Abstract
The main question of this paper is how to understand the notion of a truth-maker. In section 1, I show that the identification of truth-making with necessitation cannot capture the pretheoretic understanding of notions such as ‘x makes something true’. In section 2, I examine Barry Smith’s reaction to this problem: he defines truth-making as the combination of necessitation and projection. I focus on the formal part of Smith’s account, which is shown to yield undesired results. However, in section 3, I present an alternative account of projection, which fares better and can fruitfully be employed to circumvent the problems raised in section 1. Unfortunately, the account still has to face some troublemakers, as I show in the final section. I conclude, therefore, with a pessimistic view on the project of defining truth-making via necessitation and projection.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
G. Evans (1982) Varieties of Reference Clarendon Press Oxford
K. Fine (1995) ArticleTitle‘Ontological Dependence’ Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 95 269–290
J. Fox (1987) ArticleTitle‘Truthmaker’ Australasian Journal of Philosophy 65 188–207 Occurrence Handle10.1080/00048408712342871
D. Gregory (2001) ArticleTitle‘Smith on Truthmakers’ Australasian Journal of Philosophy 79 422–427
J. Kim (1976) ‘Events as Property Exemplifications’ J. Kim (Eds) Supervenience and Mind Cambridge University Press Cambridge 33–52
K. Mulligan P. Simons B. Smith (1984) ArticleTitle‘Truth-makers’ Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 44 287–320 Occurrence Handle10.2307/2107686
A. Rayo S. Yablo (2001) ArticleTitle‘Nominalism Through De-Nominalization’ Noûs 35 74–92
G. Restall (1996) ArticleTitle‘Truthmakers, Entailment and Necessity’ Australasian Journal for Philosophy 74 331–340
G. Rodriguez-Pereyra (2000) ArticleTitle‘What is the Problem of Universals?’ Mind 109 255–273 Occurrence Handle10.1093/mind/109.434.255
Schnieder, B.: (forthcoming) ‘Truth-making Without Truth-makers’, forthcoming in Synthese
B. Smith (1999) ArticleTitle‘Truthmaker Realism’ Australasian Journal of Philosophy 77 274–291 Occurrence Handle10.1080/00048409912349041
B. Smith (2002) ArticleTitle‘Truthmaker Realism: Response to Gregory’ Australasian Journal of Philosophy 80 231–234
T. Williamson (1999) ArticleTitle‘Truthmakers and the Converse Barcan Formula’ Dialectica 53 253–270
T. Williamson (2000) Knowledge and Its Limits OUP Oxford
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Manuscript submitted 22 September 2004 Final version received 28 September 2005
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Schnieder, B. Troubles with Truth-making: Necessitation and Projection. Erkenntnis 64, 61–74 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10670-005-3566-3
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10670-005-3566-3