The Philosophers&#39; Quarrel: Rousseau, Hume, and the Limits of Human Understanding

Robert Zaretsky; John T. Scott

Published by Yale University Press 2009

The Philosophers' Quarrel

Rousseau, Hume, and the Limits of Human Understanding

Robert Zaretsky and John T. Scott

https://doi.org/10.12987/9780300156249

Overview
Contents

About this book

The rise and spectacular fall of the friendship between the two great philosophers of the eighteenth century, barely six months after they first met, reverberated on both sides of the Channel. As the relationship between Jean-Jacques Rousseau and David Hume unraveled, a volley of rancorous letters was fired off, then quickly published and devoured by aristocrats, intellectuals, and common readers alike. Everyone took sides in this momentous dispute between the greatest of Enlightenment thinkers.

In this lively and revealing book, Robert Zaretsky and John T. Scott explore the unfolding rift between Rousseau and Hume. The authors are particularly fascinated by the connection between the thinkers’ lives and thought, especially the way that the failure of each to understand the other—and himself—illuminates the limits of human understanding. In addition, they situate the philosophers’ quarrel in the social, political, and intellectual milieu that informed their actions, as well as the actions of the other participants in the dispute, such as James Boswell, Adam Smith, and Voltaire. By examining the conflict through the prism of each philosopher’s contribution to Western thought, Zaretsky and Scott reveal the implications for the two men as individuals and philosophers as well as for the contemporary world.

Author / Editor information

Robert Zaretsky is professor of French, Honors College, University of Houston. John T. Scott is professor of political science, University of California, Davis. Zaretsky and Scott are also coauthors of Frail Happiness: An Essay o

Topics

Philosophy

Philosophy, other

Contents

Frontmatter

Publicly Available Download PDF i

Contents

Publicly Available Download PDF vii

Acknowledgments

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF ix

ONE. An Enlightenment Quarrel

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 1

TWO. The Wild Philosopher

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 8

THREE. The Great Scot

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 37

FOUR. The Lord of Ferney

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 56

FIVE. Le Bon David

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 72

SIX. A Stone’s Throw from Paris

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 90

SEVEN. First Impressions

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 104

EIGHT. A Public Spectacle

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 114

NINE. Poses and Impostures

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 128

TEN. Hume, Judge of le Bon David

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 149

ELEVEN. An Enlightenment Tragedy

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 170

TWELVE. So Great a Noise

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 183

THIRTEEN. How Philosophers Die

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 198

Notes

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 211

Index

Requires Authentication Unlicensed
Licensed Download PDF 239

Share this book

Facebook

X / Twitter

LinkedIn

Language: English

Publisher: Yale University Press

Copyright year: 2009

Pages

Main content: 264

Illustrations

Other: 10 b-w illus.

eBook

Published: March 3, 2009

ISBN: 9780300156249