Abstract
Among many managers Charles Handy might well be described as a ‘world class’ management thinker. He is certainly the first British management author to have achieved international guru status. The author of widely-commended management best-sellers and MBA set texts, known through broadcasting and management videos, he has presented himself more recently as a self-styled ‘social philosopher’. But just how philosophical is he? Does he offer genuinely new ideas? And what explains his vast appeal? Ashly Pinnington considers three works from Handy’s social philosopher period. He argues that they are conservative and focused on the interests of managers and business owners rather than employees or society as a whole. Like a mediaeval friar seeking converts, Handy uses mythic structures and exempla to invest his claims and propositions with plausibility and authority. Drawing on research into management gurus as a phenomenon, Ashly Pinnington concludes that when we read authors like Handy we should attend not merely to the ‘philosophy’ but also to the way narrative techniques are used in conveying ideological and moral messages.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Scanlon L Narrative, authority and power: The medieval exemplum and the Chaucerian tradition Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1994 p 33
Clark T and Salaman G ‘Telling tales: management gurus’ narratives and the construction of managerial identity’ Journal of Management Studies March 35, 2, 1998 pp 137–162; Huczynski A Management gurus: what makes them and how to become one London: Routledge 1993; Jackson B G ‘The goose that laid the golden egg? A rhetorical critique of Stephen Covey and the effectiveness movement’ Journal of Management Studies May 36, 3, 1999 pp 353–377
Quoted in Scanlon op cit pp 31–32
Handy C The age of unreason London: Business Books 1989 p 42
Handy op cit p 21
Handy op cit p 42
Handy op cit p 4
Handy op cit p 54
Handy op cit p 92
Handy op cit p 189
Handy C The empty raincoat: making sense of the future London: Hutchinson 1994 p 3
Guest D ‘Human resource management and the American dream’ Journal of Management Studies 27, 4, 1990 pp 378–97
Jackson loc cit 1999
Jackson loc cit 1999
Bormann E G ‘Fantasy and rhetorical vision: the rhetorical criticism of social reality’ Quarterly Journal of Speech 58, 1972 pp 396–407
Burke K ‘Dramatism’ in: International Encyclopaedia of the Social Sciences VII New York: Macmillan 1968 pp 445–452
Handy op cit 1994 p 18
Handy op cit 1994 p 22
Cooper D J, Hinings C R, Greenwood R, and Brown J L ‘Sedimentation and transformation in organisational change: the case of Canadian law firms’ Organization Studies 17, 4, 1996 pp 623–647; Pinnington A H and Morris T J ‘Power and control in professional partnerships’ Long Range Planning 29, 6, 1996 pp 842–849
Handy op cit 1994 p 147
Handy op cit 1994 p 271
Clark and Salaman loc cit 1998
du Gay and Salaman loc cit 1992
Handy C The new alchemists London: Hutchinson 1999 p 12
Handy op cit 1999 p 31 aiu]26_Handy op cit 1999 p 52
Handy op cit 1999 p 239
Handy op cit 1999 p 238
Czarniawska B Writing management: organization theory as a literary genre Oxford: Oxford University Press 1999
Gabriel Y Storytelling in organizations: facts, fictions, and fantasies Oxford: Oxford University Press 2000
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Pinnington, A. Charles Handy: The Exemplary Guru. Philos. of Manag. 1, 47–55 (2001). https://doi.org/10.5840/pom2001136
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5840/pom2001136