Abstract

This chapter focuses on one of the common fallacies in Western philosophy, 'kettle logic' (KL). KL is a fallacy in which multiple contradictory premises are presented to support a point. As such, it is logically impossible for all of the premises to be true. Formally, KL arguments are valid arguments, for it is impossible for contradictory premises to be true and the conclusion false. Sigmund Freud believes KL is employed in dreams quite often. Contradictory beliefs are commonly offered, which give notice that one is in a dream. Freud's presentation of the tea kettle argument makes it clear that the man presents all of the premises as true. In real life and even in dreams, determining whether the arguer intends for all the considerations to be true, or whether additional information is missing, is much more difficult, but necessary in order to avoid the fallacy.