Abstract
This paper examines Australian taxpayers' perceptions of their idealized tax practitioner as well as their perceptions of their current tax preparer. The analysis was based on survey responses from 2,040 randomly selected Australian taxpayers who completed the "Community Hopes, Fears and Actions Survey" (author, 2000). Three dimensions were identified as underlying taxpayer judgements of their idealized practitioner. A minority of the sample indicated that their ideal was a creative, aggressive tax planning type, a person who was well networked and familiar with tax office intelligence and enforcement priorities. A second type of idealized practitioner engaged in the cautious minimisation of tax. Unlike creative accountants, practitioners of this type avoided conflict, while being sophisticated about identifying opportunities to minimise tax. The most popular idealized type was the low risk, no fuss practitioner who was honest and risk averse. The data revealed that taxpayers are likely to find tax practitioners who have the attributes that they value most highly, but that when taxpayers' perceptions of their tax practitioner are combined with their ideals, only two substantive dimensions emerge, tax avoidance and doing the right thing. Our inability to distinguish tax practitioners who are seen to provide cautious and aggressive advice in practice has important implications for the growth of aggressive tax planning markets in the community.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Attwell, R. L. and A. J. Sawyer: 2001, 'The Ethical Attitudes of New Zealand Tax Practitioners-Still "Barely Passing" '?, New Zealand Journal of Taxation Law and Policy 7(2), 111-146.
Australian Bureau of Statistics: 2001, 2001 Census Data: Population and Housing (Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra).
Australian Taxation Office: 2002, Taxation Statistics 1999-2000 (Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra).
Ayres, F. L., B. R. Jackson and P. A. Hite: 1989, 'The Economic Benefits of Regulation: Evidence from Professional Tax Preparers', The Accounting Review LXIV(2), 300-312.
Bankman, J.: 2001, 'The Role of Accountants in Tax Evasion', paper presented at the 2nd International Conference of the Centre for Tax System Integrity, 'Taxpayers: Individualists or Concerned Citizens?', 10-11 December, Australian National University, Canberra.
Braithwaite, J.: 2002, Restorative Justice and Responsive Regulation (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
Commonwealth Ombudsman: 1999, The ATO and Budplan: Report of the Investigation into the Australian Taxation Office's Handling of Claims for Tax Deductions by Investors in a Tax-effective Financing Scheme Known as Budplan (Commonwealth Ombusdsman Office, Canberra).
Collins, J. H., V. C. Milliron and D. R. Toy: 1990, 'Factors Associated with Household Demand for Tax Preparers', Journal of the American Taxation Association 12, 9-25.
Cruz, C. A., W. E. Shafer and J. R. Strawser: 2000, 'A Multidimensional Analysis of Tax Practitioners' Ethical Judgments', Journal of Business Ethics 24, 223-244.
Donaldson, T. and T. W. Dunfee: 1999, Ties that Bind: A Social Contracts Approach to Business Ethics (Harvard Business School Press, Harvard).
Duncan, J. A., D. W. LaRue and P. M. J. Reckers: 1989, 'An Empirical Examination of the Influence of Selected Economic and Noneconomic Variables in Decision Making by Tax Professionals', Advances in Taxation 2, 91-106.
Erard, B.: 1993, 'Taxation with Representation: An Analysis of the Role of Tax Practitioners in Tax Compliance', Journal of Public Economics 52(2), 163-197.
Finn, D. W., L. B. Chonko and S. D. Hunt: 1988, 'Ethical Problems in Public Accounting: The View from the Top', Journal of Business Ethics 7, 605-615.
Fishkin, J. S.: 1997, The Voice of the People (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT).
Grbich, Y.: 2002, 'Tax Decision-making at the Cross Roads: Strategic Directions', paper presented at the 5th International Conference on Tax Administration, 4-5 April, ATAX, University of New South Wales, Sydney.
Hansen, D. R., R. L. Crosser and D. Laufer: 1992, 'Moral Ethics v. Tax Ethics: The Case of Transfer Pricing Among Multinational Corporations', Journal of Business Ethics 11, 679-686.
Hite, P. A. and G. McGill: 1992, 'An Examination of Taxpayers Preference for Aggressive Tax Advice', National Tax Journal 45, 389-403.
Hite, P. A. and A. Sawyer: 1998, 'An Investigation of Tax Preparer Effects on the Decision-Making Processes of Government Investigators', Advances in Taxation 10, 145-166.
Jackson, B. R. and V. C. Milliron: 1989, 'Tax Preparers: Government Agents or Client Advocates?', Journal of Accountancy (May), 76-83.
James, S., and C. Alley: 1999, 'Tax Compliance, Self-assessment, and Tax Administration in New Zealand? Is the Carrot or the Stick More Appropriate to Encourage Compliance?', New Zealand Journal of Taxation Law and Policy 5(1), 3-14.
Klepper, S. and D. S. Nagin: 1989, 'The Role of Tax Practitioners in Tax Compliance', Policy Sciences 22, 167-192.
Klepper, S., M. Mazur and D. S. Nagin: 1991, 'Expert Intermediaries and Legal Compliance: The Case of Tax Preparers', Journal of Law and Economics 34, 205-229.
McBarnet, D. and C. Whelan: 1999, Creative Accounting and the Cross-Eyed Javelin Thrower (John Wiley & Sons, New York).
Marshall, R. L., R. W. Armstrong and M. Smith: 1998, 'The Ethical Environment of Tax Practitioners: Western Australian Evidence', Journal of Business Ethics 17, 1265-1279.
Marshall, R. L., M. Smith and R. W. Armstrong: 1997, 'Self-assessment and the Tax Audit Lottery: The Australian Experience', Managerial Auditing Journal 21(1), 9-15.
Myers, A. J.: 1990, 'Tax Advice: The Lawyer's Ethical Responsibility', Australian Tax Review 19, 80-87.
Newberry, K. J., P. M. J. Reckers and R. W. Wyndelts: 1993, 'An Examination of Tax Practitioner Decisions: The Role of Preparer Sanctions and Framing Effects Associated with Client Condition', Journal of Economic Psychology 14, 439-452.
Richardson, M. and A. J. Sawyer: 2001, 'A Taxonomy of the Tax Compliance Literature: Further Findings, Problems and Prospects', Australian Taxation Forum 16(2), 137-320.
Rosen, R. E.: (1999), 'As the Big 5 Become Multi-Disciplinary Practices, Opportunities Abound for Tax Executives', The Tax Executive 51(2), 147-149.
Schisler, D L.: 1994, 'An Experimental Examination of Factors Affecting Tax Preparers' Aggressiveness? A Prospect Theory Approach', Journal of American Taxation Association 16(2), 124-142.
Schisler, D. L.: 1996, 'An Experimental Examination of the Effects of Withholding Positions and Tax Preparer Recommendations on Taxpayer Aggressiveness', Advances in Taxation 8, 149-173.
Senate Economics References Committee: 2001, Inquiry into Mass Marketed Tax Effective Schemes and Investor Protection: Interim Report (Parliament of the Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra).
Smith, K. W. and L. J. Stalans: 1991, 'Encouraging Tax Compliance with Positive Incentives: A Conceptual Framework and Research Directions', Law and Policy 13(1), 35-53.
Tan, L. M: 1999, 'Taxpayers' Preference for Type of Advice from Tax Practitioner: A Preliminary Examination', Journal of Economic Psychology 20, 431-447.
Thomas, W. I. and F. Znaniecki: 1918, The Polish Peasant in Europe and America (Alfred A. Knopf, New York).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sakurai, Y., Braithwaite, V. Taxpayers' Perceptions of Practitioners: Finding One Who is Effective and Does the Right Thing?. Journal of Business Ethics 46, 375–387 (2003). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1025641518700
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1025641518700