Abstract
Plato’s Timaeus contains an argument that vice is involuntary. Here I present an interpretation of that argument and, upon doing so, relate the underlying conception of voluntariness to that found in Aristotle’s Eudemian Ethics. I argue that in the Timaeus, for something to be voluntary it must be caused by the agent’s intellect (nous) in a certain way. This idea, in turn, relies on an identification of the agent with her intellect: the reason that what is voluntary must be caused by the agent’s intellect is that what is voluntary is what the agent herself is responsible for. The conception of the voluntary in the Eudemian Ethics differs less radically than one might think. There too Aristotle wishes to respect the idea that there is an important connection between what is voluntary and what is caused by our rational capacities, but he differs in how he fills out the relevant rational capacities.
Acknowledgements
I am gratefull to the São Paulo Research foundation (grant no. 2016/05983-0) for financial support for the project of which this paper is a part. I am also grateful for valuable feedback from Friedemann Buddenseik, John Cooper, Hendrik Lorenz, Benjamin Morison, Connie Qian, and Daniel Vásquez.
References
Adam, R. 1925. “Über eine unter Platos Namen erhaltene Sammlung von Definitionen.” Philologus 80: 366–76.10.1515/phil-1924-0403Search in Google Scholar
Archer-Hind, R.D. 1888. The Timaeus of Plato. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Bedau, H. A., and E. Kelly. 2015. “Punishment.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. (Fall, 2015 Edition), edited by E.N. Zalta. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2015/entries/punishment/.Search in Google Scholar
Bloch, O., and A. Leandri. 2011. Aristote: Éthique à Eudème. Paris: Encre Marine.Search in Google Scholar
Bonet, J.P. 1985. Aristóteles: Ética Nicomáquea, Ética Eudemia. Madrid: Gredos.Search in Google Scholar
Boonin, D. 2008. The Problem of Punishment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511819254Search in Google Scholar
Burnyeat, M. 2000. “Plato on Why Mathematics Is Good for the Soul.” Proceedings of the British Academy 103: 1–82.10.1017/9781009047982.004Search in Google Scholar
Caiani, L. 1996. Etiche di Aristotele Turin: Unione Tipografico-Editrice Torinese.Search in Google Scholar
Carone, G. R. 2007. “Akrasia and the Structure of the Passions in Plato’s Timaeus.” In Akrasia in Greek Philosophy: From Socrates to Plotinus, edited by C. Bobonich and P. Destrée, 101–06. Leiden: Brill,.10.1163/ej.9789004156708.i-308.32Search in Google Scholar
Cornford, F.M. 1935. Plato’s Cosmology: The Timaeus of Plato. London: Routledge.Search in Google Scholar
Décarie, V. 1978. Aristote, Ethique à Eudeme. Paris: Vrin.Search in Google Scholar
Dirlmeier, F. 1962. Eudemische Ethik (Aristoteles Werke in deutscher Ûbersetzung, Band 7). Berlin: Academie Verlag.Search in Google Scholar
Englert, W.G. 1987. Epicurus on the Swerve and Voluntary Action. Atlanta, Ga.: American Classical Studies 16; Scholars Press.Search in Google Scholar
Fraccaroli, G. 1906. Platone, Il Timeo. Torino: Fratelli Boca.Search in Google Scholar
Gerson, L. P. 2003. Knowing Persons: A Study in Plato. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Gill, C. “The body’s fault? Plato’s Timaeus on psychic illness”, in Reason and Necessity: Essays on Plato’s Timaeus, edited by M.R. Wright (London: Duckworth, 2000): 59–84.Search in Google Scholar
Grube, G.M.A. 1932. “The Composition of the World Soul in Timaeus 35A-B.” Classical Philology 27: 80–82.10.1086/361433Search in Google Scholar
Grube, G.M.A. 1997. “Phaedo”. In The Complete Works of Plato. Edited by J. Cooper. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Gulley, N. 1965. “The Interpretation of ‘No One Does Wrong Willingly’ in Plato’s Dialogues.” Phronesis 10: 82–96.10.1163/156852865X00086Search in Google Scholar
Hause, J.P. and S.S. Meyer. 2017. “Der Begriff der Verantwortung in der Antike und im Mittelalter” in Handbuch: Verantwortung (Springer Reference Sozialwissenschaften). Edited by L. Heidbrink, C. Langbehn, and J. Loh. Weisbaden: Springer VS.Search in Google Scholar
Henry, D. 2016. “Aristotle on the Moral Status of Animals.” In Oxford Philosophical Concepts: Animals, edited by P. Adamson and F. Edwards. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Inwood, B., and R. Woolf. 2012. Aristotle: Eudemian Ethics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9781139043281Search in Google Scholar
Johansen, T. K. 2008. Plato’s Natural Philosophy: A Study of the Timaeus-Critias. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Jowett, B. 1871. The Dialogues of Plato, Volume 3. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Lautner, P. 2011. “Plato’s Account of the Diseases of the Soul in Timaeus 86B1–87B9.” Apeiron 44: 22–39.10.1515/apeiron.2011.004Search in Google Scholar
Lee, E. N. 1976. “Reason and Rotation: Circular Movement as the Model of Mind (Nous) in Later Plato”. In Facets of Plato’s Thought. edited by W.H. Werkmeister, 70–102. Van Gorcum: Assen.Search in Google Scholar
Lopes, R. 2011. Platão:Timeu-Crítias. Coimbra: Centro de Estudos Clássicos e Humanísticos da Universidade de Coimbra.Search in Google Scholar
Mackenzie, M.M. 1985. Plato on Punishment. Berkeley: University of California Press.Search in Google Scholar
Menn, S.P. 1995. Plato on God as Nous (The Journal of the History of Philosophy Monograph Series). University of Illinois Press.Search in Google Scholar
Meyer, S.S. 2006. “Aristotle on the Voluntary.” In The Blackwell Companion to Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, edited by R. Kraut. Blackwell.10.1093/oseo/instance.00258591Search in Google Scholar
Meyer, S.S. 2014. “‘God Is Not to Blame': Divine Creation and Human Responsibility in Plato’s Timaeus.” Proceedings of the Boston Area Colloquium in Ancient Philosophy 29: 55–69. [‘God is Not To Blame’].10.1163/22134417-00291P05Search in Google Scholar
Meyer, S.S. Aristotle on Moral Responsibility. [Moral Responsibility]Search in Google Scholar
Ott, W. 2006. “Aristotle and Plato on Character.” Ancient Philosophy 26: 65–79.10.5840/ancientphil200626139Search in Google Scholar
Rackham, H. 1935. The Athenian Constitution; the Eudemian Ethics; on Virtues and Vices. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Rivaud, A. 1925. Platon, Œuvres complètes, tome X, Timée-Critias. Paris: Les Belles Lettres.Search in Google Scholar
Roberts, J. 1989. “Aristotle on Responsibility for Action and Character.” Ancient Philosophy 9: 23–36.10.5840/ancientphil19899123Search in Google Scholar
Robinson, T.M. 1970. Plato’s Psychology. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.Search in Google Scholar
Ross, W.D. 1961. Aristotle, De Anima. Oxford: Clarendon Press.10.1093/actrade/9780198141556.book.1Search in Google Scholar
Saunders, T.J. 1991. Plato’s Penal Code: Tradition, Controversy, and Reform in Greek Penology. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Search in Google Scholar
Saunders, T.J. 1997. “Laws” in The Complete Works of Plato. Edited by J. Cooper. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Sedley, D. 2000. “The Ideal of Godlikeness.” In Plato 2: Ethics, Politics, Religion and the Soul, edited by G. Fine. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar
Šegvić, H. 2000. “No One Errs Willingly: The Meaning of Socratic Intellectualism.” Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 19: 1–45.Search in Google Scholar
Smith, A.M. 2007. “On Being Responsible and Holding Responsible.” The Journal of Ethics 11: 465–84.10.1007/s10892-005-7989-5Search in Google Scholar
Souilhé, J. 1930. Platon, Œuvres complètes, tome XIII, 2e partie, Dialogues Suspects. Paris: Les Belles Lettres.Search in Google Scholar
Stalley, R.F. 1996. “Punishment and the Physiology of the Timaeus.” The Classical Quarterly (New Series) 46: 357–70.10.1093/cq/46.2.357Search in Google Scholar
Taylor, A.E. 1928. A Commentary on Plato’s Timaeus. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Search in Google Scholar
Weiss, R. 1985. “Ignorance, Involuntariness, and Innocence: A Reply to McTighe.” Phronesis 30: 314–22.10.1163/156852885X00129Search in Google Scholar
Wolt, D. Forthcoming. “The Aim of Eudemian Ethics ii 6–9.” Ancient Philosophy.Search in Google Scholar
Zeyl, D. 1997. “Timaeus”. In The Complete Works of Plato. Edited by J. Cooper. Princeton: Princeton University Press.Search in Google Scholar
© 2019 Walter de Gruyter Inc., Boston/Berlin
