role of the Code of Conduct’ Journal of Business Ethics 30 171–183
Richardson, J. E.: 1992, Annual Editions – Business Ethics 92/93 (Dushkin Publishing Group Guilford, Connecticut).
Rudolph, L. and L. Timm: 1998, ‘A Comprehensive Approach for Creating a Campus Climate that Promotes Academic Integrity,’ in D. Burnett L. Rudolph and K. Clifford (eds), Academic Integrity Matters, National Association of Student Personnel Administrators (NASPA) Monograph 20, (NASPA, Washington, DC) pp. 57–75.
F. Sierles I. Hendricks S. Circle (1980) ArticleTitle‘Cheating in Medical School’ Journal of Medical Education 55 124–125
Schwartz, M. and W. Cragg: 2000, ‘Corporate Codes of Ethics: Factors Leading to Effectiveness,’ Proceedings of the Academy of Management Annual Conference, Summer 2000.
Schneider, A.: 1999, ‘Why Professors Don’t Do More to Stop Students Who Cheat” The Chronicle of Higher Education, January 22, 1999.
R. L. Sims J. P. Keenan (1998) ArticleTitle‘Predictors of External Whistleblowing: Organizational and Intrapersonal Variables’ Journal of Business Ethics 17 IssueID4 411–421
A. Singhal (1982) ArticleTitle‘Factors in Students’ Dishonesty’ Psychological Reports 51 775–780
L. Trevino Nelson (1995) Managing Business Ethics Straight Talk about How to do it Right Wiley New York
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Nitsch, D., Baetz, M. & Hughes, J.C. Why Code of Conduct Violations go Unreported: A Conceptual Framework to Guide Intervention and Future Research. J Bus Ethics 57, 327–341 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-004-8203-6
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-004-8203-6