Abstract
Stephen Carter argues that biblical literalism is predicated on an epistemological position drastically different than that maintained by mainstream scientists inasmuch as it operates on the basis of a “hermeneutic of inerrancy” with respect to the ideas laid out in the Bible. By relying on considerations offered by Charles Taylor and recent sociological studies, I contend that Carter’s thesis is incorrect. The divide between proponents and opponents of biblical literalism is ethical rather than epistemological. Beyond the philosophical implications of my contention, this displays that deliberative engagement between these parties—which depends on shared epistemological norms—is possible in principle.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Bacon M. (2010) The politics of truth: A critique of Peircean deliberative democracy. Philosophy & Social Criticism 36(9): 1075–1091
Bartkowski J. (1996) Beyond biblical literalism and inerrancy: Conservative protestants and the hermeneutic interpretation of scripture. Sociology of Religion 57(3): 259–272
Bell R. (2011) Love wins: A book about heaven, hell, and the fate of every person who ever lived. HarperOne, New York
Cameron N. M. (1987) Biblical higher criticism and the defense of infallibilism in nineteenth-century Britain. E. Mellen, Lewiston, NY
Carter S. L. (1993) The culture of disbelief. Anchor Books, New York
Criswell W. A. (1969) Why I preach that the Bible is literally true. Broadman Press, Nashville
Dilday R. H. Jr. (1982) The doctrine of biblical authority. Convention Press, Nashville
Draper J. T. (1980) Authority: The critical issue for southern baptists. Fleming H. Revell, Old Tappan, NJ
Dudley J. (2011) Broken words: The abuse of science and faith in American politics. Crown Publishers, New York
Eickholm, E. (4 March 2011). Pastor stirs wrath with his views on old questions. The New York Times. http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/05/us/05bell.html
Ferrara A. (2009) The separation of religion and politics in a post-secular society. Philosophy & Social Criticism 35(1–2): 77–91
Feuerbach L. (1854) The essence of christianity, trans. Marian Evans. John Chapman, London
Gish D. T. (1979) Evolution? The fossils say no?. Creation-Life, San Diego
Graham L. (1981) Between science and religion. Columbia University Press, New York
Greeley A., Hout M. (2006) The truth about conservative Christians: What they think and what they believe. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Ham K. (2006) The new answers book: Over twenty-five questions on creation/evolution and the Bible. Answers in Genesis, Green Forest, AR
Hennell C. (1838) Inquiry concerning the origins of christianity. Smallfield, London
Hodge C. (1874) Systematic theology. Scribner, Armstrong, and Co, New York
Hofstadter R. (1963) Anti-intellectualism in American life. Knopf, New York
Hout M., Greeley A., Wilde M. J. (2001) The demographic imperative in religious change in the United States. The American Journal of Sociology 107(2): 468–500
Hout M., Fischer C. S. (2002) Why more Americans have no religious preference: Politics and generations. American Sociological Review 67(2): 165–190
Humes E. (2007) Monkey girl: Evolution, education, religion, and the battles for America’s soul. Harper Perennial, New York
Lane C. (2011) The age of doubt: Tracing the roots of religious uncertainty. Yale University Press, New Haven, CT
Lasch C. (1965) The new radicalism in America 1889–1963: The intellectual as social type. Knopf, New York
Lind, M. (2011). The three fundamentalisms of the American right. Salon.com, 5 July 2011. http://www.salon.com/news/politics/war_room/2011/07/05/lind_three_fundamentalisms/index.html
McKim, D. K. (eds) (1986) A guide to contemporary hermeneutics: Major trends in biblical interpretation. William B. Eerdmans, Grand Rapids, MI
Miller D. S. (1899) ’The will to believe’ and the duty to doubt. International Journal of Ethics 9(2): 169–195
Miller K. (1999) Finding Darwin’s god: A scientist’s search for common ground between god and evolution. Harper, New York
Miller K. (2008) Only a theory: Evolution and the battle for America’s soul. Viking, New York
Morris, H. (eds) (1974) Scientific creationism. Creation-Life Publishers, San Diego
Morriston W. (2009) Did god command genocide? a challenge to biblical inerrantists. Philosophia Christi 11(1): 7–26
Newport J. P. (1989) Life’s ultimate questions. Word Publishing, Dallas
Newport J. P., Cannon W. (1974) Why Christians fight over the bible. Thomas Nelson, Nashville
Noll M. (1995) The scandal of the evangelical mind. William B. Eerdmans, Grand Rapids, MI
Prothero S. (2007) Religious literacy: What every American needs to know—and doesn’t. HaperOne, New York
Prothero S. (2010) God is not one: The eight rival religions that run the world—and why their differences matter. HarperCollins, new York
Putnam R. D., Campbell D. E. (2010) American grace: How religion divides and unites us. Simon & Schuster, New York
Ralph’s Way. (September, 2010). The wunderkind returns. The Economist, 18, 42.
Rawls J. (1993) Political liberalism. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA
Robison, J. (February, 2002). In the beginning was the word. Gallup Poll, 5. http://poll.gallup.com
Sandeen E. R. (1962) The Princeton theology: One source of biblical literalism in American protestantism. Church History 31(3): 307–321
Sheldon W. L. (1891) The ethics of doubt—Cardinal Newman. International Journal of Ethics 1(2): 224–238
Smith, E. (1809). The spirit loving kindness of god displayed in the triumph of republicanism in America (no publisher).
Stout J. (2004) Democracy and tradition democracy and tradition. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ
Strauss D. F. (1835) The life of Jesus critically examined. Swan Sonnenechevin, London
Talisse R. B. (2007) A pragmatist philosophy of democracy. Routledge, New York
Tamney J. B. (2002) The resilience of conservative religion: The case of popular, conservative protestant congregations. Cambridge University Press, New York
Taylor C. (2007) A secular age. Harvard University, Cambridge, MA
Tennyson A. L. (1850) In memoriam. Norton, New York
Torrey, R. A., Dixon, A. C. (eds) (1994) The fundamentals: A testimony to the truth. Revell, Grand Rapids, MI
Warfield B. B. (1948) The inspiration and authority of the Bible. Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing Co, Philadelphia
Watson D. C. C. (1976) The great brain robbery: Creation or evolution?. Moody Press, Chicago
Weir J. (1994) Biblical inerrancy and infallibility: A philosophical analysis. Southwest Philosophy Review 10(2): 129–148
Wells D. F. (1993) No place for truth, or whatever happened to evangelical theology?. William B. Eerdmans, Grand Rapids, MI
Wolfe A. (2003) The transformation of American religion: How we actually live our faith. University of Chicago Press, Chicago
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Smith, A.F. Secularity and biblical literalism: confronting the case for epistemological diversity. Int J Philos Relig 71, 205–219 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11153-011-9332-3
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11153-011-9332-3