2015-02-11
|
can we imagine spirituality without religion?
|
B. N. HebbarGeorge Washington University
|
Yes, there is a reason behind the "no-soul" (anatta/anatman) theory of Buddhism. Selflessness is the major catalyst to salvation (nibbana/nirvana) from the cycle of births and deaths in both Hinduism and Buddhism.
In the case of Buddhism, the ethics has shaped its spiritual psychology and consequently its soteriology.
The question is how can one be truly selfless if one believes in a permanent self (soul).
The Hindus argue that materialistic egotism should be removed, but a permanent spiritual self would not be in conflict with the notion of selflessness.
Buddhists beg to differ and point out that it would conflict. As long as there is a "soul" one cannot but be selfish.
Hindus point out that: "if so, what is it then that attains nirvana (if there is no soul)?"
Both religio-philosophical traditions have raised some very good points.
I commend them both for this.
|