Abstract
`Proto-idea' was a central concept in the thinking of the Polish microbiologist and philosopher of science Ludwik Fleck (1896–1961). Based on studies of the origin of the modern concept of syphilis, Fleck claimed that many established scientific facts are best understood as interpretations of pre scientific, somewhat hazy `proto-ideas' in the framework of a certain `thought-style'. As an example,Fleck saw the modern knowledge of infection as an interpretation of the ancient proto-idea of diseases as caused by minute `animalcules'. However, the epistemological aspects of the concept of proto-ideas have only been sparsely developed and discussed by Fleck and his critics. This paper attempts to bridge the gap.
Firstly, I reconstruct the concept of proto-ideasin the context of Fleck's constructivist theory of knowledge. Secondly, I illustrate the relation between Fleck's concept of proto-ideas and his nominalist view on medical taxonomy. Finally, I discuss four philosophical problems implied by Fleck's concept of proto-ideas:
(a) the problem of combining two conflicting perspectives on the history of science
(b) the problem of accounting for the notion of` continuity' within a non realist theory of knowledge
(c) the problem of ascribing no truth-content to proto-ideas, and
(d) the problem concerning the non-neutrality of the analyst's viewpoint.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Cohen, R.S. and T. Schnelle: 1986, 'Introduction', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. ix-xxxi.
Engelhardt, H.T.: 1990, 'Medical knowledge and medical action: Competing visions', In H.A.M.J. ten Have, G.K. Kimsma and S.F. Spicker (eds.), The Growth of Medical Knowledge. Dordrecht: Kluwer Acad. Publ., pp. 63-71.
Fleck, L.: 1986, 'Some specific features of the medical way of thinking', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 39-46 (or. ed. 1927).
Fleck, L.: 1986, 'On the crisis of 'reality'', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 47-57 (or. ed. 1929).
Fleck, L.: 1979, Genesis and Development of a Scientific Fact. Chicago: University of Chicago Press (or. ed. 1935).
Fleck, L.: 1986, 'The problem of epistemology', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 79-112 (or. ed. 1936).
Fleck, L.: 1939-1990, 'Science and social context', Philosophy and Medicine 37, pp. 249-256.
Fleck, L.: 1986, 'Crisis in science', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 153-158 (or. ed. 1960).
Giedymin, J.: 1986, 'Polish philosophy in the inter-war period and Ludwik Fleck's theory of thought-styles and thoughtcollectives', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 179-215.
Harwood, J.: 1986, 'Ludwik Fleck and the sociology of knowledge', Social Studies of Science 16, pp. 173-187.
Heelan, P.A.: 1986, 'Fleck's contribution to epistemology', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 287-307.
Hoyningen-Huene, P.: 1993, Reconstructing Scientific Revolutions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Jacobs, S.: 1987, 'Scientific community: Formulations and critique of a sociological motive', British Journal of Sociology 38, pp. 266-276.
Kimsma, G.K.: 1990, 'Frames of reference and the growth of medical knowledge: L. Fleck and M. Foucault', In H.A.M.J. ten Have, G.K. Kimsma and S.F. Spicker (eds.), The Growth of Medical Knowledge. Dordrecht: Kluwer Acad. Publ., pp. 41-62.
Kragh, H.: 1987, An Introduction to the Historiography of Science. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Löwy, I.: 1986, 'The epistemology of the science of an epistemologist of the sciences: Ludwik Fleck's professional outlook and its relationships to his philosophical works', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 421-442.
Löwy, I.: 1988, 'Ludwik Fleck on the social construction of medical knowledge', Sociology of Health and Illness 10, pp. 133-155.
Löwy, I.: 1990, 'Ludwik Fleck. From philosophy of medicine to a constructivist and relativist epistemology', In I. Löwy (ed.), The Polish School of Philosophy of Medicine. Dordrecht: Kluwer Acad. Publ., pp. 215-227.
McCullough, L.B.: 1981, 'Thought-styles, diagnosis, and concepts of disease: Commentary on Ludwik Fleck', Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 6, pp. 257-261.
Nickles, T.: 1995, 'Philosophy of science and history of science', Osiris 10, pp. 139-163.
Rotenstreich, N.: 1986, 'The proto-ideas and their aftermath', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 161-178.
Schnelle, T.: 1986, 'Ludwik Fleck and the influence of the philosophy of Lwów', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 231-265.
ten Have, H.A.M.J.: 1990, 'Knowledge and practice in European medicine: The case of infectious diseases', In H.A.M.J. ten Have, G.K. Kimsma and S.F. Spicker (eds.), The Growth of Medical Knowledge. Dordrecht: Kluwer Acad. Publ., pp. 15-40.
Toulmin, S.: 1986, 'Ludwik Fleck and the historical interpretation of science', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 267-285.
Trenn, T.J.: 1979, 'Descriptive analysis', In: L. Fleck (ed.), Genesis and Development of a Scientific Fact. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 154-165.
Trenn, T.J.: 1981, 'Ludwik Fleck's 'on the question of the foundations of medical knowledge'', Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 6, pp. 237-256.
Wittich, D.: 1986, 'On Ludwik Fleck's use of social categories in knowledge', Boston Studies in the Philosophy of Science 87, pp. 317-323.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Brorson, S. Ludwik Fleck on proto-ideas in medicine. Med Health Care Philos 3, 147–152 (2000). https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009943420053
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1009943420053