Skip to main content

Advertisement

SpringerLink
Log in

The ethical implications and religious significance of organ transplantation payment systems

  • Scientific Contribution
  • Published:
Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy Aims and scope Submit manuscript

Abstract

One of the more polarizing policies proposed to alleviate the organ shortage is financial payment of donors in return for organs. A priori and empirical investigation concludes that such systems are ethically inadequate. A new methodological approach towards policy formation and implementation is proposed which places ethical concerns at its core. From a hypothetical secular origin, the optimal ethical policy structure concerning organ donation is derived. However, when applied universally, it does not yield ideal results for every culture and society due to region-specific variation. Since religion holds significant influence in the organ donation debate, three religions—Catholicism, Islam, and Shinto—were examined in order to illustrate this variation. Although secular ethical concerns should rest at the core of policy construction, certain region-specific contexts require cultural and religious competence and necessitate the adjustment of the optimal template policy accordingly to yield the best moral and practical results.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Log in via an institution

Price excludes VAT (USA)
Tax calculation will be finalised during checkout.

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Institutional subscriptions

Similar content being viewed by others

References

  • Abadie, A., and S. Gay. 2006. The impact of presumed consent legislation on cadaveric organ donation: A cross-country study. Journal of Health Economics 25(4): 599–620.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Abul-Foutoh, M. 1987. Sale of human organs in the balance of legitimacy. The Islamic Vision of Some Medical Practices. Lecture conducted from Medical Jurisprudence Third Symposium, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia.

  • Al-Islami, M. 1998. Qararat wa-Tawsiyat Majma Al-Figh Al-Islami (Islamic Fiqh Academy Resolutions), 59–60. Dimishq, Dar al-Qalim: The Islamic Fiqh Academy.

    Google Scholar 

  • Albar, M. 2012. Organ transplantation: A Sunni Islamic perspective. Saudi Journal of Kidney Diseases and Transplantation 23: 817–822.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Amemiya, H. 1999. Current status of organ transplantation in Japan. Transplantation Proceedings 31(5): 1990–1991.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Bakdash, T., and N. Scheper-Hughes. 2006. Is it ethical for patients with renal disease to purchase kidneys from the world’s poor? PloS Medicine 3(10): 1699–1702.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Bowman, K., and S. Richard. 2003. Culture, brain death, and transplantation. Progress in Transplantation 13(3): 211–215.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Bruzzone, P. 2008. Religious aspects of organ transplantation. Transplantation Proceedings 40(4): 1064–1067.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Caplan, A. 2004. Transplantation at any price? American Journal of Transplantation 4: 1933–1934.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Caplan, A. 2008. Organ transplantation. From birth to death and bench to clinic. In the hastings center bioethics briefing book for journalists, policymakers, and campaigns, ed. M. Crowley, 129–132. Garrison, New York: The Hastings Center.

    Google Scholar 

  • Carney, S. 2011. The red market—on the trail of the world’s organ brokers, bone thieves, blood farmers, and child traffickers. New York: William Morrow/HarperCollins.

    Google Scholar 

  • Catholic Church. 1997. Catechism of the Catholic Church: Revised in accordance with the official Latin text promulgated by Pope John Paul II. 2nd ed. 891, 2296. Washington, D.C.: United States Catholic Conference.

  • Chia, R. 2009. Organ trading: A Christian perspective. Graduates’ Christian Fellowship. http://www.gcf.org.sg/resources/organ-trading.

  • Cohen, L. 1999. Where it hurts: Indian material for an ethics of organ transplantation. Daedalus 128(4): 135–163.

    Google Scholar 

  • Daar, A. 1994. The body, the soul and organ donation beliefs of the major world religions. Nefrologia 15(1): 78–81.

    Google Scholar 

  • Ebrahim, A. 1995. Organ transplantation: Contemporary Sunni Muslim legal and ethical perspectives. Bioethics 9(3): 291–302.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Fadel, H., A. Khan, A. Misal, and H. Rahman. 2002. Contemporary bio-medical issues in the light of Islam. In Federation of Islamic Medical Associations (FIMA) year book 2002, ed. Fadel, H. Rawalpindi: Pakistan Islamic Medical Association.

  • Finger Lakes Donor Recovery Network. 2014. Pope Francis: Organ donation is a ‘testimony of Love for Our Neighbor.’ News and Views. Finger Lakes Donor Recovery Network, 11 Oct 2014. http://www.donorrecovery.org/2014/10/pope-francis-supports-organ-donation/

  • Fox, R., and J. Swazey. 1992. Spare Parts: Organ Replacement in American Society. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • Gigerenzer, G. 2008. Moral intuition = fast and frugal heuristics? In Moral psychology, Volume II: The cognitive science of morality: Intuition and diversity, vol. 1, ed. Walter Sinnott-Armstrong. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • Golmakani, M., M. Niknam, and K. Hedayat. 2005. Transplantation ethics from the Islamic point of view. Medical Science Monitor 11(4): 105–109.

    Google Scholar 

  • Goyal, M., R. Mehta, L. Schneiderman, and A. Sehgal. 2002. Economic and health consequences of selling a kidney in India. JAMA 288(13): 1589–1593.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Haghighi, A., and N. Ghahramani. 2008. Living unrelated kidney donor transplantation in Iran. Quarterly Journal of Medical Ethics 2(5): 135–142.

    Google Scholar 

  • Havel, V. 2006. Politics, morality, and civility. Washington, D.C.: The Trinity Forum.

    Google Scholar 

  • Hazmy, W., Z. Rashid, and R. Hussaini. 2003. Contemporary issues in Islamic medicine. Seremban: Islamic Medical Association of Malaysia.

    Google Scholar 

  • Islamic Fiqh Academy. 1981. Organ transplant in Islam. The Islamic Fiqh Academy, subsidiary of the Organization of the Islamic Conference. Lecture conducted from Third Islamic Summit Conference, Makkah al-Mukarramah, Saudi Arabia.

  • John Paul II, Pope. 1985. Blood and organ donors. The Pope Speaks 30(1): 1–2.

    Google Scholar 

  • Kamal, M. 2008. Ethical issues of organ transplantation in Islam. TAJ: Journal of Teachers Association 21(1): 97–103.

    Google Scholar 

  • Kin, L. 2008. Legalization of organ trade? Health Policy Monitor. 12:1–4.

  • Larijani, B., F. Zahedi, and E. Taheri. 2004. Ethical and legal aspects of organ transplantation in Iran. Transplantation Proceedings 36: 1241–1244.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • McConnell, J.R. 1999. The ambiguity about death in Japan: An ethical implication for organ procurement. Journal of Medical Ethics 25: 322–324.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Mellstrom, C., and M. Johannesson. 2008. Crowding out in blood donation: Was Titmuss right? Journal of European Economic Association 6(4): 845–863.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Morioka, M. 1995. Bioethics and Japanese culture: Brain death, patients’ rights, and cultural factors. Eubios Journal of Asian and International Bioethics 5: 87–90.

    Google Scholar 

  • Mousawi (Al), M., T. Hamed, et al. 1997. Views of Muslim scholars on organ donation and brain death. Transplantation Proceedings 29(8): 3217.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Muhammad ibn Adam, A. 2011. Is organ donation permissible? Daruliftaa Institute of Islamic Jurisprudence. http://www.daruliftaa.com/node/5896?txt_QuestionID.

  • Naçar, M., F. Cetinkaya, Z. Baykan, and S. Poyrazoğlu. 2009. Attitudes and behaviours of students from the faculty of theology regarding organ donation: a study from Turkey. Transplantation Proceedings 41(10): 4057–4061.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Namihira, E. 1990. Shinto concepts concerning the dead human body. Transplantation Proceedings 22: 940–941.

    Google Scholar 

  • Naqvi, S., B. Ali, F. Mazhar, M. Zafar, and S. Rizvi. 2007. A socioeconomic survey of kidney vendors in Pakistan. Transplant International 20(11): 934–939.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Oliver, M., A. Woywodt, A. Ahmed, and I. Saif. 2011. Organ donation, transplantation and religion. Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation 26(2): 437–444.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Pope Pius XII. 1960. Papal teachings: the human body. Monks of Solomes. Boston: The daughters of Saint Paul.

    Google Scholar 

  • Rizvi, A., A. Naqvi, N. Zafar, and E. Ahmed. 2009. Regulated compensated donation in Pakistan and Iran. Current Opinion in Organ Transplantation 14(2): 124–128.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Rousseau, J. 1987. On the Social Contract. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing, Inc. 46 (trans: Cress, D.).

  • Scheper-Hughes, N. 2007. The tyranny of the gift: Sacrificial violence in living donor transplants. American Journal of Transplantation 7(3): 507–511.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Syed, Ibrahim B. 1999. Organ transplantation. Lecture conducted from Parliament of World Religions, Cape Town, South Africa.

  • The Qur’an. 2008. (trans: Khalidi, T.). New York: Viking. 2:173, 5:32, 90:13.

  • The Transplantation Society. 2014. Declaration of Istanbul Custodian Group: Private Audience with Pope Francis. The Transplantation Society. https://www.tts.org/newstts-world/newsletter/current-newsletter/1686-declaration-of-istanbul-custodian-group-private-audience-with-pope-francis. 18 Sept 2014.

  • Thomasma, D. 1988. The quest for organ donors: A theological response. Health Progress 69(7): 22-4, 28.

  • Titmuss, R. 1997. The gift relationship: from human blood to social policy, 142–157. New York: The New Press.

    Google Scholar 

  • Tober, D. 2007. Kidneys and controversies in the Islamic Republic of Iran: The case of organ sale. Body and Society 13(3): 151.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Zargooshi, J. 2001. Quality of life of Iranian kidney ‘donors’. Journal of Urology 166(5): 1790–1799.

    Article  Google Scholar 

  • Zenit. 2008. Benedict XVI on Organ Donation. Zenit: The World Seen from Rome. Innovative Media, Inc., 7 Nov 2008. http://www.zenit.org/en/articles/benedict-xvi-on-organ-donation.

Download references

Conflict of interest

The author declares that he has no conflict of interest.

Author information

Authors and Affiliations

  1. Tulane University School of Medicine, 1470 Annunciation Street, Apartment #3203, New Orleans, LA, 70130, USA

    Hunter Jackson Smith

Authors
  1. Hunter Jackson Smith
    View author publications

    You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Hunter Jackson Smith.

Rights and permissions

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Check for updates. Verify currency and authenticity via CrossMark

Cite this article

Smith, H.J. The ethical implications and religious significance of organ transplantation payment systems. Med Health Care and Philos 19, 33–44 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-015-9632-y

Download citation

  • Published:

  • Issue Date:

  • DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11019-015-9632-y

Keywords

Search

Navigation