Race and Religious Transformations in Rome: Franz Cumont and Contemporaries on the Oriental Religions

Eline Scheerlinck; Danny Praet; Sarah Rey

doi:10.25162/historia-2016-0013

53906 Search results

Clear filter Show 53906 results

Article Authentication required

Subscibe in publisher´s online store Share via email

Race and Religious Transformations in Rome

Franz Cumont and Contemporaries on the Oriental Religions

Scheerlinck, Eline; Praet, Danny; Rey, Sarah

From the journal Historia Historia, Volume 65, June 2016, issue 2

Published by Franz Steiner Verlag

article, 13429 Words
Original language: English
Historia 2016, pp 220-243
https://doi.org/10.25162/historia-2016-0013

Abstract Related content References

Abstract

Contemporaries of Franz Cumont (1868-1947) often applied racial theories to the supposed cultural, spiritual and political decadence of Rome, holding Oriental immigrants and their religions responsible. In his Oriental Religions (1906) Cumont explicitly rejected Houston Stewart Chamberlain and Otto Seeck, arguing instead for spiritual progress in Late Antiquity, under Oriental influence. Our analysis shows certain ambiguities and stereotypes in Cumont’s publications on the Orient. We also present unpublished archive material from the Academia Belgica in Rome, showing Cumont accepted, in the 1920s, racial theories (Tenney Frank). He now explained the religious transformations in Rome by a change in the population.

Author information

Eline Scheerlinck

Danny Praet

Sarah Rey

Keywords

References

1. Banton, Michael 1998, Racial theories, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
2. Bernal, Martin 1991, Black Athena. The Afroasiatic roots of classical civilization. Volume I: the fabrication of Ancient Greece 1785-1985, London, Vintage (1987).
3. Berve, Helmut 1943, Imperium Romanum, Leipzig, Koehler & Amelang.
4. Bindman, David 2002, From Ape to Apollo. Aesthetics and the idea of race in the eighteenth century, Ithaca NY, Cornell University Press.
5. Blok, Josine 1996, “Proof and Persuasion in ‘Black Athena’: The Case of K. O. Müller”, Journal of the History of Ideas 57, pp. 705-724. DOI 10.1353/jhi.1996.0034
6. Bonnet, Corinne 1997 (ed.), La correspondance scientifique de Franz Cumont conservée à l’Academia Belgica de Rome, Études de philologie, d’archéologie et d’histoire anciennes, vol. 35, Bruxelles/ Rome, Institut historique belge de Rome.
7. Bonnet, Corinne 2009 “L’empire et ses religions. Un regard actuel sur la polémique Cumont-Toutain concernant la diffusion des ‘religions orientales”, in: Cancik, Hubert & Rüpke, Jörg (eds.), Die Religion des Imperium Romanum, Tübingen, Mohr Siebeck, pp. 55-74.
8. Bonnet, Corinne 2011, “‘Les dernières volontés du paganisme expirant’: Franz Cumont and ‘the decline and fall of Roman paganism’”, in: Gooch, De Vries & Molendijk 2011, pp. 91-107.
9. Bonnet, Corinne / Van Haeperen, Françoise 2006, “Introduction historiographique”, in Cumont 2006, pp. XI-LXXIV.
10. Bonnet, Corinne / Pirenne-Delforge, Vinciane / Danny, Praet 2009 (eds.), Les religions orientales dans le monde grec et romain: cent ans après Franz Cumont (1906-2006). Bilan historique et historiographique. Actes du colloque de Rome, 2006, Études de philologie, d’archéologie et d’histoire anciennes, vol. 45, Bruxelles/Rome, Institut historique belge de Rome.
11. Bonnet, Corinne / Ossola, Carlo / Scheid, John 2010 (eds.), Rome et ses religions: culte, morale, spiritualité. En relisant Lux Perpetua de Franz Cumont . Supplemento a Mythos, Rivista di Storia delle Religioni, Caltanissetta, Salvatore Sciascia.
12. Broughton, Thomas / Shannon, Robert 1990, “Tenney Frank”, in: Briggs, Ward & Calder, William (eds.), Classical scholarship. A biographical encyclopaedia, New York and London, Garland Press, pp. 68-76.
13. Challis, Debbie 2010, “The Ablest Race. The Ancient Greeks in Victorian Racial Theory”, in: Bradley, Mark (ed.), Classics and imperialism in the British Empire, Oxford, Oxford University Press, pp. 94-120.
14. Challis, Debbie 2013, The Archaeology of Race. The eugenic ideas of Francis Galton and Flinders Petrie, London, Bloomsbury.
15. Chamberlain, Stuart Houston 1903, Die Grundlagen des neunzehnten Jahrhunderts, München, F. Bruckmann K.-G., 1899-1941; 19034.
16. Cumont, Franz 1896, Textes et monuments figurés relatifs aux mystères de Mithra, 2 vols., Bruxelles, H. Lamertin, 1896-99. DOI 10.2307/288341
17. Cumont, Franz 1917, “Zodiacus”, in: Saglio, Edmond. Pottier, Edmond & Lafaye, Georges (eds.), Dictionnaire des antiquités grecques et romaines, Paris, Librairie Hachette et Cie, vol. 5, pp. 1046-1062.
18. Cumont, Franz 1926, Fouilles de Doura Europos, 1922-1923, 2 vols., Paris, Geuthner. DOI 10.2307/1837868
19. Cumont, Franz 2006, Bonnet, Corinne & Van Haeperen, Françoise (eds.), Les religions orientales dans le paganisme romain, Bibliotheca Cumontiana, Scripta Maiora, vol. 1, Rome & Torino, Academia Belgica & Nino Aragno.
20. Cumont, Franz 2013, Belayche Nicole & Mastrocinque, Attilio (eds.), Les mystères de Mithra, Bibliotheca Cumontiana, Scripta Maiora, vol. 3, Rome & Torino, Academia Belgica & Nino Aragno.
21. Cumont, Franz 2015, Danny Praet, Béatrice Bakhouche, Annelies Lannoy & Eline Scheerlinck (eds.), Franz Cumont, Astrologie, Bibliotheca Cumontiana, Scripta Minora, vol. 4, Rome & Torino, Academia Belgica, Belgisch Historisch Instituut te Rome & Nino Aragno.
22. Cumont, Franz 2016, Danny Praet, Annelies Lannoy & Eline Scheerlinck (eds.), Philosophie, Bibliotheca Cumontiana, Scripta Minora, vol. 1, Rome & Torino, Academia Belgica, Belgisch Historisch Instituut te Rome & Nino Aragno.
23. Demandt, Alexander 1984, Der Fall Roms. Die Auflösung des römischen Reiches im Urteil der Nachwelt, München, Beck, pp. 347-396.
24. Dühring, Eugen 1881, Die Judenfrage als Racen-, Sitten- und Culturfrage. Mit einer weltgeschichtlichen Antwort, Karslruhe & Leipzig, H. Reuther.
25. Frank, Tenney 1910, “Race Mixture in the Roman Empire”, in: American Historical Review, 21, pp. 689-708. DOI 10.2307/1835889
26. Frank, Tenney 1932, Aspects of social behavior in Ancient Rome, The Martin Classical Lectures, vol. 2, Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press. DOI 10.2307/4339322
27. Goldberg, David Theo / Solomos, John 2002 (eds.), A companion to racial and ethnic studies, Malden, MA & Oxford, Blackwell.
28. de Gobineau, Joseph Arthur 1855, Essai sur l’inégalité des races humaines, Didot, Paris, in: Gaulmier, Jean (ed.) & Boissel, Jean (coll.), Gobineau Oeuvres, vol. 1, Bibliothèque de la Pléiade, Paris, Gallimard, 1983, pp. 133-1174. DOI 10.1522/cla.goj.ess
29. de Gobineau, Joseph Arthur 1900, Les religions et les philosophies de l’ Asie centrale, Paris, Leroux, in: Gaulmier, Jean (ed.), Lesétieux, Pierre (coll.) & Monteil, Vincent (coll.), Gobineau, Oeuvres, vol. 2, Bibliothèque de la Pléiade, Paris, Gallimard, 1983, pp. 735-809.
30. Gooch, Todd / De Vries, Dawn / Molendijk, Arie 2011 (eds.), Papers of the Nineteenth Century Theology Group. American Academy of Religion (San Francisco Conference 2011), Eugene, Oregon, Wipf & Stock Publishers.
31. Grant, Madison 1916, The passing of the great race: or, the racial basis of European history, New York, C. Scribner’s Sons.
32. Günther, Hans 1929, Rassengeschichte des hellenischen und des römischen Volkes, München, J. F. Lehmann.
33. Günther, Hans 1935, Herkunft und Rassengeschichte der Germanen, München, J. F. Lehmann.
34. Hall, Jonathan 1997, Ethnic identity in Greek Antiquity, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
35. Harding, Sandra 2002, “Science, race, culture, Empire”, in: Goldberg & Solomos 2002, pp. 217-228.
36. Hentsch, Thierry 1988, L’Orient imaginaire. La vision politique occidentale de l’Est méditerranéen, Paris, Les éditions de Minuit.
37. Isaac, Benjamin 2004, The invention of racism, Princeton, Princeton University Press.
38. Lameere, William 1948, “Sur la tombe de Franz Cumont (1868-1947)”, Alumni 1947-1948, 17, pp. 99-158.
39. Lannoy, Annelies 2010, “Les masses vulgaires et les intelligences élevées. Les agents de la vie religeuse dans Lux Perpetua et leur interaction”, in: Bonnet, Ossola & Scheid 2010, pp. 63-81.
40. Losemann, Volker 1999, “The Nazi concept of Rome”, in: Catherine Edwards (ed.), Roman presences. Receptions of Rome in European culture, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp. 221-235.
41. McInerny, Jeremy 2014 (ed.), A companion to ethnicity in the Ancient Mediterranean, Malden, MA & Oxford, John Wiley & Sons.
42. Meillet, Antoine 1903, Esquisse d’une grammaire comparée de l’arménien classique, Vienne, Impr. des PP. Mékhitharistes.
43. Momigliano, Arnaldo 1984, «K.-O. Müller’s Prolegomena zu einer Wissenschaftlichen Mythologie and the meaning of ‘Myth’», in: Settimo Contributo alla storia degli studi classici e del mondo antico, Roma, Edizioni di storia e letteratura, pp. 271-286. DOI 10.2307/2504473
44. Müller, Karl Otfried 1820, Geschichten Hellenischer Stämme und Städte. Breslau, Josef Max.
45. Olender, Maurice 2002, Les langues du paradis, Paris, Gallimard et Éditions du Seuil.
46. Petrie, William Matthew Flinders 1887, Racial photographs from the Egyptian monuments, London, British Association.
47. Petrie, William Matthew Flinders 1911, The revolutions of civilisation, London, Harpers Brothers.
48. Praet, Danny 2010, “Les liens entre philosophie et religion dans quelques Scripta Minora de Franz Cumont”, in: Bonnet, Ossola & Scheid 2010, pp. 97-110.
49. Praet, Danny 2011, “Franz Cumont, the Oriental Religions, and Christianity in the Roman Empire: A Hegelian View on the Evolution of Religion, Politics, and Science”, in: Gooch, De Vries & Molendijk 2011, pp. 133-158.
50. Praet, Danny 2012, “Wird rein durch Feuer, Wasser, Luft und Erden. Teleologie, universalisme en de symboliek van de elementen in de godsdienst-filosofie van Franz Cumont”, in: Tom Claes (ed.), Door Denken en Doen. Essays bij het werk van Ronald Commers. Gent, Academia Press, pp. 177-219.
51. Praet, Danny 2013, “Symbolisme, évolution rituelle et morale dans l’histoire des religions: le cas du Taurobolium dans les publications et la correspondance de Franz Cumont et d’Alfred Loisy”, in: Frédéric Amsler (ed.), Quelle place pour Alfred Loisy dans l’histoire de la recherche en exégèse biblique et en sciences des religions?, special issue of Mythos. Rivista di Storia delle Religioni 7, Caltanissetta, Salvatore Sciascia, pp. 127-142. DOI 10.4000/rhr.8826
52. Praet, Danny 2014, “Oriental Religions and the Conversion of the Roman Empire: the views of Ernest Renan and of Franz Cumont on the transition from traditional Paganism to Christianity”, in: David Engels & Peter Van Nuffelen, Competition and Religion in Antiquity, Collection Latomus 343. Brussel, pp. 285-307.
53. Rebenich, Stefan 1998, “Otto Seeck, Theodor Mommsen und die Römische Geschichte”, in: Kneissl, Peter & Losemann, Volker (eds.), Imperium Romanum. Studien zu Geschichte und Rezeption. Festschrift für Karl Christ zum 75. Geburtstag, Stuttgart, Steiner, pp. 582-607.
54. Rebenich, Stefan 2000, “Einleitung zur Neuauflage”, in: Otto Seeck, Geschichte des Untergangs der antiken Welt, 6 vols., Darmstadt, Wi ssenscha ftlich eBuchgesellschaft.
55. Rey, Sarah 2010, “Les religions orientales en mouvement. Les ratures de Franz Cumont”, in: Bonnet, Ossola & Scheid 2010, pp. 21-32.
56. Rostovtzeff, Mikhail 1926, Social and economic history of the Roman Empire, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
57. Schachermeyr, Fritz 1939, Zur Rasse und Kultur in minoischen Kreta, Heidelberg, Carl Winter.
58. Scheerlinck, Eline 2013, “Franz Cumont’s Syrian tour : a Belgian archaeologist in the Ottoman Empire”, in: Revue belge de philologie et d’histoire 91.2, pp. 327-357. DOI 10.3406/rbph.2013.8421
59. Eline, Scheerlinck / Rey, Sarah / Praet, Danny 2014, “‘Analogies curieuses’ et ‘ressemblances frappantes’. Des antiquisants face à l’impérialisme français en Méditerranée.” Forum romanicum belgicum, E-Bulletin of the Belgian Historical Institute in Rome 2.8, pp. 1-14.
60. Seeck, Otto 2000, Geschichte des Untergangs der antiken Welt, 6 vols., Metzler Stuttgart 1895-1920. Darmstadt, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft. DOI 10.1007/978-3-476-98784-6_8
61. Siapkas, Johannes 2014, “Ancient ethnicity and modern identity”, in: McInerny 2014, pp. 66-81. DOI 10.1002/9781118834312.ch5
62. Solin, Heikki 1971, Beiträge zur Kenntnis der griechischen Personennamen in Rom I, Societas Scientiarum Fennica, Commentationes Humanarum Litterarum, vol. 48, Helsinki, Keskuskirjapaino. DOI 10.2307/1087730
63. Solin, Heikki 2003, Die griechischen Personennamen in Rom. Ein Namenbuch, 3 vols., Corpus Inscriptionum Latinarum, Auctarium, Berlin, De Gruyter, 2003².
64. Sollors, Werner 2002, “Ethnicity and race”, in: Goldberg & Solomos 2002, pp. 97-104.
65. Stroumsa, Guy 2009, “Ex oriente numen. From Orientalism to Oriental Religions”, in: Bonnet, Pirenne-Delforge & Praet 2009, pp. 91-103.
66. Toutain, Jules 1907, Cultes païens dans l’Empire romain, Paris, Leroux, 1907-1920.
67. Vacher de Lapouge, Georges 1899, L’Aryen, son rôle social, Paris, A. Fontemoing.
68. Vacher de Lapouge, Georges 1909, Race et milieu social. Essais d’anthroposociologie, Paris, M. Rivière.
69. Verboven, Koenraad 2012, “The freedman economy of Roman Italy”, in: Bell, Sinclair & Ramsby, Teresa (eds.), Free at last! The influence of freed slaves on the Roman Empire, London, Bloomsbury, pp. 88-109.
70. Vogt, Joseph 1935, “Bevölkerungsrückgang im Römischen Reich”, in: Vergangenheit und Gegenwart 25, pp. 652-655.
71. Vogt, Joseph 1936, “Rassenmischung im Römischen Reich”, in: Vergangenheit und Gegenwart 26, pp. 1-11.
72. Weiler, Ingomar 2004, “Ethnozentrismus und Fremdenangst aus althistorischer Sicht”, in: Mauritsch, Peter, Petermandl, Werner & Mauritsch-Bein, Barbara (eds.), Ingomar Weiler, Die Gegenwart der Antike. Ausgewählte Schriften zu Geschichte, Kultur und Rezeption des Altertums; Darmstadt, Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 2004, pp. 191-224.
73. Weiler, Ingomar 2004a, “Von ‘Wesen’, ‘Geist’ und ‘Eigenart’ der Völker der Alten Welt. Eine Anthologie altertumswissenschaftlicher Typisierungskunst”, in: Weiler 2004, pp. 449-512.