Abstract
One of the key events in the relations between the Athenians and Thebans was the Plataian decision to align themselves with the Athenians at the end of the sixth century BCE. This decision shook up the contemporary political landscape and proved to be a source of hostility between the two neighbouring polities throughout the fifth and fourth centuries. The orthodox view holds that the original alignment took place in 519 during the Peisistratid tyranny, based on the date given by Thucydides 3.68.5. This date, in the mind of some scholars, seems contradictory with the story of the Plataian alignment as given by Herodotus (6.108.1–6). This inconsistency resulted in a search for alternatives that fit the Herodotean narrative better. To accommodate this change, they relied on emendating the Thucydidean text, but there is no sign of corruption in this part. Emendation of a text is best avoided, although the controversy merits attention. Therefore, in this article it will be argued that the two narratives – the Thucydidean and the Herodotean – need to be separated. What follows is a renewed chronology of Plataian-Athenian relations. The orthodox date (519) was the date of an original Peisistratid-Plataian alliance that did not lead to hostilities with Thebes. Instead, it is in the context of the foundation of the Athenian democracy and the subsequent clashes with Thebes after 507/6 that the Herodotean narrative should be placed.
Acknowledgment
First and foremost I would like express my gratitude to Albert Schachter, who made invaluable suggestions to improve this article. Another note goes out to Fabienne Marchand, who pointed pointed out numerous mistakes. A further acknowledgement is to professor Nikolaos Papazarkadas, who suggested the similarities between sympoliteia and the Eleutherai inscription mentioned later on. I would also to thank the audience at Durham, where an earlier version of this paper has been given, for their comments. A last note of gratitude goes to the anonymous reviewer, whose advice radically improved this article. Finally, I would like to thank the Swiss National Science Foundation for generously supporting me to carry out research on Athenian-Boiotian relations
Funding: Swiss National Science Foundation, (Grant / Award Number: 150463)
Bibliography
Amit, M. “Le date de l’alliance entre Athènes et Platées.” AC 39 (1970): 11–58.10.3406/antiq.1970.1593Search in Google Scholar
Amit, M. “The Boeotian Confederation during the Pentekonteia.” RSA 1 (1971): 49–64.Search in Google Scholar
Amit, M. Great and Small Poleis. A study in the relations between the Great Powers and the small cities in Ancient Greece. Brussels: Collection Latomus, 1973.Search in Google Scholar
Anderson, G. The Athenian Experiment. Building an imagined political community in ancient Attica, 508–490 B.C. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, 2003.10.3998/mpub.17798Search in Google Scholar
Aravantinos, V. “A new inscribed kioniskos from Thebes.” ABSA 101 (2006): 369–377.10.1017/S0068245400021341Search in Google Scholar
Aravantinos, V. The Archaeological Museum of Thebes. Athens: John S. Latsis Public Foundation, 2010.Search in Google Scholar
Aravantinos, V. “The inscriptions from the Sanctuary of Herakles at Thebes: an overview.” In The Epigraphy and History of Boeotia. New finds. New prospects, edited by N. Papazarkadas, 149–210. Leiden/Boston: Brill, 2014.Search in Google Scholar
Badian, E. “Plataea between Athens and Sparta.” In Boiotika. Vorträge vom 5. Internationalen Böotien-Kolloquium zu Ehren von Professor Dr. Siegfried Lauffer. Institut für Alte Geschichte Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München 13.–17. Juni 1986, edited by H. Beister and J. Buckler, 95–111. Munich: Münchener Arbeiten zur Alten Geschichte, 1989.Search in Google Scholar
Badian, E. From Plataea to Potidaea: studies in the history and historiography of the Pentecontaetia. Baltimore: John Hopkins U. P., 1993.Search in Google Scholar PubMed
Beck, H. and A. Ganter. “Boiotia and the Boiotian leagues.” In Federalism in Greek Anitquity, edited by P. Funke and H. Beck, 132–157. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2015.10.1017/CBO9781139030953.009Search in Google Scholar
Beloch, K. J. Griechische Geschichte. 3 Volumes. Leipzig: Teubner, 1893–1904.10.1515/9783112384862-023Search in Google Scholar
Berthold, R. M. “The Athenian embassies to Sardis and Cleomenes’ Invasion of Attica.” Historia 51 (2002): 259–267.Search in Google Scholar
Berti, S. “The Athenian victory over the Boeotians and the Chalcidians in the light of the epigraphical findings.” AHB 24 (2010): 3–23.Search in Google Scholar
Bintliff, J. “Territorial behaviour and the natural history of the Greek polis.” In Stuttgarter Kolloquium zur Historischen Geographie des Altertums 4, edited by E. Olshausen and H. Sonnabend, 207–249. Amsterdam: Hakkert, 1994.Search in Google Scholar
Bintliff, J. “Pattern and process in the city landscapes of Boeotia from geometric to late Roman times.” In Territoires des cités grecques. BCH Suppl. 34, edited by M. Brunet, 15–33. Athens: École française d'Athènes, 1999.Search in Google Scholar
Bintliff, J. “Rethinking early Mediterranean urbanism.” In Mauerschau. Festschrift für Manfred Korfmann, edited by R. Aslan, et al., 153–177. Remshalden: Bernhard Albert Greiner, 2002.Search in Google Scholar
Bonner, R. J. and G. Smith. “Administration of justice in Boeotia.” CPh 40 (1945): 11–23.10.1086/362855Search in Google Scholar
Bousquet, J. “Inscriptions de Delphes.” BCH 115 (1991): 167–181.10.3406/bch.1991.4679Search in Google Scholar
Bowie, A. M. Herodotus: Histoires. Book VIII. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2007.Search in Google Scholar
Bruce, I. A. F. “Plataea and the fifth-century Boeotian confederacy.” Phoenix 22.3 (1968): 190–199.10.2307/1086634Search in Google Scholar
Buck, R. J. “The formation of the Boeotian League.” CP 67.2 (1972): 94–101.10.1086/365837Search in Google Scholar
Buck, R. J. A History of Boeotia. Alberta: University of Alberta, 1979.Search in Google Scholar
Burn, A. R. Persia and the Greeks. The defence of the west, c. 546–478 B.C. London: Edward Arnold, 1962.Search in Google Scholar
Busolt, G. Griechische Geschichte bis zur Schlacht bei Chaeroneia. 3 Volumes. Gotha: Friedrich Andreas Perthes, 1885–1904.Search in Google Scholar
Carpenter, T. H. Dionysian Imagery in Archaic Greek Art. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 1986.Search in Google Scholar
Cloché, P. Thèbes de Béotie, des origines à la conquête romaine. Fasc. 13 de la Bibliothèque de la Faculté de philosophie et lettres de Namur. Namur-Louvain-Paris: Facultés universitaires-Nauwelaerts-Desclée de Brouwer, 1952.Search in Google Scholar
Connor, W. R. “City Dionysia and the Athenian democracy.” C&M 40 (1989): 7–32.Search in Google Scholar
Cook, J. M. The Persian Empire. New York: Schocken Brooks, 1983.Search in Google Scholar
Coulton, J. J., E. Sapouna Sakelleraki and I. R. Metzger. The Fort at Phylla, Vrachos: excavations and researches at a late Archaic fort in central Euboea. BSA Supplements 33. London: British School at Athens, 2002. Search in Google Scholar
Crane, G. “The case of Plataea: small states and the (re-)invention of political realism.” In War and Democracy. A comparative study of the Korean War and the Peloponnesian War, edited by D. R. McCann and B. S. Strauss, 127–160. Armonk/London: M. E. Sharpe, 2001.Search in Google Scholar
Develin, R. “Numeral corruption in Greek historical texts.” Phoenix 44.1 (1990): 31–45.10.2307/1088564Search in Google Scholar
Ducat, J. “La confederation Béotienne et l’expansion Thébaine à l’époque Archaïque.” BCH 97.1 (1973): 59–73.10.3406/bch.1973.2119Search in Google Scholar
Fachard, S., A. R. Knodell and E. Banou. “The 2014 Mazi Archaeological Project (Attica).” Antike Kunst 58 (2015): 178–186.Search in Google Scholar
Farinetti, E. Boeotian Landscapes: a GIS-based study of the reconstruction and interpretation of the archaeological datasets of ancient Boeotia. Oxford: BAR, 2011.10.30861/9781407307503Search in Google Scholar
Flower, M. A. and J. Marincola. Herodotus: Histories Book IX. Cambridge Greek and Latin Classics. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2002.Search in Google Scholar
Forsdyke, S. “Athenian democratic ideology and Herodotus’ Histories.” AJP 122.3 (2001): 329–358.10.1353/ajp.2001.0038Search in Google Scholar
Fossey, J. The Ancient Topography of Opountian Lokris. Amsterdam: J. Gieben, 1990.Search in Google Scholar
Foxhall, L., H.-J. Gehkre and N. Luraghi. Intentional History: spinning time in ancient Greece. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner, 2010.10.25162/9783515112888Search in Google Scholar
French, A. “A note on Thucydides iii.68.5.” JHS 80 (1960): 191.10.2307/628387Search in Google Scholar
Frost, F. “The Athenian military before Cleisthenes.” Historia 33 (1984): 283–294.Search in Google Scholar
Ganter, A. “A two-sided story of integration: the cultic dimension of Boeotian ethnogenesis.” In Greek Federal States and Their Sanctuaries, edited by P. Funke and M. Haake, 85–105. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner, 2013.Search in Google Scholar
Gehrke, H.-J. “Mythos, Geschichte, Politik – Antik und Modern.” Saeculum 54 (1994): 239–264.10.7788/saeculum.1994.45.2.239Search in Google Scholar
Gehrke, H.-J. “Myth, history and collective identity: uses of the past in ancient Greece and beyond.” In The Historian’s Craft in the Age of Herodotus, edited by N. Luraghi, 286–313. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2001.Search in Google Scholar
Gomme, A. W. A Historical Commentary on Thucydides. Volume II and III. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 1956.Search in Google Scholar
Grethlein, J. The Greeks and Their Past: poetry, oratory and history in the fifth century BCE. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2010.Search in Google Scholar
Grote, G. A History of Greece; from the earliest period to the close of the generation contemporary with Alexander the Great. 12 Volumes. London: Murray, 1846–1856.Search in Google Scholar
Guillon, P. Le Bouclier d'Héraclès et l'histoire de la Grèce centrale dans la période de la première guerre sacrée. Aix-en-Provence: Aix-en-Provence U. P., 1963.Search in Google Scholar
Hall, J. “International relations.” In The Cambridge History of Greek and Roman Warfare Vol. 1: Greece, the Hellenistic World and the Rise of Rome, edited by P. Sabin, H. van Wees and M. Whitby, 85–107. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2007.10.1017/CHOL9780521782739.005Search in Google Scholar
Hammond, G. L. “Studies in Greek chronology in the sixth and fifth centuries B.C.” Historia 4 (1955): 371–411.Search in Google Scholar
Hammond, G. L. “Plataea’s relations with Thebes, Sparta and Athens.” JHS 112 (1992): 143–150.10.2307/632158Search in Google Scholar
Hammond, G. L. “Political developments in Boeotia.” CQ 50.1 (2000): 80–93.10.1093/cq/50.1.80Search in Google Scholar
Hennig, D. “Herodot 6.108: Athen und Plataia.” Chiron 22 (1992): 13–24.Search in Google Scholar
Herington, J. Poetry into Drama. Berkeley: University of California, 1985.Search in Google Scholar
Herman, G. Ritualised Friendship and the Greek City. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 1987.Search in Google Scholar
Horden, P. and N. Purcell. The Corrupting Sea: a study of Mediterranean history. London: Blackwell, 2000.Search in Google Scholar
Hornblower, S. Thucydides. London: Duckworth, 1987.Search in Google Scholar
Hornblower, S. A Commentary on Thucydides. Volume I. Books I-III. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 1991.Search in Google Scholar
Hornblower, S. A Commentary on Thucydides Volume II. Books IV-V.24. Oxford: Clarendon, 1996.Search in Google Scholar
How, W. W. and J. Wells. A Commentary on Herodotus. 2 Volumes. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 1912–1923.Search in Google Scholar
Kagan, D. The Archidamian War. Ithaca: Cornell U. P., 1974.10.7591/9780801467233Search in Google Scholar
Kazcko, S. Archaic and Classical Attic Dedicatory Epigrams. An epigraphic, literary and linguistic commentary. Berlin/Boston: de Gruyter, 2016.Search in Google Scholar
Keramopoullos, A. D. “Θηβαικα A′ Μερος—Ανασκαφαι εν Ωηβαις.” AD 3 (1917): 1–503.Search in Google Scholar
Keramopoullos, A.D. “Ανάθημα [Κορω]νέων ἐν Θήβαις.” AD 13 (1930–1931): 105–118.Search in Google Scholar
Knodell, A. R., S. Fachard and K. Papangeli. “The 2015 Mazi Archaeological Project: regional survey in northwest Attica.” Antike Kunst 59 (2016): 132–152.Search in Google Scholar
Knoepfler, D. “Sept années de recherches sur l’epigraphie de la Béotie (1985–1991).” Chiron 22 (1992): 411–503.Search in Google Scholar
Konecny, A., V. Aravantinos and R. Marchese. Plataiai. Plataiai. Archäologie und Geschichte einer boiotischen Polis. Sonderschriften Band 48. Vienna: Österreichisches Archäologisches Institut, 2013.10.26530/OAPEN_451002Search in Google Scholar
Kowalzig, B. Singing for the Gods. Performances of myth and ritual in Archaic and Classical Greece. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2007.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199219964.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Kühr, A. Als Kadmos nach Boiotien kam. Polis und Ethnos im Spiegel thebanischer Gründungsmythen. Hermes Einzelschriften 98. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner, 2006.Search in Google Scholar
Larsen, J. A. O. “Orchomenos and the formation of the Boeotian Confederacy in 447 B.C.” CP 50 (1960): 9–18.10.1086/364431Search in Google Scholar
Larsen, J. A. O. Greek Federal States. Their institutions and history. Oxford: Clarendon, 1968.Search in Google Scholar
Larson, S. Tales of Epic Ancestry. Boiotian collective identity in the late Archaic and early Classical Periods. Historia Einzelschriften 197. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner, 2007.Search in Google Scholar
Larson, S. “Reassessing an Archaic Boiotian dedication (Delphi Museum Inv. No. 3078.” ZPE 162 (2007): 99–106.Search in Google Scholar
Larson, S. “Boeotia, Athens, the Peisistratids and the Odyssey’s Catalogue of Heroines.” TC 6.2 (2013) 412–427.10.1515/tc-2014-0021Search in Google Scholar
Lehmann, G. A. “Thessalians Hegemonie über Mittelgriechenland.” Boreas 6 (1983): 35–43.Search in Google Scholar
Mackil, E. Creating a Common Polity. Religion, economy, and politics in the making of the Greek Koinon. Berkeley: University of California, 2013.10.1525/9780520953932Search in Google Scholar
Mackil, E. “Creating a common polity in Boeotia.” In The Epigraphy and History of Boeotia. New finds. New prospects, edited by N. Papazarkadas, 45–67. Leiden/Boston: Brill, 2014.10.1163/9789004273856_004Search in Google Scholar
Mackil, E. and P.G. van Alfen. “Cooperative coinage.” In Agoranomia: studies in money and exchange presented to John H. Kroll, edited by P. G. van Alfen, 201–246. New York: American Numismatic Society, 2006.Search in Google Scholar
Mafodda, G. “Tebe, I Pisistratidi e l’episodio di Platea. Problemi chronologici ed interpretazioni storiografiche.” SEIA 1 (1996): 99–109.Search in Google Scholar
Mafodda, G. Il koinon beotico in età archaica e classica. Storia ed instituzioni 4. Rome: Giorgio Bretschneider, 2000.Search in Google Scholar
Matthaiou, P. “Four inscribed bronze tables from Thebes: preliminary notes.” In The Epigraphy and History of Boeotia. New finds. New prospects, edited by N. Papazarkadas, 211–223. Leiden/Boston: Brill, 2014.Search in Google Scholar
Meidani, K. “Les relations entre les cités Béotiennes à l'époque archaïque.” Kentron 24 (2008): 151–164.10.4000/kentron.1659Search in Google Scholar
Mersch, A. “Archäologischer Kommentar zu den ‚Gräbern der Athener und Plataier’ in der Marathonia.” Klio 77 (1995): 55–64.10.1524/klio.1995.77.jg.55Search in Google Scholar
Meyer, E. Geschichte des Alterthums. 5 Volumes. Stuttgart: Cotta, 1884–1902.Search in Google Scholar
Moretti, L. Ricerche sulle leghe Greche. Peloponnesica, Beotica, Licia. Problemi e Richerche di Storia Antica 2. Rome: Giorgio Bretschneider, 1962.Search in Google Scholar
Naiden, F. S. Ancient Supplication. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2006.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195183412.001.0001Search in Google Scholar
Paga, J. “The monumental definition of Attica in the early democratic period.” In Autopsy in Athens. Recent archaeological research on Athens and Attica, edited by M. M. Miles, 108–125. Oxford: Oxbow, 2015. Search in Google Scholar
Parise, N. “Breve rassegna delle monetazioni arcaiche di beozia.” In Etne, identità e tradizioni: La 'terza' Grezia e l'Occidente. Diabaseis 3, edited by L. Breglia, A. Moleti and M. L. Napolitano, 285–291. Pisa: Edizioni ETS, 2011.Search in Google Scholar
Parker, R. Miasma: pollution and purification in early Greek religion. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 1983.Search in Google Scholar
Pelling, C. “Speech and narrative in the Histories.” In The Cambridge Companion to Herodotus, edited by C. Dewald and J. Marincola, 103–121. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2006.10.1017/CCOL052183001X.008Search in Google Scholar
Piccirilli, L. Gli Arbitrati Interstatali Greci. Pisa: Edizioni Marlin, 1973.Search in Google Scholar
Pickard-Cambridge, A. W. The Dramatic Festivals of Athens. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 1958. Search in Google Scholar
Prandi, L. Platea: Momenti e problemi della storia di una polis. Padua: Editoriale Programma, 1988.Search in Google Scholar
Price, J. Thucydides and Internal War. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2001.10.1017/CBO9780511483066Search in Google Scholar
Psoma, S. “Choosing and changing monetary standards in the Greek world during the Archaic and Classical Periods.” In The Ancient Greek Economy. Markets, households and city-states, edited by E. M. Harris, D. M. Lewis and M. Woolmer, 90–115. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2015.10.1017/CBO9781139565530.005Search in Google Scholar
Raaflaub, K. The Discovery of Freedom in Ancient Greece. First English edition, revised and updated from the German, translation by R. Franciscono, revised by the author. Chicago: University of Chicago, 2004.Search in Google Scholar
Roesch, P. “Notes d'épigraphie Béotienne.” RPh 39 (1965): 252–265.Search in Google Scholar
Roesch, P. Thespies et la Conféderation béotienne. Paris: de Boccard, 1965.Search in Google Scholar
Salmon, P. Étude sur la Confédération béotienne (447/6–386): son organisation et son administration. Brussels: Palais des Académies, 1978.Search in Google Scholar
Schachter, A. Cults of Boiotia. 4 Volumes. BICS Supplement 38.1–4. London: Institute of Classical Studies, 1981–1994.Search in Google Scholar
Schachter, A. “Boiotia in the sixth century B.C.” In Boiotia in Antiquity: selected papers, edited by A. Schachter, 36–50. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2016 a.Search in Google Scholar
Schachter, A. “Tanagra: the geographical and historical context: part one.” In Boiotia in Antiquity: selected papers, edited by A. Schachter, 80–112. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2016 b.10.1017/CBO9781107282049Search in Google Scholar
Schachter, A. “Politics and personalities in Classical Thebes.” In Boiotia in Antiquity: selected papers,edited by A. Schachter, 66–79. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2016 c.10.1017/CBO9781107282049.008Search in Google Scholar
Schachter, A. “Creating a legend: the war between Thebes and Orchomenos.” QUCC 135.1 (2014): 65–88.Search in Google Scholar
Scott, L. Historical Commentary on Herodotus Book 6. Leiden/Boston: Brill, 2005.10.1163/9789047407980Search in Google Scholar
Shrimpton, G. “When did Plataea join Athens?” CPh 79.4 (1984): 295–304.10.1086/366880Search in Google Scholar
Siewert, P. Die Trittyen Attikas und die Heeresreform des Kleisthenes. Munich: Beck, 1982.Search in Google Scholar
Siewert, P. “Die Drittelgliederung der elf Boiotischen Militärdistrikte im Vergleich mit der kleistenischen Trittyenordnung Attikas.” In La Béotie Antique. Colloques Internationaux du Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, edited by P. Roesch and G. Argoud, 297–300. Paris: Éditions du Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, 1985.Search in Google Scholar
Signor, H. “The military side of the Peisistratean tyranny.” In Peisistratos and the Tyranny: a reappraisal of the evidence, edited by H. Sancisi-Weerdenburg, 107–129. Amsterdam: Gieben, 2000.Search in Google Scholar
Sommerstein, A. H. and A. J. Bayliss. Oath and State in Ancient Greece. With contributions by Lynn A. Kozak and Isabelle C. Torrance. Beiträge zur Altertumskunde 306. Berlin/Boston: de Gruyter, 2013.10.1515/9783110285383Search in Google Scholar
Sordi, M. “Aspetti del federalism greco arcaico: Autonomia ed egemonia nel koinon beotico.” A&R 13 (1968): 66–75.Search in Google Scholar
Sordi, M. “La Battaglia di Ceresso e la secessione di Tespie.” In Boiotia Antiqua III. Papers in Boiotian history, institutions and epigraphy in memory of Paul Roesch, edited by J. Fossey, 25–32. Amsterdam: Gieben, 1993.Search in Google Scholar
Steinbock, B. Social Memory in Athenian Public Discourse: uses and meanings of the Past. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, 2013.10.3998/mpub.1897162Search in Google Scholar
Tausend, K. Amphiktyonie und Symmachie. Formen zwischenstaatlicher Beziehungen im archaischen Griechenland. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner, 1992.Search in Google Scholar
Taylor, M. C. “One Hundred Heroes of Phyle?” Hesperia 71 (2002): 377–397.10.2972/hesp.2002.71.4.377Search in Google Scholar
Traill, J. S. The Political Organization of Attica. A study of the demes, trittyes, and phylai, and their representation in the Athenian council. Hesperia Supplements. Princeton: American School of Classical Studies at Athens, 1974.10.2307/1353928Search in Google Scholar
Van Effenterre, H. “Clisthène et les mesures de mobilisation.” REG 89 (1976): 1–17.10.3406/reg.1976.4078Search in Google Scholar
Waanders, F. M. J. The History of telos and teleō in Ancient Greek. Amsterdam: B. R. Grüner, 1983.10.1075/zg.147Search in Google Scholar
Yates, D. “The Persian War as civil war in Plataea’s temple of Athena Areia.” Klio 95.2 (2013): 369–390.10.1524/klio.2013.95.2.369Search in Google Scholar
© 2017 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston
